Windlass Munich Sword ( Sidesword / Rapier ) Reviewed!

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
24 Video Views·Nov 11, 2024
The Windlass Munich 'town guard' sword (sidesword / rapier) - REVIEWED!
Hey everybody, it's Matt Easton here, Scholar of Gladiator. Let's have a look at the Windlass
Munich Town Guard sword. So I've had this sword for a while and I have cut with it and I've had
some surprises with it and I've also been illuminated as to the originals and the differences
where this kind of essentially this differs from the originals and I suppose you could say where
the errors are with this version. The first thing we have to say at the very beginning though is
that whilst other companies do make replicas of this particular group of swords and it's not
modelled on one specific sword, there is one in the Wallace Collection but there are a whole
collection of them because they were the Munich Town Guard swords so there are I think there's
at least about well dozens of them maybe a hundred or more of them around in different mostly in
private collections and they do share characteristics but they do vary so some of them are more or less
like this one but the one thing we have to say is this is by far the cheapest replica you can
get hold of and really for the price that it is it does offer really good value for money but
nevertheless even within that price bracket there are still things that I think could be improved
with it and could really make it into a much higher value and an even more desirable sword
than it is for for relatively little extra effort but first of all let's just describe
what this sword actually is. So it seems that this group of swords were essentially made as
town guard swords and they are swords they are fighting swords but they happen to have a swept
tilt on them and I think this leads a lot of people into likening them to what we would commonly call
these days rapiers. Now as I've spoken about in many many previous videos the term rapier is
problematic because one person's rapier is another person's sword is another person's tuck what is a
rapier how is a sword different from a rapier this is a completely complicated and confusing topic
so we're going to throw the word rapier completely out of the window for now it's a sword and
actually the blade type is essentially a type 15 if this had a medieval hilt on it if this had a
normal cross guard and a normal pommel and no complexity to the hand guard then it would look
pretty much like loads of 15th century medieval arming swords and that's basically what it is
it's an arming sword and it makes a lot of sense when you think about a essentially a government
procured sword that you're going to equip your militia with what sword are you going to give
them you're going to give them an all-purpose cut and thrust sword not a specialist sword you're
just going to give them something that they can use to fight in a way that is natural to them
and a way that it can be effectively used against lots of different opponents in lots of different
scenarios so it could be used in the civilian fight it could be used in the duel although
they're not supposed to be doing that but it could be used in on a from horseback it could be used on
foot and so on so forth it is a fairly beefy sword not just we'll talk about the replica in a
minute but just talking about the type of sword and the original munich town guard swords they
are pretty big now i years ago i think probably about six or seven years ago at the park lane
arms fair i had the honor to be able to hold two of these and they were slightly different from each
other i've never held the wallace collection example although i might do at some point
and they are beefy swords they feel lively in the hand but they feel like a medieval arming sword
they don't handle uh particularly light or nimbly they have fair amount of mass and it has to be
said there's a lot of that mass is due to this rather large and substantial guard now again i'm
talking about the originals not this particular one we'll talk about this one in a little bit
but they are fairly big beefy fighting swords they are battlefield swords in my mind now before we go
into reviewing this as a replica of that group of swords i'm going to talk about it generally as
a sword and my impressions of it so when it came there were a few things that i immediately liked
and a few things that i thought not so keen on that and i'm going to go through those in a brief
and concise summary as possible so the first thing i noticed was that the hilt had an overall
roughly nice shape and size it wasn't unusually large as some lower end swept hilts are
it was however quite beefy and one of the things that struck me initially is that the bars
are quite thick and quite heavy compared to what i think they should be for this style and size
of sword which does of course add mass to the sword and that was the next thing i noticed
on drawing it out of the scabbard i was like well that's heavier than i expected
and so it does feel rather heavy in the hand but i was quite surprised when i went to cut with it
because actually the actual blade itself moves fairly quickly and moves fairly nicely
but it is nevertheless quite a heavy sword especially when you consider that this blade
is like a medieval arming sword and the pommel is quite similar to medieval arming swords
if this was given a simple straight cross guard this would actually feel like a fairly typical
medieval arming sword but it doesn't have a simple cross guard it has a large swept hilt
and that hilt is really quite substantial i believe more with thicker bars or rather more
rectangular so more weighty bars than they need to be and therefore it adds a lot of mass a lot
of total mass to the sword there was one other thing that i noticed straight away and that was
the definition of the blade so whilst the blade is nice it doesn't have any real distal taper
okay so it's the same thickness here as it is here there might be a very very slight distal taper
but one of the things i remember crystal clear in my mind from handling the originals
at the park lane arms fair those years ago was they have savage distal taper they are really
thick much thicker than this at the base of the blade maybe a centimeter nine millimeters
thick at the base of the blade and then they distally taper down now as i've spoken about
in so many videos and as most of you will know anyway that equates to mass distribution we've
got profile taper here but we don't have enough distal taper that means that in terms of where
the mass is distributed in the blade we have too little mass here too much mass up here and that
leads to when you move the sword it has a lot of inertia it will hit with force but number one it
means that it's more difficult to change direction and move it around because your mass distribution
is not quite in the right place the mass is too far away from the hand giving you too much
rotational inertia but additionally it means that the blade is not as stiff as it should be
a blade that's thick at the base and gets thinner distally down has a very nice amount of a huge
amount of stiffness for the first half of the blade and only will flex in the second half of
the blade this means that when cutting when thrusting when encountering other blades when
cutting through a target when hitting armor helmets shields things like this your blade is stiff a
stiff blade is a forgiving blade and usually a very well cutting blade and definitely a better
thrusting blade when your blade is too flexible and has instability it is worse in the bind it's
it can be less forgiving at cutting and it is worse generally at thrusting so that leads to
and i have to be somewhat careful because this is a sharpened blade and i'll talk about the edges in
a minute this means that when i flex this blade it flexes like a like a bow almost through its whole
length and you can see it does flex in this first half of the blade which it really shouldn't for
this type of sword okay there is some greater degree of stiffness in the first half of the
blade by virtue of the fact we've got a broader blade here now i also spoke about definition so
as well as not having enough distal taper we've also got a very noted secondary bevel now i've
spoken about this with windlass swords in the past but i have some good news for you on that front
so i've been talking with windlass for a while now and we're looking at doing some things together
we'll talk about that again in in the future but one of the things that they are now looking at
is making all of their sharp swords as sharps from the outset that is with a single bevel where
there's supposed to be a single bevel so therefore the blades should be getting lighter and should be
getting sharper or should we say the the edge geometry will be becoming more conducive to good
cutting which is exciting stuff but we'll until i've seen those blades i can't talk about them
so we'll talk about that more in the future and therefore when i criticize the secondary bevel
here and say that the edge geometry is not not like the originals and is not as good as you
would want i want you to put that criticism on hold for now because windlass are working on it
and they're looking at revising that so that's kind of almost job done let's see how that goes
in the future lastly when i talk about blade definition what do i mean particularly the center
rib so looking along the blade there is a little bit of rippling which you usually get with forged
blades as windlass blades are they are forged rather than ground but what is not defined enough
is the central rib down here that the that's kind of spine of the blade running down the center
and what we should see particularly with this type of blade but i would say with with most
european blades certainly in the 16th and 15th centuries is a very defined ridge at the center
so you should have a defined ridge and then straight down to the edge sometimes it's hollow
ground sometimes in fact it's lenticular but that ridge at the center should be defined now that's
not to say that all european swords in this period or any other period had a defined spine up the
middle or ridge not all of them did and for example some 17th century highland scottish
claymores have lenticular section blades lozenge they don't have that rib or ridge along the center
but this type of blade particularly the munich guard town guard rapiers do okay so these are
the things that struck me directly when i saw the sword it seemed heavier than i expected
it didn't have the distal taper that i expected it didn't have the
middle ridge or rib that i expected we've spoken about edge geometry we'll leave that to the side
and then the guard looked a little bit i don't know what the word is here a little bit
the shape isn't quite right but we'll talk we'll talk a little bit more about that in a second
okay right now i want to refer you to a fantastic discussion that happened i think it was about a
decade ago now about this very model of sword on my armory and my armory if you don't know it is a
fantastic forum that i highly recommend you go to it's got loads and loads of reviews on it it's
still active it's one of the few forums that's still active because forums since facebook and
things like that have died a bit of a death but my armor is still fairly active it has a buy and
sell it has all this kind of stuff so go and have a read if you want to learn more about this sword
go and have a read of that review but i am going to go over some of the points now mentioned in
that review which i totally agree with and i think need to be mentioned so here are the principal
criticisms of this as a replica of the original munich town guard group of swords the headline
ones according to my opinion so firstly is the shape of the blade it should be tapered more
immediately to a point more like a typical type 15 and not still quite this broad up at the point
that would give it better handling characteristics especially if coupled with distal taper which it
must really have it is just simply a flat bar at the moment it really should be starting
at least at about seven millimeters thick going down to about four millimeters and preferably
more like eight or nine millimeters down to maybe three or four three and a half maybe millimeters
so it needs distal taper putting in it needs better profile taper it needs the ridge along
the center of the blade more clearly defined and it needs a single bevel to the edge as discussed
next up is the shape of the ricasso so the ricasso i believe should be a little bit narrower
remembering that it should be thicker bar stock and the shape here is too angular and too right
angled as it comes in here that should be more rounded around here according to the originals
the guard so the guard on this windlass munich the the bars are too rectangular in section
and in some cases a little bit too thick these are all welded together and sometimes the welds
are a bit messy so the welds need better finishing and the bars need to be more oval section and
thinned this is generally there is too much mass in this guard and i reckon maybe 100 grams
certainly at least 50 grams could come off the mass of this guard just by thinning it down and
making it more correctly shaped according to the originals at the moment it's all a little bit too
angular and a bit too rectangular in the cross section of the bars this can also lead to some
uncomfortableness when handling the sword as well because you've got hot spots and edges
where you wouldn't really necessarily want them the grip i actually quite like personally i know
not everyone does but i i think the wire wrap is very well done and the turks heads i think i mean
i know how difficult i've watched people make these that is difficult to do so i am actually
fine with the grip it is slightly too long compared to the originals so the grip actually
needs shortening by i think about a centimeter judging and obviously as i say there's variation
in the original grouping of swords some are slightly longer some are slightly shorter
but i think if it was shortened by about a centimeter bear in mind that your front finger
goes over that quillon and through that finger ring so you don't need to be able to fit the entire
hammer fist into that grip you only need to be able to fit three hands into that grip and if you
brought that grip in it would bring the pommel closer to the hand which is important for the
way that you use the sword so that would bring the pommel down a bit and very very very importantly
this pommel is wrong so the pommel has clearly been copied from a photograph of the sword taken
at the side but if you look at the originals they are practically always flatter they are thinner
than they are wide so it is not a round section it's not round there it's actually oval kind of
what to liken it to it's essentially a like a squished ball so this pommel by being round is
also too heavy which adds a lot of mass because pommels are heavy things so fundamentally that
sounds like a lot of changes but you've got to bear in mind that for the price that this sword
sits at you look at other replicas of this sword and look at the price of those this is this is
without compare in this price category and this is an amazing value sword and even with all of
those things that i've mentioned it still handles pretty nicely it's relatively stiff due to the
profile taper and i have cut with this i'm not going to go show cutting in this video i might
show some cutting in a future video with this but because i know there's new blades coming for this
i've held off doing that in this case but i've got to say this cut far better than i expected it to
despite the fact that it's not particularly sharp to the touch and it has a secondary bevel and
therefore not great edge geometry for cutting it actually performed really really well i do feel
that the sword is maybe 100 grams overweight maybe 150 possibly even 200 grams i have actually had
some difficulty in finding out what the original range of weights of this group of swords are i
couldn't find that information online or in any catalogs i know about the wallace collection one
and i have to admit that they are quite heavy swords so i don't want to overly criticize this
sword for its mass just as a fixed number but what i would criticize is the mass distribution
so what we should be seeing with this sword is whilst the total mass is only a tiny bit
overweight what we should be seeing is by having better distal taper by having better edge geometry
by thinning down those bars and giving them an oval cross section instead of a rectangular cross
section and by flattening that pommel and shortening the grip slightly that will give you
the weight saving there that's what it is that's why this sword is a little bit heavier than uh
than the originals that i've got weights for anyway um but that being said it's still not
it's not ludicrously heavy you can still use it absolutely as a fighting weapon and it is a
formidable essentially a complex hilted arming sword and maybe many people would say this is
kind of the ultimate one-handed sword because you've got really good hand protection without
constricting the hand motion in any way at all it doesn't constrict like a basket hilt would
you've got an amazing amount of strong protection that you could even take um you know blows from
halberds and stuff on incredibly good hand protection and you've got a blade that is a
good cut and thrust blade of reasonable length you could use in any situation uh any scenario
so i think windlass have the makings of a amazing sword here with some changes and i know that at
least one of those changes is coming i know that they're looking at correcting that edge geometry
i would also like them to introduce distal taper as well at least some degree of distal taper
and then with those small changes to the hilt which are almost cosmetic and they're almost
mundane trivial in their ability to change on the hilt i think they could have an absolutely
amazing product here and even at the moment for its price this sword is i won't say it's
unparalleled because i haven't gone out and compared to all the swords in the price range
but for how much this costs you're getting a hell of a sword here and this cuts really really quite
well so if you want a sharp um whatever you want to call this sword side sword it's not really i
don't know some people would call this a side sword but if you want a munich type sword with
a swept hilt and a good cut and frost blade this is a great great option in the price category
and i cut wood with this um off camera and it stood up perfectly well it's a strong sword
it does have a threaded construction here so you can take this sword apart and you can modify that
you can treat it as a project sword as well so you could just use the blade or just use the hilt you
could change the hilt so this might be in that price category it might be a fun project for you
as well link below uh to this product and i hope this review has been helpful do have a look at
that my armory review link below as well bear in mind that that my armory review is um like a decade
old okay so it some elements of the things that are spoken about in there don't apply to this one
i've got here there was something about the the ridge at the bottom of the pommel which doesn't
really apply to mine for example maybe they've changed that or maybe that example was different
to my example i've got in hand here maybe windlass have made a few changes over the last few years
but nevertheless it's a useful review i hope this has been useful and interesting there will be more
things coming from windlass in due course and some interesting developments of their products
to report soon hopefully thanks for watching give us a like and a subscribe share this video around
and take care folks thanks for watching we've got extra videos on patreon
please give our facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't already cheers folks
