Medieval Review - Windlass The Accolade

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
1 Video View·May 8, 2026
This review analyzes the aesthetics and construction of the Accolade replica sword, featuring detailed Templar iconography on the blade and pommel. It explores the balance, handling, and quality of the included scabbard and belt from Windlass Steelcrafts.
You know what? I like Templars. For a whole myriad of reasons. From a modern perspective,
I certainly find secret societies very enticing, and well, since there's so much mystery
surrounding the Templars, and with a lot of the truth lost to history, there's a lot of fun to be
had there. A great example is, I play a Templar in the game The Secret World. Good game, good
faction. But the truth is, I find their original historically accurate purpose just as interesting,
and actually really quite noble. Since the Templars, as a knightly order, kind of broke
the nation-state boundaries, they in many ways have become one of the most single recognizable
things to come from the Middle Ages. But modern recognizability and all the misinformation
sometimes does them a great disservice. So, it's rare to see something that, well,
captures the spirit of the Templars, without bringing too much of the baggage or misinformation.
In what is going to be a rather rare case, I'm going to look at a sword that breaks a lot of
rules in the kinds of swords that I tend to collect. It isn't really a simple design,
and it has a lot going on, but that's okay. And the reason is simple. I like Templars.
Non nobis, Domine. Non nobis, sed nomine, tuo du glorium. These iconic words engraved on the blade
define this historic sword replica. The creed of the Knight Templar,
nothing for us, Lord, nothing for us but the glory of thy name, marked their illustrious
and sometimes infamous 200-year military influence. This magnificent sword, named the
Accolade, would have been a sword worthy of the Grand Master to knight a loyal member of his
holy order. The best metalsmiths from windless steel crafts have spent hours on each blade,
hand-forging the high-carbon steel for optimal balance, quickness, and durability.
The pommel features a highly detailed Templar coin on each side with Latin inscription and
the symbols that have grown synonymous with the Templar order, while the grip is hand-wrapped
with a rich, genuine leather with wire overwrap. The sword includes a custom-matching wooden
scabbard covered in top-grain heavy-duty leather and a period belt with solid metal fittings.
The specifications of this sword are the overall length is 40 inches, the blade is 32 1⁄4 inches,
the weight is 3 pounds 9 ounces, the edge comes unsharpened, the point of balance is 4 inches,
the thickness is 4.3 millimeters to 4.2 millimeters, the width is 58.6 millimeters,
and the grip length is 4 1⁄2 inches. The pommel is peened. It has a retail price of $375.
Let's face it, if you are looking at this sword, or if you have ever looked at this sword,
it is because of the aesthetics, not because you wondered how well it was made or how it handled.
Well, at least not at first. And if you considered buying this sword,
what are the reasons? Pretty much guaranteed it's because of how it looks.
The sword is an oak shot type 12. The blade has a slight taper with a three-quarter length fuller,
which is pretty standard in this kind of sword. And inside the fuller is the faux etching.
The crossguard is a variation of a style 6 and looks really nice when viewing the sword as a
whole. The leather-wrapped handle is quite attractive in color and the wire wrapping
adds some much-needed texture to it. However, the way the wire wrapping is done, coming out
of the leather where it does, is a little odd. The pommel starts as a type H and then proceeds
to add so much to it that it really defies classification under that standard. However,
the pommel does have a great deal of detail in and of itself. Either side has a different inset coin,
one with a generic Crusader cross on a shield, and the other has the emblem of the Knights
Templar. Two knights riding on a single horse to signify their vows of poverty, encircled by the
Sigillum Militum Expisti, which stands for Seal of the Army of Christ. The edge of both coins has
the same Templar creed that is on the blade, as well as the text, Pauperus Camillitinus Christi
Templic Solominici Pyrosolomitanus, which means the poor fellow soldiers of Christ
and the Temple of Solomon. It is finished with a very rough peen. I feel that some of the
aesthetics of the pommel coins could have been stamped or molded a little bit better. The text
isn't always as crisp and it gets muddled at points. So one of the main things I like about
this sword is that a great deal of thought went into it. The decisions to make this sword a type
12 with a style 6 quillen, it was obviously meant to be representative of the style of sword that
was popular during the height of Templar power in the late 13th and early 14th century, just before
their disillusion. And this is one of those rare cases where the focus was mainly on the visual
design of the sword, but it isn't a movie licensed sword or a Marto. Additionally, we can talk about
some of the extras that come with the sword, the sword belt and the scabbard. The scabbard looks
nice enough, though it almost seems under decorated when compared to the rest of the sword.
The belt likewise is pretty basic, but it is designed to match the whole ensemble.
The part that baffles me is that each of the metal fittings here has a slightly different
colored patina or paint job or whatever it is. I can't really decide if that's supposed to be
intentional or not. Where to begin? This sword has all the hallmarks of a functional sword,
a high carbon steel blade, it's peened and even its overall weight isn't too bad for this kind
of arming sword. However, there is something that seems a little bit off about the balance.
The whole thing just feels very blade heavy. Now that said, I don't really doubt its functionality,
and I do think the hollow pommel really wouldn't stand up to as much of a beating as the rest of
the sword, but really what would you expect? The blade is properly tempered to be strong and
flexible, and I had mine sharpened, but normally it would come with the standard windlass false edge.
The hilt assembly feels strong, but as is usual with windlass swords,
the connection points for the cross guard and the blade have a pretty wide gap.
Now the sword actually cuts pretty well when sharpened. The biggest attraction of the sword
is how it feels in the hand, and in this regard I don't really rate it too highly. Luckily,
there is a fix for that. A good metal gauntlet while adding some weight does make it feel as
though the sword's weight is more evenly distributed. Nice little trick I picked up
once upon a time. The sword belt and scabbard from a functionality standpoint are serviceable,
but I've run into some quality issues. There is this little leather ring that I think was meant
to kind of trick your eye into thinking that there's a chape there, which is loose, and well
on this scabbard I think I'll probably have to just re-glue it. Now the scabbard is also loose
in the sword, so it won't really stay on the blade by itself. Gravity has to keep the sword
in it, and this is pretty much the standard for a windlass scabbard. They are always fairly low
quality. The leather on the belt is solid, but not nearly as rich as I was hoping. I think it
would have been a lot nicer if they had finished the leather all the way around on both sides.
I think my expectations for this sword were maybe a bit too high.
The Templar theme coupled with the apparent limited supply and a very high demand really
had me excited to get my hands on this sword. Now don't get me wrong, the sword works great
as a centerpiece for display purposes. Heck, normally it is the centerpiece for this dining
room table where I do these reviews, and it sits right under this painting, the Accolade.
But at this price point, having a functional sword as well as a decorative one seems almost
required, and I think it's at that point that windlass missed their mark. I just don't know
that I feel comfortable really using this sword. So is it worth the asking price? Well,
as I stated at the beginning, I like Templars. And because I like Templars, this sword is basically
slap dab in the middle of my must have list. Now having had it for a while, I don't really regret
the purchase, but I do question the price. I think it could have done without the scabbard
and the belt as kind of adding to the price, and I think they could have knocked down the price a
bit having just removed those from the package. But in the end, it's a decent real sword,
and the package deal isn't too bad. Functional if you have a desire to use a sword that was
obviously intended to supplant functionality with visual appeal. So at the price point,
I've bought much worse swords that have looked nice, and I've bought plenty that were functional
but looked terrible. This one skates that line, and in the end, it doesn't really impress beyond
being just eye candy. It's worth it if you want it, but if you don't, well, you can safely pass.
The Accolade Sword of the Knights Templar, I give it a 3 out of 5.
