Die PKW-Maut ist gescheitert. Schon lange. Doch das gescheiterte Projekt der ehemaligen Bundesregierung ist nach wie vor in den Schlagzeilen und auch Andreas Scheuer (Ex-Bundesverkehrsminister) wird immer wieder damit in Verbindung gebracht. In diesem zweiten Teil des Interviews gemeinsam mit dem CSU-Bundestagsabgeordneten sprechen wir über die Maut, über Fehler und darüber ob 500 Millionen Euro wirklich in den Sand gesetzt wurden oder eben doch nicht.
Marvin Neumann ist Redakteur und Journalist. In Deutschland lebend, berichtet er über gesellschaftliche und politische Themen. Mal aktuell, mal Vergangenes, aber immer mit Respekt und Anstand. Der Drang nach Ausgewogenheit und Fairness ist fundamentaler Bestandteil der Inhalte. Für geschäftliche Anfragen folgende E-Mail verwenden: [email protected]
________
Netiquette-Kommentarsektion: Die Kommentarsektionen unter meinen Videos oder Community Tab-Posts sind dazu da, um mit euch zu kommunizieren und zu interagieren. Immer respektvoll, mit Anstand und Blick auf die Gefühle des Gegenüber. Kritik darf, soll und muss geäußert werden. Letztere Aussagen/ Kommentare müssen aber auf Grundlage des deutschen Rechts stehen, als auch international vereinbarte Menschenrechte wahren.
Ich behalte mir vor bei Nichteinhaltung eines respektvollen Umgangtons oder rechtswidrigem Verhalten Kommentare zu löschen oder einzelne Kommentatoren zu blockieren.
Respekt ist Grundbaustein für eine nachhaltige und gesunde Diskussionskultur. Bitte beherzigt dies! _________
Patreon-Unterstützer:
Achim Reiser DrRush Mr. Koalabär Torsten Scheithauer Andre Rütgers Mathis WIchmann David Sophie Walther Der Fellmacher Emilia Kirner Christopher Stahl Emilia Kirner
So were you actually in favor of introducing the PKW wall as a self-employed, self-reliant politician, as it stood there, that is, as a foreigner, or back again?
I love these incredibly diplomatic, but somehow also non-independent statements.
What does that mean? Does that mean yes, does that mean no? Or don't you just know it yet? It's okay too.
And with that, welcome back to part two of the interview together with former Federal Minister of Transport Andreas Scheuer.
And now it's about the failed PKW wall. And I think he was quite open about it.
But at this point I would also recommend that you continue to deal with the topic.
I have also linked you to a lot in the description.
Otherwise, now have fun and good entertainment and thank you, by the way, for the good feedback on part one, which is linked up here in the i.
So let's start with the PKW wall and part two with Andreas Scheuer.
And so that this interview is even possible, by the way, Kira was with us and filmed the whole thing for you so that we can drive to Berlin again.
The train, the hotel and so on is of course also a cooperation partner with the state, namely SteuerBot.
Because you can already pay your taxes for 2022 early on and get your money back.
And all of this very simply with SteuerBot in the app and on average you get € 1,072 back from the financial department.
Friends of mine have already done it with the SteuerBot app and were through within 20 minutes.
And you actually have to do it and first of all pay little for your tax return, otherwise it is really expensive.
And secondly, you get a 10 euro discount with my code or link, which is also linked below.
So try it out with the link in the description and now use SteuerBot.
I have received a few more questions from my community, which all have a lot to do with your past.
Are you actually willing to talk about it?
Yes.
Very good. I wanted to ask you beforehand.
But I would like to talk about the future.
We have done that now.
So we have now asked a little bit about your political view of how you stand.
Asienbrücke is the future and there were just a lot of things that were unclear to me.
We have covered that.
Now come a few questions about the past, which you will certainly accompany a bit.
If you want to stay in politics, above all.
You are still relatively young for a politician.
Thank you.
Indeed.
Öv Tanino asks.
I would appreciate it if you, if he would just list three things that he has done positively for the railway.
First of all, in my time in office, the investments for the rail system have run in exorbitantly high investment quotas.
This means that as much money for the rail as never before is available.
For the first time, paradigm shift.
For example, in my time in office, it has been achieved that the investments in rail are more than those in the road.
And that we have implemented large projects, for example.
Whether it is the route between Munich and Zurich, which now has a driving time record of 3 hours 30 minutes, where no one has to fly anymore,
but really uses the railway because it is electrified, because it is modern.
Of course, also the topic of how we have approached new major projects.
Of course, for example, the connection of Scandinavia to the mainland with the theme of crossings.
The Greens are usually always against it.
They always speak for the railways at the German Bundestag's speaking desk.
But when you come to town, they are usually against it.
Perhaps this is also because the CSU has been sending a lot of money to the infrastructure of Bavaria for a long time.
Especially from roads.
And I can also, before you ask, yes, that's true, there are actually graphs and applicable figures for this.
Yes, but you interrupted me at the third point.
What went well with the railways is that we put a fiberglass cable to the railways at over 30,000 kilometers.
So that mobile communication, 5G, so that everything works.
Yes, that takes time and there was a huge demand for recovery.
But the digitalization of the railways is a big project for me that I have initiated.
This to the third point, because I don't want you to criticize me for having only mentioned two points.
And now to Bavaria.
Exactly, so the question is why, also from user xu8kt and so on.
Why do all CSU ministers of transport invest in infrastructure in particular?
Bavaria, shouldn't you be the minister of transport for the entire Federal Republic?
You tweeted about it in August 2022.
The Ampel coalition suffers from a Bavarian phobia.
The basic vibration of the new federal government is that the big years for Bavaria are over.
Isn't it actually just, finally Bavaria is treated equally?
Marvin, to be honest, I'm really bored by this question because it's real fake news.
Wait a minute, I have to interrupt you.
There is a small request from 2017 and a request from the Greens and a request from 2019 to the federal government back then.
And the figures that were given out, however, prove that.
No, it's just fake news.
Then the federal government gave out fake news back then.
No, stop.
We have a distribution key in Germany that goes over all federal states and that is oriented to the population.
And it is always the case that every federal state gets its share.
I can tell you, the prime minister of Lower Saxony, Stefan Weil, who is the speaker of the northern German federal states,
and they are not only proven by the CDU, but by a lot of SPD,
he said to me at a conference of the northern German federal states,
Mr. Scheuer, I have to say thank you after these three and a half to four years, that was at the end of my term of office.
There was never a no from you.
You were always pragmatic, you were always trying and helped us to implement big projects in northern Germany.
I can only implement big projects or implement projects of the federal government if it is constitutional.
Take the A20 in Schleswig-Holstein, for example.
There is no constitutional right there.
The entire policy, except for the Greens, wants this motorway.
But as Federal Minister of Transport, I can only give the money if there is a constitutional right.
There are federal states that have no constitutional right for federal projects.
And in Baden-Württemberg and Bavaria, most of the projects that are constitutional are provable.
And then the money is given.
And now I say, if you think of the S4 in Hamburg,
that is the connection of Schleswig-Holstein to Hamburg.
That is a billion-dollar project, I immediately intervened.
The A7 at Hamburg, that is Hamburg-Altona motorway extension,
there is the Green transport senator standing next to me, Mr. Tjags,
that is for the topic of discussion, the Greens do not want a motorway,
and is happy and says, man, great that we are now extending this junction.
I could ask for the entire list of motorways, rail projects, etc.,
down to the Digital Railway Center in North Rhine-Westphalia,
where we have digitized a complete junction for several hundred million.
I let it run, the debate that a Bavarian supports Bavaria.
At some point it is just such a beard, because it just doesn't fit at that point.
But if there is construction law in Bavaria, and there is simply more construction law than anywhere else,
then construction is being done.
We have other questions.
And we are also one of the big projects that did not work.
I think that will probably always, forever,
maybe a little bit of the car mouth.
A user wanted to know, how can you still make good conscience policy
if you have invested 500 million euros for the mouth in the sand,
especially if it was already clear that it was going to court?
So the next fake news is that the federal government paid 500 million euros.
That is the demand of the other party.
Yes, it is still being clarified to you what has to be paid.
Yes, this is from the Schiedsverfahren.
That is, they stand in front of me and say, Scheuer, I want 50 euros from you.
Then I say, why?
Yes, because that is my opinion now.
Then I say, well, if we don't agree, then we have to argue about it
and we have to let a referee decide about it.
I say, you did poorly, you didn't bring anything,
you miscalculated.
So we will clarify that.
It is still being clarified.
Exactly.
And the current costs for ...
But this assumption in the question that 500 million euros were invested in the sand is wrong.
However, the costs, especially for the federal government,
are at 30 million euros.
Only legal costs for that.
Yes, well, that's the court procedure.
You could have avoided that.
Yes, Marvin.
It is not said at all that I have concluded a 14-year legal dispute
over the truck murder as federal minister,
where on both sides around 250 million euros
were spent on legal costs and audit costs.
I invested over a billion euros in the federal government.
I.
That was my decision.
That was at the beginning of my office, I said,
14 years of legal dispute is enough, I'll solve it.
And I solved it.
Nobody talks about it.
Okay, fair enough.
I have to get along with that.
But on the other hand, you can't accuse me now,
we have chosen a shooting procedure when a dispute arises from it
and this dispute is a logical consequence of this failure of the truck murder.
And then you have to fight it out and say,
we are now in front of the court of appeals
and then let's talk about how we find a solution.
Then I'm out.
That's what the court of appeals does.
But still, it's contractually regulated that way.
Crash Row.
And I still ask the question,
even if it is in fact not quite right,
but do you have a bad conscience to have put so much tax money
in the sand?
As I said, it is still being found out
how much money really has to be paid to the companies
that signed the contract.
Nevertheless, something was signed,
although it was not actually clear what would come out.
You have already admitted that it was a mistake,
if I am not mistaken, some time ago.
But please correct me if I am wrong.
Nevertheless, how do you think about it today?
Well ...
Does it bother you or is it such a political decision for you
where you think, yes, shit happens?
I brought 88 regulations and laws through the Bundestag and the Bundesrat.
For example, and I do not deviate,
autonomous driving is unique in the world.
This legal framework is unique.
It only exists in Germany.
It is being written off everywhere now.
We have done satellite technology,
we have done start-up promotion,
we have done everything possible
where nobody talks about it.
Okay, and this one project has failed.
But I had an order from the parliament.
We are talking about a law
that was decided in the predecessor period
by the federal government,
the Bundestag, the Bundesrat,
by the way, with the votes of the Greens and Lefts,
the law was signed by the Federal President
and was released by the EU Commission.
All under my predecessor Alexander Dobrindt.
And I got it on the table
and a federal minister has to implement a law
So if I had not implemented it,
even though it was already in the budget,
the revenues of the next few years from the car wall
were already booked in the budget.
This is the prayer book of every federal minister.
Law approved.
Budget law approved.
Revenues booked.
Then I say to you,
should I now say,
you know, I do not care about all this,
I will not implement it.
So were you actually in favor of
introducing the car wall as an independent,
self-reliant politician?
100 percent.
As it stood there,
that is, it was foreigners who introduced it
or brought it back via the Kfz tax?
Even today.
21 countries in Europe
have a so-called user financing.
The EU Commission appeals to all member states
to make a user financing.
That means,
whoever uses the infrastructure,
he pays.
Just like with the truck wall,
just like with the rail wall,
which we also have,
also for the cars.
I am still convinced of this,
also because it has the greatest
ecological steering effect.
If now, yes, who pays?
Who drives, who pays?
So you believe that there would be
less traffic on the highway because
that would be the consequence?
No, but the ecological steering effect.
The money that would be used to
invest in ...
I think ...
I've been doing traffic policy for 15 years now.
There is no one who acts in traffic policy,
not even, for example, the Greens,
or I have to formulate it differently,
especially the Greens.
Winfried Herrmann,
the Minister of Transport of Baden-Württemberg,
said in the first plans of the car wall,
yes, this is a real instrument
to have the greatest ecological steering effect.
This is not my party friend now,
but he is proven to be greener.
Why?
Because it is all over Europe,
because it is all over Europe,
that you have a greater steering effect
and in addition to that,
that in the road system,
financed road,
then the revenues for the state improve
to make an infrastructure better.
And how now a government organizes this
is now on the other board.
Only that a car wall,
an instrument of the traffic infrastructure,
is generally, fundamentally,
is undisputed.
You could have just taxed everyone.
You could have said, yes, it applies to everyone,
not just to foreigners, but also to Germans.
Yes, but I only had what was decided in the period before.
That was not the CSU wall,
but a floundering,
in the end, failed compromise
from CDU, CSU and SPD.
The CSU would have done it quite differently.
The original draft was a completely different one.
Only we were not able to have a majority in a coalition.
The SPD did not want that.
Parts of the CDU did not want that.
But I still say,
if I look at my A3,
in my electorate,
at the road,
then I have a share of 60-70%
of foreign cars and trucks that drive through there.
And then I say,
many people drive by every day
who do not contribute to the German infrastructure,
but they use it.
It's about the same as
the channel that you
put into the network.
I'm curious how you really break down
federal political issues
on my very personal channel.
Yes, for example.
Well, but I don't necessarily have the same responsibility
as you did back then.
But you also say,
who uses the time?
No, not me.
My system works a little differently.
Nobody pays me.
Yes, but ...
I think the comparison is a bit unfair.
I think it's a bit unfair.
Anyway, Mark 831 still wanted to know,
as a responsible minister,
or former minister,
whose office is a matter of the heart,
how do you actually react
to attempts by lobbyists
and other interests
to take decisions
driven only by their own conscience?
Important question.
To illustrate this,
I think there is no time
that is so transparent
for everyone.
Because there are
from lobby registers
to all kinds of
records, protocols,
everything that is
transparent for journalists,
the Freedom of Information Act
and much more.
When requests are made,
you have to provide information.
For example, as a member of the federal government.
I think the system is okay.
It makes things difficult.
But it is better than
many years before.
And how do you defend yourself?
You are your own decision-maker.
You have to collect opinions.
For example,
from the professional level,
as well as from associations.
You have to evaluate
and say,
okay, I can't agree with this,
I can't agree with that,
I can make this decision.
This is a good professional advice,
I don't do that well.
If I look at the federal government now,
an animal protection activist
is secretary of state
in the Ministry of Agriculture,
an employee of Agora Energiewende
is secretary of state
in the Ministry of Economy,
a Greenpeace activist
and an important person
is secretary of state in the Foreign Office.
I could think of
a few things
that are not discussed much at the moment.
Okay, but we are sitting here
with you and not with them.
You just said that it makes things difficult.
What makes it difficult?
Well, because you are
busy with
requests,
you have to accept it.
It's totally okay, no problem for me.
The professional advisor
has to answer
these questions from the outside.
Who did you meet?
Yes, yes.
I'm just talking about the workflow,
not about the situation itself.
I told you,
the system is completely fine.
It's transparent.
It could be even more transparent.
Yes, yes.
For example?
Yes, for example,
and now we're going to do the circle again
before we actually close the circle
to the future or the current
to the Asian bridge.
That's why I just asked
Philipp Rösler and Koso Naar.
Will all these meetings
where Mr. Rösler
or other companies
take place
actually be considered
as lobby meetings?
Bundestagsabgeordnete?
Yes.
It's a registered association.
So should I ask back,
will every association,
the Schützenverein XY,
which meets with...
But you are still a Bundestagsabgeordnete
and not just anyone.
Well, you are responsible.
But also an association has rights.
Absolutely, I totally agree.
But you are an elected politician.
Yes, but Marvin, please don't tell
that this is a secret event.
We stream all our events,
depending on whether
it's technically possible,
but we try, because we want
to be public ourselves,
because we want to be present,
because we are transparent,
we give it to the public
to collect information.
It's not at all...
I think, what does this have to do
with the Asian bridge?
It has nothing to do with it at all.
There are no secrets, period.
Except for the family environment.
I have a clear separation there.
We don't have to talk about that.
I'm just asking, because of course
people know,
I'll call it
our political bubble,
know people who are at the Kars,
know the companies.
I also met with the Friedrich-Ebert-Foundation.
Yes, it's just about...
We are party-based,
it's not an organization of the CDU and CSU.
You, as president,
are still a member of the Bundestag,
who was elected for politics,
for independence,
as far as the economy is concerned,
or for influence.
And that's why I'm just asking
how this works,
if something like this is documented.
Even if it doesn't have to be documented
legally, there are lists.
Do something yourself.
Make sure that it's even more
transparent on the website
about the situation and the discussions
that are taking place,
which are totally legitimate
within the association,
because you are not only president
of the association,
but also a member of the Bundestag,
who still represents the people.
It's a bit like
when I, as a journalist,
can't completely
get rid of myself,
especially as my own creator,
journalist and I also do advertising.
Of course we have an influence on each other,
but I try to make it as transparent as possible,
even if both go completely different ways.
And if you are president of the
Asienbrücke and meet with
Philipp Brüster and other,
I always call him an example,
other business representatives,
then that's okay for the association.
But as a member of the Bundestag,
you are still influenced by this.
And that's why I'm just asking
how transparent you are
with lobby contacts.
As I said, we have photographers
at every event.
It's no secret
who is there.
We try to
provide our information.
I talk to the foreign minister
when it comes to
the issues of the Asia-Pacific
Partnership.
I talk to the chancellor.
I talk to the chancellor
when he makes a delegation trip.
We are party-wide.
We are an integrated association.
I don't understand
that you are
imitating because of the transparency.
Because if you look at our offer,
maybe it could even
improve.
I don't have the capacity
to document every minute.
The Asienbrücke
is not every minute of my life.
But there is
no secret
in the Asienbrücke,
but we want
the public and
the transparency.
I would be stupid
if I told you that we are working on it.
As a final question,
where do we see you
at the next election?
You are not that far away.
Again, a candidate for the Bundestag?
I am
very focused
on this period.
I am a
political person
who looks very politically
into the future.
I love these
diplomatic but not very
personal statements.
What does that mean?
Basically, yes.
But
I can't tell you
after one year of opposition
where the traffic light
is relatively bad
if the new election
is planned or
if it is
a choice
in the legislative period
that will take place
in 2025.
As far as my health is concerned,
I am doing very well.
I am fit. I am very optimistic.
I am positive.
I want to tackle the issues of the future,
especially with many young companies,
start-ups and tech companies
that are ready
to go into the world.
Above all, I want to support innovation
in Germany. Young companies
who want to take the leap into the world.
I have been to
various conferences.
Air and space travel are very close to my heart.
Basically, yes.
Air taxis were also a question.
Does that still work?
Still confident?
Yes, but just like
autonomous driving,
I think there is not enough
power and political support
in Germany.
Air taxis fly somewhere else
and not in Germany,
even though we have done
the legal framework quite well.
Politics should do more.
At the moment, I see
too little openness.
But if you basically say yes to a candidacy,
maybe it can be something next time.
And one last final question,
because someone asked
what grade would you give yourself
in your political work?
In what function?
As a minister, actually.
Two minus.
Modest.
Thank you very much, Mr. Scheuer.
In part one, it was also about
this part of lobbyism.
Maybe you have already seen it
and want to take another look.
Thank you for watching.
Thank you for your support.
Without you, all of this would not be possible.
See you next time.
Thank you.