Why are HEMA offhand daggers so huge? And what can be done?

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
Jan 23, 2026
Academy of Historical Fencing explores the size difference between historical and modern HEMA daggers. The presenter analyzes data from museum collections to compare blade lengths and designs. This insightful video examines the practical implications of dagger size in historical and modern contexts.
In the age of the rapier, this is the kind of dagger that you might use alongside it.
And yet, in HEMA today, people are using absolutely massive daggers like this.
Why is that?
Is it a problem?
And if it is a problem, how do we fix it?
Hi, I'm Nick Thomas, and welcome back to the Academy of Historical Fencing.
So this is the sort of off-hand, main gauche, or left-hand dagger that you'd pair with
a rapier or a sidesword.
And this is what it commonly looked like in the age of manuals that most people were working
from, such as Fabris, Giganti, Cabo Ferro.
And yet, in HEMA today, people are so commonly using a very large sail-type dagger, such
as this.
So about four years ago, I did some statistical analysis from museum collections of different
kinds of off-hand daggers to really look at what this will be like.
Because every time I go to museums, I see loads of examples of very small off-hand daggers,
and yet you never see them in HEMA training today.
Well, almost never anyway, because I do have one here, and we'll talk about this in a little
bit.
So both of these are made by Regheni, and they represent different sorts of daggers
in different eras and different cultures, and do a very different job.
So this data set I've collected of 84, it is not from any bias, it is just all of the
daggers from the Wallace Collection and the Royal Armouries, where the data could actually
be collected.
And in the years since, I've gone through data sets from other museums where I've been
able to find this kind of information, and found that ultimately, that even with larger
data sets, these charts still are pretty representative of the averages.
So looking at that statistical analysis, you can see that there is a significant difference
between these two types of daggers, and that is really, really important.
So the sail-type dagger, that is denoted by this big sail-like guard, came into use around
about the 1630s or 1640s, and maybe even a little bit later.
So this did not exist during the time of most rapier manuals that people are working from,
whether that's Italian or Spanish.
But especially if you're working from things like Capo Ferro Gigante, Fabris, then this
just didn't exist, not for quite some time after the manuals were originally published.
During that time, this was the sort of dagger, a much simpler dagger, you'd often call this
a ring-hilt today, again not a historical term, and it has a significantly smaller guard,
in fact these large quillings curving forwards is actually decadent compared to some.
Some of them are very simple, like the sharp that I showed at the start of the video, but
significantly they have a lot less hand protection than the sail, and they're much, much shorter.
And if you look at the statistical analysis, we have to make a distinction between the
Spanish sail daggers and everything else, and that's because time period-wise, when
the Spanish daggers were coming in, daggers in use in the rest of Europe were rapidly
falling away, and the size difference between the two is massive.
So we look at the chart and see that statistically, daggers were much shorter back then, in terms
of antique examples, than HEMA daggers today, but also if we break apart those two, sail
daggers versus everything else, you'll see there's a huge difference between the two,
and that is the sail daggers on average are massively larger in blade length than all
of the other types.
Now there are of course outliers, you can find simple daggers with long blades, and
you can find sail daggers with shorter, but we're very much looking at typicals and averages
to understand what these weapons were like on a typical basis.
Now there were other types of daggers of course in the pre-sail dagger era, there were sorts
of shell guard like this for example, or sorts of other sort of complex guards, but largely
these all kind of fit into the typically shorter, just like all the others, they don't fit into
that long sail guard type, so we're going to have sail guard and everything else.
And that means if you are practising from those typical Italian rapier manuals for example,
and using this, you're using a dagger that is way larger than they would have been using
at the time on average.
Now is that a problem and why are people doing it today?
Well there's a few simple reasons, first of all when people buy their HEMA swords and
daggers, they go to common manufacturers or popular manufacturers like Regheni and buy
what they've got, and this is the typical so-called tournament dagger, and that's what
they get, it's available, they buy it, and so they're getting what they're given if you
like.
But also, sail daggers have an advantage, so if you want to stat pad, increase your
chances of winning in the fight, you're going to take every advantage you can possibly get.
Sail daggers are a significant advantage because they give massive amounts of hand protection
so they reduce the chances of being hand sniped.
Extra blade length means you've got a better chance of catching your opponent's blade,
but also by going for longer blade lengths, you increase the chances of having a more
flexible, safe blade for when you try and stab somebody.
So from a competitive advantage and a safety advantage, these long sail daggers are an
advantage and they make practical sense over using a short, stiff dagger.
And looking at the data on the two, we can see that statistically, a simple dagger that
you might use with a rapier often has a blade length of around about 27, 28 centimetres,
and then your sail daggers are often into the 40-something centimetres, so the 43 on
average, roughly something like that.
And so the difference in blade length between a simple dagger and a sail dagger is absolutely
massive.
And that is replicated in these two here.
So these are both made by Regeni.
This is the Regeni Tournament, and this is a Regeni Parian dagger with the short blade
option.
And yeah, these are a real rare thing to see today.
And that's fair enough.
So the reality is, if you're practising with rapier sources in the late 16th and early
17th century, which is what most people doing rapier are, and using this, it's the wrong
kind of dagger for that system.
But is that necessarily a problem?
You know, people like the stat pad because it gives them advantage, and that extra blade
length does give them extra safety on thrusting impacts.
Now, of course, why were daggers this small?
It's to do with practicality, because these had to be worn and carried.
You have to sit down with them.
You have to ride a horse.
This thing is absolutely massive to be worn on your side or your back, which is where
they commonly were worn.
And today, we just chuck them in a sword bag and put them in your car, and it's not a big
deal carrying this around.
Now, is this a problem?
I would say, as a conclusion, no.
When our students want to buy daggers, I highly recommend they buy sail daggers that are nice
and flexible.
That's absolutely fine.
That said, flexible daggers, they need to be from reputable sellers that are reliable,
that don't take bad sets, that don't snap, like the Hamway sail dagger, for example,
which is horrific and you absolutely shouldn't use.
I have seen flexible daggers bend and then break and do significant injury.
And so flexible daggers are OK, as long as you don't become too reliant on them from
a safety perspective, and you get them from reputable manufacturers.
Now, personally, I'm absolutely fine with rigid offhand daggers because I kind of like
people to know that from a safety perspective, they have to pull their blows and don't become
reliant on thinking that that safe, flexible blade will be safe no matter what they do
with it.
So in regular sparring, I'm absolutely fine with rigid daggers, but I understand why in
a tournament setting that would not be the case.
And so that's fine.
I'm fine with flexible daggers being the norm across the HEMA board or tournament scene
as well.
And so you can sort of see my conclusion here is that, yes, this is the wrong type of dagger
to be using for most rapier sources.
And yet, is it a big deal?
Not really.
It does stat pad a little bit, but it's not the end of the world.
It gives people good hand protection.
It keeps people safe on the thrusting impacts.
But if you'd like to delve deeper into your understanding of these period sources and
understand what sort of weapons people were carrying and how they would act in a fight
if you're practicing from those typical rapier sources, I'd recommend that you do get some
short daggers to use for occasional training.
It's not my normal training dagger, but I do like to bring it out and get some use out
of it to just understand what it would be like to use the real thing and not basically
the stat padded absolute monster that this is.
Of course, if you're the kind of person that's practicing from 1630s onwards rapier sources,
where these kind of absolutely massive daggers were a common thing, then it wouldn't be
incorrect to use it anyway.
And so is it a problem that this is common in HEMA today and it wasn't common during
the age when they were really in use very commonly outside of those Spanish cuphilts?
No, I don't think so.
But I would really suggest that if you're getting deep into rapier, then pick up some
short daggers and get them some use from time to time.
See what it's really, really like, because it is actually really fascinating to use these
short daggers.
And the reality is that's what they were using.
In fact, the dagger I most commonly use when I am practicing rapier and dagger is this
one, which was a custom I had made by Dinelli about 10 years ago, in fact, and it's designed
to be a matching set with the rapier that I bought at the same time.
And this kind of gets me somewhere in between because it's almost as short as this little
Rugeni dagger, and yet it does have flexibility.
So it's possible to get flex on these blades, although then this is a little bit shorter
again.
But this gives me that kind of ring hilt guard.
The aquilins are a bit larger than this, obviously, because it's designed to match up with a big,
big rapier.
But this gets me that understanding of using a simple dagger of a more common length of
the time.
So this is my favourite go-to.
But I'm also happy to use the sail dagger and love using this little one as well.
And this little Rugeni is specified as just about the shortest you can possibly make it
with all of these drop-down boxes.
And so that's it.
It doesn't have to be anything super controversial.
It's an interesting research piece into museum examples.
There's no major problem here.
But I would highly recommend that, as ever with your training tools, have a variety that
represent different types of swords so you can understand the massive variety and difference
in weapons that were used for real.
That's it.
Thanks for watching.
I hope you enjoyed it.
Please like and subscribe.
Remember, we now have channel subscriptions if you want, or memberships if you want to
help out.
There's no pressure to do so.
Thanks for watching.
