Windlass "1860" Union Officer Cavalry Saber Review

Rune Slicer
2 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 25, 2025
Another sword that's out of my training wheelhouse but sort-of from my pre-martial arts youth: An India-made cavalry saber to replace the first sword I ever bought for myself: An India-made cavalry saber. Based on a popular French design, this one is more properly called an M1862, as there wasn't an official "1860" model. Overall, I think Windlass did a pretty good job for very little money, enough to maybe inspire me to finally learn how to use one of these semi-properly now that HEMA is a thing.
All right, admission. I am definitely in the middle of a major nostalgia craze.
And I blame that on the fact that it's been officially a year that I've been in semi-mostly
isolation. Minimal human contact, lots of access to the internet and extra time on my hands
apparently causes flashbacks. Memories. Don't let me sing. Don't ever let me sing. That is a rule.
But you've already seen me go down this path in a few other videos where I've shown you swords
that are outside what I consider my wheelhouse, at least my formal training, education, and decades
upon decades of practice with Japanese and Chinese martial arts, Japanese and Chinese swordsmanship.
Going back to the before time, my prehistory, inspired by my lifelong love of fantasy and
science fiction and what was available to me at the time. We're talking early 70s Phoenix, Arizona.
I acquired myself a selection of European-style-ish sword-shaped objects, many of which were made in
Toledo, Spain, and I talked about the good and the horrible about those. One of the worst things was
the construction, that welded-on rat tail that would snap off the hilt with the slightest use.
But still, I really loved the swords. I just didn't know how to use them. That was another
thing that wasn't available to me. There was some fledgling SCA in the park and you could go to the
university and, you know, learn some sport fencing. That was it. As far as I knew, historic European
arts were permanently dead. If I had access to HEMA back then, I probably would have gone down
that path and we'll kind of talk about that further in terms of future possibilities. But,
as you've seen in those other videos recently, I have spent my time flashing back and going on the
internet and finding modern reproductions similar to those old swords that I loved and left behind
when I started proper real sword training. And forgot about, apparently, until you shut me in
room for a year. Then things come back, anyway. So, overall I've been very impressed that for
very little money I found, at least what's in my mind, some really nice usable swords.
And I still don't know how to use them, right? I'm picking up little bits as I go, but in a lot
of cases I can apply what I already know about Japanese and Chinese swordsmanship to them.
And there are, indeed, some similarities. There's also, indeed, a lot of differences,
which I can immediately tell because I'm having to develop muscle groups that I've never had to
use that way. So, yeah, that's been big fun, but I think it's worthwhile. Now, the first sword I ever
bought for myself, though, did not come from Toledo. It was made in India and it was a cavalry saber.
And it was all kinds of bad, but I still loved it. We're talking mystery steel. We're talking
no distal taper, so it was balanced like a wrecking bar. We're talking no edge, so I had
to put that on myself. We're talking a very interesting acid-etched scroll pattern on the blade,
but they didn't even bother to try to put it on straight. Mystery sheet steel fixtures,
paper-thin leather-ish something over the scabbard and the hilt that was then wrapped in some wire,
and everything was barely held together by a big old ugly hex nut on the end of the tang.
But because I didn't know what I was doing, I put that sword to what would be considered
really, really abusive use. And unlike those Toledo blades, it did not fail. It didn't break.
It bent a bit. It got scuffed up a bit more, but it didn't fail, so I gotta give it that.
So here I am in the midst of my latest flashback, thinking maybe, maybe I should get myself another
cavalry saber and see how that goes. See if I remember how that felt, or maybe can finally
learn how to use it right. Possibly in my old age, you know, who knows? So what did I get?
This may or may not have been influenced by, shall we say, recent state of affairs in this country
in the last couple of weeks, couple of months, couple of years. I'm not going to say, but,
you know, for sure you decide. But what I got, coincidentally, is another saber made in India,
windless steel crafts. I got it through Atlantic Cutlery for about 150 bucks,
not a big investment whatsoever in my mind, and it's actually one of their more expensive blades
by about 23 bucks. So why did I take the risk on something just even that much more expensive? Well,
again, maybe the state of affairs in this country, or maybe just because it was pretty,
or both, not going to say. Anyway, this is called an 1860 Union Officer's Cavalry Saber,
so Civil War design, Union design. Authentic or not, kind of, at least from the examples I've seen,
they got a lot right, and there's some great things about this sword and a couple of things
that are not so great that we'll get into. But what did I get for that extra 20-30 bucks? Now,
if you if you google that, they just actually call different things on different websites
slightly, but if you google 1860 Cavalry Union Cavalry Light Cavalry Saber, you'll see a couple
of different variations of this. And there really isn't a thing, I guess, as far as I could tell,
that's an 1860 saber. There's a light cavalry saber that replaced the 1840 Heavy Cavalry Saber,
which the troopers called a wrist breaker, which I probably should not have.
The light one is based on a very popular French design, so you've got the three bar guard,
and it actually has this this correct pommel that doesn't have the metal back strap.
But most of the versions that you'll see online, the cheaper ones especially, just have plain brass
guard pommel, plain steel scabbard. So for the extra 20-30 bucks, what did I get? Well, a couple
things actually. First of all, a lot of really well done scroll work on the pommel, on the guard
where it meets the pommel, inside the guard, because I guess that's visible when you're wearing
the sword, and and there's some on on the top of it because, you know, you want your enemy to
appreciate the craftsmanship of the sword that you're pointing at him, right? That's very
important. The grip is, it may or may not be leather, it is pretty well done, very smooth. The wire wrap
is pretty well done, except for one thing immediately I noticed was where the wire goes
into the seam at the top, they left a pointy bit sticking out that kept stabbing me. Or maybe it
was just telling me I was gripping the sword wrong, but I trimmed it off. All better now. However,
one thing that I still am uncomfortable with is, I mentioned this before, I have really small hands
and my grip is smaller because of the brace, but this grip is strangely disturbingly skinny,
to the point where I don't feel like I have good control of the sword. As in, I feel like I'm
gripping the wrong end of a screwdriver. Yeah, this would feel small on a knife. Now, I've seen
other sabers before and I've held other sabers before, I don't remember any of them being this
skinny, so I don't know how accurate it is. It just feels like it needs another layer of leather,
which I'm probably going to do to it, but I wanted to show it to you first before I made any
modifications to speak of. Another upgrade that you'll, by the way, it is a peened construction,
no big hex nuts here, and it's really solid actually. Nothing's loose, nothing's rattled,
even with the stupid things I've already done to it, which I'll talk about here shortly.
Very solidly built, so I'm impressed with that for $150. The scabbard is a nice polished,
really heavy steel. This thing weighs about a pound and a half just by itself.
And the other upgrade you get are some really nice, thick, solid brass castings. You've got a
scabbard mouth, you've got two hangers with some really solid rings, and then the drag shape,
I don't know the nomenclature very well, so please feel free to correct me and
hopefully not ridicule me too much. All of those are screwed in, they're not glued on,
wedged on, they're going to stay put. Also, on the side that shoes, you will see that there is
scroll work, so that's nice. Now, before I unsheath this thing, the sheath itself does
have some plastic liners on the sides, but not top and bottom. Hits the sword reasonably well,
but absolutely does not retain it, so I may have to fix that. There was also a thick felt washer
at the base of the blade that, the first time I took it out to do any cutting, flew off and
disappeared in the snow, and I may or may not see it in the springtime, but I'm probably just going
to put a leather one on, so not a big loss. But before I unsheath it, be warned, I'm probably
going to tear up a little bit. Not because I'm nostalgic, but because the sword stinks.
And I mentioned this in a previous review when I described a sword as stinking because it was
covered in a grease that reeked of kerosene. This is worse. They used like a bucket of the stuff,
slathered it on super thick, and then shoved the blade in the scabbard with no plastic over it,
the scabbard is full of the stuff. So I've been wiping this off for days and days and days and
days, and I'm still coming out with grease. But worse, just the act of unsheathing the sword
lights up the room. I'm afraid to light a match. Or maybe I should light a match. Maybe that would
fix the problem. Maybe I'll try that. If I do, I'll let you know. Actually, I won't have to let
you know because in my next video, I won't have eyebrows. But, yeah. Desperate times. It's like
sticking your nose in a gas tank. So here goes. I will try not to lose consciousness.
That would also make a good video. Oh. Wow. Anyway. But also wow because the blade is
actually pretty well done in terms of being traditional and French in design. Well, one thing
that apparently is wrong about is it's too short by a couple of inches. I guess the originals were
36 inches and this blade is 34. It's made out of 1065 high carbon steel. It seems to be pretty
nicely hardened and tempered and has a decent amount of flex but nowhere near too much.
It has some distal taper but not a lot. Now the weight of the sword itself is two pounds three
ounces which isn't bad. It was lighter than I thought it was going to be and the point of
balance is sitting at 5.75 inches which is measured from the flat of the guard. I usually measure that
from like a Habaki. But, yeah. That's not too bad but it does make the sword blade forward in terms
of weight but not unbearably so. I think the worst part of it is the grip is so thin I just don't
have a good grasp on it. So that makes it kind of unwieldy. So thickening up the grip I think is
going to be one of my first modifications to see what that does to the sword. However the blade
itself the good and the not so good. First of all for that extra 20 bucks or 25 bucks the blade is
also etched with this blackened acid etching in a civil war motif. So on one side you've got the
work and the military designs and then it says Union Saber. On the other side this is very
interesting and this is also a sign that I've been spending too much time with Katana because
holding a sword edge down is just completely unnatural to me. I have to make myself do it
though because you need to see this. On the other side it says US and then there's a big blank spot.
It's the only blank spot in the etching anywhere where the A should be. There's clearly room there
for an A but there's no A and I don't know why. I just know there's a story behind this.
If you happen to know put it in the comment section but yeah that's that's interesting.
Now the blackening does come off when I clean it. I don't know what the final result of that's
going to be but I think it's pretty well done. What it is obscuring is some of the features of
the sword that are actually very French in terms of the double fuller. It does have one
wide fuller that runs from the ricasso all the way up to about three quarters the length of the blade
and then there is a secondary skinny fuller which again you can't really see very well because of
the etching that runs for about half of that in the middle from about there to there.
The rest of the sword has kind of a lozenge cross-section
so I'm thinking I might need to do maybe just a little bit of re-profiling to change the balance
but the first thing I'm going to do is change the grip. See how that makes it feel before I do
anything else to the blade. Speaking about doing stuff to the blade, Windlass is notorious for
shipping blades without edges. I guess that's a requirement for them, a regulation,
and this was really blunt. We're talking a couple of millimeters of just flat on the edge. Thankfully
I had just laid in a collection of fine belts from my belt sander so I went out in the snow like
Conan's dad and worked on the sword and I probably should have videoed some of that but you know there
would have been cursing and it would have been family-friendly and yeah. Anyway what I tried to
do is recreate what at least I've researched as a traditional saber edge on this thing
which means no edge on the thwart. Basically I used the engraved bit. The first half I left mostly
as it was. Just a little bit of taper, not much, no edge. That's your parrying surface.
The upper half I put, well they described it in the text as a lead cutting edge. Basically
something that you could whack into things and it wouldn't destroy it. So not like a katana,
more like what I would consider a hatchet. Sharp but not terribly acute and that is the top half
of the lead edge and then there is a relief for a back edge so I went ahead and did the back edge
as well which is about a quarter length of the blade. You've also got a tip that's just kind of
back swept, not quite a hatchet point but kind of a minimalistic version of that and then I took it
out and did some cutting. Anna sucked but I think that was mostly me but there's actually an upside
to that. My first batch of bottles went sailing over the fence like yeah we were playing baseball.
I just don't know how to cut with this but the more I practiced, the more I tried to get the
feel of it, the better I got and eventually I started being successful. Same kind of thing
happened with cardboard. Sometimes I just totally smashed the cardboard and other times ragged cuts
and then better. Not nearly as good as I could do with a katana or a gen or a dowel but
the other thing, well a couple of things that taught me. Thing one is I need a lot more practice.
Like I said there's whole muscle groups that I have not developed yet in terms of being able to
use a sword like this that I think are worth developing. Second thing is bad cutting is
usually bad for a sword. I mean I really whacked it on things for lack of any better term and I did
no damage to it. No bending, no loosening, no nothing. I didn't even scuff it so that's
impressive. 150 bucks I think it's a decent sword and has a lot of potential and I think
it's worth me investing in actually learning how to use it properly. So you're probably going to
see me doing a little bit more of this and maybe reviewing a lot of similar swords. Actually not
maybe, I can kind of guarantee it and you probably already know that if you've caught
the easter egg in the background which is now clearly visible right through the guard of the
sword. So yeah we'll be looking at that one really soon and let me tell you that's even
more special. But until then I hope you enjoyed this one, found it informative, interesting,
amusing even if it's at my expense and until next time hope to see you again.
