Katana vs Longsword Definitive Guide with Skallagrim

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
1 Video View·Jul 1, 2026
Katana vs Longswords is the original and most iconic East vs West debate in the online arms and armor community. Today @Skallagrim and I are going to settle this once and for all by offering the most all-encompassing and nuanced takes on a number of factors.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video provides a technical and historical comparison between the Japanese katana and the European longsword. Rather than declaring a winner, experts analyze how differences in blade geometry, reach, and mass distribution affect performance across various combat scenarios, environmental constraints, and cultural contexts.
Katana vs. Longsword, the internet's darling child of the East vs. West debate.
Who else better to settle this with than Skullogram, the original YouTuber himself?
During Skullogram's visit to Vancouver, we engaged in a number of debates and discussions on various
topics at my place, but also at the premier historical European martial arts club in
So stay tuned for a new series of videos featuring extensive test cutting and showcases by
practitioners, instructors, and scholars there. Today, Skull and I are going to attempt to put
this debate to bed. We're going to offer the most conclusive and nuanced takes on a number of
factors in the Longsword vs. Katana debate. That includes the most obvious one that pretty much
everybody has observed, the reach between the two. There is a massive caveat there,
so stay tuned. And also cross guard, and later complex hilt guard, versus the Tsuba,
the discard on Asian swords. The slight curvature observed on most katana,
and obviously being double edged and straight on longswords, which is the definition.
And there are a few important additional points that have been neglected or at least overlooked
by other commentators on the internet in the past regarding this debate.
First, a disclaimer. We appreciate the craftsmanship and artistry that go into both
types of these swords. We're not arguing about the genuine superiority of either of these swords,
or by extension the cultures that are making them. That's simply not the belief we hold
or the thought process we practice. However, it is demonstrably true that in many martial
related circumstances, one holds a definitive edge over the other. But in some other cases
that many have overlooked over the years, the advantage or disadvantage are pretty much reversed.
Also, there's the other elephant in the room we have to address. Using Japanese swords only to
represent the entire continent of Asia's sword making and martial traditions is simply not a
fair fight up against longswords, which is basically made throughout Europe. So prior to
engaging in this popular juxtaposition, we have compared pairs that are perhaps more appropriate
in the martial context that are Quicksmaster vs Katana and Longswords vs Chinese Changjian.
So check out those videos first, but today we're definitely going to entertain the idea of Katana
vs Longswords.
Right, so it's very closely associated with knights or samurai. Interestingly,
they're pretty much the same role. They're retainers for aristocrats. You've got to
insert a call. That's the core of the knightly or samurai code. The other things are idealized,
later additions. So there's, I guess, a lot of comparison to be had, but it just speaks to,
you know, how they're used differently. It's a vast distinction. There's some overlap, of course.
They're both swords used with two hands. They're not extremely different in size, you know, like
compared to other options. And of course, again, a lot of the basics apply, you know, like footwork.
In fact, footwork is reasonably similar from what I've seen between Ima and Kenjutsu. There are
differences, but you could definitely draw a comparison. So if you had a knight and a samurai
and they were to swap weapons, it would be awkward for them. They would still know how to fight with
a sword, obviously. So there would be that similarity, but then it would be a little bit
off. I mean, I remember the video by Seki Sensei where he complained about the guard getting so
close to his head because, yeah, of course, you know, you're not used to it because there is
nothing sticking out that far. So you're not going to hit yourself in the forearm with the suba or in
the head or whatever, which is the same. It's easy to do with that when you're not used to it. In
fact, in fact, even when you're used to it, in a careless moment, you can still knock yourself in
the head with it, you know, potentially. So yeah, it would be awkward in that sense. For reference,
this long sword guard seemed to offer a lot of protection, projecting such a long bar
across the hand and the wrist. And in some angles, it can offer very adequate protection.
In other angles, surprisingly, they offer very little. Now, in contrast, this suba, especially
the smaller ones, doesn't seem to offer a lot of protection for your wrist. But when you are
fighting, holding the sword at an angle, they offer a surprisingly helpful amount of
sight protection. As you can see, you can stop the blow at a certain angle from reaching your hand,
especially if you're holding it downward a little bit, not immediately press against the suba.
You have to consider Japanese swords are backwardly curved, so that prevents the foible
of the blade from reaching your hand. Of course, Japanese sword subas can vary in their sizes
and geometries that produce quite a bit of difference in terms of hand protection.
Of course, you have a renaissance long swords that offer not just these quillons, but also
complex hilt components such as side rings, forward projecting rings and swept hilt bars.
Those definitely offer a lot more protection to your hand and wrist and forearm than these
simple quillons. So if we just compare the stereotypical medieval long swords with Japanese
suba, you can see their protection is actually neck and neck, not really that far apart.
In some cases, this long quillon will offer some more protection from blows beneath you or
above your blade. In other cases, this side projection on the suba can protect your hand
from certain angles. So I would say neither of them have a definitive edge over the other.
The next topic we're going to talk about is the all-important reach,
or rather the difference in blade lengths. When we're on the topic of reach, there's some caveat
we have to address. Because the overwhelming majority of surviving examples of nihonto or
katana are short in the blade lengths. On average, they have somewhere between 26 inches to 28
inches. That can obviously be observed on perhaps more than 80% of the nihonto survived to this day.
However, there's a heavy caveat in there because many of these short-bladed Japanese swords were
shortened from longer, older swords. So when Japanese expected battle or intense skirmishes,
they tend to bring with them longer-bladed nihonto. If we examine the historical records
of the Akko Jiken, known in the West as the 47 Ronin Incident, when 47 samurai retainers
became masterless ronins after their liege lord Asano Takumi was attainted and ordered to commit
seppuku due to a spat with the rival lord Kira at the shogunate residence, these 47 ronins got
together to hatch a scheme for vigilante vendetta. When they stormed the residence of Kira, overwhelmed
his retinue of armed guards and forced him to commit suicide. After they achieved their goals,
they surrendered themselves and their arms to the shogunate authority. We have the detailed
measurements of these men's arms that they brought with them to the skirmish. And perhaps to many
surprise, the primary weapon, the katana they brought with them, has the average blade length
of 31 inches or 78 centimeters. Many of them have nagasa close to suishaku, which is about three
feet long, a lot longer than the typical uchi katana style Japanese swords. And this happened
in the beginning of the 18th century, which is way into the Edo period. In earlier times, when
heavy and frequent battles were expected, longer bladed Japanese swords were much more common.
To clarify our earlier point, reach for a long edged weapon
is not just the arc of the tip's movement, but a fan of the entire blade's trajectory when swung,
from the base to the tip. So this isn't just the deal of your tip cannot even reach me,
but I can chop your hand off, although that is important too. The area of the fan designates
both the defensive and offensive coverage. Can you notice the difference between the coverage
area of a long sword and a katana? And that difference is everything, you know, fair due in
open space. Depending on how the balance is, there's there's only so far up you can go for an
effective parry because otherwise it'll just blow through. So if you have more than the point at
which it stops being effective, it's also higher up. Usually it depends on the, of course, the blade
profile and the thickness, all of that. When you parry further away from your hand,
but you can't swing, it carries a little bit more tip speed over here. So you mean like an
active displacement, like cutting into it? Right. And also, you still have the entire
blade's mass behind it. So, I mean, the leverage works against you. Yeah. But then you gain some
speed. Yeah, yeah. So it's not really that bad. Only the static block. Yeah. It will really
become less effective if you parry over here. Yeah, absolutely. So I think the coverage is
what people usually ignore. And then if you just maybe pick up a shorter sword.
That's so katana. I like this one a lot, actually. It's kind of a very good,
I said, like, maybe I shouldn't even say compromised. This does definitely
seem like a powerful cutter, but one that's also good at thrusting. So it's a pretty pommel.
That's from the Zurich National Museum, right? The Fischl Hammann. It's pretty unique. I think
there are a few of them by the end of the 15th century. It's a really good pick by Peter Johnson.
Maybe just look at, if you want to look at the difference in the edge. This is how much
difference. And this is just a short longsword. It's not a long longsword. And you can just see.
So with the katana, it's not just where the tip can reach. It's where I'm able to even defend
myself. Yeah. You might be able to catch your opponent's blow over there with a longsword.
Here, you would just miss. Travel past that. It might hit you. So I think that that's what
most people ignore. It's not just, I can reach you. You cannot reach me, which is true. Important.
Especially if you're doing hand snipes. And with this, you're much more exposed.
It's always a liability that you have to cut with all extensive hand protection.
Yeah, this is quite a bit more to work with. And yeah, that's a good point that
you do gain more defensively as well. When it comes to offensive use, the difference can
sometimes shrink a little bit. Because if you have like a thicker blade, a stiffer blade in
particular, as well, you might be able to cut higher upwards. If you have a strong taper, then
you have to cut very low for it to be effective. You can still cut with the tip, but it's just not
going to do as much. It's not going to cut a scythe in half. You can cut off someone's finger.
Of course, either way, it's going to limit how much skill enters the body, shall we say. But
a tip cut, that would still do more than if you tried to cut all the way here. That wouldn't be
great. For sure. But you go a little lower. But just having a longer blade, I think the
psychological factor. Yeah, I would say so. If someone can reach you or their block covers or
parry or any swing covers more area, you psychologically have a different mindset.
Now you're reliable for, hey, I got to parry and come in to close distance. You always have to
charge in, be more aggressive, be more proactive. You're just, hey, I'm going to space out further
enough. You're losing that game because you're playing on their ground and they're always going
to win. Yeah, right. Exactly. And sure, some people are quite good at closing the gap and
are really good at grappling, etc. But it's dangerous. You enter the danger zone where
they can hit you, but you can't threaten them yet. And of course, whenever people argue, oh,
you just got to get in there. It seems like they're kind of imagining that the opponent is
just standing there. It's like if one of the things that you practice when practicing footwork is
keeping the same distance. So you see, oh, your opponent's taking a step forward.
All right, I'll take a step back. Just imagine in fighting games, how important zooming is.
Some people, some characters, they are really good at controlling the distance,
manage the distance. That's part of the game. But there are cases having a longer play becomes
liability. You find spaces. If I'm just turning around this corner or this door, it has a very
narrow opening and it's all just maybe staircase. Now suddenly having a shorter sword, even a
shorter one, like with something you can easily handle in one hand, this hanger, this briquette
is finally coming into play, right? That's why sailors use cutlass because you can't find spaces
when you use a long sword or two-handed sword. It's significantly difficult. You got stuck trying
to enter a door. Now in more open spaces, longer bladed swords have the advantage of utilising
reach and manage the distance. Close up distance quickly or sniping your opponent's arm or hand.
However, if you flip this dynamic, you have to fight in relatively confined spaces.
Even going through this doorway and you have limited widths to work with, especially if you
consider half the width for you to pass through, you don't have the clearance to use the sword
this long effectively. Now you have to shorten the reach by holding on to the sword with
half-sorting steps. Now you can see this is very difficult to manoeuvre. If someone suddenly shows
up around the corner, I may just bend on the door or the wall or get caught on the ceiling,
etc. with all these long projections, you know, the pommel grip and cross guard, not to mention
the blade. And suddenly, I'm in a grave disadvantage against someone with a knife or shorter sword.
Even with the door fully open, you see, now you're just banging over everything and you're
creating hindrance for yourself. And you have to be very careful how you want to approach this.
Something compact truly shines in this kind of situation. Now with a katana, you can also
half-sort it. And when you have to fight around the corner, this curvature will aid you. You can
jab around it. You also kind of, you know, retract it with your arms holding on to the sword.
You don't have to worry too much about the long sword. If I want to half-sort it like this,
see how much further back my arm has to be. And I just run the risk of banging on to
the door and other objects. Now, when the reach is equalized between katana and long swords,
if we consider primarily battlefield katana with long blades, the other factor creeps in. That is
the mass distribution difference between these two. The way Japanese swords are made cause the
upper portion of the blade or the foible carry far more mass in relation to the lower portion.
When compared to swords made in Europe, continental Asia, the Middle East, and the Indian
subcontinent. In addition to being that light, also has a significant distal taper. Now you can
see how it's thinner near the hilt and then thins out toward the point. You can see the balance
right here. And that makes this saber extremely nimble, like ridiculously so. You can very quickly
swing it around, change direction, you know, like feint and quickly attack another opening.
It's so, so easy to move this around. Takes very little effort. Perfect. When the blades are short
like Japanese swords and generally handled in two hands, this is less noticeable as the mass
is condensed and the leverage provided by the two-handed grip mitigates the clumsiness greatly.
When Japanese sword blades get longer to gain reach, the lack of responsiveness becomes far
more noticeable. Of course, when the blades on Japanese swords get longer, the base tend to get
wider and thicker. So proportionally, there is less mass overall on the upper portion comparing
to the short-bladed average katana. But it's still noticeably more tip-heavy comparing to
European swords and continental Asian swords. You can see here, when I compared a Chinese
Chengdao to a Japanese Nodachi with a Chinese School of Mantis martial arts practitioner,
we noticed that the Chinese two-handed Dao is far more responsive and even feels lighter despite
being quite a bit longer and actually heavier in weight by a full pound. Why? The much more
noticeable distal taper. Now this brings to the next topic, which is mass distribution.
But we deliberately pick a longer-bladed katana or Tachi because people tend to, when they compare
two kinds of sword, katana versus longsword, they're saying the katana is shorter, so we talk
about the coverage. Earlier, there's like a significant advantage for average longsword versus
average katana. But you have loads of Japanese swords, katanas, they're just longer.
And in a way, I'm kind of, now that I'm thinking about it, a katana does kind of feel more like a
longsword in that sense, based on what I just talked about with follow-through versus cutting
to a forward guard. With a katana, you do that just fine. So I guess it's more similar in that
sense. And again, the effective reach, the sweet spot on the blade is quite a bit higher on a
katana generally because it's broader and thicker and has more presence up there.
So depending on the longsword, especially when we look at something like the Prince Shippei,
you cut quite a bit lower. So the effective reach may not actually be much more there,
it may actually be somewhat similar to a katana if you cut a little bit higher up.
This, you have like a much greater region where you can be effective. If you cut even lower,
down here, it can still cut very well. If you cut over here, it'll be very well. This one here
can flex this much. If you cut near the tip, not only like leverage is working against you,
but also if you're just off by two degrees, it's going to flex around. The energy is going to be
dissipated along the entire blade. So it wouldn't cut this far.
Yeah, this can be more forgiving in that sense. You still have to control the edge alignment, but
if you mess it up, it's not going to just violently flex and just go all over the place.
Actually, that's kind of a funny thought because sometimes people make the argument that,
oh, a katana requires more skill to use.
I think Kunjuso, they focus on very streamlined parry and then very quick,
decisive cuts to end it very... Now, if you're talking about like a short blade katana,
it's even more like that because this is a kind of blade heavy, but when the blade is shorter.
So European swords benefits tremendously from having less mass here to make it nimble.
You can make longer swords very nimble, not so for katana. But katanas being short,
you're not just having less mass, you're having no mass past the tip. So they can be pretty quick
and nimble too because you have a compact sword. It's just different from a longer nimble sword
because longer one, you still have the momentum on the upper portions carrying your hand.
Whereas if you have a short sword, it's just like a stick. It's katana, shorter katanas feel more
like a stick than European long swords. Long swords or even these greater swords of war,
you can just even categorize them based on people say, oh, this is a long sword,
earliest long sword. It kind of is, but it's kind of not because it doesn't involve so much
technique, which is, I mean, you can try to use the techniques, but it wouldn't work so well
because just the mass distribution just is that different. My calculation is near the tip. It's
about 25% of the mass as a base. It's more like cutting around it, a greater source of war.
Whereas something extreme like the ring neck, there's always variations, but we're talking
about specimen and then they share similar characteristics. This one, it's about 10% of
the mass and the base because it's one fifth of the width, half of the thickness, so it's 10%.
And then this is more like a stereotypical fencing long sword or like a thrusting oriented long sword
for precision or rigidity. Whereas if you go back to lots of the cutting, cut and thrust swords,
like this Viceroy or some type 18B, 18C, the tip has about 15 to 20% of the mass. So it's just
in your hand, you can feel the intent of that without even looking at the profile. You can
close your eyes and say, hey, this is more of a cut and thrust sword. There's enough precision,
nimbleness. Japanese swords, in contrast, are observed to have 20 to 40% distal taper and 20
to 40% profile taper. Of course, there are exceptions in both directions, but even the
ones on the nimbler extreme of Japanese sword spectrum are more tip heavy and slower to
accelerate or to stop than the most clumsy and the slowest European long swords, including the
Great Sword of War. But just the handling, can you just like check out how it rotates? Yeah.
Just easily can be used in one hand. Oh yeah, quite easily. I mean, it's like two fingers on.
Yeah, late 13th century example. Yeah, and that is definitely a very different feel. Of course,
your balance is noticeably further out, so this is really more for powerful cuts.
Like thrusting, you could do, but it's really clearly not what it's built for primarily.
You don't want to take any sword hit, obviously, but this, that's a particularly bad case of
lost limb probably. A lot messier. Yep. It's effortless cutting. Yeah, and it still moves
well, but you have to kind of put your back into it a little more, and it's not going to
be quite as quick, and you're not going to have that point control and all of the comparison.
You have way more mass in the blade here. Like this is substantially more forward heavy.
So observe these Nimbler long swords that act as natural extensions of your arm and a straight
bar where the mass is distributed evenly across the entire length. Katana occupies a weird space
somewhere in between the natural extensions of your arm and the iron rod. Not saying the iron
rod cannot be a weapon, but usually staff weapons or pole arms are held with the hands far apart
in the middle of the shaft to use the leverage. If you hold it by the end of the iron rod,
that will be very awkward and unwieldable. But in cutting terms, having a rigid and thick bar
is sometimes kind of reassuring. Anyone that regularly cut with katanas will know this is
a joy to cut with them, even the ones that are not particularly lively. And combined with the
fact that the ideal cutting portion of the blade is usually left thick on katana, and a very stout
edge geometry that doesn't start a bevel from the spine, but at the two-third of the blade's width,
these create a very unique feel for katanas. Kind of like a crossover between proper swords
and battle axes. They also cut and split more like an axe than a sword, which tend to be very thin
on the upper portion to have very small edge angles. Well, at least it's found on swords made
by other cultures. If you look at European swords, Chinese swords, they become very thin
to accelerate easily, but also have smaller edge angle to meet less resistance as the blade passes
through the target. Like the reach and coverage, the responsiveness of the sword in fair fights in
open spaces is a huge advantage. However, when fighting in full suits of plate armor, which most
styles of Japanese armor are, just offer slightly less coverage than the European counterparts.
Both the reach and the maneuverability become less important, and there's more room for error
allowed when you are heavily protected. And when fighting against opponents also clad in heavy
armor, it almost always comes down to grappling, which the nimbleness and reach of the sword
doesn't really mean much. So these advantages and disadvantages are very much real, but they
can be either overstated or understated, depending on the circumstances.
Also, one more thing to add to the comparison to the Kriegsmesser. Just because it's curved,
that only means so much, really, because it's a very different curvature we're talking about.
This is quite strongly curved. Now, Itachi, of course, tends to be much more strongly curved,
but it feels different and it moves different because of that. Also because, like we already
pointed out, it still has quite a bit more mass near the tip, and because it curves away,
you have that mass kind of pulling in that direction. That's always something I find
with a blade like this. In terms of edge alignment, it kind of wants to tip over a little
bit, and you have to counteract that. That doesn't happen with a European sword. Okay,
depends on what it is, but usually not to that extent. So there's different dynamics happening
here. Curved swords don't necessarily cut better than straight swords when swung at high speed,
although the curvature assists with lessening the contact area and making contact with the target
at an angle, assisting at initially biting onto the target. When you draw the blade from the target,
curved blades are easier to retrieve and tend to make some additional slicing motion
to cause longer but shallower secondary wounds. Of course, many types of European longswords
have bellied edges, even when the central ridge is straight. So this serves, essentially,
as a curved edge to give some benefit of curved swords. When they are properly sharpened,
they can slice very well even against toughened material. As for Japanese swords, more curved
swords such as Shamshir can slice even better, but Nihonto's two-handed grip naturally utilizes
the leverage to apply more pressure and stability when making the slicing draw cuts for generally
better results. Skull has done extensive tests in the past, so you can check out his videos,
link in the description. The curvature of katana also makes the tip naturally tilt away from the
direction of the grip, rendering straight thrusts and half-swording stabs far less effective,
but jabbing and poking motions with the blade at an angle with the forearm may not be diminished
much in terms of power and it can go through soft material easily still, just not maximizing the
Also, the backward curvature makes Japanese sword cuts easier to parry than straight swords as the
blade curves away from the opponent. On the other hand, temporarily turning the blade around at
binding may have the effect of bypassing the obstacles in parry and block from certain angles
to still reach the target, though this isn't in the repertoire of most orthodox Japanese swordsmanship.
While we are on the blade geometry, we should point out that obviously having double edges on a
blade opens up many opportunities, which is the reason many techniques in European martial arts
involve cutting with the false edge from various angles, and this is essential to parry and riposte
in one tempo in European swordsmanship. Of course, some rare examples of Japanese swords such as
have a sharpened false edge on the upper portion, and this enables techniques that cut with the
false edge on the spine or even simply flipping the sword around to cut with the conventional grip,
but then again this is not orthodox as these examples are exceedingly atypical. Japanese
sword tip geometries are also far less effective at armor penetration than many types of European
longswords. Even some of the more specialized armor-fighting katana with more tapered long
okizaki can penetrate easier but still not able to defeat the range of European male armor,
but then of course Japanese kusuri is butted male and it is far less robust against thrusting
than the riveted European male armor, so those more acute okizaki tip on some katana
would suffice in Japanese domestic context. Next up, we will talk about the variety these
broad categories of sword offer, which happens to be European longswords' biggest advantage
over katana. For whatever purpose and speciality a user would prefer, you can find a longsword
variety that embodies it. I've made an 87 minute long video on the evolution of European longswords
linked in the description below, so I won't reiterate the entire history of longswords here,
but let us examine a few select examples of diverse designs with scaligrim.
quite a different profile can be of course more extreme than that right you can have something
that's based like borderline s-talk you know now you're talking lot this is not really light but
the tip has so much less weight yeah yeah you can very easily control the tip and disengage
all of that that is really quite nice so that's so of course a better thruster than it is cutter
right but um i've got low enough so i'll be decent so i have seen people discussing
like the going extreme from cutting oriented to saucing oriented you assume this is pretty
pretty much saucing oriented and then some of the more extreme ones they remain sick there's one
type 17 in a book and i've got a measurement it actually has a reverse normally they will
they will become a lot thinner at least half the same near the tip and base right there's one that
actually becomes sicker as it approaches the tip and the point of balance is like in the middle of
the blade so you will think well that's that's got to be used in a way that point of balance
so for the most part you're supposed to just i'm sorting in a gauntlet against
heavy armor opponents so worry about this point doesn't really matter because you're not holding
a uh you know long sword grip right like not not in the you're you're just holding a sword and
jab because the shortening of where the tip is as opposed to your hand the pivot point
the shorter it is the more accurate it is yeah and the more the more rigid it is imagine a sword
that's plenty flexible but it's not really that flexible America always gonna have some spring
right but you're doing this you jab into something it's not like the force doesn't just dissipate
paper went through
so this one definitely is not dedicated for
armor fighting harness fighting you're you're talking more about cutting still so this is this
is by the end of medieval times renaissance you can see the ricasso this is a very good sign for
a lot of long swords they just start to have the castle so at base you don't need like that
broad like this one where you're the principal that's another one you're going to but we're
going to talk about that one later because they wanted to they want to have the cake and eat it
too so essentially you gotta have a very large amount of profile paper and still have it broad
pretty much broader than this one near cutting portion so the base is so broad and it gets so
the edge angle gets so small right because the wider you have the center you have it gets very
fragile near the edge which is why it cuts so much better but then if you cut into some hard
material or any resistance it gets stuck into it it's definitely hand and a half sword in the sense
when you hold it in one hand this is still still quite maneuverable so i could definitely imagine
you know like sure with one hand normally you would prefer an arming sword that's
meant for it but you can handle this quite easily with one hand in fact so let alone
material plenty of control right yeah some people came over here they're like casual sword enthusiasts
yeah it was the casual let me handle this one the first impression was it's so light yeah wow
it's so light actually it's well heavier also this is not very long 35 inches blade and then
weighs close to 1700 grams but if you have really impression i would not have guessed that
and you know you would think i'd be fairly decent at judging weights at this point but
no i would have guessed like 1.5 kilos at most so we just go from let's i'm gonna grab the albion
baron also too many swords show the point on this up close because it is it is a little thicker
which of course is good four and a half millimeters yeah some of these type 15a
they have reinforced tip so it swells up this one over here the Lancaster which is a 15
it has you know reinforced swelling tip so it gets in there right before the tip it gets
this one doesn't even need it because it's already plenty sick yeah true so why don't we
look at this it's like a 13 late 13th century example so that's when when people have cold
plates they're thinking great helm limb protection hey i'm pretty impervious to
regular troops weaponry against cut and thrust so i'm gonna just scale up scale up of course
yeah and that is definitely a very different field it's hard to say exactly how they fought
because we weren't there and everything and battlefield fighting is not covered in the
manuscripts but i would imagine probably on average it was probably a little less refined
yeah like they were still trained they were still knights so they still you know knew like it wasn't
just pick it up and swing like crowbar obviously which some people think some people still have
strength no i don't think so but probably a little bit less refined and say you know mid
16th century fencing um but like with something like this there's definitely a lot of just
timing is more important than like fancy stuff so you're just gonna lay into them at the right time
stopping power stopping power yeah hopefully make it through the armor because this will
kill someone but it's okay fine unless like one jab to the brain or the heart yeah otherwise
they're gonna it wouldn't even notice they got stabbed and that is not that one hit one good hit
that's it you're not gonna the shock will stop you yeah even in mail depending on where you take
that hit like particularly the bonier areas like if you yeah a collarbone will break so easily
even a rib or you know anything like you know flesh of your bits okay you might be all right
but it's not gonna hurt but if you get hit with this particularly on a limb you know like okay
you have mail there that's not enough it may not cut through the mail but your your flimsy flesh
right for sure i've caught some targets before and i put you know textile not mail
mail has a little bit of rigidity but uh the gambeson on top and what's really surprising
surprising is that it cut the meat open without penetrating the gambeson using oh you're totally
fine you're you're fine the armor is fine you're fine not not really so it press the gambeson into
the flesh it's a little bit shallow but that's it's pretty bad news for you because you've got
fiber in what is sweaty dirty and then inside your wound and then medieval level of medicine
you check it out and later on it's already infected and many even nobles and aristocrats
they died yeah from the infection right yeah and there's so much that can go wrong even if
the armor doesn't get damaged you know there's like shearing forces that act on the flesh
underneath so you might get a laceration even though it doesn't penetrate just because it you
know tears on your skin right so there's so many things that can happen nasty things events just
one century one century that the the events of armor and cause this degree of shift in the design
of swords yeah so very no problem cut oriented to completely stress oriented something flexible
you want to flex it you want to do a flex up the baron you see show people how much it flex
i just want to touch it with my bare hands yeah there's plenty of flex in it yeah that's not so
much yeah we can just meanwhile i'm gonna check my podium see what areas they'll do well yeah
there's some flex but it is much more rigid which is what you want i mean i find like an
excessively flexible blade can interfere with cutting too but definitely thrusting yeah it's
just a hand loading you just like check out how it rotates yeah just easily can be using my hand
oh yeah quite easily i mean it's like two fingers on yeah there's one technique it's very helpful
for people who are new to cutting without chambering the sword back you can chamber
in the blade back by releasing middle ring and pinky and that can be enough space enough
distance for to accelerate particularly if you combine it with a lunge and you just pop forward
like that i mean it's not a powerful cut but in an unarmored fight depending on hit location forehead
it'll do something yeah yeah in contrast japanese swords have some degree of diversity too such as
different blade geometries called tsukuri but over the course of one millennium their overall
silhouette haven't changed that much although the curvature and the mass distribution has gone
through some subtle revisions the overwhelming majority of them have the shinogi tsukuri
geometry the reason of which we will discuss in the next section as for the craftsmanship just
like swords made in other parts of the world both japanese and european swords demonstrate
incredible artistry when the makers care to embellish the swords with all sorts of decorative
elements such as relief sculptures inlays perforations to showcase the prestige of the
sword no surprise there really but even just the craftsmanship on basic components themselves
such as the blade and simpler hilt furniture extreme care is taken on the geometric front
especially true on japanese swords surface polish evenness and symmetry we have established earlier
that japanese sword making tradition produces blades that don't taper greatly in the width
and thickness primarily due to over one millennium's experimentation and evolution
that originally took inspiration from both chinese swords and swords of emishi people an ethnic group
that had been the traditional enemy of yamato japanese people the reason they make these stout
swords was originally ensuring the durability of swords that were treasured possessions of the
bushi class since the kofun period japanese swordsmiths have been able to perfectly replicate
continental asian swords refined geometries with great amount of tapering in the thickness by
studying the examples brought back to japan as gifts or purchases but they lacked the heat
treatment infrastructure and technology to reliably make such swords with acceptable durability
the solution eventually crystallized in producing sword grade tamahagane steel in rather laborious
ways and making blades extra thick and stout to trade refinement in handling for durability
the true mystery is why such tradition persisted in the age of industrialization and even earlier
when high grade namban steel of european and continental asian origins became more accessible
starting from the trading with portuguese from the 16th century katana made of namban steels
were not given any spring temper or any delicate geometries still even in the 19th century when
japanese started to make military sabers they still made them to carry the traditional stout
and robust geometries while homogenous steel and industrial grade heat treatment were widely
available the answer really lies in the japanese national ethos that many commentators have
observed that although absorbing influence and taking elements from foreign cultures
is a frequent phenomenon throughout japanese history given its geographic realities
conforming with traditions especially those tied into the national identity is a mandate and it
carries heavy social stigma to innovate and buck the orthodoxies in short although the solution of
and extremely hard edge on soft spine does have its pitfall in comparison to the spring steel
on later century european swords we shouldn't debunk the myths propagated by pop culture
by going to the other extreme the traditionally made japanese swords are perfectly acceptable
in terms of durability in its historical context and modern usage by practitioners
these traits definitely have their unique advantages here i linked the destruction
tests by japanese swordsmith talo asano done on the katana forged by himself in the traditional
way and it's a wonderful demonstration on the right expectations of japanese swords durability
next up is the ease of carrying and the art of unsheathing and sheathing now some of you
might say hey is that such a deciding factor now just think about it for a second your sword will
hopefully sit in the scabbard way more than it is out in your hand and sheathed which means
if the sword is easy to carry it around then there's a better chance you might choose them
otherwise you might pick something else alternatives such as you know an arming sword
falchions things are shorter more compact easier to carry right and long swords are not bad in that
department because the size is manageable especially you consider a medieval way of carrying
two or three points of suspension and they generally sit pretty comfortably by your side
and unsheathing is not really that hard but being straight means that biomechanically it's not as
fast as katanas to unsheathe especially when the average length blade length is a lot more than
uh average which katana were you know touching and particularly also for everyday self-defense
do you want to carry this in town like you just walk around like this hey how's it going guys
maybe just go to the tavern it's you can but it's just much more inconvenient than if you have like
a short messer or something on you which is like it's almost like that's what they're made for
you know exactly you're constantly adjusting and putting it to be vertical and not knock down
objects etc yeah this is yeah and if you end up in an everyday situation where suddenly it goes down
the sword you have versus what you don't you know like maybe you have say a messer and oh okay you
would have so much more reach if you carried one of these but imagine your opponent just has a knife
or a dagger like you're better off with a messer you know so if you have that as opposed to nothing
yeah now with touching mounting has essentially the same way of carrying by suspending it on your
belt usually resting at the back of the wielder which you can honor you know later style mountings
have simpler ways of carrying you just stick to a sash i'm not sure uh long swords can be carried
that way i'm pretty sure you can't stick a long sword scabber to your belt but i'm fairly certain
that's considered vulgar in medieval europe whereas sticking uh which katanas to your
sash is perfectly acceptable socially in feudal japan and the ease of carrying it this way or
removing the sword and scabbard is pretty much one of the reason they are they were so popular
over touching right over time particularly having an average blade length meaning that the the sword
is not really sticking out that much away from you so it's not likely to catch onto branches or
furniture or the doorway or etc so having a slight curvature will also help if you carry it this way
all you have to do is make it slightly resting slightly more vertical and you can see the the
blade is closer to your body to your leg right whereas long swords definitely projects more
away from you and this is a shorter long sword it's already you know having a pretty long scabbard
especially if you consider most of the shape the furniture on the scabbard by the end of it
actually extends the lengths of it and you can see this is quite a bit longer than the actual
blade lengths right so it's already longer and then it's projecting more from your body being
straight resting diagonally when you turn around it's more likely to bang things objects of course
you can try to adjust this by making it resting more vertically and that's what long sword owners
typically do they have to make it rest more in line flush with your body temporarily but you
know the carrying system doesn't make it too comfortable as soon as you let go it becomes
of course carrying a long sword is cool it invokes confidence so that's fine especially
you have such a longer hilt projecting forward and you can rest your hand onto the the pommel
the hilt it's pretty convenient pretty comfortable but when you start walking around it becomes
more of a nuisance than the uchi katana style of Japanese swords and having a curvature and
whether it's a slight curvature or the more pronounced type will assist with unsheathing
and sheathing but just having a short blade easier to draw you're ready at a moment's notice
for you to defend yourself with the blade right and stepping offline and still be able to cover
your line with the blade and calm down uchi katana style scabbards saiya have simpler
furniture they just have horn on the mouth the koiguchi kojiri the shape they don't actually
lengthen the dimension saiya that much it doesn't project that much even the metal shape
is form conforming so they're not really adding anything into the dimension i would definitely say
in this department uchi katana style Japanese swords have a definitive edge over European
long swords now not to even mention lots of long swords are way longer than this it will
be a little bit harder to carry and draw of course some of the more compact long swords
are not really that harder to draw than katana so you can fairly easily quick draw this and
defend yourself with parrying and counter-attack and treatises by the likes of fury delivery
also talk about how to quickly deploy a weapon so that's not really that much of a disadvantage i
would say i hope this discussion has been illuminating and really if you have to think
about it comparing katana long swords superficially they are definitely comparable right but the more
i think about it it's more like comparing automatic rifles with shotguns and which
category is more superior it's really tough to tell because although you can say well automatic
rifles are going to be better superior and most of the tasks shotguns can do but you have to
consider other factors right maybe one category is more cost prohibitive to manufacture and purchase
to own to maintain and that's a major thing if you're an owner of a weapon obviously maybe it's
socially less acceptable there are legal reasons or more reasons for to carry one or the other and
the optics the image is not a small thing right it's tied to the fashion but what is considered
acceptable think about are police officers allowed to carry shotguns or automatic rifle and that's
huge difference right so in a verified one-on-one in open space either outdoors or
you know on the flat ground and without any interference or indoors like in a dojo or
a fencing school long swords undoubtedly have multiple advantages over katana especially
but even the longer bladed touches or okatana
no doubt about it right over the responsiveness over hand protection
having two edges easier to thrust more tools in your box you know more technique oriented
but real life is not always one-on-one fair fights right in fact most of the time they are not
when you are expecting opposition it's either you know in the places you least expect right at a
the most opportune time for you right ambushes assassination or it's on the battlefield lots
of sword owners back then could afford full plate harness or full suits of samurai harness so lots
the advantages of long swords it just become less relevant i would say that yes definitely they are
much more different but overall they are arms representing their culture and the sword making
technologies techniques and traditions so if you are a rational person you have to respect
both of them equally and we learn to appreciate them equally give them the benefit of the doubt
and think about alternative circumstances and scenarios so there you go hope this video has
been illuminating and thought-provoking and if you enjoy this video check out some of the other
discussions between scuttlegram and i but also our reviews of a number of swords and topics
