How Good Is the KATANA, Really?

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
5 Video Views¡Mar 19, 2026
A deep dive into the katana. Its metallurgy, design, cutting ability, and the historical evidence behind many common claims about this famous sword.
AI Generated¡May contain errors
Hello everyone and welcome to this deep dive into the katana, probably one of the most
famous swords from history.
A lot of people have already tried to answer the question of how good it really is, but
most of the time, not always, but most of the time, this is done by testing individual
swords, meaning that those tests aren't necessarily representative of all the katanas there are,
or of all of the other swords they are actually comparing it to.
On top of that, discussions about the katana will usually end up in two extremes.
On one side, you have the people who claim the katana is the best sword ever made, which
is obviously not true, and then on the other side, you have the people who say that it
is a terrible weapon, which is not entirely true either.
The katana is definitely not the best sword ever at everything.
It does have a lot of limitations, but it also has certain strengths.
So in this video, we'll explore all the different aspects of the katana, from metallurgy to
weight distribution, passing through blade shape or dimensions, to hopefully find out
what are the disadvantages and advantages of that curved Japanese sword.
But first, we need to find out why the katana ever became so legendary and popular, and
the main reason for that is that after World War II, Japan started promoting their culture
to Western countries through movies, animes, mangas, anything like that, and part of that
culture was the katana.
So a lot of people who actually watched these Japanese cultural things actually started
believing that the katana was one of the best swords ever to exist because of the things
it did in the movies or whatever they watched.
And meanwhile, European swords, the longsword for example, were represented as being badly
made, crude, and so on.
So a lot of people actually started believing that was true.
Now I just want to make clear that this is not a video about katana vs longsword, nor
is it a video about katana vs any other specific sword.
It just is a video exploring all the different aspects of the katana to find out what are
its advantages and disadvantages.
And yes, I will sometimes be referring to other swords and comparing to other swords,
but it's not directly a comparison video.
And it's also very important to remember that we're always talking about swords, always
talking about the katana, but the main weapons of the samurai were actually bows and spears
or the polearms, not actually the katana.
The katana was only a secondary weapon in case they lost, broke, or anything like that
their spear.
And if a samurai used a sword as his primary weapon on the battlefield, it would usually
be a longer sword than the katana.
For example, it could be something like an Odachi, an Odachi, or even an Okatana, which
are essentially longer versions of the katana.
On top of that, the katana is a relatively modern sword that was used from approximately
the 14th to 19th century.
During other periods of history, Japanese people would actually use other swords.
For example, they would use a sword called the Chokuto from the 3rd to the 10th century.
Now, the Chokuto is a very, very similar sword to the katana, essentially the main difference
is that it is straight.
And then in between the 10th and 16th century, they would use a sword called the Tachi, which
is basically, I'm simplifying obviously, but it's roughly a more curved katana.
And after the katana, from 1875 to 1945 approximately, they would use another sword that is called
the Gunto.
Now, we'll come back to the Gunto later.
So as I said, we'll go through all the different aspects of the katana, all the different commonly
given reasons for why it is supposedly so great, and I just want to add that I have
tried to gather as many sources to make this video as trustworthy as possible, meaning
I have sources for every claim, or at least for the most important claims.
For example, I haven't actually saved the sources that state during which period the
katana was used, because it has little to no importance for the rest of the video.
But for all the important claims, I actually have sources, and I have tried to mix together
both European or Western sources, and Japanese or Eastern sources, so there is no form of
bias.
Because obviously, the European or Western sources might be slightly biased against the
katana, and the opposite might be true for the Japanese sources.
So I have tried to mix them together for maximum objectivity.
Now, I will not mention every single source during the video while I'm speaking, because
it will make the video unnecessarily long and redundant.
However, all the sources will be available in the description, so if you're interested
in actually fact-checking everything I say, I have actually left everything in the description.
And obviously, I have tried to use as many trustworthy sources as possible, so mythological
studies, museum data, anything like that, but for some things, there simply aren't any
study on that one particular thing, so for some things, I will have to rely on less trustworthy
sources.
Even though when I don't have a trustworthy source, I will mention it, mention that I
don't have a trustworthy source and I'm actually just relying on less trustworthy sources,
and I will also state that we cannot be sure of that one claim, since we don't have a trustworthy
source proving it.
Now, to be very honest, I much prefer European sources like Viking sword, arming sword, long
sword, rapier, anything like that, to the katana, so you could say that I'm slightly
biased against the katana, but I have tried to stay as objective, fair and evidence-based
as possible, so there's not any bias in the video.
So finally, let's get started.
So the first important aspect of the katana is that it is differentially harmed.
Usually, swords will be through-hardened, meaning that the hardness will be of the same
level on the entire blade.
Differential hardening basically means that certain sections of the blade will be harder
than others.
So, for example, the edge is harder than the spine, and the idea behind this is that you
don't need a very hard spine, you only need the edge to be very, very hard, and the problem
is that if you have a very, very hard edge, it is going to be brittle, and therefore you're
going to have a softer spine to compensate for the brittleness of the edge.
The problem is that if we take a through-hardened sword, the sword will flex under pressure
and then will go back to its original shape after the pressure is released.
Now, obviously, it can still bend if it goes over the plastic deformation threshold of
the steel, and it can obviously still snap, but it will flex back more easily than a differentially
hardened sword, because the problem is that the plastic deformation threshold of the soft
steel used in the spine is actually lower, meaning that if you actually hit something
hard with the sword, it bends, then it will actually have a higher chance to stay bent
rather than flex back.
On top of that, since the edge is harder, it will chip more easily because it is more brittle.
Now, obviously, with differential hardening, you have the advantage that you have better
edge retention on your blade.
Now, we'll come back to edge retention later.
And I also want to add that differential hardening is not unique to the katana or to any other
Japanese sword.
Contrary to what some people claim, Europeans, for example, are also perfectly well new of
differential hardening.
Now, to be fair, they have a slightly different way of doing it.
When you differentially harden a katana, it is usually going to be done in two steps.
The first of those steps is actually going to be the composite construction, meaning
that you are going to forge weld hard and soft steel together, the hard steel for the
edge and the soft steel for the spine.
And the second step is going to be during the quenching, meaning when you dip the sword
into oil or water to actually make it hard because of the sudden temperature change.
And during the quenching, the katana would actually be covered in a layer of clay, which
would be thicker around the spine, and that would act as an insulator and prevent that
spine from actually cooling down that fast, meaning it wouldn't get so hot.
What Europeans usually did was to actually only use the composite construction phase
of the entire differential hardening, meaning that they would use hard steel for the edge
and soft steel for the rest, and they would forge weld these two pieces of steel together,
but they would not go through the extra step of differentially hardening the sword during
the quench.
The sword would actually be quenched without any protection, because they actually wanted
maximum hardness out of the soft steel, even though it was only softer steel.
The Japanese actually purposefully made the spine softer.
So for example, that was incredibly common to do on axes, because you don't need to have
all of this section made out of good quality steel, because it just is the head, you're
not going to sharpen it to any level at all.
Only the edge itself needs to be hard, meaning that you're actually going to make this part
out of softer, worse steel, maybe even iron, and then you're going to forge weld the hard
edge to the head.
And that way of making things is usually called a composite construction, but it is incredibly
similar in use to differential hardening.
On top of that, it was also sometimes used for swords.
Vikings, especially, actually had a lot of differentially hardened or composite constructed
swords.
Essentially, they would have the core of the sword made out of worse quality steel, and
would forge weld better quality steel to the edges and point, because that's actually where
you primarily need it.
However, it's important to note that they did not do this because it made the sword
better, they did this because they lacked good steel.
Because Scandinavia was relatively poor in good quality steel, obviously today Sweden
is actually relatively rich in good steel, but they didn't have the technology to actually
extract that steel during the Viking Age, so they actually had to use more lower quality
steel.
And towards the end of the Viking Age, the composite constructed swords became less common
because they actually had more access to better steel through trading, and also to a certain
degree through raiding, so they could actually afford to make the entire blade out of good
steel, which was better, because through hardened swords are actually better.
And then we also have bronze sword.
Now, bronze is absolutely not the same material as steel, but bronze swords are actually,
to a certain degree, differentially hardened, because obviously they are not quenched in
oil or water or anything like that to make them hard, they actually work hard, meaning
that you're actually going to hammer on the bronze to make it harder, basically by compressing
it.
And that was only done on the edge and point of the bronze sword, it was unnecessary to
do on the core, so essentially bronze swords are differentially hardened.
The next important aspect of the katana is the folding.
Basically, when you have your billet of steel, you will actually forge it out and then bend
it back together, and then repeat that process again and again.
It's essentially the same principle as when you knead bread, you're actually going to
press it down, then fold it back together, press it down, and so on.
And the idea with this is to actually spread all the impurities that might be in the steel
to actually have a more homogeneous steel, because obviously if you have a certain piece
of steel and you have a big impurity right in the center of it, it will actually create
a massive weak spot in the finished sword, because you have a big impurity in there.
That way, by actually flattening, folding, flattening, folding, and so on, you're spreading
that impurity out, meaning that you don't have such a weak spot on the finished blade.
Now, the average amount of folds in a katana is in between 10 and 15, so essentially fold
the steel in between 10 and 15 times.
And that makes you a total of layers of in between 1,024 layers for the 10 folds, and
32,768 layers for the 15 folds, because obviously when you're folding it once, you're essentially
doubling the amount of layers.
Now, you do have some katanas that go up to 27 folds, which is equal to 134,217,728 layers,
so some katanas have an insane amount of folds in them.
Now, usually the ideal amount of folds is 13 folds, which is equal to 8,192 folds, because
obviously, the more folds you have, the more you'll spread the impurities out, and the
better it is.
But if you fold it too much, you're actually losing a certain amount of carbon contained
in the steel with each fold, so if you fold it too much, you're actually going to lose
a lot of the carbon, which is obviously not ideal.
On top of that, when you're actually putting the steel together again, there is a chance
that certain impurities actually get trapped in between there when you are folding, so
you can essentially end up with more impurities in the steel if you fold it too much.
And usually you can see the folds of the steel on the blade, you have all of these wavy lines
that are actually the folds.
Now obviously, folding steel sounds like a genius idea.
The problem is that it only is a genius idea when you have low quality steel with a lot
of impurities in it, because of course, if you have a completely pure steel, of course
you'll usually not have a completely pure steel, but let's admit you had, you wouldn't
spread any impurities out by folding it, because there are no impurities in there, so you would
basically only lose a certain carbon content, and have a chance of actually getting impurities
in there with each fold.
And this means that with a good quality steel, with a low amount of impurities, it is actually
better to not fold the steel.
But of course, if you have bad quality steel, then yes, it is an advantage to fold the steel.
And the truth is that the katana did have a relatively low quality steel.
The steel used to make the katana comes from iron sand, so basically sand rich in iron.
And the fact is that they are actually extracting the iron from the sand in a bloomery forge
by heating it up to a very high temperature and not entirely smelting it, because then
you would end up with cast iron, but to a very high temperature, so the iron actually
sinks to the bottom.
The problem is that you actually end up with a lot of impurities in your steel when you
do that.
So the katana is made of a steel with a lot of impurities, therefore it is an advantage
to actually fold it.
But that folded steel is still worse than a very simple good quality steel.
It just improves slightly the quality of the steel.
And I may also add that, again, this is not unique to the katana or to any other Japanese
sword.
Again, if we come back to the Vikings, they very often had a similar system used on their
sword.
Now it's not exactly the same because they are not actually folding the steel on itself,
they are actually folding it out into a longer billet that they are cutting up in pieces,
stacking on top of each other, and then forge welding back together.
But the core idea is the same and the result is the same, you are spreading out the impurities.
And that was very, very often done on that lower quality steel that was used on the core
of the blades.
And that is why a lot of Viking swords will be pattern-welded, basically meaning you will
have all of these waves in the steel of the sword, in the center of the sword, but not
in the edges or point, because those are actually made out of better steel that doesn't need
to be folded any sort of way.
And obviously I mentioned the Vikings doing that on their swords, but it was also done
earlier in history.
For example, the Romans sometimes pattern-welded their gladi, at least the late gladi, and
quite commonly pattern-welded their sparthae.
So again, it's not unique to the katana or to Japan.
Now we need to discuss the sharpness and cutting ability of the katana, because this is one
of the main things it is praised for, the fact that it supposedly can cut incredibly
well.
Now the idea is that the katana has a harder edge, which allows it to be sharper.
However, that is not entirely true.
The harder edge can improve edge retention, meaning the capacity to keep a sharp edge,
but it doesn't allow you to sharpen the sword to a higher level of sharpness.
In actual fact, even bronze can be sharpened to the same level as the steel used in katana.
It doesn't have anything to do with the hardness of the steel, it's only the edge retention
that matters.
And obviously the edge retention of bronze swords, if they are sharpened to the same
level as a katana, will be incredibly bad because they are so soft.
But you can sharpen any sword to the same level as a katana.
Not only that, but some swords will actually be easier to sharpen to an as high degree
as the katana than the katana itself, because they are softer.
And paradoxically, that makes it easier to sharpen the sword.
You cannot sharpen it to a higher or lower level, but it's easier to sharpen a softer
sword, because for each pass on the grinding stone, you're actually going to be able
to remove more material, because the material is softer.
So the hard edge only changes edge retention.
The main thing that matters for how well a sword can cut is the edge geometry.
So you will have all sorts of different bevels.
A bevel more optimized for cutting will be a straighter bevel, or even incurved a little
bit like this.
But some bevels will also be convex like this, if they want to be tougher.
That is the case, for example, on axes.
Axes will usually have a bit of a convex bevel, because they need to be tougher, not really
sharp.
Having an incredibly sharp axe doesn't matter to the same degree as having an axe with actually
a tough edge.
So the kind of bevel you're using changes how well the sword can cut, but also the angle
of the bevel.
Because obviously I might have a flat bevel, but if the angle is like this, I will not
cut as well as a sword with an angle like this, because the thinner the angle, the easier
the sword will cut.
And obviously, if the angle is wider like this, it means that the edge will be tougher.
But that doesn't really matter for cutting performances alone.
And the katana does have an edge relatively optimized for cutting, because it does have
a relatively steep angle, meaning that, at least in the examples I could find, the angle
will be in between 12 and 18 degrees per side, while on something like a longsword, they
will usually be in between 15 and 22 degrees, again, per side, and again, on the examples
I could find.
But there are swords with similar or steeper angles than the katana.
For example, a cavalry saber is relatively similar to the katana, with an edge angle
of in between 12 and 20 degrees.
But some swords, like the shamshir, will be even better.
The shamshir has in between 10 and 15 degrees on each side.
So in terms of edge geometry, something like a shamshir is better at cutting than the katana.
But yes, the katana does have a very hard edge.
On the examples I could find, the hardness usually ranges from in between 58 and 67 units
on the Rockwell hardness scale.
As a comparison, a longsword would usually sit in between 43 and 52 units on that same
scale.
And a cavalry saber would be approximately in between 45 and 52 on that same scale.
So yes, the katana has a harder edge than other swords, meaning it will have a better
edge retention than other swords.
I did not find any sword with a higher level of hardness than the katana.
It might exist, but I did not find any personally.
Then you also have the fact that a katana is a curved sword.
And as I explained in the video about the leaf-shaped sword, a curve can indeed help
you when you are cutting, because it accompanies the slicing movement better, and also concentrates
the force on a smaller surface because of that curve.
If this is my target and it's flat, and I have a flat edge, which is my hand like this,
and I hit, the force I put into the swing is going to get spread out on the entirety
of the blade.
But if I have a curved sword, so for example you can use this part of my hand to illustrate
that, I'm concentrating the force on a smaller surface, meaning that yes, I will be able
to cut more easily.
On top of that, it also makes it easier to keep a good edge alignment when you are cutting.
Edge alignment being your capacity to actually keep the blade straight when you're cutting,
because obviously if I cut like this, I will be able to cut relatively easily.
But if I come in at an angle like this, I will be much less capable of cutting.
And a curve will actually help you keep that good edge alignment.
However, I did not find any study whatsoever exploring specifically the curve of a katana.
And knowing the curve isn't very pronounced, the effects of having a curve would probably
be relatively limited for a katana.
And again, it is not unique to the katana, nor to any other Japanese sword.
A lot of other swords will have a curve in them.
The katana has a curve ranging from in between 1.4 and 2.8 centimeters off center, generally
speaking, which is relatively similar to something like a European Kriegsmesser.
Now to be fair, I did not find any data on how curved a Kriegsmesser is, and there is
a lot of difference between different Kriegsmessers, but if you look at the blades side to side,
you can see it is relatively similar.
And you will even have some swords with a more pronounced curve than the katana.
For example, if we take the British 1796 Light Cavalry Saber, it is described as having a
point diverging almost 3 inches, which is approximately 7.6 centimeters, from the straight.
So, way more curved than the katana.
And also, if we take some swords like the Shamshir, it will have a curve that is even
more pronounced than the one of a cavalry saber.
So now that we've gone through the basics of the katana's blade, let's look at some
impressive performances of the katana.
Because the katana is known for doing a lot of impressive things.
For example, cutting bullets in half.
There is one guy called Isao Machi, probably pronounced that wrong, that is actually known
for having chopped a bullet in half while it was flying through the air.
Now to be fair, that was a BB pellet, not exactly a bullet.
And to be fair, it doesn't really have anything to do with the sword itself.
Obviously, it is incredibly impressive from a swordsman's point of view, but he could
most probably have done that with almost any sword, as long as it was relatively sharp.
Because any sword that is actually sharpened to a relatively high level, and that doesn't
have a big flaw in it, should be able to cut a bullet in half.
And now I'm talking about a proper, real bullet, not only about a BB pellet.
Forged in Fire, which is a TV show, actually sometimes uses that test to test a different
sword.
I've seen them done it with a katana, but also with a claymore and a cutlass.
And as far as I've seen, all swords have been able to actually cut the bullet in half,
because they were sharp enough, the edge alignment was good, and there wasn't any
particular flaw in the blade.
Now obviously, Forged in Fire, I am not considering it as a trustworthy sword at all, but they
were able to do it, so it still is an indication that it can be relatively easy to do.
Then you might also have seen some katanas actually chopping through sheet steel.
So basically you have a big sheet of mild steel that is braced, and you have some guys
actually chopping the sheet in half with a katana.
Now obviously that looks incredibly impressive for a sword to be able to do that, because
you're essentially cutting through steel.
But the truth is that it's actually not impressive, it's actually a fairly easy thing to do, as
long as the blade is not flawed in any particular way.
For example, a guy who has a YouTube channel called Thanganthrand actually chopped through
a sheet of mild steel with a bronze sword that he states is historically accurate.
And obviously that one test on that one YouTube channel is not trustworthy in any sort of
way, especially because at least the dimensions of the sheet were smaller than the one of
the sheets cut by the katana, and I don't know exactly the specifications of that sheet
of steel, it might be softer or anything like that, I don't know.
But in any case, it shows that it can be incredibly easy for a sword to actually cut through sheet
steel, because he did it with a bronze sword.
So I think we can say fairly safely that it's not incredibly hard to do that with a sword.
So, there is nothing that proves that the katana is stronger than other swords like
the longsword, cavalry saber, or chamshur.
It might be stronger than some other swords like the viking swords with composite construction,
and obviously earlier swords made entirely out of lower quality steel, or even iron.
But the toughness is not an advantage of the katana.
The folding does make bad steel better, but it's only worth doing it on steel that's already
bad, and bad steel that is folded will usually not become as good as good steel that is not
folded.
Nothing proves that the katana can be sharpened to a higher level than any other sword, and
while it does have an edge geometry that is better for cutting than some other swords
like the longsword, it doesn't have an edge geometry that is as good at cutting as some
other swords like, for example, the cavalry saber or chamshur.
Having a curve on the blade does improve cutting abilities, but again, some other swords like
the cavalry saber or chamshur have a more pronounced curve that should theoretically
help them even more.
So, staying 100% objective, we have no reason to believe that the katana is any better at
cutting or any tougher than some swords like the cavalry saber or chamshur.
It does have the advantage that it has a hotter edge, meaning that it has a better edge retention,
but again, we'll come back to that later.
So, we have now looked at the metallurgy and cutting ability aspects of the katana, but
now let's look at the overall design of the sword, because the design is a big factor
to how easy you will actually be able to hit with the sword, and obviously, the sword can
be the best sword ever at cutting, but if you're not able to hit your opponent, then
it doesn't matter because you're not hitting him.
So, let's start with the curvature, because of course, we have just seen how it changes
the cutting abilities of the katana, but it also has an effect of how you use the sword.
Some people claim that it makes the sword easier to draw faster, draw from the scabbard,
you can theoretically do it faster because of the curve, it follows through the movement
better.
Now, I have found no evidence that this is true, no study actually testing if you can
draw a katana faster, but generally speaking, the people who handle both katanas and other
swords tend to say that you can actually draw the katana faster.
The katana is also very well known for draw cuts, meaning, well, not when you take your
sword towards your opponent and pull to cut, but when you have the sword in the scabbard
and pull it out and cut in one motion.
So basically, you pull it out and then extend and cut in one motion.
So, knowing that this is a big thing around the katana, it does make sense for it to be
good at actually being drawn fast, because that allows you to do that draw cut more easily.
So, I have no evidence this is true, but it likely is.
The problem with having a curve on your sword is that it makes it worse at thrusting, and
obviously the katana is definitely not a good thrusting sword, and a part of the reason
for that is because of the curve, because obviously if you grab something like a long
sword, the point is right behind the handle, meaning that when you push on the handle,
you can actually transfer the energy directly through the blade into the point.
When you have a curve, you are actually having to transfer that energy through a curve into
the target, which means you're probably just going to end up losing a lot of the energy.
Let's now talk about the hilt of the katana, and the first thing we can notice very, very
clearly is that the handle is incredibly long compared to some other swords.
So, the handle would usually range from in between 25 and 30 centimetres, roughly.
Obviously, there might be some exceptions, but that is a general true number.
Now, the good thing about this is that you get much more leverage on your sword.
This long sword right here actually has a very, very long handle, probably not entirely
historical, but it has an incredibly long handle, but I'm just going to use this to
illustrate.
When you can hold your hand all the way up to the guard and all the way down to the bottom,
you can actually have much more leverage on your sword than when you have to hold your
more tightly together like this.
Let's now talk about the guard of the katana.
Now, the guard of the katana is usually called a tsuba, and it is very different from most
European swords.
European swords from around this era will usually have a crossguard, meaning a guard
like this, which is basically just a bar that you will use as a guard, and as you can see,
it is rather long.
Now, you do have tons of other different designs.
Obviously, some European swords, especially earlier ones, will not have such a long guard,
and obviously, some later swords will have a basket tilt or something like that to actually
offer even more protection, but generally speaking, for European swords, a crossguard
is rather common.
Now, the tsuba, meaning the guard of the katana, is basically a disc that will separate the
blade from the handle, and the problem with that is that it will offer much less protection
than something like a big crossguard, because obviously, this extends much further out.
When you have only a small disc, you can actually relatively easily hit beside it on the arm
or something like that.
It doesn't offer as much protection, and also, to a certain degree, you can slide off the
disc and actually hit the hand of the person wielding the katana.
Now, obviously, you can still perfectly well prevent a lot of blades from hitting your
with the tsuba, but generally speaking, it is slightly worse than the guard of a long
sword.
Then we have the length of the katana, because obviously, we saw that the handle was really
long, in between 25 and 30 centimetres, but the blade is actually quite short.
Usually, it will range from in between 60 and 73 centimetres as a rough average, meaning
that the total length of the entire katana will be of in between 87 and 107 centimetres
when we include the two centimetres for the guard and different fittings.
Now, obviously, this means that it is shorter than some swords like the long sword, the
long sword usually being in between 111 and 128 centimetres as a rough average, or indeed
as something like the rapier, which is usually in between 105 and 125 centimetres, with some
examples going up to 140 centimetres, and it is relatively similar in length to something
like a shamshur, which will usually range from in between 88 and 93 centimetres, a cavalry
sabre, which will usually range from between 100 and 104 centimetres, with some examples
going up to 107, a viking sword ranging from 85 to 95 centimetres on average, or an arming
sword that ranges from 90 to 105 centimetres on average.
Now, obviously, all of these numbers I gave right here are very rough, and there will
be some examples that are slightly longer or slightly shorter than these examples, meaning
that, generally speaking, the katana is approximately as long as an average one-handed sword.
Now, the good thing about this is that the katana will usually be easier to carry around
than some other swords like, for example, a long sword or rapier.
The bad thing about this is that if you do end up fighting with your katana, it will
actually have less range than some other swords like the long sword, especially because a
lot of the length of the katana comes from the handle itself.
As I said, the handle is in between 25 and 30 centimetres long, and obviously, you generally
speaking, hold your hands relatively close to the guard, meaning that you will actually
have a lot of unused space at the back, which is not actually going to add more range.
Now, the katana is traditionally used in two hands, but you can also use it in one hand.
It works perfectly fine.
Now, the good thing about actually having the option to change them in between both
is that when you actually want to deliver a powerful strike, you can actually deliver
it with two hands for extra power, but when you want more reach, for example, you can
use the sword in one hand, because for the same length of sword, you're actually getting
more reach if you're using the sword in one hand.
If I just stand like this without bending forward or anything like that, I'm just staying
straight with the centre of my body right here, then the sword will have a certain range.
Now, look at the crossguard to actually have an idea of how much range I actually have.
Now, you can see it is between the shield and the mail shirt in the background.
If I keep the centre of my body in the exact same position, but actually grab the sword
in two hands, as you can see, the guard has now reversed and I have lost a little bit
of range of the sword.
As you can see, it is now in the middle of the mail shirt in the background, and this
is because when I hold the sword in one hand, I am actually getting some reach from basically
half my body being used as extra reach.
When I'm grabbing the sword in two hands, I suddenly cannot use that part of my body
for extra reach.
Basically, this entire part of my body is used as extra range that I can actually use
but once I switch to two hands, I can only use my arms as extra range.
So actually, switching to a one-handed grip in certain situations can be good.
That being said, you can also switch to a one-handed grip with other swords like the
longsword, even though the longsword is heavier.
Especially if you're just considering a quick strike in which you need maximum range, you
can actually pretty easily just use one hand for that one movement.
Now, the problem is that, well, the katana has a relatively average weight for a sword
of its size, meaning it's usually going to sit in between 0.9 and 1.4 kilograms.
The heaviest katanas will be heavier than some one-handed swords, the average one-handed
sword, but generally speaking, you're talking about approximately the same weight.
The problem is that the point of balance of the katana will be much farther in front on
the blade.
So generally speaking, the point of balance of the katana is in between 10 and 16 centimeters
in front of the guard.
And this is partly because the katana has no pommel and also partly because the blade
is rather thick.
Now, this means that if you use a katana in one hand, it is going to be slightly less
nimble than some other dedicated one-handed swords.
For example, a shamshur is usually in between 0.7 and 0.8 kilograms, with some example going
down to 496.1 gram, I have seen, for a point of balance of in between 13 and 18 centimeters
in front of the guard.
And a cavalry saber will be in between 0.7 and 1 kilograms in weight and have a point
of balance of in between 14.5 and 19 centimeters from the heel.
That being said, a katana, or at least lighter katanas, will probably be about as nimble
as something like a viking sword.
Because viking swords will usually be in between 950 grams and 1.1 kilograms, with a point
of balance of in between 12 and 18 centimeters from the guard.
So the katana can absolutely be used in one hand effectively, it just won't be as nimble
as some other lighter one-handed swords.
Then we also have the fact that the katana only has one edge.
Something like the longsword will have two edges, one on each side of the blade.
And the problem with this is that the katana cannot perform as wide of a range of attacks
as something like a longsword, because a longsword can do reverse edge cuts, for example.
Meaning that if I come down in a cut like this, I can actually just pull my blade back
up again to perform another cut.
Either to actually perform two cuts, or if I miss the first strike, then I can actually
come back up with another strike with reverse edge.
That cannot be done with a katana.
Now, to be fair, it doesn't matter too much, because you don't need to do a reverse edge
cut.
You can basically just turn your sword around.
So basically, if I come into a cut like this, instead of just going the same way back up,
I can actually just hit like this, then turn around like this, and actually hit with the
same edge.
That works perfectly fine, but it takes a little bit more time, and it means you cannot
perform such a wide range of attacks.
Now, I just want to come back on edge retention, because, as I said, the edge retention of
the katana is really good, because the edge is so hard.
So, for example, if we have an object that the katana can cut, let's say, a thousand
times before getting dull, if we grab something like an average longsword, it will probably
only be able to cut it like 600 to 800 times before getting dull.
Now, these numbers are only illustrative, and the scale might not be entirely correct,
but generally speaking, it's probably true that if a katana cuts something a thousand
times before getting dull, the longsword will probably be able to do it around 600 to 800
times.
But again, I'm just using these numbers as an illustration to illustrate the point,
because it is important to remember that you might only be able to cut that one object
600 to 800 times with your longsword, but you have two edges on your longsword, meaning
that once you've cut it 600 to 800 times, you can actually flip your sword around and
cut it 600 to 800 more times because you have another edge, meaning you get a total amount
of cuts of in between 1200 and 1600.
Now, again, these are only illustrative numbers, but it is important to remember that even
though the katana has a very good edge retention for a particular section of the edge, it doesn't
mean that it will actually be able to retain its edge for longer when you consider the
entirety of the blade, because it only has one edge.
Now, anyways, let's go back to the design of the katana, because the ultimate question
really is how efficient is it to fight with in a duel, for example.
And to be fair, I have found no study, trustworthy study, actually testing how good a katana
is in a duel compared to something like a longsword or any other sword.
I've only seen some people actually testing it on YouTube, for example, and usually the
results are that the katana is worse in a duel than something like a longsword or something
like a cavalry saber.
And while I do believe that the katana is worse in a duel than either a longsword or
a cavalry saber, it is important to remember that, first of all, there might be some people
I haven't seen tests of that are getting other results.
And also, very important to remember, the test might be slightly biased, not because
the people are not trying to find out the truth, but simply because they are usually
mostly trained in HEMA, so historical European martial arts, with longswords, not in actually
using a katana most of the time.
Obviously, some of them are, but generally speaking, they are not trained with a katana
as much as with a longsword, because the two swords are relatively different to fight with.
There are all sorts of different techniques that you're going to use with a katana, but
not with a longsword, and opposites.
For example, I spoke about reverse edge cuts, but you also have some techniques in just
how you perform a cut that will be different from HEMA to Kendo, Kendo being the Japanese
martial art for actually fighting with swords.
Generally speaking, what you're going to do with a European sword is that you're going
to leverage your hands around one center to effectively deliver power with both of your
hand for your strike.
With a katana, this is slightly different.
What you're actually going to do is focus more on the lower, meaning, in most cases,
the left hand.
So a cut, instead of looking like this, it will look more like this.
So essentially, you're drawing your lower hand backwards to actually leverage the sword
instead of both pushing and pulling.
Generally speaking, that is going to be true.
And you obviously have tons of other differences that you're just using a katana in a different
way, and obviously, if you're not used to it, you might get a slight disadvantage when
you're using a katana.
So even though I have seen a lot of people actually testing it and ending up finding
out that the katana is worse in a duel than something like a longsword, I cannot and will
not confirm anything without a trustworthy source to back it up, because there might
be all sorts of biases in these less trustworthy sources.
Now, I have also seen some other people claim that the katana is better in close-quarter
combat than the longsword, meaning that when you're actually fighting closer to each
other, the katana is better.
Now, to be honest, I believe this is completely wrong, because they are only considering the
blade, but they're also not considering half-swording.
Because what you are very, very commonly going to do with a longsword is to half-sword it,
meaning you're going to grab the blade with a hand that has a gauntlet, so you can
actually leverage the sword around, essentially shortening the range for wrestling.
And obviously, you could do this with a katana too, but the problem is that there is much
less purpose in doing this with a katana, because a katana is worse at thrusting, and
when you are half-swording, you're essentially losing all ability to chop or cut, because
you're holding your hand on the blade.
So the damage a katana is going to deliver in a half-sword is going to be much worse
than the damage a longsword is going to deliver, because the longsword is very thrust-focused.
And also, you can use the guard and pommel, this particular sword doesn't have a pommel,
that's not historical, and this is only a training sword, but you can use the guard
and pommel to strike with.
So for example, if my opponent is very close to me, let's say my arm here is my opponent,
I can actually use the guard of the sword to actually hit him with.
And I can also pommel him with the pommel of the sword.
And on top of that, you also have some techniques which include holding both hands on the blade
of the sword, and actually using the guard as a sort of hammer, like this.
Now this is especially when you're fighting against armor, but still, you can definitely
use the crossguard when you're fighting in close combat.
A katana does not have a proper pommel, so if you try to hit with the back of the handle,
you essentially only hit with the back of the handle, not with a proper pommel, so there
will be less effect from such an attack.
And also, the guard isn't as good for actually hitting with as a crossguard.
Now again, I have no evidence that the katana is either worse or better in close quarter
combat.
I believe that the katana is worse in close quarter combat, but that is only my personal
opinion.
I have no trustworthy source to back it up or anything like that, so I will not conclude
with anything.
Now an interesting side note is that when Japan modernized its army in the 19th century,
military swords called the Gunto were introduced.
Some of these used European-style saber hilts, and some older Japanese blades were attached
to those new hilts.
Now, part of the reason why this was done was for the sword to fit better with the new
military uniform.
However, one could imagine that the European saber hilt was better than the older katana
hilt.
Now, I have no trustworthy evidence for this, so I won't state it as a fact, but it still
is interesting.
Also, European swords like the rapier or some Japanese-made European-style swords were used
in Japan from the mid-16th century onwards.
And this can lead us to believe that those European-style swords were better, at least
for certain things.
But again, I have no strong evidence for this, so I will not state it as a fact.
Now, all of this being said, it is still important to remember that the katana and all the different
choices made in the katana can still make sense within the specific context of how and
when it was used.
For example, the Japanese relied heavily on iron sand for the steel of their swords,
and their smelting method did not allow them to obtain very pure steel, and this means
that one cannot afford to make a sword entirely out of good quality steel.
It was also mostly designed to be used against unarmoured or lightly armoured targets.
Obviously, it was also used against heavily armoured targets, but that was less common,
meaning it did not need to be very thrust-focused, it did not need to be any good at penetrating
armour.
And on top of that, also very important to remember, it is a secondary weapon, not a
primary weapon, meaning that having something like an impractical big guard can actually
be impractical when you have it in the belt and actually are trying to fight with it.
Same goes for the length of the entire blade.
Having a very, very long sword can be impractical.
Now, obviously, the long sword was primarily a secondary weapon too, but still, for a katana,
it can be more worth it to not have these large guards or being so long, because it's
easier to carry around with you.
So the fact is that, obviously, it could have been improved and improved rather easily,
simply by using better steel, simply by adding crossguard weight to it, for example, but
the problem is that it wasn't necessarily worth it or possible to do it, because they
didn't have the materials to do it.
And also, the sword was never required to be better.
It was good enough.
So, in the end, the katana is definitely not the best sword ever made, but it does have
certain strengths.
For example, edge retention for one specific area of the edge can actually be better than
on other swords, because the sword has a harder edge.
Now, obviously, you do have the caveat that I mentioned with the fact that it only has
one edge, and therefore, once the edge is dull, the entire sword is dull, which is not
necessarily the case on the longsword, but generally speaking, for one area, the edge
retention is better.
Then you also have the fact that it might be easier or faster to draw the sword from
the scabbard than some other swords.
Now, again, this is only based off what certain people are saying, and they're usually saying
it when they are comparing a katana to a longsword.
So, obviously, they're not taking into account other swords that might be even easier to
draw from the scabbard, but generally speaking, I think we can say that the katana is relatively
easy to draw from the scabbard.
And then you also have the ease of use, because, well, first of all, it is a two-handed sword,
and two-handed swords are, generally speaking, easier for beginners to actually handle, because
getting things like edge alignment right is easier, and also putting more power into the
sword is easier.
And you also have the fact that it is a curved sword, and curved swords are, generally speaking,
more forgiving for bad edge alignment.
They would actually correct themselves more easily.
And I have seen a lot of people who actually are familiar with both katana and other swords
who actually claim that the katana is easier to use.
Now, obviously, some other swords, like, for example, the Karu Saber or the Shamsher, are
also curved, so that should also help them, but then they are not two-handed.
But then something like the Kriegsmaser is both curved and is two-handed, so maybe it
is as easy to cut with as a katana.
I don't exactly know, I have just seen some people claim that the katana is a relatively
easy sword to use, because of those different factors.
But I cannot be sure it's true, and I have no evidence that it is true, it's just something
that I have heard other people say.
So those three things, edge retention, ease of drawing, and ease of use, are the three
things to which the katana might be the best, but again, I have no strong evidence proving,
at least for the last two, that it actually is.
But for other things, like, for example, toughness, cutting ability, thrusting ability especially,
and all other things, there is always a sword that is actually better at that one specific
thing than the katana.
However, the katana does make sense, at least to a certain degree, considering the limitations
due to the environment and the materials.
It's also important to remember that it was a secondary weapon, meaning it didn't need
to be incredibly good to fight with, because people usually fought with polearms in melee
instead of swords.
Longswords, for example, actually had to be good both against unarmoured and armoured
opponents, heavily armoured opponents, they needed to be good against all sorts of different
armours, different weapons, different fighting techniques, because Europeans fought against
a lot of different foraging cultures too, so the longsword had to evolve and had to
be constantly better to actually not be useless.
So, in the end, the katana is not a universal weapon, but the best that could be done at
that time with the materials available for that one specific task it was designed to
do.
Anyways, this video has been a very, very long one, but I thought it was worth to actually
go very, very deeply into this subject with all sorts of evidence and so on, to actually
go deeply into every single subject about the katana, because videos about the katana
will usually tend to not go very, very far into the subject, which is also fine, but
it can tend to leave the problem unsolved.
Anyways, as I said, I will leave links to all the sources, or at least all the sources
that I should remember to save, in the description, so if you want to go and actually fact-check
everything, you can.
Anyways, hope you enjoyed the video, and I'll see you in the next one.
