Everything we love, everything we hold onto, and even each passing moment is subject to change. How can we face the inevitability of loss without being overwhelmed by grief, fear, or sorrow?
This week I explored the Buddhist wisdom of impermanence and how we can find peace in a world where nothing stays the same. I talk about the difference between the unavoidable pain of loss and the additional suffering we create through clinging and resistance, and I offered five ways to practice with loss, from allowing ourselves to grieve to finding trustworthy sources of refuge and stability.
Impermanence isn't just about what we're losing. Every passing moment also brings something new. By recognizing both sides of change, we can appreciate the preciousness of life, deepen our compassion for others, and live more fully in the present.
Timecodes & main topics: 00:00 – Finding Peace and Letting Go of Self-Criticism 07:04 – Can We Love Without Attachment? 10:48 – Understanding Impermanence and the Nature of Loss 16:42 – Why Loss Hurts More Than Gain Feels Good 23:45 – How to Grieve Without Adding Suffering 29:47 – Living Fully in the Time We Have 31:21 – Finding Freedom in the Present Moment 36:54 – Taking Refuge in What Endures
This talk explores the cultivation of a \"global state of being\"—grounded, peaceful, and open-hearted—as a foundation for mental health. The speaker integrates Buddhist philosophy to address fear in meditation, the distinction between healthy desire and craving, and the nature of impermanence, offering a framework for processing loss and living with intention and compassion.
I offer these every week along with a guided meditation.
Just click the subscribe link below
to be notified through YouTube when I
post the latest recording. Or if you'd like to join us live, which
would be great, just go into the description section
below and follow the link along to be able to sign up for free.
Before my prepared talk,
I'd like to make a comment on the meditation and then speak to
two questions that came up in the chat.
The first comment is that it's really valuable
to have a global sense of being in ways that are good for you
and good for others too.
So it's sort of like a global sense of being.
We can focus on cultivating particular factors in the mind,
you know, like tranquility or compassion in Buddhism, let's say.
Or we can cultivate things like gratitude or sense of grit.
You know, we can focus on different factors.
There's a place for that.
More fundamentally, though, what's the total package?
What's a state of being that's fairly global?
Described in simple ways, typically,
that's a good base for you, like centered and present,
or grounded, peaceful, and open-hearted,
as a kind of an integrated package for you.
So there are both.
The global ways of being that are good,
I think grounded, peaceful, and open-hearted is good.
And more generally, I just kind of invite you
into reflecting on what's your overall state of being
and appreciate that your overall state of being
is a kind of floor on which everything else rests.
So if you can get that floor right,
your overall attitude, your overall way of presenting and
being and resting, then everything kind of originates from that.
So not to get all caught
up in, oh my goodness, I've got to find
the best possible global state of being. I'm just naming it
as something to reflect on. And it also goes to levels of identity.
The more that you can have a
sense, for example, that it is your nature.
Deep down, to be grounded, peaceful,
and open-hearted and warm-hearted, that that's
kind of who you are. That's your resting state.
That's your home base. The more you're able to
stabilize in that, the better that could be for you.
So just a passing observation to reflect on.
Then I got a comment from Maria McCleary
at 55 minutes past five, who writes,
I was meditating the other day following your open presence meditation.
I became aware that
there was an undercurrent of self-criticism
that I realized is there much of the time,
though not always in awareness.
As I worked to let that go, fear came up.
I wondered if that fear was protective
or how to deal with fear if it comes up while meditating.
So there are a lot of questions in this.
First, there are different ways to meditate. One form of
meditation is to keep letting go, aware and letting go.
So you're in a state of open awareness.
You're making the minimal necessary effort to stay present
and otherwise you are just disengaging
from everything as it rolls through awareness.
You're not following after it. You're not
resisting it. You're not labeling it.
You're not trying to understand it. You're not trying to grow
Grow from it.
So you're not trying to help us sink in.
You're just letting the movie roll. Sometimes people
that there are versions of this in different
traditions, there are subtle differences
sometimes, but there's kind
of a general similarity between what could be called
open awareness or just sitting or luminous awareness.
You're just there.
So in that kind of deliberate practice,
you would just, the fear is there, so what?
It rolls in, it rolls out, it sticks around, whatever.
You're not trying to do anything with it.
Now, sometimes, on the other hand,
it could be skillful to actually move out of that just
bare witnessing mode of being, choiceless awareness,
it's also called, and actually
inquire and investigate.
Oh.
Fear. Isn't this interesting?
Here I am in this very open place in which the deeper layers of my
psyche are becoming revealed to me. How interesting.
How useful. And you might explore it. And you might
Sense down into what is younger about it, or the body sensations of it.
You're not trying to fix
anything. You're just exploring.
And in the process of exploring, you may learn things
about yourself. There might be some releasing as you unpack,
and open up, and disentangle
different aspects of your...
psyche, your stream of consciousness. Great.
That might be appropriate to do. So you kind of make
a choice. Myself, I confess, I will typically rest in open awareness.
And then if things bubble up
that are kind of interesting, I may divert,
you know, for a little bit, a few minutes, maybe
kind of get some good value there on the cushion.
And then, all right, all right,
I know enough now I can kind of go back to the deeper undertaking.
you know, that I'm engaged in at the time.
The other thing I'll just say is that, isn't it
interesting that, as this person says,
there's maybe an undercurrent of self-criticism, and then
if we start moving into letting that go,
letting go of over-the-top, excessively harsh self-criticism,
maybe an anxiety starts coming up.
Ooh, you know, what could we be afraid
of related to letting go of self-criticism?
Different kinds of things, you know,
an obvious usual suspect in therapy world
would be the fear that if you're not hard on yourself,
other people will be. In other words,
if you're not hard on yourself, you'll mess up in some way.
You'll take your eye off the ball
and then whackola, some kind
of shaming attack will come rolling in from
big brother, big sister, you know, big coach, big parent, whatever.
So that's interesting.
And then what's useful is to appreciate
that you can definitely guide yourself.
You can encourage yourself.
You can hold yourself to account.
You can remind yourself,
as my friends would sometimes around rock climbing,
stop whining, Hanson, and start climbing.
Thank
You know, there could be a place for that.
But that's really different from harsh criticism.
And in the knowing that you can prevent what...
you
harsh self-criticism is trying to prevent
and that you can accomplish what that criticism is
very
trying to accomplish without the collateral damage
of feeling bad about yourself and getting really,
you know, kind of mean to yourself. But when you know that,
much.
then there need not be anxiety
or fear about releasing self-criticism. Okay?
And then the other question or comment that came in.
So, dear Dr. Hanson, on your comment
on grieving as an indicator of what we value,
can we then value something without attachment
so that we can have equanimity,
that we will be okay no matter what?
Thank you.
I suspect that Sue here...
Is already tuned into the answer to the question?
Definitely yes. And the Buddha never spoke against
desire per se. And there's a lot in Buddhism,
certainly early Buddhism, which I'm most familiar
with, that is about healthy desire.
The Eightfold Path is about desiring wise view, wise intentions.
Wise intentions are full of
desire. The wish that others be happy,
the wish that others not suffer, as wholesome desire.
There are even two distinct words in a key language
of early Buddhism, Pali, P-A-L-I,
the word for, you know,
the desire that creates suffering is often translated as craving.
The root of it as a word is thirst.
Something is missing, something is wrong,
pushing us into a drive state.
And then the word for wholesome desire is chanda.
Chanda is beneficial desire.
So there's definitely a place for that.
And I've been thinking here about
this well-known metaphor in Buddhism of the first and the
second door.
which I'll be talking about a little more in a moment.
The first dart has to do with the
inescapable, unavoidable pains of life.
Physical pain, you drop a brick on the foot of a Buddha,
that foot will still hurt.
The inevitable pains of loss, of aging, of losing those we love,
for example. Then there are the second darts
of our reactions driven by craving,
which creates suffering and harm.
All right, first dart, second dart. There is a place.
For grieving, mourning, there's a place for feeling sad, for sorrow.
There's a place for
that. Those are the first darts of life.
Now, there are also the first cookies of life. If you
take issue with my metaphor here, I apologize.
I don't know. Cookie Monster just seems like a good
thing. Cookies. All right. So there are the first cookies of life.
The sound of children laughing, the beauty of a dawn,
the taste of a cookie, you know,
getting your back scratched when it itches,
feeling good about accomplishing something
challenging. There are many first cookies in life.
No problem. Just like first darts
are not inherently a problem,
first cookies are not inherently a problem. It's part of life.
Trouble begins when we get caught up in the second and cookies,
the cookies we create
ourselves in our reactions, our cravings,
our clingings, our attachments to the pleasures of
life, subtle and, you know, just in commonplace.
That's when trouble begins. Isn't that an
interesting addition to the metaphor of the first darts?
I like it. I like it. Identifying a cool,
Cool, neat idea.
That's a first cookie.
But as soon as I start getting caught up in, oh, wow, I'm pretty smart.
Merd!
Now the second cookies are coming
and lots and lots of suffering begins.
Okay?
All right.
Good.
So here we go into my kind of more formal talk.
And I want to kind of create a framework.
In the previous two weeks, we've been together.
Two weeks ago, I talked about this teaching
from a great Korean Zen master, Jinul,
about sudden awakening to our true nature,
peaceful, spacious, unbounded, unconditioned,
beyond language,
and the gradual cultivation of the capacity to rest in our true nature
and to become increasingly permeable to it.
Beautiful.
So here we have this pointing to, toward true nature.
And the recognition that with our body minds,
we have some practice to do.
There's a line from Suzuki Roshi,
you are perfect as you are, and you could use a little
improvement, gradual cultivation.
Then last week, I explored an aspect of what I think
is a kind of home base and very down
to earth ways for our own deep nature
or an approach to it of heartfelt presence.
You could use other words if you like.
It's the global state of being in which we are really
present. We're really here with an open heart, with love, if you will.
That state of being
is an opening that you can follow
and follow as far as you go and see what you find. You can
follow that into the qualities way down deep
in the ground of reality that
seem to be timeless and even with qualities of beneficence, generosity.
If only the generosity,
the endless giving of the arising moment, heartfelt presence.
That then takes us into
our topic now about the fundamental matter
of impermanence. What is impermanent? What is not
Not impermanent.
And how can we draw upon wisdom?
Including the ultimate grounding in what
is not subject to arising and passing away
as we grapple with that aspect of impermanence,
which is loss. A central driver of
Siddhartha's journey, as best we can gather from the biography,
The Life of the Buddha,
in his late 20s, he walked away from, in his era, 2,500 years ago,
a very privileged and comfortable life. He had a wife, he had a...
child, either born or on the way, and he walked away from all of it.
We can think about the
morality of that in terms of standards 2,500 years ago,
and we can also think about the morality of
that abandonment of his wife
and soon-to-be son from the morality now of us today. That's a kind
of a side topic and important one, certainly.
I'm going to keep moving here. And Siddhartha
Siddhartha left all that in his quest.
An ultimately fulfilling, reliably fulfilling basis
for an everlasting, sublime peacefulness.
And as the story of his life has it,
he soon encountered four messengers, four heavenly messengers.
He encountered someone who was ill.
He encountered someone who was aging.
He encountered someone who was dying or dead.
And he encountered someone who was engaged in spiritual practice,
wisdom practices of various
kinds. And we have here, obviously,
the first three of these as reflections of transience.
Here he was in the prime of life, mid to late 20s,
wealthy by the standards of his time,
as best we know, healthy in the prime of life.
And yet he knew eventually that
Certainly three of the four heavenly messengers would come knocking,
aging, disease, and death.
How to practice with all that?
And in his own journey of practice,
at least as we know from his own account, he moved
through progressively more sublime meditative attainments,
and yet each one faded away.
Because it was subject to arising,
and therefore subject to passing away.
It was conditioned.
And he kept looking and looking
and looking for that which is not subject to arising and
passing away, which he ultimately found
and came back from to tell us about and help us
in our own journey, find our way to that,
both as a destination and as an aspect of
our own practice along the way,
which I'll be getting to toward the end of my talk here.
So to think about this confrontation with impermanence,
certainly a central aspect of
life, central to early Buddhism,
is this exploration of impermanence and what it means,
both macro, like losing loved ones,
losing capabilities, losing our own life eventually.
What does impermanence mean to us at the macro level,
and also what does it mean to us at,
we could say, the micro level as well, of very short time scales?
Now, to preview the end of
the story, the Buddha was known as the happy one.
How could it be that a deep facing of
the endless losing of the present moment could lead
Someone who penetrates into that with enormous clarity,
what kind of clarity could lead someone
to be happy? So we'll be exploring that here.
So contextually, you could understand that,
of course, even as in this moment it ends,
the ending of this moment is endlessly offset
by the arising of the next one. Why don't people talk about that part?
You see throughout early Buddhism,
you see throughout lots and lots of philosophy and
lots and lots of existentialism,
this focus on only one of the two aspects of existence,
the endingness of the present.
There's very little attention to the arisingness
of the next one. As a matter of practice,
I think the foundation of practice is clear seeing.
And it's really important to see clearly the arisingness,
the buoying of you,
the way that the making of you is an ongoing process.
That's really half of the truth.
It's important to include that half.
And due to the brain's evolved negativity bias,
like Velcro for bad experiences,
but Teflon for good ones, understandably,
We tend to be more affected by what we lose than by what we gain.
This is inherent in our biology.
The psychologist Daniel Kahneman,
bless his memory, won a Nobel Prize in economics
for identifying the ways that people
are more affected by losses than gains
and more motivated to prevent losses than to acquire equal gains.
We're affected, so it's understandable.
We have the understandable sorrow and grief of our losses,
like loved ones, objects.
I was thinking as I prepared for this talk
of a very significant memory of my childhood.
I was probably about 9 or 10 maybe, and I was a quiet,
shy, young, per-grade kid who skipped a grade.
And I knew I was loved, but there
was a distance between me and my parents.
And I had made at school this art project in which,
you probably did this yourself as a kid,
where you would cut out strips of paper
and then you would glue them together into a formal loop.
And then you would do that one after the other.
So you would have an intertwining collection
of loops that then you could string up.
Three feet long, six or ten feet long, and I had done that in school,
and I wasn't particularly arty, and I was just really glad I did it,
and I had it, you know, kind of in a loose pile,
probably on my desk, because I brought it home.
And I came into my bedroom and my mom,
who was very loving and also kind of controlling
and organized and things had to be a certain way.
It was her way to kind of ward off disaster as someone
who grew up and with a fair amount
of chaos and in her own background.
And she had taken those, you know,
that art project and hadn't really understood it and
just crumpled it and threw it away.
I was so hurt.
I was devastated. And I didn't want to, I was awkward.
I didn't want to reveal how hurt I was.
I was very stoic. And I kind of turned away
and she looked at me and she could, she was stricken.
I could tell she felt really bad.
She didn't realize that she had done this like, whoa. And
I didn't know how to mend
with her and she didn't know how to repair with me. And
I left, I went, I just kind of shrugged and left the room.
Loss. Loss of an object.
Loss of a moment that could have been a repair. Loss of an opportunity
for closeness with my mom. Things like that.
So that's one example. We lose objects and we can
lose what's associated with them.
We can lose possibilities. We can realize that we are just
never going to publish that book.
That boat has sailed. That bus has left the station.
We can realize that, you know.
We're never going to be able to repair that person
because they're not here anymore or they
have cut us off. Or we realize in terms
of a possibility that we're just getting too old to
climb Mount Everest. It's just not going to happen.
Or you lose capabilities. You get older,
your hearing fades, you need your wife to say that again.
What? You know, you're not as sharp
as you used to be. You lose your fitness faster.
It takes a lot longer to gain it. Things change.
So in the realness of appreciating that,
notwithstanding the fact that the losingness
of the present is offset by the gainingness of the next arising,
still it's understandable
that we are indeed really affected by our losses.
And indeed, it is natural to have grief about them.
So I'm going to focus on this in a Buddhist perspective.
And if this material is interesting
for you and you want to go further than in just 45 minutes or so,
I'm going to be exploring it
with you. If you like, check out this four-hour workshop I have.
It's on grief and loss. It's
really about the psychology of all that.
If there's financial need, we're really happy to
scholarship people in. We love doing that.
So just knowing that that material is sitting there,
if you'd like to check it out, I'm going
to keep going with this more Buddhist-y stuff.
Okay, so one of the key teachings, as I've said,
is to feel the first darts, to feel the feelings,
feel the feels of grief without adding second darts to it.
How to do that? Easier said than done,
as Leonard Cohen, some of his best lines here,
teaches us, I know your burden's heavy as you
wheel it through the night.
The guru says it's empty that doesn't make it light. We can have
into the impermanent nature of our grief.
We can have wisdom into all of this, and still,
it can be really painful.
One of the things that can make loss particularly hard to bear
is if we have associated unresolved remorse
or guilt or shame associated with it. Even in
complicated situations in which we know that there
were many factors in play, including with the
the other person,
if we feel that part of what was in play is our own...
Misdeeds, misjudgments, bad actions, bad attitudes,
negligence, etc., that can complicate the loss
further. So part of dealing with loss is letting yourself feel it.
Now maybe you need to empty
your bucket of tears one spoonful at a time,
as I have, very appropriately. Maybe you need to
swing into the pain like a pendulum,
as Peter Levine teaches, and swing back out again.
Pendulating, but spoonful by spoonful,
swing by swing, is a feeling your feelings fully.
The central manual of practice in original Buddhism is mindfulness
and the establishments
of mindfulness, including through investigation,
the depth of our own feeling.
There's just no replacement for feeling the feelings.
Second, how do we face our losses?
Well, there's a lot of Buddhist wisdom about facing them,
especially in their macro forms,
as an inherent inescapable aspect of life.
This is where the teaching of the four heavenly messengers comes in.
And don't forget the fourth, spiritual practice.
There are also the five reflections.
They're stated in different ways. I'll say them like this.
These are questions. Is it given to me
to avoid illness?
Is it given to me to avoid aging?
Is it given to me to avoid death?
Is it given to
me to avoid being separated one way or another,
one day or another, from all that I love? And
is it given to me to avoid inheriting the results
of my deliberate actions? That's part of life.
And, you know, we might like rail against those questions,
but as we, you know, wisdom is
certainly facing, that's part of life.
You know, it's quite something to walk down a street
and to look at faces of strangers passing
by and one by one, take a moment, half a breath,
to look at them and know, oh,
you too will die someday and to see how you feel about that.
You know, sometimes in gatherings, I'm in a group of friends.
We get together once a month, a fairly large group.
And in my mind, of course,
is who among us will be the first to go or the next to go?
We've actually lost two people already from the group over the years.
You know, you realize you're part of that,
and they're looking at you that way.
And you might be the next one to go.
You don't know.
That's common humanity.
You know, it makes it easier to bear our losses
to realize that others have lost as well.
This is not looking on the bright side
or a spiritual bypass or sugarcoating anything,
but there's something that makes it easier
to bear the large-scale macro losses of life
to know that other people have lost too.
Lovely quote here that really has touched me.
For thousands of years, people have said goodbye.
I had two friends as a couple who loved each other dearly,
deep in practice, and in the
morning when they parted company to go to their separate jobs,
when they said things
like see you or bye-bye or love you,
they would take a moment deliberately, just a beat,
if only a beat,
and register the fact that life's uncertain and they might not ever see
that other person again.
And as it actually turned out,
kind of protect their privacy and not give identifying details,
but one of them went into the hospital for a very routine procedure
and acquired an infection
and was gone in a day or two.
Twists, turns.
I had a dear friend who, on his birthday,
his 70th birthday, began feeling unwell, was
taken to the ER.
And within hours of entering the ER,
learned that he had a terminal diagnosis of late-stage cancer,
and he was gone six or seven months later or so.
We don't know, you know,
and just realizing it's like that for them makes it easier to include
that it could be like that for you.
There's a lot of commonplace wisdom about
this in terms of dealing with these kind of
macro scale losses,
including just appreciating people and the time you have with them.
And knowing that we are all hostages to fate.
There's a deep Zen teaching in which Master Yunmen was asked,
so what is it that trees wither and leaves fall?
He said, body exposed in the golden wind.
When our kids were younger and living with us,
they would sometimes go off to an event together in a single car.
And as they pulled out of the driveway,
knowing that they were good drivers
or that they were being with a good driver still,
you know, you go out statistically once in a while, one in a million.
1 in 10 million. I had to live with the fact that I wasn't certain,
certain that they would
both come home. And we live with this.
I think Jimmy Chin, a wonderful rock climbing guide and
filmmaker, says the greatest risk of all
is taking no risks whatsoever. How do we live?
How do we live? We include it.
For me, at least, it's really important to focus on
what's under your control, what's under your relative influence.
The Buddha was right there, you know, his last words,
things fall apart, tread your path with
care. You know, what's under your control is how you live today,
or more exactly, how you live in
the next minute. What are you bringing to the next minute here?
Minute after minute after minute.
No pressure, just love unfolding.
Love living through you unfolding in the next minute.
The proverb, I think, in Tibet is that if you take care
of the minutes, the years will take
Take care of themselves.
I think the most important minute of our life is the next one,
minute after minute after minute.
So if you know that you have lived with a whole heart,
with gusto and intention and ethics and a
learning orientation, and that's how you've lived during
your day amidst, you know, that I slipped
here and I slopped there, on the whole, good on you.
That's what's under our influence day after
Then I want to talk about the micro-losses
that have to do with the transient nature of all
experiences. It's interesting.
Lately, cue the laughter lines, maybe, I've been reading
Ecclesiastes. This is a fantastic translation from Rabbi Rami Shapiro.
Somebody told me about
this book. In fact, I think, yeah,
a friend of mine who's a professor of Christian contemplative practice
It's a fantastic book about,
and it's a translation in which there's an emphasis
on the emptying of every moment.
Every moment the bottom is falling out beneath us, even as
we are buoyed by the next arising, an endless emptying.
Now, the author of Ecclesiastes
is really focused on the losingness of life.
Okay, but that's part of life,
including a continual losingness of life,
moment by moment by moment by moment.
And as the Buddha taught, you can only lose what you cling to.
If we're not clinging, we're not losing.
It's passing away,
but we're not losing because we're not trying to possess or hold on.
And as you come closer and closer to the present,
you become less and less attached to what's passing away.
Now the brain...
is designed to try to cling to what is endlessly changing,
to stabilize it, to keep it for survival purposes, to essentialize it,
to form static things out of the tremendously active fizzing
and bubbling in the nervous system.
That's an inherent kind of tension that flies
in the face of the nature of reality
as endlessly changing as the temporal dimension
of the four-dimensional Big Bang universe is
continually expanding, drawing us endlessly into the next moment.
The brain that's trying to hold
on to the present can't do it.
That creates a subtle tension that's inherent in lived experience
alongside other things that feel a lot better.
What do we do about that?
The more that we come into the present,
the more that we disrupt the brain's tendency
to be a prediction machine and to be fixated on becoming.
And neurologically, to help yourself come into the present,
it's really useful to stay
in touch with what is kind of happening right at the front edge of now.
Rather than getting caught up in labeling it or reacting to it,
you know, just a sense of receiving the arisingness of the present.
And it helps to have a kind of beginner's mind or a childlike mind,
even a sense of wonder and delight for what's arising in the present.
That can help us in our practice rest in the eternal now
and be less, you know, hurt or suffering by what is passing away.
Now, that strategy...
It's about the micro-losses of the transient present,
and it doesn't really touch the fact
that you're still really sad that you lost those cool,
you know, purple and blue bands that you
glued together, you know, as a nine-year-old boy,
and that you lost opportunities for sweetness and
love with your mother, and that will never be gained, you know.
Knowing the transience
of the present doesn't help me feel any better about that.
Like Leonard Cohen says, you know, the guru says, this moment is empty.
That doesn't make it light.
And to name another way to practice
from the Buddhist tradition with our losses, and I'm
going to give you a quick summary here.
The first headline is to feel the first darts of life
without adding second darts. Second headline, facing
macro losses as an inherent part of life
and accepting that we must bear that part of life
if we are to enjoy the rest of it.
Third, recognizing micro losses in the transient
nature of all experience and not overreacting to them
by trying to cling to them. You can only lose
what you cling to.
Now, my fourth headline here for practicing
with loss in a Buddhist frame is to look for
trustworthy refuges that you can count on.
If we lost it, we could not count on it sticking around.
Now, maybe, of course, we couldn't count
on it sticking around, but in any case,
it's not. It didn't stick around.
What are the things that generally stick around?
Well, in the Buddhist tradition,
we have the three refuges of the Buddha, the Dharma, the Sangha.
In other words, it could be understood as we have the refuge.
We can take refuge in or find refuge
in or even abide as the refuge of the teacher,
the teaching, and the community of the taught.
You can take refuge as well in your own good intentions,
your own showing up,
Your own quiet grit, your perseverance,
your own willingness to admit your mistakes
after a certain amount of whining, in my case, you know, that's you.
And you can take refuge in what endures of life.
Life altogether endures, even as individual living organisms pass away.
The world endures, you know, reality altogether.
Here's a lovely quotation from Li Po.
We live together, the mountain and me.
until only the mountain remains.
These are lovely forms of refuge, lovely forms of refuge.
So the fifth headline that the Buddha really pointed
to is to find your footing or have
at least an intuition of that which is beyond all gains and all losses,
that which is not
subject to arising and passing away. This can get very airy-fairy.
If you simply have an intuition of something
or other that is always just prior to the
present, in which or the present is occurring,
the present moment of the Big Bang universe
is occurring, super, you might relate to this in other kinds of ways.
I'm going to offer here three quotations
from the Buddhist tradition that speak to
that which is beyond gaining or losing.
This is the ultimate kind of stuff.
expressed in the Buddhist tradition.
This can be expressed in other ways, in other traditions,
including in theistic ones,
like the Abrahamic traditions of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam,
and in other traditions around the world
that point to a transcendental aspect of reality.
Here we have in the Buddhist sutta,
the entire world is in flames, the entire world is going up
in smoke, the entire world is burning, the entire world is vibrating.
The world of experience, certainly.
But that which does not vibrate or burn,
which is experienced by the noble ones,
in other words, they found it, it's real.
That which is experienced by the noble ones,
where death has no entry,
in that my mind delights.
It was a nudge toward practice to the extent
that you find that which is worthy for you,
even if it is subject to passing away eventually,
or even if you find that which is ultimately
timeless and eternal, delighting in it,
delighting in that which is wholesome and wise is good
practice. Another quotation from a wonderful teacher,
highly recommend her work, Jetsunma
I'm going to Tenzin Palmo.
Woman, originally born, I believe, in Great Britain,
who spent 12 years in retreat in a cave
in Tibet, spent many more years than that also
in retreat in various ways, writes here,
we're not trying to acquire something.
What we're trying to do is to recognize what we already have,
innate, obscured, covered over, distracted from,
perhaps, but always already true,
underneath it all.
This quotation from Zen.
There is something that does not die.
True nature does not disperse like a mist. Knowing true life,
you can be at peace. So here we have
the great matter of life and death.
And we have the great
matter of your own life.
As Mary Oliver puts it, tell me, what shall you do with your one
wild and precious life? How shall you practice
in the next minute, the next day?
How shall you live knowing that eventually you will cross a line
and have less than one year
to live and most likely not know
when you've crossed that line?
There's a sweet spot in which
we don't freak out. We don't get all morbid,
in which we really appreciate the giftedness
of a human life. And also, there
is a certain nudging from Coach Buddha, Dr. Buddha.
who reminds us that things fall apart.
You will fall apart completely one day. Tread your path
with care, which to me, in two meanings of the word care,
mean heartfelt and conscientious.
And then meanwhile, just finishing here,
realize that all around you, everyone else is subject to
the same fate. I don't mind dying.
I think we'll see how I really feel.
It really bugs me that my
My kids are going to die.
The people we pass on the street.
They are subject to the same fates that we are, that you are.
And this is where, you've heard me quote this before probably,
the lines from Miller Williams are,
have compassion for everyone you meet.
And then later in the poem, he writes,
you do not know what secret wars are going on down there
where the spirit meets the bone.
You know, other people are frail too.
As Dylan says, or sang, one who is not busy being born is busy dying.
They're dying.
They're dying too, and they know it.
So that this can take us to tread more lightly on other people.
I'll finish by making the point that in America,
certainly, and probably in other
countries in the world,
political divisions can be very intense, very hot.
And I find for myself that looking
at someone whose politics I find disgusting, morally
appalling, and yet still, and yet still,
they too are exposed to the golden wind.
They too will lose all that they love one day through
the passing of others or their
own passing.
They too will feel pain.
They too will have their last weeks.
They too may experience the light suddenly going out.
And it does something when you look at people in that way.
It opens your heart wider.
It soothes you, helps you be more grounded,
helps you move into love.
And it's good for you,
even while being good for others too.
Oh thank you so much for being here with me.