Insider drops HUGE Giants trade update...

SF Giants Digest
2 followers
Nov 16, 2026
Trevor McGill was just closing games
for the World Series champion Milwaukee Brewers.
Now, one of baseball's top insiders says
the San Francisco Giants make sense for him.
A McGill trade this winter does feel possible,
FanGraphs' Robert Murray wrote on November 12th.
And the one team he named was the Giants,
who are, quote, in need of a closer.
San Francisco blew 27 saves in 2026
and converted only 30 of 57 chances.
McGill saved 30 of 33.
That's the exact piece the Giants were missing,
and I would most likely still tell them to
say no.
They lost 97 games and finished 35 games out in the NL West,
and every prospect they would
send in Milwaukee belongs to the years when they can actually win.
So what is one season of a closer worth
to a team that's not going to be contending?
The numbers that show how badly they need him come
from the biggest moments of games,
and they're ugly.
FanGraphs tracks high leverage innings,
the spots that swing a game the most.
The Giants' bullpen had the fourth worst ERA
in baseball, in them at 11.22.
Colorado, Houston, and Washington were the only teams worse,
and that was across 134 innings of high leverage work.
They also struggled to miss bats in those moments,
striking out 6.1 batters per nine innings in high leverage,
the lowest rate in all of Major League Baseball.
The next lowest team, the Cubs, was at 7-0-5,
so the Giants were almost a full strikeout
per nine innings behind everyone in baseball.
That's exactly how you end up with a team
that went 16-29 in one-run games, and that's
a bullpen problem as much as a hitting one.
The Giants had 57 save chances and blew 27 of them,
so the bullpen failed on almost half.
12 different pitchers got a save for San Francisco in 2023
because nobody could hold the job.
Dylan Smith had the most blown saves with 5,
converting 4 of his 9 chances.
Caleb Killian was the closest thing they ever had
to a closer with 8 saves and 11 chances,
and he was traded to Philadelphia at the deadline.
Ryan Walker, who started the year with the job,
had a 7.16 ERA in 32 and 2 thirds innings before he was gone from it.
In October, Buster Posey took the blame, saying,
The bullpen struggled this year, and I'll take the blame for that.
So the need is real, and Murray is not making it up.
But one closer doesn't fix a bullpen that was losing games in the 6th,
7th, and 8th innings too,
so here's exactly what went wrong.
In those high leverage innings,
Giants relievers walked 5.1 hitters per 9 innings,
and that is how the damage would start.
McGill walked just 2.19 per 9 all year, less than half of that.
Hitters also had a 3-10 batting average on balls in play against them,
which is a bit worse than the league usually sees,
and that tells you some of the damage was bad luck.
The fielding independent number agrees, their FIP in high leverage
was 5, which is poor, but nowhere near the 11.2 ERA.
So yes, this Giants bullpen was bad, but it wasn't hopeless,
and a few arms would have made a huge difference heading into 2026.
And it wasn't home runs, the Giants gave up only .87 per 9
in high leverage, among the lower rates on that list.
It was walks, no strikeouts, and balls in play dropping,
which are exactly the three things a swing
and miss closer with good command takes away.
Posey admitted back in October,
saying the Giants probably overestimated some of the guys that we
had in the pen. So the front office knows it got the bullpen wrong,
and it should be careful about
getting it wrong again with prospects.
McGill is the exact opposite of that bullpen, and the best
proof is how long he's done it.
In 2024, he had 21 saves in a 2-7-2 ERA. In 2025, he had 30 saves
in a 2.49 ERA. And in 2023, he had 30 saves in a 2.63 ERA.
In 2026, he pitched in 63 games,
Saved 30 of 33 chances.
He had a .89 whip,
which is in the 98th percentile among pitchers, and a .201 FIP.
He struck out 10.07 batters per 9 innings in 2026,
while the Giants' bullpen managed 6.1 in high leverage.
The fastball averages about 98 mph,
and he throws it about 65% of the time,
and he gets hitters to chase outside
the zone at a rate in the 99th percentile.
He also walked only 2.19 batters per 9,
and gave up only .15 home runs per 9 innings.
McGill signed for $4.7 million in 2026 and went 30 for 33.
On the Brewers, he was the guy who finished it.
Milwaukee went 55 for 76 in save chances,
and McGill had 30 of those 55 saves.
The one spot where hitters did get him was hard contact,
with 46.5% of balls in play hit hard, which is in the 13th percentile.
And that's the thing about a closer.
Even a good one has a few bad outings,
as his six blown saves in 2025 do show.
Voters noticed too, he finished 3rd
in the first ever NL Reliever of the Year voting,
behind Mason Miller and Johan Duran.
Compare that to Killian, the Giants' best closer option last year,
who had a 4.26 ERA and blew 3 of his 11 chances.
The Giants would go from a bullpen
that blew 27 saves to a closer who blew 3,
and that would change a lot of nights at Oracle Park.
Now, the part that doesn't work is what Milwaukee wants back,
and what the Giants would get for it.
On November 13th, Bob Nightingale said Milwaukee
is listening to offers for McGill.
A closer like that can bring at least one notable prospect,
MLB trade rumor says, and it projects him
at $8 million in 2027 before free agency.
Milwaukee also literally just won the World Series
with him finishing games, and they know what he's worth in October.
So the Giants would be handing a real prospect
or two to Milwaukee for one season of a closer
on a team that was outscored by 91 runs in 2026.
But a prospect the Giants send out is a player
who could be on the team for six years once
he reaches the big leagues.
And that's a cost you pay long after McGill's one season is over.
In 2024, he had 48 appearances and 21 saves.
And in 2021 and 2022,
he had ERAs of 837 and 480 for the Cubs and the Minnesota Twins.
With how bad their 2026 season went,
the San Francisco Giants can't afford to give up on
prospects that will help them in the future.
The Giants have one of the best farm systems
in baseball right now,
ranked 4th by Baseball America and 5th by MLB Pipeline, up from 19th
before the season. That is not a coincidence,
because Posey pointed to the farm system and
the draft when the Giants decided
not to chase players who got qualifying offers.
Posey also said, quote, it's hard to make trades,
it's hard to trade for pitching.
That tells you the Giants know the price of a trade,
and most of the time are not ready to pay it.
Think about what a closer is worth to a team
that is not going to win anything in 2027 anyways.
A win in the 9th inning is the same win in April,
and the Giants lost 97 games last year.
There are other ways to fix this rotation and bullpen,
and the Giants are already looking at them.
Another report on November 12th said San
Francisco has checked in on Freddy Peralta.
The Giants are also in the mix for left-hander Tim Hill,
John Hammond reported back on November 12th.
Those are moves the Giants can make with money,
and the farm system stays exactly where it is.
The Giants are not likely to chase players
who got a qualifying offer because that costs a draft
pick, Pavlovich reported on November 10th.
So they're already protecting draft picks,
and they should protect prospects at least as much.
If Milwaukee wants a real, legitimate
prospect for Trevor McGill, I would walk away.
But if it's a low-level arm or a player who's
not in the Giants' plans, then there's a conversation.
A trade for a closer only makes sense
when it costs the Giants nothing they'll miss in 2029.
Two things can be true at the same time. The Giants should want McGill,
but they should not give up a significant prospect to go get him.
I completely understand why Murray put the Giants and McGill together,
because on the numbers, it's one of the best fits in baseball.
They're the worst high leverage bullpen
with strikeouts and the 4th worst by ERA,
and there's a closer with a 10.07 strikeout rate
per 9 innings available.
However, the Giants just went 65-97 with a minus 91 run differential,
so the smart play is to spend dollars on the bullpen this winter
and keep every prospect that is going to matter
when this team is actually good.
To make it abundantly clear, I would say yes to the arm,
but I'd say no to the prospect price.
It makes zero sense to give up significant assets in your farm system
to go get a closer for one season before he walks in free agency,
and you're probably not going to contend anyways.
Now let me know down in the comment section below,
would you pay the prospect price for
Trevor McGill or hold on to your top prospects?
I want to hear what you guys think down in the
comment section below. And if you enjoyed today's video,
hit that like button, hit that subscribe
button. Thank you for watching.
