How can we stay caring in a world that can make compassion feel naïve—or even dangerous?
In “The Courage to Care,” Dr. Rick Hanson explores a vision of compassion that is inclusive, courageous, and effective. Compassion isn’t just about being gentle. It can also mean standing firm, speaking directly, confronting injustice, and addressing the conditions that cause suffering in the first place.
Bringing together psychology, neuroscience, and reflective practices, Rick explores how to combine a warm heart with inner strength—and extend our care beyond the people we naturally think of as “us.”
In this presentation, you’ll explore:
- The three essential elements of compassion: empathy, benevolence, and motivation - How to find common ground with people you find challenging - Why compassion and assertiveness belong together - How to be firm—even fierce—without hostility or hatred - How recognizing systemic causes of suffering can open the door to self-compassion and personal agency - Why collective action matters, and how we can support those working toward a more caring world
At its heart, this talk asks: How can we care for ourselves and others while finding the courage to help change the world we share?
Learn more at rickhanson.com, and subscribe for more teachings from Dr. Rick Hanson on compassion, inner strength, and well-being.
The speaker advocates for an expanded vision of compassion that evolves from simple empathy into a systemic, \"fierce\" approach. By analyzing evolutionary roots and neurological biases, the presentation argues that we must consciously extend our moral concern beyond immediate in-groups to address the structural causes of suffering and foster global collective action.
I'd like to explore with you a vision and especially experiences,
the ground of being,
the kind of prior.
They're increasingly stable qualities of being that are both local
and global, take
into account local and global,
that are both personal and political, immediate and systemic,
and involve a sense of compassion for us and compassion for them.
It's a both and here.
What's the simple, familiar essence of compassion?
So taking a moment here,
imagine a friend who has suffered a loss or is dealing with
something hard, and I'll do it with you.
What arises within you?
And in what arises,
you can probably find three intertwining qualities, a sense of their
suffering, caring toward them.
You're not just aware of their suffering,
you actually care about it, you have the courage
to care about it, and there's a wish that they not suffer.
You're not indifferent to it,
and a desire to relieve their suffering if you can.
These three fundamental aspects of compassion,
to name them in terminology, and other people
use different terminology and kind of frame this.
I'm drawing on a lot of sources here.
Take what I say with a grain of salt,
see for yourself what's useful for you.
We have these three qualities of empathy, benevolence, and motivation.
So in common forms of compassion that are really quite familiar
and incredibly beautiful and
wonderful, empathy typically is applied to people we like
and or are included in some sense in our
circle of us. I like them and they're like me.
That's very straightforward.
Benevolence often is described in soft, tender,
very gentle kinds of ways. When we think and see
how compassion is modeled in literature or TV,
etc., it's often very tender, beautiful, beautiful.
And motivation. We're trying to relieve the suffering.
Well, what do we tend to aim toward?
We tend to aim toward the immediacy of the suffering at hand
or its local causes.
Intrapersonal causes within the individual
or interpersonal causes with other people.
Beautiful, fantastic, and is that all it can be?
Is that all it can be?
So here I'd like to start to explore with you,
both and, an expansion from that beautiful,
commonly experienced core to a wider vision and a bigger experience.
So with regard to compassion in general, it is situated.
It's really important to appreciate
that our compassion for people has to do very often
with situations and causes
and conditions that they find themselves in, in terms of
social structures and systems and upstream factors of suffering.
And we live in times that have many good things.
I'm quite happy about ibuprofen and refrigeration and ESPN.
Thank
There are many, many beautiful things,
including opportunities right here to have access to
information and to share experiences with each other.
And also, we live in times that really challenge empathy
with divisiveness and polarization.
Our times also can really challenge benevolence with norms
you.
and even performative cruelty,
and also a sense of just numbing and overwhelm.
challenging benevolence. Our times also challenge our motivation
because we live in a time in which
there are so many, there are numerous fundamental systemic factors
of suffering, wealth inequality,
authoritarianism included,
that are so big that it feels like we can't be motivated to
do anything about them. They're just too big to deal with.
And so therefore, in terms of these aspects,
empathy, benevolence, motivation,
compassion can sound like or seem like,
or people can come back to us when we talk about compassion.
Compassion can feel, you know, like an opening to attack.
My empathy for you is like opens the
gates of Troy, the Trojan horse to penetrate and then overrun me.
Or compassion in terms of benevolence and its sweet,
soft, tender expressions, you know,
can sometimes feel sort of naive
or like we're missing the big picture or, you know, like trying
to put out a fire with a, you know, a squirt gun or sappy saccharine.
And then also it can seem in
terms of motivation sort of trivial,
like we're bypassing addressing politics and economics and
poverty and other kinds of factors, you know,
in something that, you know, can be
Criticized as like a band-aid or a spiritual bypass.
I want to emphasize the word seem or feel here, or words.
And then, including in our clinical work,
as a coach or a therapist or helping professions
in other ways, as an educator, healthcare provider,
perhaps, unwittingly, not through
our intent, still, its impact,
that encouraging compassion, if we don't take into account
the larger situated context,
compassion can increase the sense, paradoxically, of
Separation and isolation in terms
of empathy can increase the sense of personal weakness
regarding benevolence and can reinforce a sense of helplessness
when we try to address
our motivation for dealing with larger systems.
So what are we going to do about it?
We need to expand our compassion to be more inclusive,
passionate, and effective.
And I want to explore with you major aspects of this.
In terms of empathy, we can extend our empathic circle
of moral concern to those who are them,
not just to us. We can find benevolence.
Compassion can be expressed in ways that are
persistent, penetrating, even fierce.
The word fierce can be understood in different ways as
not something that's vicious and horrible,
rather something that's penetrating and powerful.
Speaking to myself, the first time I went to Haiti,
Some years ago, I was just appalled by the conditions
in which almost everyone there lives.
I walked around in a cold rage.
I was regulated, I was present, I was grounded.
I wasn't afflicted with hatred, and I was in a moral rage.
And I think that's a kind of fierceness.
It's not the only kind, but it's a kind that counts.
Also, motivation. We can apply our motivation
to the upstream systemic causes of suffering,
not just to their downstream consequences.
Okay, so let's explore each of these three.
Empathy, benevolence, and motivation,
starting with widening the circle of us. So this is where
There's an opportunity for the Wayback Machine to,
what a long, strange trip it's been as a human
being evolving on this planet over such a long period.
This gives us an opportunity
to understand the neurological,
neuropsychological evolutionary roots of compassion.
So the complicated neural systems underlying human
compassion have evolved over millions of years.
And interestingly, they have deep roots in the care of children.
If there's one function
that an organism has, it's to pass on genes that pass on genes.
It's a really central
driver, obviously.
Well, it's very interesting that compassion is situated in this most
fundamental driver of biological evolution,
protecting and promoting the survival and
the longevity
and the onward passing of their own genes of our children.
So to simplify that complicated journey,
to highlight some key features.
Our hominin ancestors began manufacturing stone tools.
They would use tools to make tools.
You know, I'm a wilderness guy and had a lot of adventures,
usually based on poor judgment, but anyway.
And I couldn't make a stone tool.
So full props and credit to ancestors with brains a third our size
who could manufacture stone tools.
As the brain got bigger,
childhood necessarily got longer so that it could mature to its full
development. For example,
the brain of an adult chimpanzee or bonobo, our two closest genetic
relatives in the tree of life,
an adult chimpanzee brain is twice the size of a newborn chimpanzee
So a newborn's brain has to double in its size over the course of...
physical maturation if you're a chimpanzee.
Well, your brain, I think we're probably all
adults here. I'm an adult.
Our adult brain as humans is four times larger than the brain of
a newborn. It has to quadruple in size. And if a human newborn were
With a brain half the size of an adult brain, its mothers would
not be able to walk while being able to deliver a baby.
And so as the brain got bigger, necessarily, childhood grew longer,
which forced longer and longer periods of dependency of infants.
toddlers on their mothers and a longer
and longer period of dependency of their mothers
on their mates and with extended circles of care,
the village it takes to raise a child.
Compassion and other pro-social capabilities,
in other words, supported the care of our
hominid ancestors and early human ancestors,
so that enabled the brain to get bigger.
And as the brain got bigger,
it acquired more and more pro-social capabilities,
which then enabled it to get even bigger in an upward spiral.
So here we are now as human beings who've walked the earth,
believe it or not, for 300,000 years.
I live in Northern California
and I routinely think about the native people whose lands were
stolen from them walking through my backyard
at the bottom of a watershed on the edge of
open space for certainly the last 10,000 years, if not longer.
And until farming and herding emerged in various places
in various ways around 10,000 or even more recently 5,000 years ago,
we all lived in small hunter-gatherer bands with 40 or 50 other people,
mainly, our entire lives.
With a little bit of diffusion into and out of our bands,
but that's who we were living with.
And depending on each other for survival...
The foundation of social life was a particular strategy
that scientists call, including leading
scholars like Paul Gilbert,
as Chris Kerman was speaking a little earlier, we developed
a unique strategy among hundreds,
hundreds of other primate species, a unique foundational
strategy for social life called caring and sharing.
Which essentially boils down to compassion and justice,
rather than the holding and controlling
alpha dominance social structure of all other primate species,
in which alphas, predominantly
male alphas, hold onto food and control reproduction.
It's quite remarkable to realize
that the foundation of being human is a unique way
of life that's grounded in compassion and justice.
So in that life that we lived, our ancestors lived,
you might locate yourself in a Stone
Age band, you know, in which you're dealing
with and putting up with and needing to rely
upon the same 40-ish people your entire life.
The circle of us was obvious in daily activities
in which we were gathering together, raising
children together, sometimes hunting together,
and that sense of us was reinforced routinely
in conflicts with them.
So we have these two qualities within us,
certainly, metaphorically, routinely spoken
of as the wolf of love and the wolf of hate,
us and them, and they are both present in
us, certainly, but in terms of everyday encounters
with most other people, they were grounded
in the wolf of love.
Empathy, the foundation of compassion.
Without empathy, compassion is rote and routine. I've
been on the receiving end of the compassion of some people
and kind of my circles over my life
in which they kind of phoned it in.
They couldn't be bothered to have the courage
to actually let it land.
Whoa, what it was like to be me sometimes as a result of the impacts of
themselves. So compassion is really nested in, certainly, empathy.
So that foundation
of compassion was naturally evoked in conditions of daily life.
People did not have to go to
workshops in hunter-gatherer bands to have empathy
for the other members of their band.
These days, though, right,
we are surrounded by and affected by people who are unknown to us.
They are them.
Think about the number of people in a typical city
that we walk past over the course of
A day. We don't know who they are.
And think about the degree to which often we're in pretty
delicate situations or even conflict-centered situations
with people who have different
viewpoints, different identities, different politics.
That sense of difference really
undermines empathy. And there's a ton of research about it.
I'm summarizing here in my bullet
bullet points, some of the key features.
There's a term called intergroup empathy bias.
In other words, it's a decline of empathy.
There's a reduction of empathy for the other group
with a support for empathy for my group.
Arbitrary categories and labels matter.
There are studies in which people are assigned,
you know, they have a different bandana.
It makes me think about the TV show Survivor
in which they have different, you know, bandanas.
And, you know, the purple bandana and the green bandana.
And so you sort people into groups
and you just kind of let them roll.
And pretty soon people in the purple group
are coming up with theories as to why purple
is a much better color than green
or vice versa, skin color.
Pretty arbitrary, isn't it?
But think about, you know, the consequential sorting of groups
just grounded in the color of a person's skin.
Neurology.
Neurologically, the sense of difference
as it gets manipulated in laboratory experiments
and with analogies or extensions, rather, to everyday life,
there's less activity in the interior, which means frontal, cingulate,
which is a really important part of the brain.
Two of them, one on either side around the midline,
that's very much involved in
Thank
Social activity, social cognition,
and also in the integration of thinking and feeling.
So there's less anterior cingulate activity
as the sense of difference grows, and there's
less mirroring broadly,
both somatically and emotionally and cognitively, in all three
you.
ways of mirroring, particularly sensory-motor mirroring,
for another in pain.
We don't respond so much to the pain of another on average.
We can train ourselves out of this,
we'll be talking about that more later,
but we don't respond so much to the pain of a person who's different.
And then on the other hand, seeing a rival,
I will.
a them that maybe we're opposed or we don't like very much in pain,
that can actually activate reward circuits in the brain.
That sense of difference really, really matters.
So what are we going to do about it?
You know, less empathy means more indifference,
more divisiveness, more conflicts.
So these days, we need to make efforts
that our ancestors didn't have to make
to look for similarities and shared values and common ground.
And research shows that doing this benefits oneself,
benefits us, not just them.
As we expand that circle, actually, our sense of stress reduces.
Wow. There's less anxiety. We have more of a sense of common
ground, common humanity, and there's less reactivity neurologically.
There are lower demands on executive functions
when there's less sense of separation.
We don't have to keep figuring out what to do about being beleaguered
and put upon and mistreated.
Lower demands on executive functions for problem solving,
including regions around the prefrontal cortex.
And there's better problem solving with a greater sense of what we have
in common and more effective negotiating and more effective repair.
Lots of benefits.
in widening the circle of us.
So, if you like,
here's a minute of experiential practice.
Bring to mind, if you like,
someone who's moderately challenging for you.
Perhaps a neighbor, co-worker, relative, family member,
even someone you like or love a lot
and who still has some challenges for you.
Bring that person to mind
and notice what it's like for you.
Plant them squarely in the forefront
of your consciousness now.
Take a moment to consider what you share in common.
You might have soft thoughts like,
like me, you suffer pain.
Like me, you love your children.
Like me, you are human. Like me,
you make mistakes. Like me, one day you will die.
See what happens. You just cognitively recognize
what you have in common.
I noticed for myself, there's
an immediate softening
and paradoxically,
There's a greater sense of a kind of recognition
of and relaxation into my own needs, standing up
for myself in ways that are much calmer
and in a way confident that are nested in a sense of how
we are we somehow that in healthy ways can
also strengthen that sense of me. So these days at this
time in our history in the larger context.
There really could be nothing more important than
our own deliberate efforts, our own mindful efforts
to expand that circle of us,
to include other humans and eventually all of life itself, leading
onward into a greater sense of solving our problems together
with other people and in a greater sense
of vulnerability and humility as the human species
and stewardship in the planet altogether.
So then let's take a look at that second aspect of a wider
or more expansive sense of compassion
having to do with benevolence.
So when others are dominating, pushy, aggressive, dismissive,
high-handed, I think about Ta-Nehisi Coates' definition
of privilege as not having to take
something into account when we're dealing with other people
who maybe have the privilege or
or carry the privilege of not having to take us into account.
How do we respond? Well,
certainly one kind of a response is just to get really reactive and
go to war with them. That's not always very effective.
Another very common response is to
go beta, just to kind of go one down, knuckle under,
get passive, dissociate, tune out. And
those reactions are really turbocharged by a previous life history.
Particularly including trauma in which we got through
the situation by in effect becoming
submissive and subordinate to whatever was happening at the time.
And that's a serious
survival strategy that's been well studied in mammalian
and primate ancestors. And sometimes
to get through, to survive, to just get to the other side,
we may need to go there today.
Still, that beta swerve is very close to the shame response,
and Chris Germer has recently
just written a beautiful book about self-compassion and shame.
And that shame response leads onward
and relates to subordination and repeated subordination.
There's a lot of research on
this. Gradually wears down personal health and well-being. Therefore,
Move to relieve suffering in others as well as in ourselves.
Sometimes it's necessary
and skillful to come into things with a strong heart,
to combine compassion and assertiveness, heart and strength.
And then occasionally how we talk to ourselves.
You know, when we wake up having hit bottom
in a puddle of our own vomit,
you know, I've had my moments that are fairly close
to that in different kinds of ways.
There's a way of speaking to ourselves
that doesn't get sucked into the pitfalls of self-hatred,
but definitely can bring a kind of firmness to bear.
So this kind of expression of benevolence can be blunt, loud, fiery,
willing for others to be uncomfortable.
For myself, you know, I started meditating in 1974.
Thank
Totally sloppy. Anyway, I've been doing it for a while,
and I think it's really true that the
you
older I get, the calmer I get, and the madder I get,
for
add so much unnecessary suffering,
so much injustice in the world.
having
That combination is what we're talking about here.
But to do it effectively and to not get sucked into the wolf of hate,
me.
because anger among
the four major classes of negative so-called emotions, sadness, shame.
Fear and anger. Anger is the one that releases
a lot of reward chemicals in the brain.
Dopamine or norepinephrine.
You know, the proverb about anger is that it has a honeyed
tip and a poisoned barb.
That honeyed tip can suck us right in. So, wisdom.
It's really necessary.
You know, we need to have discernment.
We need to have a sense of proportionality.
How bad was this actually?
You know, insight and also tools of various kinds
and versions of emotional intelligence,
skillful modes of communicating.
I know that Chris Willard has taught and written a lot about that.
We also need determination, persistence,
a kind of grit, bravery, and we need passion.
We need aliveness, vitality, enthusiasm,
energy to be able to communicate in this more passionate
and effective way. When we're embodying these qualities,
because they're rusted in us, and we
grow them over time of wisdom, persistence,
determination, wisdom, determination, and
passion, then how does it feel to be that way?
There's a quality of dignity, gravity, seriousness,
Look at the face.
It means business.
Mama means business.
There's that quality there.
Or Papa too.
And interesting, there's a sense of humility as well.
It's not about me.
It's the truth being named flowing through me.
Without hostility, vengeance, cruelty, or hatred.
It's really useful to,
as we cultivate qualities and we study people and embody them and then
kind of reverse engineer them experientially
and somatically in ourselves, it's really
useful to have models for this.
You might think about people in your life
who embody this quality, including maybe in
certain situations.
My wife is a very kind of relaxed person who had a very healthy,
happy childhood.
Cursor. So she has less empathic understanding
of my neuroticism. But anyway,
she's, you know, very sweet.
She doesn't, you know, she's not a rager. And so occasionally
in our relationship or family or in life,
when she just drops in and name it and how it is,
it has a lot of weight. You might also think about public figures.
Pick your list. You know,
for me, my list, people, Greta Thunberg,
who, at the UN and elsewhere, Malala,
Nelson Mandela and others, not dysregulated,
not afflicted with rancor or malice, or one of the
most beautiful photographs I have seen.
Think about Thich Nhat Hanh and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
Just feel the weight of that. I really like
this proverb that one is truly wise who is peaceable,
friendly, and fearless.
So let's take a moment here, another minute or so.
We're calling it time
Or finding your way into a felt sense in your body
of this kind of expressed benevolence,
caring, courageous caring.
You care, and you're really strong about it.
You might recall a time when you were really loyal to someone else,
and you spoke up for them.
You were strong on their behalf,
getting better care for an aging parent, maybe,
or sticking up for a child or someone who was vulnerable.
You were the real deal.
You really brought it to bear then.
Or a time when you really
stuck up for yourself.
You really brought it to bear
on your own behalf.
You might notice
the embodied sense of this
into the chest coming up.
What's happening in your face
when you're expressing your caring
in really firm ways.
I mean this.
I really want to thank you
for your own willingness
to step into your power
in that way
for your own sake
and the sake of all of us.
And then,
on to the third aspect.
of an expansive vision
and experience of compassion for the times that we have that
has to do with addressing, in terms of motivation,
upstream sources of suffering. You know,
compassion moves us to relieve suffering, okay,
which necessarily leads onward to changing the
causes of suffering to the extent they can be changed. Much suffering,
the causes of much suffering cannot be changed.
We feel a loss. We're sorrowful.
Events have occurred that cannot be undone. They have ripple
effects. Okay. And still, there is much suffering
that has causes that in principle can be relieved,
including causes that are structural
and broad and cultural and systemic.
You know, many of us spend our days helping people out
of the river of suffering.
That's been my personal career.
I started in the wild and woolly human potential movement in the 70s,
kind of broadened onward,
and thankfully into getting some clinical training
and a license, and it's continued
onward in my own teaching in different areas
that draw upon contemplative wisdom.
Beautiful, beautiful work,
helping people out of the river of suffering and keeping
them out of the river of suffering.
And after a while, after you've been doing that for a while,
including 50 years by now,
roughly for me, you start to look upstream.
What's pushing all those people in, right?
What's going on?
What?
And what can we do about it?
So many forces push people into the river of suffering.
And I'm speaking here about, in principle,
preventable forces that very often operate
to the advantage of the few and the disadvantage of the many.
So many forces are pushing people into the river of suffering.
It can seem really complicated.
How do I really understand it?
Still, one underlying factor just stands out.
Stands out.
We made a shift with...
Herding and farming, roughly five or 10,000 years ago, for most people,
we made a shift that led us to depart from the caring and sharing
that was sustainable in small groups, hunter-gatherer bands.
We made a shift from compassion
and justice to social structures based on the more primitive,
atavistic, primate strategy of social life, holding and controlling.
And for the past 10,000 years, for most people,
most situations, including arguably the majority
of people in the world today,
it's kind of more or less Game of Thrones.
It's the uncommon good today.
And you can check the references in the back if you like my slides,
it's factually true.
Roughly two-thirds of humanity lives under autocratic control,
lives under the thumb
or the boot of a dictator or dictatorial systems.
Just one in eight humans today live in a full democracy.
And frankly, there's some argument about whether America,
my home country, would fit
into that category today.
Many inequities persist.
Total unfairness for women and many other groups.
Persistent inequities. Notwithstanding whatever
progress may have been made, much inequity persists.
Stolen wealth. It's just...
It's shocking as an American for me to look around and recognize,
first of all, the lands that were stolen from the Native people
in profoundly brutal ways and terrorizing ways, and then the terrorism
that's innate in systems of enslaving people whose labor
is a major factor, stolen labor, stolen lives.
In the prosperity of America,
the wealthiest country in the world today.
And then colonialism, you know, Jeremy Lenton,
as a scholar, calls it a wealth pump in which
trillions of dollars were extracted more
or less from the global south to, you know, prosper
certain countries and certain individuals in the global north.
It's just astonishing.
In the USA, just factually, these are facts.
It's not.
Left or right, liberal or conservative, these are just facts.
In, you know, 16 years, fossil fuel
and related companies spent over two billion dollars legally,
and probably much more than
that through shadier forms of influence in America,
to block climate change action. Outspending environmental groups,
10 to 1, and they got what they paid for. And to avoid taxes worldwide.
Close to 40% of multinational profits are hidden
or sheltered in tax havens each year.
That's the not common good.
Recognizing that many of the sources
of individual suffering originate outside the front door,
actually, here's some research for you,
reduces self-criticism and self-blame.
Reduces depression. To realize that you're dealing with,
you have to swim upstream every day
and you didn't make the river.
You got to deal with it, but it's not a personal fault. That
recognition can reduce depressed mood.
Also, recognizing what is outside your control and
landing on you, by contrast, really recognizes,
highlights rather, highlights those areas where
you do have personal agency. Certainly within your own mind,
there's a lot of agency opportunity there
for what's actually possible and increases self-compassion.
Recognizing systemic sources
of suffering can increase a person's self-compassion.
Wow, that's pretty cool, right?
And so, after we recognize systemic sources of suffering,
upstream causes, we ask, of course,
what can we actually do about them?
There are many things to do, and one thing really stands out.
In significant past changes to those systems,
and in efforts and realistic plans today,
we see one essential factor. What is it?
It's effective collective action,
Which goes back to our past and coming home again.
In their small bands, our ancestors solved
their problems through collective action.
They came together and they regulated the bullies
and the freeloaders that have free
reign in other primate species
in the more primitive strategy of holding and controlling.
Our ancestors came together to regulate bullies
and freeloaders who would otherwise dominate.
And that regulation of bullies
and freeloaders for the sake of the greater good was a necessary
condition.
to arise and to thrive and persist.
In our lifetime, I grew up during this period in
America, we've seen collective action for civil rights,
environmentalism, women's rights,
respect for children, anti-racism, anti-war, and so forth.
It works when people come together.
People may wonder, of course, what can I actually do?
All right. You can't probably yourself initiate some kind
of mass movement, although certainly
a few people have done that and are doing that today.
I love Mr. Rogers. I think he's an American
saint. And he says famously that his mother told him as a boy
when he was upset, look for the
helpers, look for the helpers.
And if you don't know what to do, there are millions of organizations
and groups working right now to make a better world.
You know, with your voice or vote or time,
sometimes a little money, we can help the
helpers.
Now, if you're totally nuts, you can found your own nonprofit.
Whoa, you know, but you don't have to do that.
You can look around for other people
who are effective in their place, a cause you
care about, and you can lend your support.
Right? In the body, enzymes speed up positive reactions.
In humanity altogether, the body
politic, our species altogether, all eight billion of us today,
collective action is like an enzyme
that accelerates positive change. Right?
Stepping back, big picture, a key determining force in how
this century turns out,
whether we have big change by 2100 in good ways.
Key determining force, maybe the determining force,
will be the amount of collective action
that enzyme we can mobilize in the body politic for the common good.
How do we do it? How do we
actually accelerate the rate of effective collective action
in the 21st century? Compassion
has a unique biological, psychological,
evolutionary, and even spiritual power.
Deep in our biology, compassion brings us together.
And together, we really can change the world.
How do we expand
into the 21st century in this way?
It's interesting that this expansive view of compassion,
this expanded paradigm of compassion might sound so lofty.
And actually, it's about being normal.
It's about coming home.
Right. It brings us home to our past.
This way of approaching the future brings us home to our
past. Our biological nature.
It is your nature to care and to share with others. That nature
might be obstructed or distracted or hindered
or threatened or overwhelmed. And still, it's
our home base. We may have been driven from home.
We might experience inner homelessness.
And still, we can come home to that base in which everyone is included.
We have fierce commitments to each other,
and we solve our problems together.
This is normal.
We just have to get normal again.
This expanded approach can carry us into the future.
It took 10,000 years to get here.
I think it's important to be patient.
I love the fact that patience is one
of the perfections of the Bodhisattva and the Buddhist
tradition, and I'm still working on my own.
It'll take us a while to get to a better place.
Still, individuals at the individual level, personal is political.
We can care about them.
We may disagree with them.
We may oppose them.
We may recognize that it's actually in their interest
for us to succeed politically, really, long-term,
definitely in their children's interest,
but still we can care about them.
We can also speak out fiercely about injustice
and we can actively support causes.
We see here as individuals,
these three aspects of compassion,
empathy, benevolence, and motivation.
Also, small groups can do much the same.
They can really form around projects.
I think about the, there's plenty of opportunity between
the individual level and the level
of central governments.
Central governments are often the problem, not the solution.
But in the in-between,
people can strengthen the fabric of their societies at the scale
of groups, neighborhoods, organizations.
health care settings, schools, and so forth to make things better.
And pro-social organizations can start forming alliances
at the scale that's big enough to solve real problems.
It's interesting that I have a business background somewhat,
and business people compete at the market level.
They cooperate at the political level, singing kumbaya together.
They put their money in a single bucket.
legally and corruptly to influence policy.
And I'm just stunned, frankly, by the ways in which many,
many, many, many most nonprofit
pro-social organizations,
including many of them run by people who are my teachers or
friends, are very friendly with each other at the street level
and just about never.
Cooperate with each other,
never pool their resources in meaningful ways at a scale that's
big enough to compete with those other forces of wealth and privilege.
And I think that's a terrible shame
and something really important to correct.
So, finishing up. To support this expanded paradigm in individuals,
groups, and alliances,
four years ago, we established
the non-profit Global Compassion Coalition. We promote the study,
the cultivation, the application in different contexts,
like in schools, prisons, and workplaces
of compassion, and we support the advocacy of expansive compassion.
And the heart of our work, and if you'd like
to learn more about it, just go to our website.
The heart of our work involves humility.
It's about encouraging the greater impacts that come
when together we bring our efforts
to problems at larger and larger scales.
So, finishing up here.
Speaking of Mr. Rogers, you know,
he teaches that each of us has been loved into being.
So we might finish here with just a kind
of a personal reflection on the ways that you have
been loved into being by others.
In meaningful ways,
I have been loved into being by my friends
and colleagues and teachers here. And be aware
of how you have loved others into being. Children,
clients, patients, colleagues,
friends, the wider world.
It's really beautiful. And in much the same
By joining together, together is the crucial word,
by joining together at the global scale,
we can love into being the world that we long
for with compassion in its heart.
What a beautiful thing that will be.
And we should never lose faith with that possibility.
Never give up our commitment to that possibility.
Thank you.