Three Wise Efforts: Talk with Dr. Rick Hanson

Rick Hanson
90 followers
172 Video Views·Apr 23, 2020
In this talk from Dr. Rick Hanson for his Wednesday Night Meditation + Talk series, he coversThree Wise Efforts.
You can see the meditation that went along with this talk here: https://youtu.be/b8utF0Fx6GE
And if you'd like to join the free, online Wednesday Meditations, sign up here:
https://www.rickhanson.net/teaching/wednesday-meditations-with-dr-rick-hanson/
So I'd like to welcome you again to this Wednesday meditation gathering. There are people
involved with this right now, about 222 people right now online with many more who will watch
the recording later, as you may also want to do that yourself. And actually, I think over 2,000
who are part of all this and will be coming from time to time. So it's kind of quite something to
really appreciate myself, your interest here, and I want to express my own gratitude to you.
I want to say a word about community altogether. It's interesting that in the Buddhist tradition,
it is said that there are three jewels, three primary refuges, the Buddha, the Dharma,
and the Sangha. The Buddha can be understood as both the historical teacher and the natural
wakefulness in ourselves, the Buddha within. Second, the Dharma can be understood as the way
it is, reality, and a wise and useful description of reality, such as contained in the teachings of
the Buddhist tradition as it's evolved and developed over 2,500 years, and certainly other
wisdom traditions from around the world, Dharma. And then we have the Sangha, which can be
with sort of a vertical dimension of respect for our teachers, including the monastic wisdom holders
that have kept this tradition alive for 2,500 years. And Sangha can be understood horizontally
as the community of fellow practitioners, such as all those who are involved right now.
And in an online environment, the good news is that it's a lot easier for a lot of people
to come. They don't have to drive to a hall somewhere, which is what I used to do with
people in the past. On the other hand, because it's on screen, there's muting, you can't look
at someone nearby and kind of elbow them and be like, oh, that was a good point, or whoa,
Rick's way out there right now, or something like that. You can't really do that.
So how do we cultivate that sense of togetherness here, which really is a jewel and a support
for practice? One way is to practice with other people. I look out and I see some people who are
doing this sitting side by side with others. I see cats coming in and out who are part of our
Sangha as well. And you might want to do that, you know, once a week, make it a time, at least a few
times a month, maybe even weekly, where you gather with your partner or family members or perhaps a
friend, and you're physically in the same space. Now, since we're sheltering in place, and a lot
of us are practicing social distancing, you might also want to just arrange with a friend of yours
that you're going to do this together. And afterward, you're going to maybe talk a bit
about it, or just know that it's in the flow of your week together. And it's one of the things
that you have in common, and maybe you draw useful wisdom from or some information from.
I really invite you to just tell other people about this if you want, see if they're interested.
It's very easy for them to participate. It's free. And once they sort of register for it, they'll get
a weekly email that actually typically two emails a week, one that tells them that the recordings
have been posted from the previous group on the previous Wednesday, and an email that will
give them the link for the Wednesday to come. So anyway, that's a way to do it.
Additionally, we're going to be looking for ways to do this using the Zoom platform online. One way to
do that is for me to, at the end, randomly assign people into small mini Zoom groups. And I can do
that with groups of any size. So imagine that as we approach 7.30 Pacific time, quarter, half past
the hour, wherever you are, that we finish formally. And then I just assign people into
groups of three for half an hour, totally voluntary, completely voluntary. And if you don't want to be
in a group, you just sort of can exit. It's not personal, you know, to the other people. You're
just not in the mood maybe for it. Yet those who want can form little groups of three and can talk
with each other and see how it goes. We'll offer some suggestions for making sure that everybody
gets their voice in and it doesn't get weird and really recognize that you can disengage
from a Zoom meeting anytime you want. So with regard to that particular idea, which we're not
going to do tonight, we will not do that tonight, but I want to get a sense of interest in that.
If you think about it, how many people would like to try that at least once? And so if you raise your
hand, I can then get a sense of hands raised and, you know, oh, actually a fair amount of people,
particularly the people who are willing to be on video right now, maybe you're a self-selected group,
right? The researcher in me would want to acknowledge that. But what I'm immediately
getting is that we should try this. Great. So we'll try it. And in the venerable tradition
of herding cats, I will try to organize it at least a little bit for the safety of people,
not to be oppressive. I will not manage it. I will exit. I will say, buh-bye. You're on your own.
So, you know, be careful. First of all, do no harm. Okay, that was clear. Okay, good. So that's it on
the sangha part, right? So now what I'd like to do for about 10 more minutes or so, a little more
perhaps, is talk about wise effort. And in the Buddhist tradition, there is the Eightfold Path.
It has eight—what a surprise—elements to it. And one of those eight elements recommended and
offered by the Buddha for us to see for ourselves what's valuable is what he called wise or right
effort. And this is the effort to do two things. On the one hand, to prevent, decrease, or release
what is harmful or painful for ourselves and others. And the other effort is to create,
protect, and increase that which is beneficial and enjoyable for oneself and others.
These are the wise efforts. What's interesting is to explore the balance of or the integration
of mindfulness and wise or right effort. And I want to apply that as well to this peculiar
and particular and painful and something or other, the starch of the pea, time that we're
living in today with this epidemic that's moving through the world. So to be mindful,
we must exercise a little effort. Effort is not at odds with mindfulness. And our mindfulness
enables our efforts to be productive and useful. When we, as in the meditation,
enable and encourage effort increasingly to fall away, such as in the instruction to leave your
mind alone, let go of the past, let go of the future, let go of the present, and leave your
mind alone, which is a Tibetan meditation instruction. When we're really leaving the
mind alone, we start increasingly resting in awareness itself in a state of what's called
choiceless awareness. We're not making any choices. We're not making the effort to make
any choices. Simply present, increasingly present as presence, as open, boundless awareness.
In that stance or particular state of being, a little bit mindfulness is present. That's why
some people have made the mistake of asserting that the only way to be truly mindful is in the
utterly receptive, fairly inert stance of choiceless awareness. That's a mistake.
We need to make a little effort to enter into choiceless awareness and to maintain it.
And it's really hard to live there when we're driving in traffic or talking to someone while
stirring the spaghetti sauce and keeping an eye on the kids in the next row. As practice matures,
increasingly, people are just more and more just kind of hanging out in the present choicelessly.
Okay. But along the way, efforts needed to be made. And so mindfulness is not at odds
with making efforts. The efforts need to be skillful. They need to be wise. They need to
be effective and well-considered. And we need to avoid pitfalls, which I know well, of over-striving.
I am determined to have fault, right? And I've had to learn to know when it's time to just
let go or give up or realize that this dog will not hunt. This rock will not give water. This
duck will never fly like an eagle or something like that, right? I just let it go. The causes
and conditions are not present. I'm trying to grow roses heroically, but unsuccessful
in a parking lot. So we have to be careful about straining and striving and so forth with regard
to effort. On the other hand, there are pitfalls in not making efforts enough.
And I want to speak to several efforts that I think are really important at this time.
One is the effort of generosity. The Buddha strongly emphasized generosity. The word for
that in Pali, the language of the early written record of his teachings, is dana. So he talked
about dana, the dana of attention, giving of attention. You're giving me your attention.
You're giving others your attention. We can see what it's like to be generous with people,
to just give them our attention. I mean, it's kind of remarkable to feel really received by
another person for half a minute in a row, which seems like such a small ask, right? Half a minute.
And yet, it's kind of startling that they actually were listening to us for half a
minute in a row. Well, turn it around. We give others a beautiful gift, generosity,
by giving them the gift of our own attention. We give others the gift of restraint. We give
them the gift of time. Sometimes we give them different forms of financial contributions,
different forms of money. Recently, I was going to be part of a conference at Gaia House,
actually, in England. And the conference was canceled due to the coronavirus. And
Gaia House said, if you care to, we will refund your registration fee, or if you care to
offer it as dana to this Buddhist institution there in England, Gaia House, you have a choice.
It wasn't a huge amount of money, and I wanted to give it to them. We give because it serves
our own practice. It serves our practice in the moment of the giving, the release of the open hand,
the way it feels good to give, the way that it helps us feel active and potent in some way rather
than helpless and overwhelmed, and the ways in which it helps us to give out into the world,
which eventually gives back. So we give as a major aspect of practice. It's appropriate
for me as a teacher to call us all, including to call myself, to the practice of generosity,
to the wise effort of generosity. It's okay for me to talk about that.
And for example, it's okay for me to say, there's a donation button on my website or on the webpage
for this gathering, and if you care to donate there, I welcome that. If you care to donate
by sending me an email, as people do, just expressing gratitude or some personal insight
you've had or form of growth you've had, I appreciate that. That's your generosity,
and to enable your giving, I need to receive. We offer a gift to the giver when we receive
their generosity ourselves. Occasionally, I even get advice, and I try to be receptive
to that as well. So the effort of generosity, a very important one at this time.
A second effort these days, I think it's really important, is to let the pitch go by. In other
words, to disengage from opportunities that we might have taken the bait for, as it were,
in the past. To disengage from wrangles with people that are needless. There are people that
I know and love who will give me their infinite wisdom about something or other that I ought to
do or do differently, or their view about the public health epidemiology at this time, or
whatever it might be. And in the old days, like February, I might argue back. I might argue with
them. But these days, there's too much going on. People are under too much pressure. They're
scared too. They're stressed too. I don't need to resist it. It doesn't serve the greater good.
And so it's my judgment to not be reactive and to let that sail on by.
So just think about the generosity of non-contentiousness. This is not walking
on eggshells. This is not being a doormat for other people. Wisdom, the wise effort,
is when to make the effort to actually say something to another person, or perhaps calmly
mention a fact in passing, and then disengage and go get some dinner, or to actually speak up.
It's okay to make those kinds of efforts and to have the wisdom to know when to make them.
But otherwise, to ask ourselves a lot, can I disengage from needless contentiousness?
Do I actually need to oppose this view right now? Will it matter? If you find yourself like me,
some from time to time, making speeches at the television set when you're watching the news,
once is enough. But if you have family members that start to stare at you oddly,
that's a signal that it's invaded you, and it's time to disengage.
So that's the second wise effort I want to speak to these days, the wise effort of
non-contentiousness. I remember many, many years ago reading an interview with Ajahn,
that's an honorific, he's a monk in the Buddhist tradition, Ajahn Amaro, a British man,
really wonderful teacher. And the person asked, I think, what he was practicing with himself these
days. And I know Ajahn Amaro, he was on the board with me at Sparrow Rock Meditation Center for a
number of years. I know him well, deep practitioner, great teacher, I would listen to him
anytime. And he said, well, I'm working on not being contentious. And I thought, Ajahn Amaro,
quarrelsome, argumentative, contentious. And he went on to say, a lot of that contentiousness
is inside my own mind. He might smile calmly or lovingly, but inside,
and he was saying he's practicing with non-contentiousness inside his own mind.
And that, I think, is a second wise effort that's really useful these days. So we don't take on the
added burden, the technical term, the added allostatic load of stress burden that comes from
contentiousness of any kind. The third wise effort I just want to mention these days is to
engage the effort of practice. Just practice. Are we practicing with our experiences? Are we
practicing with our reactions? Or are we hijacked by them, identified by them, swept away by them,
given over to them? Are we giving them power over us? Or are we practicing in our relationship to
them? The anxiety may still be there. The irritation may still be there. The weariness,
the pain in your back, the, in my case right now, the stye, actually two, up and down,
upper and lower, the stye in your eye, they may be there, but you can practice with it.
We can also bring practice to what we do over the course of the day. The mindfulness we bring
to what our fingers have touched, to how long it's been since we washed our hands,
the practice we might bring in terms of the care we bring to what we say to another person,
or the way we deliberately might reach into ourselves to find a genuine love that's not
top of mind, but it's there, it's accessible, it's authentic, a genuine love for another person,
and to communicate the cherishing of them, the pricing of them, our loyalty for them.
That's practice. And I recently was on an interview, as I'll just finish on this point,
that someone was saying, as I was talking about taking in the good or disengaging,
given the negativity bias of the brain, Velcro for bad, Teflon for good, disengaging, you know,
from resentments or anxieties that are not adding any value. And they said, wow,
that takes a lot of work. And I just started thinking about it. I thought about ordinary
occupations, right? Driving a bus. I so respect bus drivers, just think about what they're dealing
with there, and yet we think hardly of it. They're managing all the traffic, they're dealing with
what's going on inside the bus. And, you know, they're doing that eight hours at least a day.
And yet, for some people, it seems like a really high bar to ask themselves to bring just a little
bit of the same competence, the same effort, the same deliberateness as the bus driver mind
to the external traffic of what's around them, and the internal traffic of what's on the bus
inside their own mind with them. There's no substitute for a little bit of effort and the
effort of practice. And you can tell very quickly in this world, who has practice and who doesn't,
who brings practice to bear and who doesn't. Or more realistically, even, how rapidly people
bring practice online, after they kind of ride the first shock of some kind of reaction to
something that's arisen externally or internally. And that's a wonderful thing. And I want to end
on the notion of the nobility of our practice, just bringing our effort every day, so that when
you go to bed, you look back on your day and you go, yeah, no gold medal necessary, you know,
no speech before the UN necessary, no halo necessary, and still, good on you. Good for you.
You tried. You tried. Good. Buddha encouraged us to find gladness in our goodness, because that
serves our practice. And to make sure that we have a practice that we can be glad about.
So, I'd like to open it up for discussion. For the sake of the greater good,
I'm going to just take a moment here and let this kind of sink in. I'll be kind of quiet for
half a minute. And if you would like to ask a question, please raise your hand physically,
or you can push the little Zoom button. I'll see it. And when you have a question,
try to be succinct. Make sure it's related to what I've talked about tonight. And I'll also
try to be relatively succinct in my response. I've talked about the integration of mindfulness
and effort, and the irreplaceable nature of effort, and the three efforts of generosity,
non-contentiousness, and practice. Okay. Who has a question? And I'll move through the screens,
and I'll call you and unmute you if I see your hand up. Okay. Barbara, which means Jerry.
I had an incident recently. I was talking with a relative, and I was able to disengage,
but without going into the longer story, I was left with a residue of anger, and frustration,
and sadness. This relative was so far out there, politically, to the point of paranoia,
and it's still hanging around an unusually long time. I was wondering if you have any
thoughts about how to disengage cleanly, as opposed to still holding on to
resentment, or sadness, and anger, and that kind of stuff. Thank you for saying that, Jerry. And
I'll make two general comments, and then maybe you have a response to them. I'll be brief.
I find both as a longtime psychotherapist, as well as someone who's had a lot of creepy crawlers
under the rocks in the basement of my own mind, you know, from my childhood and young adulthood,
that periodically gets stirred up myself, right? And also from the Buddhist wisdom. So two keys
here. One is to observe whether we are feeding and fueling the reaction at all. That's very
important. And if the answer is yes, then the next question becomes, okay, can I stop doing that?
Can I make the effort, the wise effort, to release that negative feeding, following,
preoccupying, and fueling of that material? And can I also make the wise effort of shifting my
attention to something else? Including, as you know from my material, looking for the something
else that is a natural kind of antidote or resource for the particular need or issue that
was stirred up by that other person. So for example, if that other person, let's say, stirs up
fears that they're going to do things that will hurt you or others you care about, then reaching
for resources for anxiety, such as calm strength, feeling protected, a realistic appraisal of the
scale of the threats, and so forth, that would be matched. Or it could well be that there's
a kind of interpersonal wounding, a sense of feeling dismissed or disrespected,
or kind of cut off almost, like other people these days sometimes have views that can feel
as if we are exiled from any possibility of a reasonable interaction with them. And that
sense of exile can be quite painful, and it can even stir up old feelings of exile that are
interpersonal, right? Feeling dismissed and shoved away and devalued, you know, in the language
narcissistic injury. So the naturally matched supplies or experiences for that would be things
like feeling worthy already, feeling loved by others, befriended by others, a part of a gathering
like this of sane and friendly people, right? Who, as Suzuki Roshi put it, are both perfect and could
use some improvement, me included. So, you know, that's natural. So that's a first key question
with practice, you know, am I feeding and following this? If often the answer is no,
and the material is just there, including different kinds of situations where we grieve
losses, or we're just frustrated by being cooped up or deprived of familiar activities, like taking
a thoroughbred who wants to run and just trapping it in a small stall, you know, it's naturally
going to be affected by that. But that's the first dart or the first arrow of life, as the Buddha
taught. The key question is, am I adding my own reactivity to it that's creating the second darts?
First question. Second question, even when we stop feeding and fueling it,
and it still is hanging around, it's often useful to ask, what's deeper? What's underneath this?
What's the deeper wound? What's the younger longing? What's the more intimate or vulnerable
hurt? Is there something underneath it all that this has stirred up? Because when we do all the
right things, you know, the skillful, wise efforts, and that, I'm going to use the metaphor,
the weed in the garden of the mind is still rooted somehow, we probably haven't yet gotten in touch
with mindfully, complete vulnerability with ourselves, with the deepest tip of the root of
that material. So that can be very, very useful to sense down to that. And these, if you'll observe it,
are efforts, aren't they? The effort to disengage from habits of feeding and following and
preoccupation. Resentment is like taking poison and waiting for others to die, right, as the saying
has it. That takes effort. It takes effort to shift attention elsewhere. It takes effort to
deliberately kind of evoke and then internalize resources that are matched to the problem.
It takes effort to help oneself to uncover and bear and feel the deeper material and to experience
it out, to allow it to flow through one out the door. It takes effort as well. It's practice. It's
okay. That's part of our practice to do this. There's more to practice than simply witnessing
the stream of consciousness. As profoundly important as that is. Okay? So I feel like I've
just kind of stopped. So this gives me some impetus to go ahead with the exploration. Yeah.
Yeah. I would encourage you to do that. Okay, good. Thank you, Jerry. All right. All right.
Next person. Anybody else have a comment or question so far? I'm going to keep scrolling
through. Oli. Oli. Hello, Oli. Someone who gives me lots of good comments and feedback
because he's generous. Thank you. Thank you kindly for that. Observations. I found
when the creepy crawlies and nasty stuff come up, the two very powerful tools I have are
forgiveness and self-compassion. Great. Then the other thing that came up when a really big bump
in the road comes along rather than I may fall flat my face on it, but keep chipping away at it.
Like you said, put some perspective out there. Look at it. It's kind of like untangling a big
ball of flying. Just keep pulling at it. Yeah. Might take time, but it seems to work. Is that
on track kind of? Oh, yeah. That's an uncovering. You know, the Buddha was, I mean, I'm a writer,
and I try to write at least, and Buddha was amazing with language. He used so many metaphors,
and one of his metaphors recurrent is the idea of disentangling, just like you said, Oli.
Okay, great. So I'm going to move on then to see if there's maybe a question out there.
How about you, Sophia? I'm unmuting you. Yeah. Hi, Rick. I'm so happy to talk to you.
I was just wondering whether or not you had any thoughts on the effort of non-contentiousness
when you're working with somebody who has a tendency to lean towards perfectionism
and the battle that kind of goes on within. And it's something that, well, I'm somebody who
suffers from perfectionism. I'm finding I'm having some real difficulty during this period of time
where I'm doing limited work from home and then trying to fit in all of these wonderful classes
that are available and everything and not being able to do everything perfectly. So
that battle in my head. Oh, yeah. Well, thank you very much, Sophia. And if I understand it
correctly, and myself, I'm a recovering duoholic, right? And it's very hard for me
to not do something excellently, at least if I can, right? And so, in some ways, I can relate
to what you're saying. And I'm sure I have at least one of the 10 genes for OCD. I don't know
if they're 10 or 11 or 9, but something like that. All right. Here's an interesting thing.
Question is, what is the perfectionism trying to keep it back? In other words, to what extent
are we being lived by healthy aspirations toward being impeccable and, you know,
shaping something into beauty or making sure that just something is simply done properly,
right? That all the hatches are battened down, you know, that the door is locked when we leave.
To what extent is there that which has a nobility in it and a beauty even,
versus to what extent are these perfectionistic efforts a strategy to keep anxiety at bay?
That's my strategy. Yeah, okay. Or as in my case, given my fault-finding
upbringing from the outside, to preempt any possibility of criticism coming my way, right?
That's a different, yeah, that's a different collection of motivation. So then the art often
is to disengage from the old machinery while shifting our motivations again and again and
again. It takes a while to develop this new habit, this new motivational habit,
so that increasingly we are being lived on the basis of these motivations, these aspirations
that feel contented already. They're not based on craving, right? The effort that's driven by
anxiety or threat, including the preempting of the social threat of criticism, you know,
from others and all that might follow, you know, that's a form of craving. That's based on an
aversion to the unpleasant or the chasing of social supplies, let's say, narcissistic rewards
from others. That's not so good. That's second noble truth life. You know, that's life from the
red zone. The alternative is to live life more and more from the green zone, from, you know,
a growing sense of the third noble truth, the cessation of craving-based motivations,
and living more, in effect, as Maslow talked about it, shifting from, he called them D needs,
deficiency-based needs, the lower four, and shifting more and more into B needs, he called
them being needs, that are based on self-actualization. That's a major shift, and this
is a very important way to understand effort. When I see people who are deeply committed to practice,
both laypeople and monastics, they make efforts, you know, they are, you know, impeccable,
they sweep the temple floor, they chop the carrots carefully, they tend to the sick, they
demonstrate in the streets, they speak truth to power, they bring effort to bear,
they study, they learn languages, they bring those efforts to bear. But much of the time,
there's a sense of inner lightness and joy, as if they are lived by their practice,
they're lived by the inspiration of their practice, rather than a contracted scratching
and clawing up the mountaintop. And that's an enormous shift, and it's really useful to observe,
do we wash the dish out of fear or joy? Do we fold the clothes out of a grim sense of duty,
or to make sure they don't criticize us, or for the experience itself, or the opportunity to
be mindful while doing something physical, or for the beauty of the folded t-shirt?
I love folding my t-shirts, they look so good when I'm all done. You know, what is our basis?
Same action, but so different, because it's coming from a different wellspring inside.
So, thank you, Sophia. I'm going to finish up now, because it is very much my pleasure. Sorry,
Bill and others, I'm going to end on time. But what I'd like to do first, though,
is what we used to do when we met physically, is to just sit together for a minute in silence,
to let whatever is useful today, tonight, to sink in. And then I'll unmute everyone,
so we can say goodbye to each other for a last minute. And then I'll ring the bell three times,
and we'll finish. Letting it sink in. And if I can offer one suggestion for your practice this week,
actually, it is to find gladness in your goodness. Exploring the wise effort
of finding gladness in your goodness. It takes a certain courage, even a nobility,
to name, at least to yourself and, if appropriate, to others, a gladness in your goodness.
I, myself, experience much gladness in your goodness, truly.
