Do you ever feel caught up in striving, worrying about how you're doing, or trying to become a better version of yourself? In this talk, I explore an early Buddhist teaching on how craving and self-identification create suffering—and how loosening our grip on who we think we are can bring greater freedom, peace, and genuine happiness.
Key Topics & Timecodes 0:00 — Returning to the Original Teachings 5:32 — Meeting Dhammadinna 9:11 — What Is the Self, Really? 12:36 — The Three Forms of Craving 15:54 — The Noble Pony and the Naughty Pony 18:43 — Three Questions for Wise Living 20:49 — What Would It Feel Like to Let Go? 22:27 — The Eightfold Path as a Practical Cure 23:32 — Investigating the Self Through Direct Experience 29:26 — Does Letting Go of Self Lead to Depersonalization? 30:18 — Filling the Hole in the Heart 32:30 — The Difference Between Happiness and Craving 35:42 — Impermanence, Suffering, and Interdependence
I offer these every week, along with a guided meditation.
Just click the subscribe link below to be notified through YouTube when I post the latest
recording.
Or, if you'd like to join us live, which would be great, just go into the description
section below and follow the link along to be able to sign up for free.
Well, I'm going to do an experiment with you, and I'm a little nervous about this.
I hope it doesn't go too badly.
What I'd like to do is to go through and kind of talk through a fairly short sutra,
or sutta, from early Buddhism.
As context here, the Buddha lived and taught for many years, probably close to 80 or so,
and his teachings were listened to and essentially memorized by the monastics of his time.
And then those memorized versions of his teachings, including some commentaries from other people—and
we'll be hearing one of those tonight—were then passed down in an oral tradition for
hundreds of years until written record survived that is the basis for the canon, the collection
of sutras and teachings that we have today that were written down originally in several
languages, perhaps the one that's best known as Pali, P-A-L-I, which gives us the Pali
canon, the collection of teachings from early Buddhism.
I think of it as OG Buddhism, you know, original gangster, old guard, original Buddhism.
And I'm often struck by the degree to which sometimes people in Tibetan or Zen or modern
mindfulness settings just are not aware of the root teachings that really began this
whole lineage.
And I find these original teachings to be very psychological, rarely cosmic, really
down to earth, and unflinching, unafraid in the directness of the analysis of the mental
processes that create suffering and harm for ourselves and others, and the practices that
we can engage.
Everyone is invited to engage these practices that can lead increasingly to freedom and
awakening and the highest happiness, which is peace, to quote the Buddha.
So I'm going to go through the sutta with you.
Let's recognize that it's probably an imperfect reconstruction of the exact words that were
used.
I'm sure there was some editing that slipped into the record here, maybe some sections
were kind of moved around.
I'm going to deliberately glide right past some major sections of this sutta to really
focus on the parts that I think are most down to earth and most relevant for our own practice.
Are you ready?
I hope you'll go along with me on this ride.
We'll see how it turns out.
Early on in my own encounter with Buddhism, starting in a serious way, starting around
30 years ago, after a while I began to realize that I'd been taught Buddhist light, and so
much that was fundamental, penetrating, radical, profound, edgy in early Buddhism was kind
of left out.
It was all watered down.
You know, yeah, the essence of Buddhist light is, you know, be aware and be nice.
That's better than the alternative.
But I wish there'd been more respect in those teaching traditions that I first encountered
for the capacity of regular people to actually grasp and grapple with these teachings of
the Buddha, which he just offered to everybody, you know, in his time.
And also, I just think, I owe you this, you know, I owe you this.
To just, from time to time, yeah, let's get into it.
So here we go.
And I recognize that the translator, Thanissaro Bhikkhu, sometimes referred to as Ajahn Jeff,
who's the abbot of a really significant Buddhist center down in San Diego area in Southern
California.
He's asked, you know, he said there's a little bit of more of an updated website.
So that's the one I'm going to speak from.
And as with everything, see for yourself and see what touches your heart.
For me, as you could tell, you know, I get really touched by these real people, as best
we gather today, 2,500 years later, who are grappling with the same questions that we're
grappling with in everyday life.
What makes me happy?
What makes me cranky?
What makes them cranky?
How can I train and practice in ways that are helpful to myself and others?
This comes from the Majjhima Nikaya, Nikaya means collection of teachings, Majjhima means
middle link.
All right.
And this is Majjhima Nikaya 44.
And the translator's note is that this is mainly a conversation with the nun, Dhammadena.
And I particularly love that this is an interaction with a very awakened woman, Dhammadena, while
acknowledging the very patriarchal time in which the Buddha arose, and the very unfortunate
moving away from the bhikkhuni tradition in early Buddhism, in which nuns had a serious
monastic order, significant one, and a lack of that, and terrible, to me, very un-Buddhist
resistance to full ordination of women as monastics, until very recently with people
who are really supporting progress in that area.
That said, Dhammadena.
So we have the Buddha praised Dhammadena the nun as the foremost Dhamma teacher among his
nun disciples.
Dhamma and Dharma are synonymous.
In this discourse, she answers questions put to her by a layman, Visakha, who, according
to the commentary, was her former husband, a merchant of Rajagaha, and a non-returner.
A, I love the fact that she's schooling her former husband, as a husband who gets routinely
schooled by his wife and current wife, and the term non-returner has to do with a frame
of reference, which you don't have to believe in, but it's the frame of reference cosmologically
in which there are rounds of birth and death and rebirth.
And Chogyam Trungpa answered the question of, well, if there's no self, what is reborn?
He said, your bad habits.
I think that's pretty comical, but without getting into all the metaphysics of this,
there are kind of four levels of awakening identified in early Buddhism.
Someone who is a stream-enterer, entering the stream, who will have seven more births.
And then we have someone who is a one-time returner, a once-returner, who will have one
more birth because they're so far along.
Then we have a non-returner, someone who will be reborn in heavenly realms, but not this
earthly plane.
And then, fourth and highest, we have the arahant, one who is completely released, and
all the causes and conditions that lead to rebirth have dissipated, much like a candle
or a fire dissipates when there is no longer any fuel for it.
That's the framework here, okay?
So to continue, I have heard, so detail, the person who says, I have heard, is typically
the Buddha's cousin, Ananda, who memorized all these teachings, and at the first sort
of major gathering of the key people after the Buddha died, people recited the teachings
so that they could be memorized and passed on from generation to generation to generation.
So think about the custodial stewardship here, I mean, the seriousness in which people guarded
and protected and passed on freely.
There are no secret teachings in early Buddhism.
Passed on freely, these precious teachings, having to do with the liberation and awakening
of all beings.
Wow, thank you.
Thank you, all those who are involved in memorizing, chanting, and teaching these teachings.
So probably Ananda says, I have heard that on one occasion, the Blessed One, the Buddha,
was staying near Rajagaha in the bamboo forest, the squirrel's sanctuary.
Just love kind of the locating of all this.
And then Visakha, the lay follower, went to Dhammadena, the nun, and on arrival, having
bowed down to her, sat to one side.
Okay, now we're getting in to the heart of the matter here, the teachings.
As he was sitting there, he said to her, self-identification, self-identification, it is said, lady.
Which self-identification is described by the Blessed One?
So right here, right at the heart of the matter, what is self?
What do we take to be self?
And what are the ways in which selfing, taking things personally, wanting to possess, identifying,
getting caught up in, you know, grievances, narcissistic injury from others, how does
that create suffering?
What is the fundamental process of self?
Pretty freaking deep.
And psychologists today are still banging away at that one.
So Dhammadena responds.
She says, there are these five clinging aggregates, friend Visakha, form, feeling, perception,
fabrications in general, I'll explain, and consciousness.
The word aggregate is a funny word.
I'm going to zero in on the view in early Buddhism that everything boils down to these
five things.
The reality is actually made of these five elements.
Physical reality involves form, bare physical reality, which we now understand involves
energy and matter together.
Okay.
Form.
And now we're moving in to mental processes.
The form element of reality also involves just the bare perception, the bare awareness
that something is happening.
Something is here.
Okay.
Then we have feeling, which is not about emotion.
It's about what psychologists today call hedonic tone, which we'll be getting into a little
later.
The sense of things as pleasant or unpleasant or neither pleasant nor unpleasant.
That's the feeling aggregate, which is really key because the sense of something as pleasant
or unpleasant tends to drive the craving and clinging that creates a lot of suffering.
So creating in our practice more of a kind of shock absorber or buffer or mud room in
the mind or space between the hedonic tone of experiences and the drivenness that tends
to follow after that, creating more of that space is really central to practice.
Okay.
So we have essentially to go on.
Then there's perception, which is labeling and memory, categorizing.
It's a dog, not a cat.
It's a tail, only the tail, for example, perception.
Then we have the so-called fabrications, but just all the other mishigas in the mind.
All the thoughts, all the feelings, all the desires, the images, all extreme sorrows and
neogram types and all the rest of that.
And then we have consciousness, which is not taken here as some kind of infinite cosmic
consciousness, but really is sort of like ordinary awareness.
The Buddha basically says, you know, who you take yourself to be boils down to these five
elements.
Okay.
So then we continue, saying, yes, lady, Visakha, the lay follower, delighted and rejoiced in
what Dhammadhena, the nun, had said.
Then he asked her a further question, the origination of self-identification, the origination
of self-identification.
It is said, lady, which origination of self-identification is described by the Blessed One, the Buddha?
Here we go.
The craving that makes for further becoming, accompanied by passion and delight, relishing
now here and now there.
In other words, three things, craving for sensual pleasure, craving for becoming and
craving for non-becoming.
This, friend Visakha, is the origination of self-identification described by the Blessed
One.
So when we get a sense of self and we look at it closely, Buddha is not asking us to
take anything on faith or belief, but to look directly.
When we observe our mindstream, we can observe an ongoingness, and in the ongoingness of
the mindstream, we can observe motivational motivations underneath it all that could
be sorted into three types, the motivation for kind of immediate pleasure or the reduction
immediately of pain, really direct.
And you can see that fundamental motivation in animals with an increasingly primitive
or simple nervous system, the immediacy of approaching that which is pleasurable in a
crab or a frog or a mouse, and then the withdrawal from what is unpleasant, what is painful in
a frog, crab, or mouse.
Then second, and this is really useful, especially for people like me who are pretty goal-directed,
there is the craving for becoming, for achieving certain goals, for constructing a future self
who is fill-in-the-blank, richer, better-looking, happier, more loved, more famous.
Craving for becoming, and if you watch closely, you can see that there's a lot of subtle and
not-so-subtle contraction, pressure, stress, suffering, harms to self and others from that
powerful, powerful movement toward becoming.
Now to preview a really important point, the Buddha does not say that desire per se is
bad.
In fact, he calls out wholesome desire, and technically the word in Pali for problematic
craving is tanha.
The word for wholesome desire, such as the desire that others prosper and flourish and
be happy, is chanda.
So there's a place for wholesome desire, but the Buddha keeps calling us to, very pragmatically,
what are the results?
When you pursue your purposes, are they wholesome purposes?
And you decide if your purposes, your aims, your goals, your values are good ones.
I know for myself that, and I joke about one road, two ponies, you know, the noble pony
and the naughty pony, and we can be aware of two kinds of motives at the same time.
We're in conversation with another person, and there are maybe some noble motives in
that conversation that involve kindness and standing up for ourselves in appropriate ways.
And then on the other hand, there could be naughty or neurotic pony purposes running
alongside it about proving your superiority, or driving home your point, or enacting a
certain aggrieved ill will that wants to punish that other person, you know, for not
agreeing with you from the start.
Both of those can be present.
And over time, we can sort out for ourselves what are wise intentions, wise purposes, wholesome
purposes from the ones that are not so much.
First question.
Second, can we pursue our wholesome, wise purposes in wholesome and wise ways?
And here too, we see for ourselves.
I think back on my wholesome purposes of helping our kids succeed in school and be appropriately,
you know, make appropriate efforts there.
But I can see that some of the time, and they never let me forget this one, when it was
probably Forrest who wrote some kind of book report and said, well, what do you think,
dad?
He was probably sixth grade or so.
And I went, oh, okay.
And I just line edited it, like people line edit me, you know, marked it up, and my wholesome
intent there, you know, to help him become a better writer, was pursued in a really dumb
way.
You know, he never let me talk to him about his schoolwork again for at least a while.
Anyway, so that's the second question.
You know, if you have your wise and wholesome values, okay, are you pursuing them in wise
and wholesome ways?
And then the third question is, even with wise and wholesome purposes pursued in wise
and wholesome ways, can you be at peace fundamentally with whatever happens?
That underlying peacefulness may include understandable disappointment, might include understandable
moral outrage at the actions of others, but underneath it all, underneath it all, in the
core of your own being, can you find a stillness and a vastness and a contentment there and
an ongoingness of lovingness, no matter what happens?
This is aspirational.
This is the work we do to find those wholesome wise purposes pursued in wholesome wise means
the fundamental, increasingly unconditional inner peace regarding whatever happens.
These teachings call us to that in our relationship to what's going through our mind.
So how do we do it?
So, Visakha continues, the cessation of self-identification, the cessation of self-identification, it is
said, lady.
Which cessation of self-identification is described by the Blessed One?
Check out these words.
The remainderless fading and cessation, renunciation, relinquishment, release, and letting go of
that very craving, craving for pleasure, craving for becoming, craving for non-becoming.
Non-becoming is sort of a wish that can arise if people are suicidal to just not be here
anymore.
So craving, especially craving for becoming, the remainderless fading away of that.
This, friends, Visakha, is the cessation of self-identification described by the Blessed
One.
So we're talking here about a remainderless fading and cessation.
We're talking about a renunciation of this engine of craving that causes so much suffering
and harm.
Just feel the weight of those words, remainderless fading away of this craving.
What do you feel when you imagine the remainderless fading away of craving in the way it is meant
here in your case?
What comes up for me is a sense of like, wow, that would be big, you know, and also a sense
of peacefulness when I kind of tune into what that would feel like.
So continuing, which way of practice leading to the cessation of self-identification is
described by the Buddha?
And the answer from Dhammadhena is precisely this noble eightfold path consisting of right
view, right resolve or intention, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort,
right mindfulness, right concentration.
This friend, Visakha, is the way of practice leading to the cessation of self-identification
described by the Blessed One.
So the Buddha is not just describing our problem.
He is offering a path of practice with eight elements in it that lead to the cessation
of that craving.
So then you might ask yourself, okay, eight suggestions from Coach Buddha, Dr. Buddha,
right view, right resolve, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right
mindfulness, right concentration.
Which of these for you is pretty strong these days, and, you know, which of these call to
you as maybe worthy of some greater effort or focus on your part?
Good question.
All right.
So I'm going to do a little more and then open it up again.
So I'm going to move ahead to the question, but lady, how does self-identification view
come about?
There is the case, friend Visakha, where an uninstructed, run-of-the-mill person who has
no regard for noble ones, is not well-versed or disciplined in their dharma or dhamma,
who has no regard for people of integrity, is not well-versed or disciplined in their
dhamma, assumes that form, in other words, the body, is the self, or the self as possessing
the body, or the body as in the self, or the self as in the body.
These actually are very cool four distinct ways to investigate your own experience.
In other words, do you assume that your body is the self?
Do you assume alternately that your self possesses your body?
Or do you presume that your body is in the self, or that your self is in the body?
And then similarly, we have these four ways of talking about this with regard to the hedonic
tones of experience, the feeling tones as pleasant, unpleasant, or neither.
We have the same structure with regard to perception, labeling, memory, categorizing.
We have the same construction, the same opportunity for investigation with regard to all the other
thoughts and feelings, memories, hopes, and illusions in the mind.
And we have the same kind of investigation with consciousness.
Do we assume that consciousness is the self?
Or do we assume that the self possesses consciousness?
Or do we think that consciousness is in the self, or the self is in consciousness?
See the strategy here, it's very characteristic of early Buddhism, which drives some people
crazy because it's kind of analytical and might seem really heady, but it's really
about directly observing what it's like to be you.
And in that observing, in that investigating, becoming increasingly free.
And so then, Dhammadhina continues that this release of self-identification is fading away.
This relinquishment of self-identification is supported by not assuming that the body
and the self are equivalent, or not identifying with hedonic tones as self, not identifying
with perceptions as self, not identifying with thoughts, feelings, and other activities
as self, and not identifying with consciousness as self.
There is an ongoingness of personing, crucial point, and there is a body-mind process with
a sense of self associated with it.
And if we look closely though, we actually, when we deconstruct, we can never find the
basis for the presumed unified, enduring, and independent entity that we take to be
I, or me.
It's important, as we appreciate this, that, as the teacher put it in writing, love yourself.
Just don't love your self.
In other words, you're here, you in the broadest sense, you as a person are here.
You exist as a person, a body-mind process with continuity over time, arising based on
causes and conditions and fading away eventually, all eddies disperse in the stream of reality
eventually.
That is occurring.
And, as we look closely with insight, with vipassana, into what it's actually like to
be ourselves, we start realizing, oh, there's this ongoing streaming of mental activity.
And when it is related to, in a wider way, with less contraction, more awareness of the
bigger picture, more of a sense of openness and vastness and emptying out that we explored
in meditation, oh, I suffer less, I'm more peaceful, and I get into fewer wrangles with
others.
That's the very down-to-earth result of this kind of increasing insight into your own stream
of consciousness.
I find that this text is really worth some time.
There's some technical stuff in it about really advanced meditative states leading to cessation
of ordinary consciousness and then return that you could maybe glide past or slow down
and really absorb in the footnotes.
I wanted to respect you enough to dive into this more fundamental material and to invite
you, as the Buddha invited everyone, to dive into it yourself and to see for yourself what
speaks to you here.
Is there a danger in these teachings of depersonalization?
Yeah.
In other words, I think it's important, especially if a person is already sort of fragmented
or fractured, sometimes as a result of trauma, to be careful with this material.
On the other hand, interestingly, as we lighten up about our self, there's more of a basis
you'll find for caring for yourself broadly as a person.
When we interact with others, if we conventionally presume that there's some kind of entity in
there behind their eyes who is just making us mad, then we're often going to get caught
up in cycles of reactivity with that other person.
On the other hand, if we can recognize that over there, a lot of stuff is happening, a
lot of subpersonalities are in the mix, there are multiple selves over there in that other
person, and they're the result of a complex history, causes and conditions, swirling through
that person right now, you know, if we can look at them in more that way, we become more
skillful about dealing with the specific forces moving through them, and we give them
more breathing room.
There's more of a buffer, there's more spaciousness between us and them.
And also I should add that as we really feed ourselves with appropriate social supplies
that help us to feel valued and included and loved, and as we address so-called narcissistic
injuries that many of us, including me, suffer in childhood and even adulthood, where we
feel dismissed or put down by or rejected or attacked by others, as we deliberately
internalize healthy experiences of being seen and valued and even cherished by other beings,
as we actually take those in, we feed the person who longs for those experiences and
needs those experiences, and as we feed that inner being so that the person we are, the
sense of self relaxes, and people become less self-preoccupied, they become less selfish
over time.
It's a really important point, and I think there are a lot of spiritual circles that
push away and somehow put, you know, look down on the important needs that people have
to feel recognized and wanted and valued, because they think that'll just feed the ego.
Well, yeah, it could just feed the ego, but most people, actually, especially with a little,
you know, instruction or encouragement, take in the caring and the valuing coming to them
from other people to gradually fill that hole in their heart.
So they feel increasingly filled up from the inside out and less needy about getting self-referential
self-oriented supplies from other people over time.
Really important point.
Why is it so difficult to let go of the desire to be happy?
I don't think the Buddha is counseling us, or Dhammadhena, to let go of the desire to
be happy.
There's a lot of teaching in early Buddhism about the Buddha's rejection of the asceticism
of the traditions of his time, where there was denial of the ordinary desire to be happy.
And the Buddha actually talks about the importance of the happiness visible in this present life.
It's okay, and much as out of, you know, for example, among the four so-called heavenly
abodes or immeasurables of compassion, kindness, equanimity, and happiness for the happiness
of others, there's an appreciation of the desire for others to be happy.
That's a wholesome desire.
Well, you know, in the desire for all beings to be safe and happy and healthy and to live
with ease, all beings include yourself.
So that's really okay.
And that's where I think the metaphor of the noble pony and the naughty pony or the
neurotic pony is quite useful, because there can be that desire for our own happiness that
has a quality of compassion in it and a quality of justice in it, fairness and decency, sticking
up for our own rights, much as we recognize the rights of others.
You know, that I would call the noble pony in terms of the desire to be happy yourself,
the desire to actualize and to fulfill your talents, your abilities, to allow them to
come into being, to realize that your own personal happiness is the foundation for spiritual
practice.
You know, when you're really unhappy, it's hard to awaken personal happiness, including
the quality of not just sukha, which is basic happiness, but blissfulness, piti, and pali.
These are factors of awakening, right?
We can value and appreciate those forms of happiness, and we can distinguish between
those noble motivations for happiness from the more problematic ones that want to be
happy at the expense of others or want to have short-term happiness through various
things, intoxications included, that, yeah, bring momentary relief and pleasure, but carry
a long-term price.
I love the proverb embedded in the Dhammapada, which says that one is not wise because one
can recite the scriptures.
One is truly wise who can choose a greater happiness over a lesser one.
And it is that choosing of a greater happiness for ourselves, entwined, of course, and interdependent
with others, that is the really wholesome and wise desire for happiness.
Really important.
There is a particular teaching in a footnote, I think it's footnote three, that landed
for me personally, so I want to kind of call it out.
And the framing of it is in reference to deep, deep meditative practice, which has to do
with sort of the return from the cessation of ordinary consciousness.
I have never experienced that.
I know multiple people who have and have been really supported by it, and that meditative
attainment or event is highly valued, especially in early Buddhism.
That said, the footnoted point is to appreciate that there are sort of three major characteristics
of existing, notably impermanence, interdependence, and the inevitability of pain or disappointment.
Some people are very engaged with an awareness of impermanence, and they are, I'm going to
check the footnote, footnote number two.
If you're particularly drawn to an awareness of impermanence, you might, especially when
you're really in touch with impermanence, have a sense that in reality, there are no
signs, there is nothing stable, and finding comfort with this deepens, in part, as we
shore up our sense of ourselves being okay as a person.
You may relate to what I'm saying.
You may not relate to it.
Either one is okay.
Those who are focused on the theme of dukkha, which Thanissaro Bhikkhu translates as stress,
those who have a particular awareness of stress or that which is unsatisfactory,
the inevitability that that which we like will change, the inevitability of pain,
those who are particularly aware of that aspect of existing can be particularly drawn
to a sense of being undirected and might gain particular value from tuning into a
sense of being undirected.
This has been very useful recently for me.
And then third, in footnote two, those who have been focusing on the theme of interdependence,
interbeing, or not-self, been really releasing the sense of self, the sense of taking things
personally, might increasingly have a sense of what could be called emptiness or vastness
that is sort of absolute and impersonal.
I'm just tossing this out there.
You may not relate to it.
It's really okay.
For myself, I've practiced a lot with relaxing the sense of self while caring for and tending to
the person process ongoing.
I have a pretty full growing, but pretty full sense of emptiness.
And given my goal-directed, accomplishing nature,
really facing dukkha and exploring the value of being undirected in the flow of everyday life
in a healthy way, kind of lived by everything, all things coming through, living through us,
rather than the self top-down being goal-directed.
That's been really useful for me personally.
So, I just want to offer these out there.
It might be, you know, kind of real abstract.
You don't relate to it.
Or you could go, whoa, one of those, you know, comments here really speaks to you.