Sometimes our anxiety is trying to tell us something important about a real threat, something we need to take care of, or someone we love. The trouble comes when anxiety keeps going long after it’s useful, turning into rumination, clinging, and worry about things we can’t control.
This week I focused in on how to find a middle way with anxiety: listening to the useful signals without letting them take over. Listen in to learn ways to work with your anxiety: making room for unavoidable fear, finding realistic reassurance, creating a plan and taking action where you can, loosening the grip of unnecessary worry, and surrendering what is ultimately beyond your control.
3:11 — Healthy anxiety: Why some fear and worry are normal, useful signals that help us recognize threats and take care of what matters. 6:50 — What should you worry about a little more? Using healthy concern to protect relationships, health, and the things that matter over the long term. 13:30 — When anxiety is understandable and unavoidable: Working with fear that comes from health problems, difficult circumstances, or concern for someone you love. 14:53 — Mindfulness of anxiety: Stepping back from anxiety, opening to it, and disentangling its sensations, emotions, thoughts, and beliefs. 18:52 — Turn toward realistic reassurance: Notice what’s genuinely reassuring without ignoring real risks or pretending everything is fine. 20:12 — Make a plan — and surrender the rest: Take action on what you can influence while accepting what remains outside your control. 23:18 — How clinging creates anxiety: How grasping at pleasure, approval, our views, and our sense of self can generate unnecessary suffering. 29:33 — Take the message, then hang up the phone: Learn from worry, extract whatever is useful, and interrupt the cycle of rumination when it stops helping.
I offer these every week along with a guided meditation.
Just click the subscribe link below to be notified through YouTube when I post the latest
recording.
Or, if you'd like to join us live, which would be great, just go into the description
section below and follow the link along to be able to sign up for free.
Somebody made a comment, several people actually, that in this guided practice it was difficult
to access some of the experiences I was inviting you into, and maybe especially difficult to
rest in them.
So, I'll make the distinction you may be familiar with in two typical classic types of meditation.
One is an open awareness meditation in which we simply remain present with whatever's flowing
through consciousness without trying to influence it.
The other classic kind of meditation, researchers call it focused attention meditation, where
essentially we concentrate in and become absorbed in a particular object of attention, very
often some particular wholesome quality of being, like compassion, or a sense of one's
own worth, or a sense of kindness and lovingness toward others.
Well, it's okay.
In a way, it's challenging to do open awareness because it's easy to get distracted.
It can also be challenging to do focused attention practices because sometimes it's hard to feel
certain things, even if a well-intended teacher is trying to help elicit that kind of experience
in you.
It's okay.
Just do the best you can, the way I look at it, quite pragmatically, both as a psychologist
and as someone who has great respect for and has learned a lot from the early teachings
of the Buddha himself.
There is a place for working with the mind in an effortful and direct way, and there
is a place for cultivating various factors such as energy, or tranquility, or happiness
as a factor in Buddhism, or in this case a sense of growing calm, tranquility, with a
sense of openness and spaciousness of awareness, and even exploring blends of those.
There's a place for that, and if you bump into difficulty, it's okay.
You're normal.
I've had difficulties myself, and very often what happens is you just stick with it and
gradually what's blocking you or hindering you from resting in some of these normal states
of being.
Calm is a normal state of being, a sense of strength is normal, openness is normal, warmheartedness
is normal.
It might be difficult to access, but it's a normal range of experience, which means
that it's natural to us, and over time as you work through the obstructions to that
and come home to what is natural to you, you will be increasingly successful at it.
And as you rest your mind in and as you increasingly stably experience these qualities of being,
they become hardwired, literally so, in lasting changes of neural structure and function and
become enduring parts of you or qualities of you that you can take with you wherever
you go.
So I'd like to explore with you here the topic of anxiety, and I want to start with what
we could call healthy anxiety, and then we could call problematic anxiety, and I want
to approach this from both a Buddhist perspective and from the perspective of modern neuropsychology.
So on the one hand, anxiety is perfectly normal and has an evolved survival function.
It provides signals to us about threat, and there's what's called signal anxiety in psychology.
That's its useful purpose, and it alerts us to, you know, the tiger that might be dwelling
in the bushes.
It might alert us as well to what will happen if, you know, we don't, I don't know, listen
carefully to our partner, you know, or what might happen if we don't go see that doctor
about this funny lump in our neck.
There's a place for healthy anxiety in the world around us to be anxious about things
that feel like they're falling apart in your country or worried on behalf of others.
A lot of anxiety is on behalf of others.
My wife and I have two adult kids, and you better believe we worry about them.
We're proud of worrying about them, and we intend to keep worrying about them even if
they don't want us to.
So there's a place for that kind of anxiety too.
It's natural, of course.
I'll tell you a little story about myself and rock climbing.
When I very first started climbing really seriously in my early 20s, I would go to bed
at night, camping out, lying in my sleeping bag near my friend who was my climbing partner.
And as I was falling asleep, I would suddenly have an extremely vivid sense of tumbling
through the air down the face of the 1,000 or more foot cliff we had been climbing that
day, falling down toward the hard boulders at the bottom to smack on them.
Whoa!
You know, that was a shocker.
So I would pull myself up and out of that experience, shake it off, and then start falling
back into sleep again.
And then, bloop, there I was, tumbling in space, falling to my death, you know, to smack
on the boulders below.
And after, I think, the third time, then I thought, well, harumph.
So as I'm falling asleep, then it starts again, and I let it happen.
I let it go all the way to completion, where smack, right on that gray, I can see it here
now, gray granite flat boulder.
And then in the moment, just before, a millisecond just before impact, I realized, oh, what I
was experiencing was an upsurge of the fear that I had been suppressing all day long as
an inexperienced young climber on the lead.
So that if I fell, you know, I might go 20 or 30 or more feet with a little tiny piece
of metal holding me.
It was a little scary.
I just shut it all down, and it was now flooding up again.
And I learned, oh, there's a middle path, there's a middle place, what a surprise, for
healthy anxiety, healthy fear, you know, and to allow it, to make room for it, and find
that middle place where one is not overwhelmed by it and also one is not trying to, you know,
lie about it or numb to it or push it all the way down.
There's a place in life in general for healthy anxiety.
And this goes to a major stream of teaching in early Buddhism, direct teachings of the
Buddha himself, and in some cases, some of his contemporaries, his students, in which
he talked about appropriate fear, including fear of, you know, doing things that will
cause future suffering or suffering in the present for yourself or for other people.
He talked about, you know, for example, the five reflections that I've talked about previously,
recognizing that each one of us is involved in processes of, you know, of aging, and we're
inevitably exposed to illness.
Eventually the body will die, eventually we will be separated from all that we love, and
eventually we will, and along the way, we will inherit the results of our actions.
This is not a gloomy prospect, this is a recognition of what's simply true.
So healthy anxiety, you know, healthy caution, healthy vigilance, prudence, thoughtfulness,
is really, really wise.
As a psychologist with a lot of interest in neuropsychology, there's a wonderful term,
I think wonderful, called allostatic load.
Trying to recall the person who coined it, I can't on the moment.
Anyway, it's the notion that in the body-mind, there is the accumulating wear and tear of
stress, particularly stress that's invasive and overwhelming.
There is a place for stressful experiences, there is a place for fairly mild experiences
of being stressed that are well-managed.
The problem is, arguably most of the stressful experiences of most people are not the kind
that are just sort of going to make you stronger and stronger, but they actually wear you down.
That's allostatic load, that's the gradual accumulating burden of stressful experiences
and negative emotions that invade us, our stressful experiences.
Invasive irritability, resentment, helpless outrage, politically, is full of allostatic
load, carrying grudges, allostatic load, ruminating about worries, allostatic load.
It's appropriate to be anxious, in a sense, to be aware of the threats and the risks and
the costs of certain things.
I wish I had been more anxious about saving a little bit of money in my 20s and 30s, which
would have helped me later on in life, rather than just totally resisting the advice of
my parents.
There's a place.
So you might pause here, you might pause here, and ask yourself, huh, would it help me to
be a little more worried about some things, just a little?
And for example, one of the things that I think many couples would do well to worry
more about is a gradual chilling in their relationship.
The forces of entropy are continuously at work.
Rust never sleeps.
Disorder occurs.
And if we're not continually re-knitting the fabric of a relationship, thread by thread,
often in very little and easy ways, just life itself tends to push people apart and create
more distance in the relationship, which may be fine for a while, then something may come
along.
Maybe one person is particularly challenged with some health issues, or some appealing
alternative emerges, and you suddenly realize that, wow, the threads that really held us
strongly together for so long have been quite frayed, and now we're really vulnerable to
major disruption.
Another thing to, I think, pay attention to is the impact in relationships of irritability
and pushiness.
I'm calling myself out on that one.
People roll with our behavior for a while, but at a certain point, they just kind of
maybe get quietly fed up and start to vote with their feet out the door.
So that would be a thing.
Also as we age, I don't know about you, but I'm aging, sure.
We inherit in our 80s what we did in our 60s or 40s, so it's never too late to stop going
down the wrong road.
It might be worth just being a little reflective about being concerned, being motivated, being
vigilant about the impact over time of not setting aside a little time in your week to
be active, to move, to exercise, to build muscle mass.
So there's a place for that.
And in the Buddhist tradition, there's a definite encouragement from the Buddha to realize that
in this precious human birth, we have limited opportunities.
Very few of us will know when we've crossed the line, when we will have, as Stephen Levine
put it, one year to live.
We don't know.
And I live with the knowing that the lights could go out, the lights could go out for
me at any point.
I had friends as a couple who said that when they parted in the morning to go off to their
different jobs, when they said goodbye, they took a moment to realize that they might not
see the other person ever again.
Not morbidly, but tenderly and appreciatively.
And as it turned out, one of them went into the hospital for a fairly ordinary operation
and did not come out.
I hope I didn't shock you there, the realness of it all.
Okay?
Then on the other hand, there's problematic anxiety.
And what can we do about that?
So I want to talk about two kinds of approaches.
One kind of approach is given in the fact that understandably, often due to some kind
of underlying physical condition, the body will generate chronic anxiety, just general.
And one of the major symptoms of an underlying health condition is an internal sense of alarm.
Even before you identify what that internal condition might be, you know, the early warning
systems in the body-mind process start bubbling up alarm into your consciousness.
So if you're dealing with a chronic health problem, for example, or you're in the middle
of a difficult situation, you lost your job, or you're maybe someone in a country who is
being targeted for mistreatment of various kinds, oof, it's understandable that you feel scared.
It's understandable, you know, your heart is pounding, your body is tense, it's really understandable.
If you're desperately worried about somebody else, it's really understandable.
And this is where the Buddha's teachings about how to bear, and how to live with, and how
to, in some senses, shift our relationship to ongoing painful experiences, is really useful.
His teachings are really useful here.
These are teachings around mindfulness, so there can be a witnessing of the anxiety,
not being identified with it and hijacked by it.
We're not trying to reduce it, we're just simply stepping back from it.
If anything, it's helpful, to the extent you can, to open to it.
That's why I did the practice with you in the beginning of the meditation around establishing
a base, a refuge of calm strength, as best you can.
Because that base, and there are other aspects of things that can help you establish that,
such as a warm-heartedness flowing out and flowing in.
It's a major factor of being centered in the body-mind.
Establishing that base then enables us to be more open to the anxiety, to feel it, to
let it flow, to open to and deconstruct, disentangle the body sensations aspects, the emotional
aspects, the subtle differences between, let's say, apprehensiveness and fear, uneasiness,
worry, to disentangle and identify the thought track in the experience, what are the cognitions,
what are the beliefs, particularly beliefs about the future, this kind of unpacking.
If you haven't done this before, try it.
It's really helpful.
You're being with the experience while tracking its different aspects.
And in the tracking of its different aspects, it becomes easier to bear.
Because you start recognizing a kind of airiness, a space between the different aspects and
ways in which they feel less personal.
They're there.
They're unpleasant.
They hurt.
And they're not so invasive.
They're not so personal.
There's more space in them and around them.
It's like airing out the threads that previously had formed a tight-fisted knot.
Highly recommended in the Buddhadharma.
Fundamental process.
Also, there is the aspect of recognizing that this experience has arisen due to various causes.
It's there dependently.
And as those causes change, well, the experience of anxiety can change as well.
You know, the Buddha talks about his own youth as a practitioner, as a meditator, in which
there's a kind of a sutta.
This is Majjhimanikaya number four, titled Fear and Dread.
That's the title.
In which the Buddha talks about feeling really scared.
It's arising.
You know, you would go into the forest full of lethal threats, frankly, and close his
eyes and sit and hear all the sounds and the smells.
And even with imagination and in the worldview of the time, there would be spirits of various
kinds, not always so friendly.
And you just stayed in place.
Stayed in place.
You know, to not be so overwhelmed by all this.
So, that's good practice too.
I want to say also that in terms of practicing with, we could say, inescapable anxiety,
first dart, first arrow anxiety, I have found as a therapist and as a friend to others,
two things in particular, and I use them myself.
So, in addition to what I've said so far, which is essentially mindfulness of anxiety
with compassion for yourself, it's unpleasant.
Additionally, I find that turning toward realistic reassurance is quite helpful.
If there is reassurance, if there is the possibility of helpful treatment, if it might be getting
better, anything that might be reassuring.
And I think often for people, they're aware of what might be reassuring.
They're also aware of what might be worrisome, what might be getting worse.
And then the question is, what's the last thing your attention rests on?
If both are worth being aware of, maybe finish with reassurance, just to help yourself feel less anxious.
You're still going to keep your eyes on dangers, you're still going to take prudent action,
but you're opening to reassurance.
That's helpful.
And then the other thing I think is really, really helpful is to make a plan.
And to make a plan you have confidence in.
That it's the best plan you've got.
And you're going to take steps, and then those steps will lead to an even better plan.
Know your plan, and take refuge in your plan.
A lot of people, they freeze, understandably, in the face of threat.
But once you get through the freeze, and help yourself to get through the freeze, plan and take action.
Angela Sarian, to paraphrase her, talks about how action binds anxiety.
And then, I'm sorry I'm going to say it, surrender to what's beyond your control.
Your plan is about what you can influence.
Surrender is about what you can't.
And see if you can find your way into being at peace with the most dreaded outcome.
I'm not saying you like it, I'm not talking about sugarcoating it.
I'm talking about a sort of ultimate acceptance.
In a larger context of the universe as a whole.
People, I don't mean, and if you can't get there, you can't get there.
And some people sometimes say they're there, but they're not really there.
I'm talking about with your belly, your heart, and your bones, surrendering to what might happen that's beyond your control.
Not acquiescing to it, or not knuckling under to it, not succumbing to it.
Surrendering is different from succumbing.
Doing all that you can while surrendering to it.
There are these two lovely lines from Dylan Thomas, a Welsh poet.
They're actually inscribed on the top of his tombstone in Westminster Cathedral or Westminster Abbey, whatever.
Anyway, I was there. I saw them. They're great.
They're from the end of the poem Fern Hill, in which he talks about his childhood.
And these last two lines I love. Ready? Here we go.
Time held me green and dying, though I sang in my chains like the sea.
Both end. Surrender to the dying and the chains while singing like the sea.
And then the Buddha put a fair amount of attention on the anxieties that we create ourselves.
The anxieties that are not so beneficial and that are very worthy targets of practice.
So I want to name two from classic early Buddhism.
The first of these is the anxiety that is produced through clinging, which seems counterintuitive, right?
I'm a rock climber. I want to cling to those holes.
There's healthy clinging, sure.
But then there's the clinging, for example, to sense pleasures, which inevitably fade.
And we get anxious about their fading.
We get anxious about, will we get them?
We get anxious about, will I get the last cookie? Right?
We get anxious about the sense pleasure of approval from other people and responses to us of various kinds.
You know, we cling to them.
Or, the Buddha pointed out, we cling to views, ways we think we're right.
We get anxious about, don't other people see it the way I do? Why not? What's wrong with them?
Or, oh, I got to defend my view. Oh, it's under attack.
We get anxious about that, the root of which, the root of that anxiety is the clinging to the view.
We also cling to the sense of self.
Whoa, you know, me.
And so anything that seems like it undermines me, you know, like others are not so impressed with me,
oh, that would make us anxious.
We, you know, get caught up in what's called affective forecasting,
in which we project a future self into situations involving, let's say, sense pleasures,
or communicating our viewpoint, or a sense of appreciating us as a self.
And then, oh, we get anxious about that.
So here we have the great, you know, the fundamental teaching of the Second Noble Truth,
the ways in which craving and follow-on clinging is a major factor of suffering.
And as we cling less, we suffer less.
So the Buddha pointed to that.
And yeah, easier said than done.
And there certainly is a place for enjoying pleasures in life,
and there is a place for knowing what you think,
and as need be, asserting what your viewpoint is.
And there's a place for appreciating, you know, healthy narcissistic supplies.
We're very social primates.
We need to feel cherished.
We need to feel prized.
We need to feel seen.
We need to feel included and liked.
There's a place for that.
And there's a place where we go too far.
And often we recognize where that place is by how it feels.
It starts feeling contracted.
It starts feeling insistent.
It starts feeling like we're taking things really, really personally.
That's the kind of clinging that leads to an anxiety that's not so good for us.
And through insight and through practice over time,
we're able to hold our pleasures, our views, and our sense of self more and more lightly
with an open hand rather than a clinging, clenched fist.
And then there's a second kind or source of problematic anxiety
that's given among the five so-called hindrances.
This is a really useful area of teaching.
I know I've taught about it sometime in the distant past,
probably back in the Bronze Age.
So I think I'm going to dust these five off.
Essentially, it's the idea that in our practice,
which, you know, could have a beneficial forward quality,
we are hindered by certain things.
Interestingly, I've learned from Gil Fronstel
that a way of translating the Pali word, P-A-L-I, in early Buddhism
that's translated routinely as hindrances is as coverings.
Coverings. Isn't that interesting?
These are coverings over the beautiful true nature
that is inherent in all of us but is covered over by various things.
So what are the five hindrances?
We have the hindrance of attachment to sense pleasure.
We have the hindrance of doubt.
We have the hindrance of ill will.
We have the hindrance of sloth and lethargy.
And we have the hindrance of restlessness and worry,
sometimes translated as restlessness and remorse.
This is rumination. This is mental preoccupation.
Worrying that is not productive hinders your progress on the path
and hinders relationships, hinders productivity at work.
It saps energy.
It pulls us away from the present as it is
and gets us caught up in mental time travel about the future
or, you know, being preoccupied about, you know, the past.
So worry gets in the way.
It's a hindrance. It's a hindrance.
And it can make people feel kind of restless.
Sometimes we worry also intertwining with remorse.
We worry about what we've done.
We worry if we'll ever be able to repair something.
You know, we worry about people who are estranged from us
and what will happen, right?
So it's really understandable. It's really understandable.
And what can we do about it?
I have a fair amount of material on rumination.
And you can burrow into it on my website.
I did a workshop on rumination.
It's available online.
And, you know, if you're blocked financially from doing it,
you can just ask for a scholarship and do it for free.
A lot of material about ruminating.
You can find it elsewhere in my world.
I'll be kind of quick here.
With regard to worry,
what's really useful is to ask yourself,
what's productive here?
What's useful?
To welcome the worry.
Thank you, worry.
What do you have to say?
And at the point that you've gotten the phone call,
hang up the phone.
At the point you've gotten the message,
you can hang up the phone.
I got it. I understand.
I understand there are certain things that are uncertain.
I understand that there are things that are beyond my control.
I understand that some bad things might happen.
I don't know.
And meanwhile, I'm going to do what I can.
Thank you.
But I don't need to add worry
to my discerning and my planning and my acting.
I can disrupt ruminating,
which is like a cow chewing its cud.
I can disrupt laps around the rumination track.
I can glean the value.
I can harvest the value.
I can squeeze the juice out of that orange of worrying
and then release the rind.
Release the part that's not so helpful.
Very useful.
I want to say a word about the worries of others
because as someone who, myself, two things.
Number one, privilege plays a role.
Many people don't have to worry about certain things.
As a man, cisgender man,
I don't worry, particularly about walking down dark alleys.
I'm not worried about being sexually assaulted.
I don't have to worry about that.
I don't have to, or in other situations,
I don't have to worry, as a white person, let's say,
about what are people thinking about me, necessarily, personally.
So it's important to appreciate that what we worry about
or what we're anxious about is the result of being part
of a larger network, systems in society,
family systems, neighborhood systems, economic systems,
access to healthcare.
Some people don't have good access to healthcare,
so they worry, of course, a lot about their child having the sniffles.
What is this going to lead to?
Can we afford the expense?
One of the major sources of bankruptcy in America is medical debt.
So it's understandable that, you know,
it's privilege plays a role in worry.
And second, in interacting with others,
I don't know about you, if I'm worried about something,
to have some well-intended person tell me,
ah, don't worry about that.
I want to smack them.
They should worry about my reaction to them telling me to not worry, right?
And so don't be that person.
Don't be Rick, because I've been that way sometimes.
So it's just really important, when other people are worried about something,
make room for that, you know?
Can you give them room to breathe?
It's easy to get kind of, frankly, arrogant.
And maybe you have the privilege of a lot of practice.
Maybe you have a lot of years of therapy and Buddhist practice
and some good enlightenment experiences under your belt.
Okay, great, that's you.
But to come from that place of, frankly, superiority,
and just be like, well, you're still worrying about that?
Not so good. Not so good.
I think that's an important point here.
To quote the poet Miller Williams, you know, with his line,
or his poem about compassion,
have compassion for everyone you meet.
It's not conceit, something something,
for you do not know what secret wars are going on down there
where the spirit meets the bone.
We don't know.
Very often we really don't know the circumstances of other people's lives
that they are understandably freaking out about.
We don't know.
It's respectful to have an attitude of gentleness and inquiry and softness
and receptivity around that.
I think also, I'm on a poet role here.
Quoting Leonard Cohen, Zen practitioner.
Bless his memory.
I think this is close to what he says.
I know your burden's heavy as you carry it through the night.
The guru says it's empty, but that doesn't make it light.
And that's true for your own situation as well.
You know, some kindness for yourself about all this.
So I wanted to say a word about that,
about how we treat the worries of others.
You want to hear my quick fix for worrying about public speaking?
There's some kind of list of things people worry about,
and down in the middle are things like terminal illness.
The top is public speaking.
On average, it's the one that got the highest ratings.
What I learned to do was to look around the room,
either before I went up on stage or just when I was on stage,
to just look around the room and take a moment
to register the faces of some people and a sense of them,
and frankly, to recognize, in a broad sense, the suffering,
the common humanity, the weariness, the fatigue,
the concern about others, the longings for the good.
And when I would register that,
it would draw me out of myself into being over there
and shifted me into what could be of value or of service for them.
And then that helped me be a lot calmer, you know, as a presenter.
So you might play with that a little bit.
And it shows up in other places.
You're going out on a blind date or whatever.
You're meeting the in-laws for the first time or whatever.
You're going into kind of a tough situation at work.
Just putting a little bit of attention on tracking,
not in a patronizing way at all, but in a respectful and open way.
Oh, how life is landing on that other person too.
And taking a beat to register it in your body,
not just knowing it conceptually quickly,
but taking a few extra seconds to register in your body.
Oh, it might really help you to feel better and do better in that situation.
So let's see if there's anything else that's coming up here.
Anxiety.
I think it's okay to not want to feel anxious.
Anxiety is unpleasant.
Would you want someone else to feel more anxiety than they really need to feel?
Need based on, you know, inherent causes and conditions.
You probably wouldn't.
In the same way, I think it's really okay to find this middle place
in which you're not fighting the anxiety.
And you're not pushing it down and you're not ignoring it.
And you're in a way welcoming it.
Thank you, anxiety, for trying to help me.
It's trying to help you on the one hand.
And on the other hand, appreciating that,
you know, I don't want to feel more anxious than I need to.
I love this proverb from the Dhammapada
that one is truly wise, not because they can quote the teachings.
One is truly wise who is peaceable, friendly, and fearless.
Not like an aggressive jerk, but their cause is just.
They're looking clear-eyed, you know.
They're not carrying unnecessary anxiety along the way.
So you might, you know, I think a lot of people,
they feel like they're stuck with their anxieties.
And in this presentation, I hope, drawing on the wisdom of the Buddha
and a few good psychologists as well, plus some poets,
you know, I hope you have found some skillful means in this talk
to relieve yourself of the burdens of extra unnecessary anxiety
while learning ways or being reminded of ways, perhaps,
to practice with inescapable and informative anxiety.
So how about we just take a moment, a few breaths,
you know, a handful of breaths here at the end,
to let whatever is useful for you settle in.
The line is, people will forget what you said.
They will not forget how you made them feel.
How we feel, our state of being, is the real prize.
Sinking into the state of being that you value here, appreciate,
you know, with a blessing in your heart for others.