The Power of No – Talk with Dr. Rick Hanson

Rick Hanson
90 followers
10.6K Video Views·Dec 7, 2024
I offer these every week along with a
guided meditation just click the uh
subscribe link below to be notified
through YouTube when I post the latest
recording or if you'd like to join us
live which would be great uh just go
into the description section below and
follow the link along to be able to sign
up for
free I'd like to talk with you about um
my response to a really interesting
email I got
from I guess we might say If This Were A
you know talk radio longtime listener
here you know and this person wrote me
and they they said essentially Rick
appreciate your work thank you Etc
appreciate your focus on that which is
beneficial let's say that which is
positive and saying yes to those aspects
of
life
and as
a 70ish year old woman this person wrote
me I think it's also really important
to appreciate the value not just of yes
but of
no which for she went on many many women
uh including women of my age and women
girls and women in general is is really
important to be able to to say and to
live I thought that was really useful
and very provocative so I want to
explore that with you here uh Under The
Heading of the power of no which is
slightly uh for me as an homage to eart
and the Power of Now this is the power
of no so here we go and as we do this I
really invite you to consider the
applications into your own immediate
life both the power of know um expressed
out into the world toward certainly
other people as well as toward certain
conditions or
constraints um or um threats that are
accumulating and also aiming the power
of know and using the power of know
inside your own mind in various ways so
that's what we're going to be exploring
first what do I mean by
no I don't
mean a rigid
reactive aversive
mean now you know kind of thing aimed at
the outside or the inside okay there's a
place for that it arises maybe we need
to clean up the me you clean up the mess
later I can speak from some personal
experience about that I'm really talking
about a kind of no that has uh positive
effects and uh comes from positive
purposes beneficial
purposes to broaden it out there is
certainly the very direct no uh recently
I was uh preparing to kind of get into
relationship with someone who was going
to help me with something and it became
more and more clear that this person had
been
deceptive
and
was costing me in various ways and
internally I just went to nope nope
going to wrap this one up nope we're not
going down this road any F farther so
sometimes the no is just a very no
straight up no and you might explore
your versions of no good
healthy versions of no for you whatever
they are you might even say them out
loud if you can or mutter them to
yourself to broaden it out one of the
most powerful uh forms of no is do not
know don't know not so sure one of my
favorite collections of short piy
teachings from the grade zen teacher
Suzuki roshi is not always
so um a version of no
is not so sure or uh gonna think about
it or not ready to go to yes
so you might think about your kinds of
NOS that are really good for
you a key kind of no is really Central
in Buddhist practice and teaching and it
goes back to
um uh the combination of the moral
elements in
Buddhism as well as deep deep practice
so many of the if you will in Buddhism
there are these three pill of
practice in the language of early a key
language of early Buddhism poly they are
Sila samati and Pa Sila I think could be
well translated as virtue somat as
mental training including deep states of
absorption and Pa as wisdom wise view
well the Sila element The Virtue element
is often described through negation not
killing not stealing
um not
intoxicated not lying not harming
yourself for others through sexuality
those are the basic five precepts also
we have the wise intention element of
the eight-fold path who which has
several Elements which are also uh
described a lot in the form of
negations uh basically not
harming not having ill will toward
others and not being attached to sense
Pleasures notice the form of that so
there's a place for that and you might
ask yourself in your own inner practice
and your own um moral approach to life
you know your own Integrity system what
are your NOS what are your
knots
um I took on myself the precept many
years ago of never speaking around
acting from anger and the first day I
took that precept that
admonition I failed multiple
times and I began to realize how much
anger was leaking you know and I'm a
pretty relaxed mellow guy and still oh
my goodness exasperation eye roll snippy
tone
attitude you know certain gestures they
just came from anger and I'm not talking
here about suppressing anger and I'm not
making the expression of anger bad I'm
saying this was a personal no for me uh
particularly in my family uh to not
speaking or acting from anger anger
could be present but not putting it in
charge not putting it in the driver's
seat which forced me then to really
acknowledge what else was in the car
often the softer more vulnerable hurt
feelings inside or the anxieties or the
longings that were under the expression
of anger which would be obscured when by
habit I just engaged speaking or acting
from
anger so that's an example of taking on
a certain kind of no that is in we could
say the the ca or virtue element of
practice and also uh deep in Buddha
Dharma is this fundamental view that
um ordinary
reality
consists of processes in relationship
with each other that have the quality of
impermanence and change uh due to
underlying causes and conditions that
which arises due to causes and
conditions also passes away eventually
this is deep in the durma which then
leads to the recognition of the ways in
which craving for certain phenomena to
persist and to possess them my precious
boom is a fast track to to suffering
and harm for others so in all this the
Buddha's Journey himself was toward what
he described as that which is not
subject to arising and passing away that
which is
eternal
unconditioned and that's the essence of
the third of the Four Noble Truths
nurota or the cessation of um
conditioned phenomena and and with an
opening into the unconditioned and
people have been trying to figure out
what the Buddha was talking about for
2500 years since and arguing about it
quite often
still there is a lot of not not
conditioned not born not dying or un
unconditioned
unabated so a very
um profound form of know that we are
invited to explore in our practice
including in our explorations of the
ultimate ground of
all I call it the great
un what is
unabated what is
undefended what
is um
unclouded what is
undying the great
un uh in Zen the little I know there's
often a work with coons and one of the
primary Coons is the great con of moo
you know the response I believe of joshu
or a great zen master to the question
does does a dog have Buddha nature and
their reply was was Mo which I
understand in Translation in effect is
not now what does that not mean what
does that not mean including does that
not refer to the question
itself and that
not as a kind of know is a great un so I
invite you to explore that which is UN
for you you know um
so broadening the sense of
no okay second we apply the no out into
the world so I invite you here to
reflect on what are the ways in which
usefully you set
boundaries or just tell people nope I'm
not going to hop on board your belief
system or nope I'm not going to do that
anymore uh you know thinking about
people and families uh particularly
relevant to uh as a
generalization you know women uh or
people who identify as women in family
systems for people to say nope I'm not
going to do more than my fair share of
the housework around here
anymore I'm just not going to I'm on
strike I'm not going to so you might
consider some of the useful ways you've
said no in the various forms we're
exploring here in the outer
world just take a moment we'll take a
few breaths of reflection here to
consider how do you or have you said no
in various ways directed outwardly
toward other people or conditions
for example you might have decided nope
I'm not going to vote for you let's say
or you might say um as as I'm needing to
increasingly no I'm just not going to
add that to the cup that I'm really
trying to empty to create more space at
this stage in my life for all kinds of
things such as Wilderness or deepening
practice or time with my wife uh no I'm
I'm just not going to add that no I'm
not going to agree to that no I'm not
going to commit to
that on the other hand you might ask
yourself these days looking out at the
world including other
people what could you say no to that
would be
useful let's take a a few breaths to
reflect on that question right
now you might even want to make a little
list for yourself
and this inquiry then really starts to
surface something important which
is what's on the inside for us
about saying
no to others who want things from us and
we'll be sad if we don't do them or
will'll be angry
or punishing toward
us but both in
reality sometimes it's real we have to
be careful about saying no or revealing
even that deep inside our mind is a no
even if our mouth is saying yes because
we have to say yes to stay safe um very
often we transfer into the present our
history from the past notably in our
families so for
example myself I grew up with loving
decent really wonderful parents who were
traditional
and no was not allowed to come out of
the mouth of their three kids including
the oldest one me no
no no was verboten was a big no and so I
made myself it I was I recall exactly
where I was too when I made myself do it
at about age
22 I made myself say no to my father
about a fairly trial thing I set it up I
wrote notes to myself before talking
with him on the phone it was easier to
do over the phone and I said no to him I
don't know what it was
about doing something for him going to a
thing or I don't know what it was in any
case he he paused you could tell like
huh and then he then he rolled with it
it was not a big deal but boy it was
that hard for me to do so you might ask
yourself particularly given your own
history of and how you've been
socialized especially if you are come
from a culture in which no especially
maybe from certain people or kinds of
people in that culture are forbidden um
there's a no cult there's a cultural no
wrapped around that individual no um or
maybe a particular history in your
family or uh experiences in environments
where saying no was was really trained
out of you in a way and the habit of
suppressing your no is trained
in what's in
you that's blocking the authentic nose
from coming
out yeah and what can you do about that
can you soften that inhibition on saying
no can you uh risk the dreaded
experience uh can you maybe take a look
at that chapter in my book just one
thing risking a dreaded experience or
stuff I've said about that that's freely
offered out in the world you know to to
help yourself gradually push back the
bars of your invisible
cage how can you you know strengthen the
sense of being on your own side being a
kind Ally to yourself who tells yourself
hey your your know is legitimate other
people get to say no they say no to
you you you too have that right to say
no it's okay you can say
no partly because if we have the right
to say no then our yes has more
traction and then there is the no that
we say to
ourselves in various ways that are good
for
us so so for
example I we can say no to that
mindstream that train of thought that
comes along while we're meditating or in
life in general that wants to carry us
away whatever it might
be often because the brain's negativity
bias it's a resentment of some kind or
regret or worry or
remorse or grievance or c
about other
people or criticism of
ourselves and we can basically go when
we start to recognize that that train
the the the conductor is saying all
aboard or we find that we've been on the
train for the last few minutes if not
more at that point can we say no and go
nope nope not going to not going to
follow after this the muttering
persist for a bit but I'm not going to
Feed and Fuel this I'm not going to
follow after it nope nope Sharon
saltzburg has this lovely way of
describing mindfulness as saying
mindfulness particularly as things
settle down a bit it is some ways like
being in a nice Meadow flowers
butterflies even if you know there's an
awareness of pain but you're present
you're there and periodically you'll see
a train go by that that wants to kind of
call call you but nope nope you stay in
the meadow and then at some point you
find that you're in the
Train the train of thought the
distraction the
rumination but as soon as you realize
you're in the train and then you you
make a choice right there do you want to
continue ruminating about that or
thinking about that or problem solving
that or in meditation do you want to
return to the meadow do you want to come
back come home if you will to the meadow
and as soon as you realize you're on the
train very often you're suddenly back in
the meadow so that's a internally
directed no uh there are other important
noes directed at some of our habits or
appetites uh I've myself been you know
among other kind of forms of raising the
bar for myself becoming ex more and more
granular and and
um careful and detailed in the present
about uh dropping my criticisms or
exasperations on other people and I say
this as a fellow who's pretty relaxed
pretty okay but I have my standards and
I try to meet them and I notice other
people who
aren't so what do I do with
that and so I've internalized I'm and
I'm working on it it's a working proc
progress what I call
NBC NBC never that's a no never be
critical
now to be clear I think it's important
to see clearly it's important to have
values it's important to be able to be
fiery it's important to speak from the
heart and it's really interesting for me
at least it's a work in progress I'm not
saying this as a rule for everybody but
for me it's really interesting to
explore what is what is it like to speak
up for myself
and
to name what from to me at least appears
to be factually
true
reality and also what is it like to
express values what I care about which
then leads to often what I would like to
have happen or suggest happens including
the behavior of other people I don't do
all that in a way that doesn't add that
kind of
critical Top Spin that you know it when
you feel it and you know it when it's
kind of coming at you so that's for me
but it's an example I'm offering NBC you
here's another one I I can't even tell
you how often I mentioned this to my
clients um jokingly that it would really
serve them to tattoo on the inside of
their eyelids n
MP not my
problem not as a kind of no not my
problem not my problem here's another
kind of know that I've shared in the
past it comes from this movie from the
70s North Dallas 40 in which a main
character Nick NY I think is a is a
football player uh and he's a receiver
he catches balls and his best friend is
this quarterback and the best friend and
the ownership of the football team
toward the end into the movie are trying
to get him to agree to come back for one
more season and his body has just been
broken by football and it's time to
retire that's a kind of no not going
down that road anymore walking another
road okay and in the culminating scene
essentially spoiler alert that he tells
the big bosses nope I'm I'm out fine I'm
out I'm I'm out your money your appeals
to my pride everything I'm out sorry I'm
out so he walks out he's on the sidewalk
his buddy follows him the quarterback
playing with a football and then there's
this moment where the quarterback who's
trying to talk his his friend into
staying throws him the ball throws him
the ball and if you've ever played catch
it's re I have a lot it's kind of a
reflex you hands go up to catch the ball
it's natural and you could just see his
face the the receiver the primary
character the impulse is to say yes to
the seductions there and his hands go up
and
then goes like that ball bounces off his
chest
nope nope so that's the kind of know
that we aim to to the outside but also
to the inside as well so what are some
some of the other really useful NOS that
we say to
ourselves there's a whole
category in
which we give ourselves be an
earned blessing and permission to turn a
corner we've reflected on our faults our
mistakes we've felt our remorse our
regrets we've done what we can to repair
uh we realize yeah
I sure wish and I had not said that or I
sure wish I had said something else or
at a certain point we go nope you don't
have to keep beating yourself up about
that you've been punished enough by
now
nope
enough it could be a kind of um
forgiveness for yourself it could be a
kind of
um you know quality of you know that
comes through Absolution that's the word
I was looking for absolution you give to
yourself it's okay it's
okay you're not
resisting you know what happened you're
not trying to deny it but you're just
saying it it's okay it's okay it's okay
sweetling you don't need to you don't
need to um beat yourself up about that
anymore that's a beautiful and really
really important kind of
note another note is when you realize
that there's no cheese down that tunnel
in other words when you realize a
version another one is that um that dog
won't hunt you know that duck will not
Fly Like an Eagle or the causes and
conditions are just not present it nope
it's just not going to work that you
know that restaurant on this corner is
never going to turn AP profit uh or know
that a career aspiration is just not
going to come true and you just admit it
no um you come to terms with it you know
that person in this relationship is just
never going to X whatever that might be
and then you sort out do I want to stay
in the relationship do I want to resize
it in some way so I carve out the X so
I'm no longer trying to go down the
tunnel and get X but there's no X down
that tunnel no cheese down that tunnel
you just say no um sometimes you get
there later in life with your with your
career will you say um no I'm I'm done
you know I'm just not gonna chase that
gold ring anymore I'm I'm kind of done
with that that's a no that's a no that's
often really helpful and then I would
just say last toward our elves there are
certain uh habits that we often have
where you know we're we're drawn to
certain Pleasures I I had a grandfather
who by all accounts was an alcoholic and
I can be aware of that part of my brain
that wants that molecule let's say and
you know I need to be careful about that
what do you need to be careful about uh
what's what's a skillful kind of
self-regulation directed at yourself
where you you know you know your
Tendencies and you can help yourself in
various ways whatever your Tendencies
may be by not having so many Temptations
so available to you but there's a kind
of a no a healthy no directed to
ourselves uh in terms of our our
appetites of various kinds um okay so I
think I'm going to finish on this right
now I invite you to explore this week to
come the power of no the power of no for
you and by the way to make an obvious
point I'm sure someone else has made it
in the chat so far um a no to this in
effect is a yes to
that and so one way we can help
ourselves in the the yin and the Yang
the polarity of all this the two sides
of one coin is okay if I'm saying no to
that what is that saying yes
to if I'm saying no as tikon Han the
great tikon Han has pointed out and
others have too if I'm saying no to
killing any living thing certainly
through my direct action which raises
all kinds of complications about what to
do with mosquitoes
and meat eating not going down that road
right here point is I'm saying no to
killing over here can I say yes to
affirming life over there if I said no
to stealing over here can I say yes to
generosity over there you know that if
I'm saying no to certain appetites I
might have certain um addictions in some
sense I have what's the alternative that
I'm saying yes to that can help me
maintaining to maintain my no it's a
important thing okay let's review some
of the wonderful things that have come
through uh yes indeed Elaine that you
know there's an old line don't send a
duck to Eagle school and I don't mean
that in a nasty nasty way I just mean
frankly sometimes you realize wow it's
not that it's not of the nature of a
duck to Fly Like an Eagle much like it's
not of the nature of an eagle to paddle
and swim like a duck so there's a kind
of a recognition about that okay I'm
seeing NBC standing for never be
critical this is my own personal
admonition uh I'm not proposing it a
rule for
everyone okay
um oh this is wonderful the commentary
that's really come in um how to say no
that doesn't sound like excuses this is
great to a person's request um also fear
that saying no can eventually lead to
isolation I still remember reading Mis
manners uh who said that when you uh
turn down an invit a you do not need to
give a
reason
wow wow wow I'm seeing thumbs coming up
here um
so now sometimes it's helpful to give a
context appropriately but you're right
how do we for me what helps is I kind of
draw on a sense of internal
dignity sometimes by channeling certain
people you know Michelle Obama
Obi-Wan
Kenobi so that's okay there's a certain
internal self-respect dignity uh um that
gives me a a sense that it's okay to say
no and I can explain my reasons why but
I'm not asking for their
permission my no does not require their
consent very
important I'm not asking for their
permission I'm giving them the courtesy
or I'm giving myself the self-respect of
declaring for the record my reasons for
the
no and um I think there's a place
sometimes for a no that is a matter of
Simply
disengaging we can decide for
ourselves I don't really owe them an
explanation or there are five reasons
why I'm reducing my contact with this
person four of them are about the ways
in which this
person is really bugging me or is acting
inappropriately or I just don't like
what happens in our interactions but the
one reason that's authentic is more face
saving for them I've just gotten busier
I'm I'm I'm wanting to spend more time
with my
family something like that so there's a
place if we are going to give a reason
for our no that um can be skillful uh
while also being authentic to ourselves
okay I'm looking at some of these
lines
um here's a very important thing that's
come in at 17 minutes past can saying no
be helpful when we want to lose weight
and want to eat some treat so there's a
conflict we're
ambivalent certain kinds of
no put us on the slippery SL to trouble
because they they trigger
us and this is especially important
around things like eating especially if
there's any history of anorexia or an
eating disorder bulimia and so forth and
so I just want to be clear that
sometimes that
no um just the word no can suddenly be
the mean harsh no from an
internalized person from your own
history
or the culture let's say broadly or
authority figures
no and so it's important to find a way
for the
no directed toward
ourselves if not toward
others can be claimed as our own like I
said in the very early on we can reclaim
a word like home for our own purposes
uh friend and someone I'm learning a lot
from Recently on the board of the global
compassion Coalition I invite you to
look into his work Michael Yellowbird
has done a lot of work on decolonizing
the brain Michael is a is a Native
American um a Dean at a university
currently in Canada and
um so my point being is that we can kind
of decolonize in some sense or however
you relate to that word choose other
words if you like certainly um in some
cases it's literally
decolonizing uh the mind uh reclaiming
for yourself the meanings of certain
things like the meanings for you of your
hearts know the healthy heart know and
and being aware of sometimes the word no
can just get um incorporated into or
co-opted by you know other uh your own
personal history so being careful about
that and if you like finding
other other words I'm thinking I never
watched much SFI but something like NADA
NADA or you
know find your own versions you know of
no
okay
um okay great I'm looking through great
comments about this great
um beautiful comments thank you for just
the wisdom coming through the chat I'm
looking for specific
questions uh I might say a lot of people
talked about the
inhibitions you know on saying no and um
I think it's very useful to be mindful
of those and then practice with them you
know we're kind to ourselves we stand up
for the no inside ourselves we remind
ourselves of the ways that others are
entitled to say no so we are
entitled as well um maybe talking with
other
people who make come from a similar
culture or have a similar history
perhaps you're on gender
socialization uh to help each other
learn to say
no maybe we'll come back next week and
we'll find that some people have formed
you know a little club like the nope
Club
nope I think of that TV ad some years
ago nope where the character was just
hitting the no button all the time you
know it no no
no right and support each other in that
regard okay um let's
see so I'm seeing all kinds of great
comments I'm seeing if anything is is
last setting boundaries that's a no
including tacet
boundaries we communicate our no
sometimes simply with our own
behavior okay
um there's an important note that I want
to name that for many many people is
highly relevant these
days uh and you can apply it in any
which way you like but it's the idea of
getting
certain
people out of your
head that critical stepparent
or dealing with the ways these days some
of the greatest minds of our generation
are trying to get into our heads in all
these sneaky subversive ways through
social media getting us to want to buy
stuff getting into our heads and also
getting into our heads
politically uh you know in all kinds of
ways or including that what they're
doing is outrageous so we're outraged
and now they're in our head and I'm not
talking about putting our head in the
sand like the proverbial ostrich and
ignoring the facts but more like huh how
much rentree real estate do we want to
provide them or
their
um Behavior or latest things they do
whatever inside our heads and one of the
nose is sort like nah nah you're out
there
bad enough that you're running the show
out there one way or another like your
landlord that you're really mad about
and you're just or bad enough they're in
they're your ex and it's just this
constant hassle bad enough that that's
happening out
[Music]
there a no
says not in here you don't get to as the
Buddha talked about a long time ago you
do not get to invade my mind and
remain not that's a
no okay and then finishing here if I may
I want to go back to the great un I was
talking about unborn undying
unconditioned and in ordinary reality
the sense of being
um unafflicted un un un unafflicted
uncont attracted
unpressured and as as you may know um
our natural
home is where we go when we're
undisturbed
untroubled and feel that way in the core
of our being even if outside ourselves
we're dealing with troubles pressures
are coming at us in the core of our
being at least
uh we feel untroubled
unpressured
um
undriven and that's a very important
homecoming to the extent we can
repeatedly practice that and um in terms
of our three major needs for safety
satisfaction and connection we can feel
and help ourselves feel in the
present um unthreatened
all basically all right right now in
terms of our need for satisfaction we
can help ourselves feel
um not dissatisfied not discontent in
other words
content and also in relationships we can
help ourselves to feel
um unconflicted you know deep in our
heart heart we know how we feel and we
feel
loving and clear about who we are where
we stand and what we're going to do
whatever that might be and the more that
we can come home to the great un
including to the extent that it's real
for you uh the great un of the
underlying ground of all unborn undying
and thus
Timeless um the more rested will be in a
resilient
well-being and uh with with an
unshakable sense in the core of uh
peacefulness contentment and
love and that's a very ultimate and
profound kind
of
no not craving not
contracted not self
not
intimidated not
befuddled
[Music]
nope no more of that
