The Falx: The Sword That Beat Roman Armor

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
4 Video Views·Apr 27, 2026
Swords aren't usually good against armor. Yet there was one that was so good that the Romans had to reinforce their armors because it could pierce right through them.
Swords are usually not the best weapon against armor.
If you're fighting a well-armored soldier, a sword is probably one of the worst weapons you could choose.
Yet, there was one that was so effective that it could split open Roman helmets.
So dangerous that the Romans had to reinforce their armors just to deal with this simple sword.
And that sword is called the Phalx.
So what made this weapon so deadly? Let's find out.
To understand why this weapon was such a big problem, we first need to be clear on what the Phalx even was.
Now, as I said, the Phalx is a sword.
However, it is a very particular kind of sword.
Usually, a sword will be straight with a straight blade.
You also have some swords that are curved, meaning that you will have a curve in the blade itself
with the sharpened edge on the outside of that curve.
Now, the Phalx is very different from that. It's actually inward curving.
Meaning that, essentially, it will be the same as today's sickle.
So you will have a curve in the blade, but the sharpened edge will be on the inside of the curve
rather than on the outside, like, for example, you would have on a shamsha or something like that.
A shamsha would have a curve with a sharpened edge on the outside.
A Phalx is the other way around, with the sharpened edge on the inside of the curve.
This is not a Phalx, by the way. It's just a simple sickle.
I'll just be using this during the video to illustrate certain points, because it is rather similar to a Phalx.
Now, the handle of a Phalx is very simple.
It doesn't have any form of guard or pommel. It's just a very simple wooden handle.
And the Phalx is either one- or two-handed, depending on the exact size of the weapon,
because it did vary a lot in size.
Usually, you will be looking at approximately 70 to 100 centimeters in overall length.
And the shorter versions would be one-handed, and the longer versions would be two-handed.
Now, the Phalx was used by the Dacians and Thracians, particularly during the Dacian Wars,
meaning when the Romans attacked the Dacians.
Now, the Dacians also had other very, very similar weapons.
For example, they had a one-handed, shorter version of the Phalx that was called the Sika.
Essentially, very similar to a Phalx, only it is a short sword version of the Phalx,
and was always used in one hand.
And the Thracians also had another very similar kind of sword.
That was called the Runfaya.
Now, the Runfaya is a two-handed sword,
usually longer, especially the handle, was usually longer than the one of a Phalx,
and also the blade was usually straighter.
And on top of that, the Runfaya is also usually called a Polam rather than a sword,
because it is, generally speaking, so long,
and isn't really a sword, because already a Phalx is on the verge of not being a sword,
because it is so particular compared to other swords.
Now, there is some overlap between those three categories, Sika, Phalx, and Runfaya.
Certain Phalx would be straighter and slightly larger,
and could be considered a Runfaya-like weapon.
And some of them would be shorter and only used in one hand,
and would be more similar to a Sika.
But, generally speaking, those are three different categories,
and the Phalx is kind of in between,
with either being used in one or two hands and kind of varying a lot in size.
Now, the name Phalx is actually Latin,
and it is what the Romans would call that kind of sword,
and it just simply means sickle, so exactly the same as the modern-day sickle.
And that is obviously because the two weapons are very obviously related.
The Romans actually adopted similar things to the Phalx after the Dacian Wars,
particularly as tools,
and the modern-day sickles are simply just evolutions of those Roman tools,
inspired by the Phalx.
Now, as I said, swords are usually relatively bad against armour,
and that is for the simple reason that armour does its job very, very well.
Because a sword is very, very good at cutting,
the problem is that you're very, very unlikely to be able to pierce an armour like mail, for example, with a cut.
It's virtually impossible with the vast majority of swords,
and since a sword doesn't have a lot of weight behind it,
it cannot deliver a lot of blunt force,
so it's not going to deliver a lot of blunt force through the armour.
If you have something like an axe, or something like that,
it's probably not going to be able to cut through something like a mail shell,
but it does have more weight, so more blunt force,
so it can still deliver a little bit more damage through the armour, even though it doesn't pierce it.
A sword has limited blunt force, so it's not great against armour.
And the same goes for a thrust.
You're very, very unlikely to be able to pierce an armour with a sword thrust.
Now, that being said, there are obviously certain exceptions.
Certain swords are going to be pretty good against armour.
If we take something like a longsword, for example,
it was used against armour, and is pretty decent against armour,
because it has relatively narrow points,
so you can more easily pierce it through weaker sections of mail,
and also you can half-sword it to actually get it into the gaps of armour.
If I grab something like a mace,
I might be able to hit on someone wearing plate armour, for example,
but I cannot really do any great amounts of damage
by hitting a gap in the armour,
simply because I cannot pierce the mail too easily with a mace swing.
A sword like a longsword, for example,
can more easily get to that gap and thrust through the mail
if the mail is weak at that section.
So, obviously, there are certain exceptions,
but as a general rule, a sword is not great against armour.
You're better off using a more optimised weapon,
like, for example, a polearm, a mace, a warhammer, or even a spear.
So what made the Phalx so good against armour?
Well, as I said, it has this inward curve.
Now, that inward curve on itself doesn't really help you penetrating armour.
If I'm wearing armour on my arm and I get hit by an inward-curved weapon,
the inward curve is not really going to help it to pierce the armour.
However, it does have the advantage that,
instead of having just a plain straight edge like most swords,
it actually has this sort of spike at the end.
And this spike here works in a similar manner to the spike on a warhammer, for example,
because a spike is really good for penetrating armour,
because it is a spike, it's perfect to drive yourself through armour.
And most armours are way more easy to pierce with the point of the sword,
which is essentially a sort of spike, than by cutting on it.
Because of the construction of the armour, it's just easier to pierce it with a pointy thing.
The problem is that if you take a sword and thrust it in armour,
the amount of power you can generate is limited.
If you take a Phalx, it has this spike that it uses when chopping.
So you're not thrusting, you're chopping, and the spike hits when you are chopping.
It works in a similar manner to a medieval warhammer,
which has a spike, but obviously you're not using it when you're thrusting,
you're using it when you're swinging the weapon and generating maximum power.
And the same goes for a Phalx.
When you're taking your Phalx and swinging it,
you're going to hit with the spike of the weapon,
rather than just a normal sharp edge.
To be fair, this particular sickle right here is kind of an abrupt curve,
meaning that the spike is almost straight on when you're hitting straight.
On a Phalx, the curve will generally be slightly less exaggerated,
so you're not going to hit straight on with the spike of the sword,
you're more likely to hit with this section here,
partly on the spike, partly on the sharpened edge.
But the idea is still there, and you're still getting more power,
because you're essentially hitting with a sword spike.
And that obviously allows you to pierce through armour more easily.
But that's not the only thing.
It also has an advantage that it is, at least some of them, two-handed.
Meaning that obviously you're going to generate more power with two hands
than you are with one hand, meaning that you get more power,
meaning that it's more easy to pierce armour.
And the inward curve also gives it another advantage.
And the next advantage is if you're fighting someone with a shield.
And obviously every single Roman legionary used a shield,
that was the primary line of defence of every single legionary.
Now obviously this is not a Roman shield, not a scutum,
but I'm just going to use this to illustrate a point.
Because if you're fighting someone with a straight sword,
I'm going to lift my shield to parry his attack like this,
and that's going to work just fine because his sword is straight.
However, if I'm fighting someone with a Phalx,
I'm using this sickle to illustrate.
If I want to defend a blow from them,
and I lift the shield the same amount as I did with a straight sword,
the problem is that that inward curve is actually going to allow them
to hit me in the head, in this case in the head,
depends where he attacks obviously,
but I can still get hit even though I lifted my shield enough
to parry a straight sword because of that inward curve
that comes above the shield just like this.
So a normal parry is not enough to protect against a Phalx,
and if I want to protect against a Phalx,
I need to lift my shield even higher up like this
to actually be able to protect.
And obviously that has the problem that
you don't necessarily have the time to lift your shield that much up,
it's much more tiring to move your shield so much around.
Also with a scutum, a scutum is so heavy
that you're going to struggle even more to lift that high up,
so it just gets way harder to parry any attack from a Phalx
because of that inward curve.
And obviously I used attack at the head as an example,
but the same goes for any sort of attack,
whether it's at the arm or anything like that,
at the shoulder, everything works,
it just is harder to parry an attack from a Phalx.
So essentially what it does is to bypass the shield,
which is the primary line of defence of every single Roman soldier.
And the problem is that the entirety
of the Roman soldier's equipment relies on the shield,
meaning that if you can bypass the shield,
then the equipment of a Roman soldier isn't too good.
And when you combine that with its great ability
to pierce through armour, because it is two-handed
and because it essentially has a sort of spike,
you just end up with a weapon that is incredibly good
against that one kind of protection that the Romans had.
Because obviously if you're using it against something
like a medieval knight or something like that
that does not use a shield that uses the polearm instead,
it suddenly isn't that great because,
well, you can bypass the shield,
but the problem is that he doesn't have a shield.
So his armour is the primary line of defence, not the shield.
Now obviously the Romans not just ignored this problem,
they adapted.
So this is a helmet from that period.
I forgot to mention that, but the Dacian Wars,
there were two campaigns,
the first one ranging from year 101 to year 102,
and the second one ranging from year 105 to year 106.
And during that period the Romans would use the Imperial helmet,
because obviously there is a lot of evolution in the Roman helmets
throughout the Roman Republic,
but when the Roman Empire replaced the Roman Republic,
they would have a new sort of helmet
that we have called the Imperial helmet
because it appeared during the Roman Empire,
and this is the kind of helmet they would use.
It is slightly more complicated than the earlier helmet,
I'm not going to go into detail into that
because it doesn't really matter.
The important thing is that during the Dacian Wars,
they would add this reinforcement bar right here.
So, as you can see, it is a bar on the exterior of the helmet
that is just attached there to add extra protection.
And that bar was added there to protect against the Falks,
literally because the Falks had to add this bar.
Now, exactly why is hard to know.
What is commonly said is that the Falks could split open Roman helmets.
Now I found no evidence of a Roman helmet being split open by a Falks,
but in any case, it could do a lot of damage through the helmet,
either by denting it, maybe cutting through it a little bit,
or maybe even splitting it.
I don't exactly know, we don't exactly know
because the amount of sources we have from that era
is rather limited in terms of such specific details.
But in any case, they had to reinforce their helmets
because of the Falks, and they added that bar.
They also used the lorica segmentata,
so the laminated armour of the Romans,
less because it was pierced easily by the Falks.
Because obviously the lorica segmentata is made of rather thin plates,
so the spike of the Falks could pierce it pretty easily,
at least with a very, very heavy strike.
And they instead used more of the lorica gallica,
also called lorica hamata, essentially just a mail shirt,
and more of the lorica squamata, so the scale armour.
And this was done, apparently, because these armours,
lorica gallica and lorica squamata,
were harder to pierce for the Falks.
Because obviously, if you are able to pierce one plate of the lorica segmentata,
obviously they're overlapping slightly,
but generally speaking, if you are able to pierce one plate,
you will go through the armour and into the shoulder of the person,
and you will have pierced the whole armour.
With the two other armours, lorica gallica and lorica segmentata,
they have additional shoulder guards.
If you take a normal mail shirt, it's just normal mail everywhere,
and nothing is doubled up.
But if you take a lorica gallica or lorica hamata,
it actually has additional shoulder guards,
so you essentially have two layers of mail on the shoulders.
And obviously that is really useful against the Falks,
because it is likely to hit you on the shoulders,
because of the way the weapon works,
so it's likely to hit you on the shoulders,
and if you have two layers there, that's really good.
Now, those additional shoulder guards were not added there
because of the Falks, they already were there,
but they figured out that having those additional shoulder guards
was great against the Falks.
And they would not only reinforce their armours
or use other better armours against the Falks,
they would also add other pieces to their suits.
For example, they would very often add another piece of armour
called a manica.
Manica just meaning sleeve in Latin.
Now, that is a laminated armour, just like the lorica segmentata,
only it will protect the arm, the entirety of the arm.
So essentially from the bottom of the shoulder to the wrist,
the entirety of that covered in laminated armour.
And they added that to the sole arm,
because obviously that is where you're most likely to get hit
by a Falks coming around the shield,
because that is where you're most exposed.
Your shield arm will already be protected by the shield
because it already holds in the middle of the shield,
so even Falks cannot really reach it if it hits around the shield.
However, it can hit the sword arm because it is more exposed.
On top of that, they would also very often use greaves or shins,
which essentially are just leg protection for the lower leg.
And it also seems like they would use some form of petrugas.
Now, that is sort of straps hanging down from the belt area
to protect the upper leg.
Now, we don't exactly know how those were made or attached or anything like that,
for the simple reason that, as far as I know,
the only evidence we have of them adding those petrugas
are from different illustrations,
like, for example, mainly the Trojan column,
which is a sort of stone engraving
that shows different illustrations from the Dacian Wars.
And that would show Roman soldiers with petrugas,
but we don't have very much further information
on how those were attached or made.
It might be some form of a supermarlis,
maybe the supermarlis had petrugas hanging down to protect the lower legs,
or maybe they had some form of leather petrugas or something like that.
So we don't exactly know how those petrugas were added,
but it seems like they also wanted some upper leg protection, too.
And also, it seems like they added those petrugas to the top of the arm, also,
to protect the places where the mannequin was not protecting.
Now, obviously, all of this does not mean that the original Roman armour was useless.
Not at all.
It just means that it wasn't really adapted to fighting against the Phalax.
Because, as I said, the primary line of defence of the Roman legionary
is his shield, the scutum.
And the problem with the Phalax is that it can, to a certain degree,
bypass the defence of the shield because of this inward curve.
The equipment of a Roman soldier, generally speaking,
against straight swords, against spears, or anything like that,
works fantastic.
It's just that they weren't really expecting or adapted to fighting
against an inward-curved weapon like the Phalax.
And the Phalax obviously had that advantage
that it could pretty easily bypass the defence of the shield
and was also good at penetrating armour, generally speaking, if it hit it.
And when you combine those two advantages of the Phalax,
the fact that it could bypass the protection of the shield
more easily than other weapons,
and the fact that it could also be better at penetrating armour
than some other weapons,
you have the problem that it would more easily bypass the protection
of the Roman shield and then hit on the different pieces of armour,
meaning that, in the end, it was a really, really good anti-armour weapon
simply because it was really good against that specific kind of Roman armour.
Obviously, if you put the Phalax up against late-medieval plate armour
or something like that,
late-medieval plate armour is going to be too thick for the Phalax to penetrate,
and also, late-medieval plate armour already has arm guards greased and so on,
and it's not relying that much on the shield,
so if it can bypass the protection of the shield,
it doesn't really matter that much,
because the primary line of defence is the armour itself,
on late-medieval plate armour.
So, in the end, the Phalax was good at penetrating armour if it hit it,
but it was also good at bypassing the protection of the shield,
and that meant that it just was incredibly good against the Roman equipment,
because it relied a lot on the shield and relatively thin pieces of armour
that could be relatively easily pierced by something like a Phalax.
And obviously, the Romans just adapted to that new threat
by adding reinforcements to their armour and also new pieces of armour
that would protect the now unprotected areas,
and once those new pieces of armour were not needed anymore,
some of them were abandoned.
For example, the Greaves were abandoned after the Dacian Wars,
the Marnica was abandoned,
and obviously some of them were kept,
like, for example, the bar on the front of the helmet,
on the Roman helmet, was kept after the Dacian Wars,
but some of them were abandoned.
Now, this also shows that there isn't just a constant straight evolution in the armour,
there is actually more of an adaptation,
because people just use the amount of protection that is worth using,
that they need to use against the weapons they are fighting against.
So even though they have the technology to make better armour,
they don't necessarily do it, simply because it isn't worth it, usually.
But obviously, when they encounter a weapon that is more dangerous,
they need more armour, and then they just adapt,
and when they don't need that armour anymore,
they just abandon it, like the Marnica, for example,
they just abandon it after the Dacian Wars,
because it wasn't necessary anymore.
So anyways, hope you enjoyed the video, and I'll see you in the next one.
