Practicing with Unprecedented Sources of Anxiety – Talk with Dr. Rick Hanson

Rick Hanson
90 followers
997 Video Views·Aug 4, 2024
I offer these every week along with a
guided meditation just click the uh
subscribe link below to be notified
through YouTube when I post the latest
recording or if you'd like to join us
live which would be great uh just go
into the description section below and
follow the link along to be able to sign
up for
free I'd like to also if I could now
segue into my you know formal uh
prepared talk as it were uh about wow
how to be
with the uh often turbulent times and
challenging times we find ourselves in
these
days okay all right so I did a podc
earlier today with Forest that we'll
probably Post in a few weeks I don't
know what the title will be um but
basically it's about how to deal with
anxiety about large scale forces that
seem atic control political upheaval
institutions falling apart global
warming economic
change
[Music]
um nuclear weapons
AI that stuff and so I'm gonna
actually name
it not to freak you out Fe not this is
not going to be a new show I just want
to name what a lot of people feel
as a kind of anxiety which is
interesting at a time that
historically has is safer healthier
wealthier more
knowledgeable more regulated in good
ways than at any other time in human
history why are we anxious so I'd like
to dive into this topic here and um
since it starts it could sort of overlap
politics uh I especially encourage you
please to follow
my uh admonitions that if you use the
chat you focus on your own experience
what life is like for you and you avoid
challenging the experience of others
trying to talk people out of their
experience um trying to educate others
persuade others teach others criticize
others
H you know what I'm talking about and
I've done every single one of those
things so I know what you're doing if
you do it because I've done it myself
don't do it Okie do here we go so I want
to
name three categories and I want to
invite you into finding what fits for
you the first category is that we're
worried about things that we really
don't need to be worried
about truly don't need to be worried
about
because
maybe some of what we think is true is
not
true if you just sort of randomly wander
through Twitter which I spent you know a
certain amount of time on I would say
political Twitter there are wild claims
about reality that you know and I know
are not really
true and so many of these claims about
reality are are alarmist and taken out
of
context wow you know that's what I I
call delusional anxiety we're worried
about stuff that's just not it's just
not true or very often the case is that
we habituate to sources of security
because they become familiar and we
don't have anything to compare them to
so we don't appreciate how actually
secure uh
we are in many many kinds of ways that
can uh offset and compensate for and
help us deal with some of the things
that are gener genuinely
worrisome all
right that's the first
category I'm really interested in the
second and third
categories the second
category is stuff in the world that has
always been bad
worrisome
threatening horrible and yet people in
previous times did not have the
communication systems and the
Technologies to be aware of it they were
blissfully ignorant like think about
people in ancient Rome 2,000 years ago
uh who you know did not have any idea
The Barbarians were marching toward the
gates blissfully ignorant they did not
have the idea that volcanoes were
erupting somewhere else in the world
that was going
to put so much dust in the atmosphere
that it led to crop failures and famines
in a year or two to come they just had
no idea but these days with 247 news
people being really dialed in we're just
aware of all these things that might
have consequences for us because they
they really might have consequences for
us but our parents and grandparents and
especially great-grandparents had no way
of knowing about this stuff so they
weren't bothered by
it that's a that's a category that's a
way to understand why we
are
worried and kind of sometimes really the
sense of dread in the
belly that seems so out of proportion
you know in America the Dow Jones is
soaring unemployment is an historic low
all these good things are happening and
yet and yet and yet here and around the
world so many people feel really
particularly young people feel really
anxious and it it's not the typical
anxiety about can I get a job can I find
love uh can we make a baby um you know
it's it's anxiety about systemic forces
large scale systemic forces that could
be
harmful all right and these things are
real I want to be really clear with you
as I move through these categories
global warming is real the risk of
nuclear war is real I'm not trying to
freak you out but I mean these things
are real uh the the incredibly rapid
development of AI and the ways it could
be misused for military purposes
surveillance purposes you know these
things are real the fact that people of
our children's generation um have a much
harder time buying a home than their
parents did for all kinds of reasons uh
college education is much more expensive
today uh things that people of my
generation kind of took for granted or
were able to ride tremendous
acceleration of wealth development in
much of the world that's starting to
taper off for everybody kind of below
the top 1% of 1%
um those are real things those are real
things you know um the rise of
authoritarianism in Europe in
America uh we see it in recent elections
um certainly in Venezuela and elsewhere
uh it's real
stuff so I'm not here to Bang a Drum and
say you all should be freaked out I'm
basically saying hey if you're already
freaked out there's a reason for it and
I want to explore Buddhist principles
about how to practice with it okay and
then there's the third um category of
basically
unprecedented
sources of anxiety unprecedented and
these you could put into two categories
um unprecedented factors like global
warming which 3 four 500 years ago
was not a thing
[Music]
um unprecedented categories that can be
worrisome and also the ways in which
just being
bombarded by endless information streams
and fast PA even positive information
just fastpaced constantly changing
information is really disturbing to the
nervous
system independent of the content that
the information stream is carrying
all right so what do we do about all
this what would the Buddhist
say
Okay
um I offer
several
highlights from uh the teachings of the
Buddha for your consideration and I
really invite your reflection and
discussion here you can put your
observations in the chat please follow
my guidelines don't give
lectures focus on your own experiences
what's helpful to you um perhaps your
own history uh so first
off the Buddha profoundly emphasized
clear
seeeing recognizing what is true you may
know the term vasana a lot of U us we
included have been trained in a kind of
aasana tradition that to went from early
Buddhism through southeast Asia and now
into America sometimes called Insight
it's about clear seeeing
recognizing um bowing at the altar of
reality so we want to see these things
clearly real stuff is real stuff and
unreal stuff is unreal stuff and know
the difference what's real what what is
the state of democracy in your country
um what are the sources of growing
national debt you don't have to be a
scholar you know to recognize what's
real you know what are time
tested effective approaches when a
plague starts sweeping through the human
species what's true recognizing what's
true knowing for yourself what's true
standing up for the truth standing
against people who would deliberately
spew disinformation misinformation
and outright
lies we don't always get it right but we
can trust those who when they get it
wrong admit it and then try to get it
right so you may recall that the
personification of evil in the early
mythology of Buddhism was Mara the
trickster the
deceiver so there's a tremendous
emphasis in Buddhism about knowing what
the facts are
knowing what is actually the
case know what is actually the case it's
not less than what is really true but
it's not more than what is really true
that's a deeply Buddhist
principle uh by the way the article I
mentioned that I wrote that lists these
eight factors of steepening your
learning curve learning broadly stated
uh is called learning to learn from
positive experiences I would have
preferred the word beneficial in the
title because positive experiences can
be on a you know fast track to oh just
be positive I don't mean that at all uh
but you know it made sense particularly
since it was published in the Journal of
positive psychology so okay right
primary Buddhist
principle find refuge in your
recognition of what's
true as best you
can five minutes a day five minutes a
day
what's
true
second deconstruct tease apart the
elements of
things so much of Buddhist meditative
training is about recognizing the
compounded nature of our experiences and
all phenomena in general they're made of
parts that are made of parts that are
made of Parts all of which are in
relationship with each other and
changing so I already have things into
three
parts four actually um large scale
forces that we really don't need to be
worried about for various reasons
because they don't exist or they're
managed by positive developments over
the last centuries Millennia second
category things that were always
worrisome and bad but we just didn't
know about because we didn't have modern
information systems and communication
systems the second category and then
third category
unprecedented
new sources of threat to humanity in
general and often to us in particular
okay that's a sorting device that's
helpful to sort that
out
okay
third the Buddha really honored all
aspects of our
experience so what are the many aspects
of experience that we have rather than
numbing out or swerving away you turning
away how do you feel when you look at
the paper when you see
various uh leaders worldwide making
statements about this or that when
you uh know more and more of what the
facts are how do you
feel and rather than going numb or
suppressing it the Buddha encouraged us
to open to it all nothing left out as a
Zen saying Zen happened after the Buddha
but throughout for example the four
foundations of mindfulness or the four
establishments of mindfulness there's an
emphasis on recognizing
everything for example in meditations on
the body there's an emphasis on
recognizing the mortality of the body
and including our fears of
dying um in the third Foundation of
mindfulness it's about recognizing
whether you know our Consciousness
broadly is colored by greed or not
colored by hatred or not uh colored by
delusion or not broadly so we want to
take it all into account and this goes
to what I think is a really useful and
important point which is to
differentiate between anxiety and grief
so to um continue this sort of sorting
things into different boxes or
categories or teasing apart untangling
the knottedness of the
mind we can be worried about things that
could affect us
directly like huh as a younger person
who would love to own a home how do I
actually do that with with property
values and parts of the world in which
I'd want to live Rising um or if you're
a person in a country and you happen to
be Jewish and there's Rising
anti-Semitism that's a large scale
force it affects you personally if
you're a woman in a country um that is
restricting access to uh reproductive
health and control over your own body
body um that could affect you
personally then there is worry about
things that could harm those we care
about um you know worry about impact of
the economy on other people worry about
the impact of global warming on other
species that are headed for extinction
due to human
causes tragically you know it helps to
kind of sort this out okay this is what
I'm worried about me and then this is
how I'm worried about
us and then with that uh there can be a
kind of grief about a future for
oneself that um is less and less likely
or it's harder and harder to
attain there can also
be the grief not just about the loss of
a personal future but the future of
others you know for example gradually
warming
world and there can be certainly grief
about the loss going forward for
countless
Generations um of um driving species to
Extinction or heating up the planet for
generations for hundreds of generations
to
come there can be these things it's
helpful to sort these out the Sorting it
out actually opens us to it to these
sources and over time helps us bear them
because as we as the Buddha advises
disentangle the knots in the mind we let
in air and light and space which helps
us bear them and be wise about them
increasingly so it's helpful to do this
for yourself to find what it is that you
are concerned about
as to
grief the Buddha in effect had two
practices that are implicit in um the uh
the widely known tale of the woman who
lost a baby and was advised to seek a
medicine made of mustard seeds from
homes that had not known loss and she
could not find any homes that had not
known lost so she returned to the Buddha
and he pointed this out to her in terms
of our common Humanity in
grief we're not alone in our
grief
others are losing
too uh we do not make it through this
life without loss Suzuki roshi said you
know living is like setting sail in a
boat that you know will eventually sink
uh the five Reflections in Tibetan
Buddhism include you know is it given to
me to avoid losing everything I love one
way or another you know through their
passing or my own so you know we're not
alone in our grief that's helpful to
appreciate and that's the teaching of
the Buddha very explicitly in that
story and I think there's another
teaching that's implicit in that story
this mother was racked with grief
understandably because she loved her
child grieving is
loving we don't grieve the loss of
things we don't
value we grieve the loss of what we love
including the
future that we understandably thought we
could have or that we would wish for
others and turning to the
loving through the Buddhist teachings
The Meta practice of loving kindness his
emphasis on compassion and kindness
and a generous happiness for others as
three of the four um Divine Dwelling
Places for the heart right if you want
to know where to you know what is rest
your mind and what your heart longs for
um you know compassion kindness and a
generous happiness for the welfare of
others good places to rest it he
advocated that and turning into love
turning toward love finding the love
that underlies the grief even the love
that underlies the worry and being aware
of it being aware of that love as you
feel the grief can help it can help us
bear the grief it's a lot easier to bear
that grief including a grief about the
state of the world it's because we love
of the world that
we that we grieve the harms being done
to
it and then I'll finish on this
point and by the way the the fourth
category that I alluded to I just want
to name I mean more the kind of ordinary
anxieties of everyday life uh not having
to do with large scale social systemic
structural factors um daily life um and
I should so I wanted to name that and
then also for sure in terms of large
scale factors uh there are the ones that
others bear that you don't perhaps and
I'm speaking now for myself um I have
not had to Bear uh or deal with um
systemic factors such as racism or
sexism or I don't know what to call it
um prejudice against people who are gay
lesbian transsexual as well um and so
these two are things that sometimes we
have to take into account both as they
affect us and as they affect others um
girls and women
worldwide have come a long way well
overdue and they still are subjugated
and mistreated routinely throughout the
world incl ining in my own country um
certainly to deal with that so the last
point I want to finish with is has to do
with again a very Buddhist emphasis on
self-reliance if you are
concerned after
reflection you are concerned about the
personal impact of large scale
forces take the action you can both to
protect
yourself and to do what you can in your
way and to know that you've done what
you can to help and to help others with
those large scale
forces uh I think there are a lot of
people who are worried about low
probability but High catastrophe
events right understandably me included
but they don't take
action I live in the San Francisco Bay
Area we're prone to catastrophic
earthquakes uh you know every 50 to 100
years it's been quite a while since our
last catastrophic earthquake we probably
due for one fairly soon people living
near Mount La um Mount reneer uh in the
Pacific Northwest uh that is an area
that's just low probability on any given
day but eventually something big and bad
is going to happen there uh what do you
want how do you think about that um
maybe they're you're you're concerned
about you know not being resourced in
your old age well one of the most useful
things we could do is save a little
every day put a dollar in a jar put $10
in a jar every day that gradually
accumulates over time take the action
you can um I think about simple things
like having some water uh you know
having uh some extra food uh having a go
bag having a plan if a very low
likelihood but catastrophic event occurs
like certain kinds of policies uh coming
down the pipeline in your own country or
you know hopefully not the use of a
tactical nuclear weapon somewhere in the
world not to freak you out but to
basically say you know if you're already
concerned about this stuff the Buddha
was profoundly self-reliant
and he made it clear that we are the
inheritors of our choices including our
choices for inaction not
acting um and his last words translated
by Stephen Bachelor where Things Fall
Apart tread the path with
care and it's your path that you're
treading so I don't again mean to be
nihilistic I mean take the action you
can put an umbrella in the trunk of your
car I don't know put a $20 bill in the
glove compartment I'm speaking
personally I mean if you have the
privilege and the resources to do this
and then in terms of the World At Large
gosh uh you know there are a handful of
simple things that uh are definitely
within the reach of most of us uh with
regard to global warming and our own
personal carbon footprint we all have a
carbon footprint the average American
say 20 metric tons a year of greenhouse
gases well reduce your footprint in
simple ways as best you can that'll
probably get you 10 or 20% of the way
and then if you have the means donate 50
cents a day that's about the cost to
offset what remains or to repair what
remains to very legitimate nonprofits
that do carbon capture that suck the
carbon out of the sky that you
unavoidably participated in releasing
for example
uh if you live in a anywhere you are
participate in Civic engagement as best
you can in your country whether it's
Saudi Arabia or Sweden or the United
States you know if you can vote vote get
informed vote however you want but
participate in the process and along the
way if you have friends and others who
are lowi information people they're just
kind of don't know what's actually true
and you know you can direct them to
things that are actually true uh you
might like to go to a website I put up
recently uh with some uh friends called
heal democracy that's nonpartisan and it
lists very straightforward it has two
buttons on it basically one will take
people to vote.org which is where you
can register and check your status and
find your local polling booth and so
forth to vote and then the other is
guides. vote which is nonpartisan
information about candidates and issues
participate
it's not that hard also in terms of the
larger world uh the systemic forces that
threaten us will not be changed by
individual action they will only be
changed by Collective action by
effective coalitions forming to
accomplish real things so if there are
things you care about join with others
who are mobilizing and coming together
to take care of them uh I had a deep
conversation earlier today with a woman
from the Middle East who is pulling
together resources for new mothers there
uh in cultures that um are not always
supportive of um of mothers and uh young
children so uh she's starting to form a
network of people who really care about
that and pulling together resources
including some of the things I know
because that's been an early interest of
mine supporting mothers um you know who
are doing something real join with
others
collectively so these are three things
if you care about the world in terms of
some of the major issues of the day uh
we can all in
effect
um repair the harms to the planet we
cannot help participating in in terms of
greenhouse
gases we can repair those harms related
to us as individuals we can do that we
can participate in the political process
and encourage others to do so and we can
start to form coalitions alliances
networks movements Collective action
with others that it's about getting real
things done not just ringing our hands
and Railing at the skies but actually
making things
better very much of course what the
Buddha did to finish here uh what did he
he do he encouraged people to certainly
take the individual action that they
could while also really emphasizing the
third Jewel of practice
s
Community both that involves
appreciating teachers and wisdom holders
such as monastics and also coming
together in community with others um who
have shared interests who care about
making a better world and uh we have
broadly now a community here and we have
a communities around the world that care
about making things better and that
absolutely is Central to the Buddhist
teachings one of the very first things
he did was begin to form a community
around him and a fair amount of his
efforts in the Venia the monastic code
applying to male and female M monastics
alike although in definitely unfair ways
to the female monastics of the time um
you know he was very interested in
helping to form communities so that's uh
the last thing that I'm talking about
here so I hope this was helpful to you
in various ways um my point here is to
not overstate threats nor understate
them and my point here is to respond to
the longing in the hearts of people to
not feel so anxious about you know
things that are that are
unprecedented uh that we're all facing
today wish you well with this uh I can
tell you personally uh that I perhaps
should not say this but for
myself uh I'm very concerned about some
of the major trend lines uh that we've
talked about here but fundamentally I'm
really hopeful for
Humanity and I'm
really um hopeful for the better angels
in our nature gradually
prevailing and I'm really hopeful about
the fundamental um ground of all you
know working its way upward and outward
through the human
heart and I'd like to share that hope
with you
