A lot of us feel overwhelmed these days — flooded by other people’s emotions, worn down by the suffering around us, or confused about how to stay open-hearted without burning out.
In this week’s teaching, I talk about the real nature of empathy, the sweetness of compassion, and how to stay grounded while engaging with a world that’s hurting. We explore how to be with our own reactions, how to keep our hearts open without collapsing, and how to move from individual healing to collective action that really makes a difference.
00:00 — Three fundamental forms of practice: letting be, letting go, and letting in as the foundation of inner work. 00:03 — Discernment vs. judgment: how to take a stand without collapsing into self-righteousness or spiritual bypassing. 00:06 — Healthy values & wise action: recognizing what matters without adding blame, ill-will, or superiority. 00:07 — The neuroscience of empathy: mirror neurons, emotional resonance, and theory of mind. 00:11 — Empathy vs. compassion: empathy is neutral; compassion adds benevolence and motivation to help. 00:14 — How compassion evolved: the social brain, long human childhoods, and the mother–infant caring system. 00:19 — There is no such thing as “compassion fatigue”: how compassion actually protects and sustains us. 00:20 — A four-step self-compassion first-aid: notice, soothe, strengthen, and plan. 00:23 — Training compassion: how structured compassion practices (MSC, CCT) grow resilience and freedom. 00:24 — Beyond individual suffering: addressing upstream, systemic causes of harm through collective action. 00:27 — Invitation: expand empathy, deepen compassion, and join with others to reduce suffering at its roots.
I offer these every week along with a
guided meditation. Just click the uh
subscribe link below to be notified
through YouTube when I post the latest
recording. Or if you'd like to join us
live, which would be great, uh just go
into the description section below and
follow the link along to be able to sign
up for free.
First, somebody asked, would I repeat
what I consider to be the three
fundamental ways to practice? And
whether it's with what's out in the
world or in your physical body or in
your your mind and the three basic forms
of practice that I just see again and
again that lots of many lots of things
fall into these three groups being with
what's there. We simply observe it. We
accept it. We hopefully bring compassion
to ourselves about it, some curiosity
and investigation. It may change on its
own, but we're not deliberately trying
to nudge it. We're not making efforts to
change what is. We're simply being with
what is. This is the ground practice.
It's fundamental. It's a foundation of
everything. And as your practice matures
over time more and more, it's kind of
what's going on. You know, people are,
you know, really far along. They're sort
of hanging out in the present at the
front edge of now, receiving what's
arising as it passes through, simply
being with what's there. But that's not
the only way to practice. We have to
work with the mind too, not just to be
with it. And that's where wise effort
comes in. And wise effort has two
aspects. One has to do with reducing or
releasing or preventing that which is
stressful, painful, toxic, harmful,
unwise in, you know, for yourself and
and for others. Okay. And then there's
the third aspect of practice extremely
important which is growing the good you
know creating it protecting it even
increasing that which is wholesome
beneficial supportive nurturing you know
kind and so on for yourself and for
others. It's a little bit like if your
mind were a garden. We can witness the
garden. We can be with it. We can also
pull weeds. That's the you know
releasing what's problematic and and
also we can grow flowers cultivating
that which is beneficial which I
summarize in three ways as letting be
letting go and letting in. It's a really
fundamental model and often you'll find
yourself when something has happened
sort of moving through all three. You
know, first you be with what's there.
Like, oh, you know, my neck hurts. Or,
oh, they said that weird thing. I didn't
like that. Or, oh, oops, I I kind of
messed up with somebody. I got to clean
that mess up. Oo. So, you're being with
what's there. And then you move
naturally at a certain point to ah
letting go. Letting go. And sometimes it
takes a long time to get to the
authentic place truly of letting go. But
sometimes it can happen pretty quickly
also, especially as you get to know
yourself better. And then letting in,
not just letting go, but replacing what
we've released with what would be
helpful for you. Sometimes kind of
matched to what you let go of. Like
letting go of tension in the body and
replacing it, letting in relaxation and
a sense of calm, strength. Let be, let
go, let in.
Okay.
And then also somebody asked here just a
moment ago in terms of challenging
times, how do we Robert asked this at 40
minutes past the hour. How do we get the
balance right in terms of taking a stand
versus quote unquote non-judgment? And
this is a classic one especially in the
more mindfulnessoriented and non-dual
oriented and you know kind of newagy
type communities in which I find much of
my home to be sure. Uh you know there is
this view that somehow we should be
non-judgmental.
Well let's be really clear about what
we're saying. For one there's no escape
from values.
Wanting or trying not to have a value is
a value. So we live amidst values, we
live amidst goals. There's no escape of
it from it. The only question is what's
our relationship to it. And so for me,
it's really important to be discerning.
You know, you see what is. Oh, you see
that the shoe is untied.
You see that? And then you bring your
values to bear. Oh, do I like having
untied shoes? Do I think that's a really
good thing? Well, maybe sometimes it is
when you're seated and you, you know,
you want to let your shoes expand. Okay.
On the other hand, if you're walking or
running, do you really want to have a
shoe that's untied? So, your value there
might say, "Nah, better to tie the
shoe." So, you have discernment and you
have valuing. Discerning and value. It's
very natural. And then you take
appropriate action. Hopefully, you tie
your shoe. Now, in all that, oftentimes
people, you were having judgments. It's
okay to have a judgment. Oh, an untied
shoe is worse than a tied shoe under
most circumstances. At least for me. And
my tennis shoes, by the way, routinely
come untied. So, I'm on top of this one.
All right, that's okay. It's when we
start adding, you know, ill will or
criticism or piling on. Oh, stupid shoe.
Stupid Rick. Let his shoe get untied.
Oh, why do you keep those old tennis
shoes around? Why don't you get some new
Velcro tennis shoes? dum dum dum. I'll
call that being critical in a
negativistic kind of way. There's a
world of difference between healthy
discernment and valuing and judging in
the healthy sense of that and unhealthy
criticality, righteousness, superiority,
you know, shaming others. Okay, there's
a big difference. And I think some of
these people use the teachings about not
being attached to our views and not
getting caught up in self. They use that
sometimes as a spiritual bypass to
overlook real harms being done in the
world that are appropriate to see and
have values about and then do something
about as best we can. So for me the the
thing is are you seeing clearly? Are you
discerning?
Do you feel good about your values?
And do you know what your plan is? And
can you do all that without the add-on,
you know, righteousness and, you know,
accusing others and hating others and
having ill will toward others, that's
the key. And when you look at people who
historically and presently really rested
in both wisdom and activism,
the intersection of those, they're
clearly rested in their heart. And they
combine, you know, assertiveness,
appropriate assertiveness with a heart-c
centered kindness and compassion for
others. And I think as long as we're
rested in that sweet spot, appropriate
action tends to follow. And it's much
more effective typically than if we get
all cranky and pissy and you know quote
unquote judgmental in the negative
problematic sense of that. Now on to my
primary talk here about empathy and
compassion.
Empathy is the capacity to basically
tune in to other people. Non-human
animals have this capacity in various
ways. Empathy in your brain has these
three fundamental circuits. One in which
we simulate over here or we create over
here some sense of what it's like over
there in terms of actions. These are the
so-called mirror neurons or mirror like
networks. We tune into the actions of
others. Okay. Then there's empathy for
the feelings of others. This has to do
with another part of the brain, the
insula, primarily on the inside of the
temporal loes in which we resonate with
the emotions of others.
And then last, there's the neural
circuitry mainly located behind the
forehead, which really doesn't tend to
come online until around the third
birthday in which we tune into and
create a sense of the thoughts broadly
stated of others. So we have these three
empathy circuits,
actions, emotions, and thoughts. Empathy
for actions and emotions are present at
birth. They're also quite present in
some ways with non-human animals. Uh
there's an interesting study done
recently on bumblebees in which they
will track the sort of emotional state
of another bumblebee and be affected by
it. And this is established
scientifically. It's a fairly simplistic
kind of empathic attunement, you know,
at the emotional level for a bumblebee
with maybe a millionish neurons compared
to our 85 billion or so inside the
coconut. But it's still empathic
attunement.
It's only later on that the capacity for
what's called theory of mind where we
really contract the motivations and
thought processes and values and covert
agendas even of other people. That tends
to come later. And if people start
dementing or going into pretty serious
cognitive decline with aging, those
theory of mind capacities may gradually
be lost while retaining empathy for the
vibes,
the attitudes, the feelings of other
people. That's why I think it's really
important if you're around people who
are gradually, you know, losing their
grip that you stay rested in a
fundamental kindness as best you can
because they can still pick up your
quote unquote energy. Okay. Empathy.
Empathy capacities are fairly innate.
Some people are innately more initially
empathic and porous. Some people
describe them as empaths. It's true.
There's normal variation. And then life
lands on us. Sometimes contracting our
empathic capacities, other times
expanding them. And then with training,
with training, we can get better and
better at tuning into the actions, the
emotions, and the thoughts of other
people. In part by becoming more mindful
and attuned to your own bodily sense of
action, your own inner emotional life
and the subtleties even of your own
thought processes, not just
language-based also imagery processes,
memory processes inside your own being.
You can become more empathic with
training. There is such a thing as
empathy fatigue because we can become
burned out if we get too flooded by the
way it is for other people. We can
become overwhelmed by it. That is
actually a case if we are too porous and
we have too little a sense of you know
me here distinct from you there
and then there is compassion.
Now empathy alone is morally neutral.
you know, con artists, con artists,
interrogators,
dodgy characters, they they're pretty
empathic. They they can track what's
going on. They can read you. You know,
just because they're empathic doesn't
mean it's good. It's when we add good
intentions to empathy and that's becomes
compassion. Compassion is a empathic
response to suffering.
combined with benevolence,
a caring stance with the motivation to
help if we can. That's the nature of
compassion. And the evolution of
compassion is very interesting. very
kind of basic animals with fairly simple
nervous systems are pretty good at
mirroring or empathy for action, tuning
into the behavior of predators and prey.
That's pretty basic, right? our nearest
primate relatives, the chimpanzees and
bonobos from whom our family tree
separated only about six million years
ago. They're empathic, you know, they're
they're empathic to some extent, pretty
motivated around getting what they want.
They're really not very compassionate
generally speaking. And then inside
their bands, they tend to be organized
not on the basis of caring and sharing,
compassion and justice, but on the basis
of alpha dominance, what anthropologists
call holding and controlling, holding on
to food and controlling reproduction
with alpha dominance. Okay, so humans
though, this is so cool. The brain has
roughly tripled in volume over the last
roughly 3 million years. And I [snorts]
kind of mark it. You go back to when our
homminid ancestors with brains roughly a
third our size became clever enough to
man manufacture stone tools
and then during that period of time the
volume of the brain increased
dramatically.
All right. Our you know hommined
ancestors did not dramatically increase
sharp claws or sharp teeth you know for
so forth. They dramatically increase the
size of the brain. Huh? How come? The
brain is an incredibly costly
metabolically costly organ. Uses even
though it's 2 to 3% of body weight, it
uses what around 20 or 25% of the oxygen
circulating in your blood vessels, the
glucose, you know, the food we're
processing. It's a hungry hungry beast.
That old brain. Whoa.
How come? So big. Why is it so busy? Why
is it so thirsty? Well, an adult
chimpanzee's brain is about twice as big
as a newborn chimpanzeee's brain.
An adult human brain is about four times
as big as the brain of a newborn infant.
That
time period that was required for the
brain to literally get bigger and bigger
and bigger and bigger
created the the longest childhood of any
species on the planet.
Long childhood. And during that long
childhood, including the first years,
the first few years, that infant and
toddler and then the equivalent of a
preschooler back in the stone age was
completely dependent for survival, even
longer on initially the care of his,
her, its mother initially. So the mother
had to take care of that little baby.
You know, if you look at pictures of
chimpanzees or gor gorillas with
infants, they're holding on to their
mummies.
Human babies can't do that. They got to
be carried. Okay. Well, that create the
dependency of the infant now having a
longer and longer childhood to enable a
bigger and bigger brain required a
growing dependency on its mother, their
mothers who themselves became
increasingly helpless and you know I
won't say impaired more like occupied or
they were busy taking care of this
little baby. They needed the protection
of their mates and increasingly in their
bands, the so-called village it takes to
raise a child. These processes
centered around compassionate care for
the baby gradually drove the process of
the evolution of the brain. Because
those processes that enable the brain to
become bigger and bigger and develop the
capacities of the so-called social brain
with compassion, a response to
suffering, to care and to tend and to
keep alive.
All that
drove the processes of brain evolution
that have enabled us to be here today.
Wow.
That's the nature of compassion. Really
interesting. Grounded in the the mother
infant caring system and then gradually
elaborated in pair bonding and then
elaborated further in the village it
takes to raise a child. So we have
empathy and then we have empathy plus
benevolence and motivation equals
compassion.
Good so far. There is no such thing as
compassion fatigue.
Compassion is bittersweet.
There is the opening your heart to
suffering. I've been with people in, you
know, Buddhisty worlds, I won't name any
names, who just phoned in their
compassion. You know, yeah, they wished
they didn't suffer, yada yada, but they
could not be bothered to be empathic.
They could not be bothered to let my own
troubles, some of which they were
creating, huh, land in their heart.
It's really important to be big enough
and brave enough and resourced enough,
you know, so you're stable here so that
you can open to others to really let
them land. You know, the fundamental
question of empathy is what's it like to
be you?
What's it like? You know, it's a
powerful thing in your key relationships
or those you work with or walking down
the street or imagining people, you
know, in these divisive days who are on
who are on the other side of the
political aisle. What's it like to be
you?
You know, and sometimes it's quite
poignant to realize that what it's like
to be them is to enjoy making other
people miserable
or that what it's like to be them is to
be is doubling down on some ridiculous
position because they won't admit
they're wrong.
You know, empathy isn't all sunflowers,
you know, and fairy tales and puppy dogs
and all that chocolate chips. No,
sometimes we're empathic. we realize
that what's going on over there is they
are actually out to get you or they
really don't care and that's some of
what we come to. We also sometimes with
empathy we just tune into what's
beautiful in another person, what it's
like to be them, their good intentions,
their kindness, the ways they're working
with their pain, the ways they're trying
to work and practice with their issues.
You know, empathy. What is it like to be
you? All right. And then when we apply
the sweetness of compassion to the
bitter of empathy for suffering, that
sweetness protects us even
neurologically, releasing different
reward neurochemicals that kind of
buffer us. They create shock absorbers
between us and the impact of the
suffering that we're empathic for. So
research shows that actually when you
really look closely, while there may be
empathic fatigue and while there may be
caregiver burnout and other kinds of
burnout, compassion fatigue per se is
actually not really a thing or or it's
very uncommon. So when you're working
with compassion, it's really important
to turn tune in to the sweet amidst the
bitter.
That's really really really important.
Compassion includes self-compassion.
Compassion for the being who wears your
name tag who happens to be stressed and
tired and hurting and suffering. It's
okay to bring compassion to yourself.
It's a good thing. Compassion for
yourself, research shows, makes you
stronger, makes you more resilient.
People who can bounce back or recover
from or or just survive traumatic
experiences often are protected and
energized and fueled by the compassion
they have for themselves. For myself,
when something happens that, you know,
rattles me, I have this sort of
four-part, you know, it's a kind of
first aid that I'll walk you through
right now. You may like this that you
can do really, really quickly. First, I
notice that I'm getting triggered. I
notice that I'm rattled by this. I'm
revved up. I don't like it. Kind of
frozen. Whatever it might be. Notice it.
Be with it. Number one. Number two,
there's a natural response of a kind of
sweetness, a kind of tenderness, like,
"Ouch, that hurts." Oo, you know,
classically, the little kid running
around, you know, trips and falls, skins
her knees, comes back, comes to the
parents. Oh, they kiss the owie, they
make it all better. Oh, you know,
there's that natural response that's
tender even to yourself. Oo,
I wish I didn't suffer this. I wish I
did wasn't so mad right now. I wish I
wasn't so hard on myself that I forgot
that thing. Oh, this loss. Yeah, it's
heavy grief. Yeah,
that's the second response. And then
third, a kind of muscular response.
Okay, what are we going to do about it?
How can we learn to bear this pain or
even what can we do to actually address
it, reduce it, relieve it? And then
based on that kind of muscular response,
there's a making of a plan. What's your
plan? What are you going to do about it?
Really important. Being with what's
there, self-compassion,
kind of a musket or getting on your own
side, and then making a plan. That's
good first aid. And very often you can
move through each one of those four
steps in a dozen seconds, a few breaths
maybe.
Okay. Interestingly, compassion can be
trained. Someone made a note there Jamie
did about compassion cultivation
training. Their trainings now mindful
self-compassion.
Wonderful training. Emory, my friend and
former GCC board member Lobsang Negi at
Emory University has created with others
kind of a cognitively centered and
ethically oriented compassion training.
There are a number of these trainings
out there including trainings for
children and uh teenagers and there's
increasingly good research behind them
that's showing you know what people
would say who go through them that yeah
this stuff works. You can train you can
cultivate compassion. I find for myself
that if I'm upset with someone who has
wronged me
and really wronged me, you know, and
I've concluded based on discerning and
valuing that yep, they did wrong me or
somebody else. I only get free of it
when I find my way into whatever was my
own responsibility in the matter, which
may be zero,
but I'm willing to recognize more than
zero. And second, I only get free when I
find compassion for them.
And we can train. I have trained in that
growing capacity for compassion.
All right. So, quick recap. We have
empathy, three neural circuits. We have
compassion and the evolution of
compassion and the fact that it's
trainable and the fact that a focus on
the sweetness of the caring response
alongside empathy for suffering enables
us not to be fatigued in our compassion
actually feeds us as we as it flows
through us. And then the question
becomes and it's a hot one in circles of
so-called engaged Buddhism or other
areas. Wow. What do we do about the
causes of suffering,
not just the suffering itself? If we
care about suffering and we are moved to
relieve it, huh? By extension does that
call us to look at its fundamental
causes including in broadcale systems
like poverty, wealth inequality,
injustice, tyrannical rule, prejudice,
economic systems. These are systems that
create a lot of suffering. Well, I can
say for myself that my own career and I
kind of started sort of young
because I was unhappy and I wanted to do
something about it. Uh certainly around
50 years I've been focused on relieving
suffering at the individual level
through my work including here, my
books, programs, doing therapy with
people and so forth. uh many many other
people have also been engaged on
relieving suffering at the individual
level. Incredibly important work. I
think it's noble work. Uh health care
providers, emergency, you know,
situation responders, all kinds of
people around the world. We we pull
people out. In effect, we do what we
can. We help people get out of the river
of suffering.
Great. And increasingly it's important
to ask yourself and to ask ourselves
what's pushing people into the river of
suffering upstream.
What are the upstream causes
of the stress, the loss,
stuckness,
the bias that people have to deal with
the overheating of the planet? What are
the upstream causes of a 100 million
tons a day of CO2 or CO2 equivalent
gases being excreted into our
atmosphere? What are those upstream
causes that are inexurably, inevitably
like a giant greenhouse? That's why they
call them greenhouse gases heating up
our planet. What are the upstream causes
of wars?
What are the upstream causes of very
very wealthy people making sure that the
world runs, you know, according to their
own personal, you know, desires. Well,
the only way we're going to be able to
address those upstream causes is by
coming together.
You can't address those upstream causes
on your own. You have to join with other
people. And that's why for myself I've
been really heartened by a growing
clarity in the world today grounded in
compassion that we need to form new
collectives and take action collectively
at all kinds of scales whether it's two
mothers organizing to get a street light
installed in a rural area in Kenya so
that when their daughters walk home from
school they are not being harassed you
know by the teenage age boys. That's
collective action. Collective action
also happens when people come together
to improve a health care system or to
organize a neighborhood group or to
increase the fundamental institutions of
civil society like a relatively free
press or the right to to organize and
gather and assemble yourself without
needing to get a permit from the local
police department to do so. These are
the sorts of things that are alive in
the world today. There are many powerful
forces doing them and we can join with
those forces that are already happening.
Worthy nonprofits around the world or
start your own as I did. What was I
thinking? I thought I'd retire three
years ago.
Anyway, to form collective action with
others. So, I really invite you as I
finish here to reflect on three things
here. One, your own capacities for
empathy and how it might serve you to
cultivate them and expand them,
especially when you're dealing with
challenging people.
Empathy is not agreement. Compassion is
not agreement either, right? Empathy.
Second, compassion.
You know, can you respond to suffering
with compassionate concern and a tender
wish that the suffering ease even if you
don't agree with that person? Can you
expand that? And third, can you look to
the causes upstream of so much needless
suffering? So much needless suffering in
the world today and gather together with
others and look for ways to come
together with others. whether it's in
the global compassion coalition or in
other forms of collective action to
address the upstream systemic sources of
so much needless suffering.
That's my offering. Somebody asked an
interesting question right up my alley.
You know, as a psychologist, Saul, does
ADHD symptoms make it more difficult to
not be so empathic? I'll I'll address it
this way. Is does do the aspects of
distractability, impulsivity and
stimulation seeking, you know, kind of
being skittery, you know, jack gravity,
does that make it harder to be empathic?
Actually, I think many people who are
toward the nor on the normal range
temperament toward the spirited/ADHDN,
they tend to be actually extra empathic.
They actually tend to be really quite
open to stimuli, including stimuli
coming from others. Sometimes it's it's
almost overwhelming. So they start
distancing
excessively perhaps to manage all the
input. So paradoxically
by developing healthy boundaries and a
deeply bodily grounded sense of whoosh
me here then you can be more open to you
over there. particularly if you're if
you're more toward a distractable,
permeable, you know, fastm moving end of
the normal temperamental spectrum.
Okay, let's see if there's anything
else. Finishing up, empathy, compassion,
and addressing not just the effects, but
the causes, the systemic sources of
suffering as best you can collectively
with others. Those are my main themes
tonight.