Jensen Huang’s Exit: Huang Le Spy Claims Unravel, Nvidia Rejects Musk-Led 100,000-Signature Appeal

China Insights
283 followers
Was there more behind Jensen Huang’s departure? This episode examines challenges to the spy allegations surrounding Huang Le, competing factions, and claims that Nvidia rejected a Musk-led appeal backed by 100,000 signatures calling for Huang’s return.
#JensenHuang #Nvidia #ElonMusk #HuangLe #ChinaInsights
Just two days after Jensen Huang stepped down,
the plot took a stunning turn.
Musk led the charge on a petition
with over 100,000 signatures demanding NVIDIA bring Jensen Huang back.
NVIDIA employees left over 1,600 comments
on the company's internal message board asking for his return.
However, the board flatly refused,
stating Huang will not cooperate with NVIDIA in the future.
Two bombshell reports today hint at office politics,
explaining why the board made such
a clean break from him. Even more dramatically,
the spy narrative used to take Jensen Huang down
is now starting to crumble.
The CIA says they can't confirm it yet, and the attorney general
says no one has called him a spy.
Even Trump said that if he isn't a spy, then that's a different story
So after all that, Huang isn't a spy.
Where did the original spy narrative come from in the first
place? And what does the internal conflict
at Nvidia have to do with Jensen Huang being
completely kicked to the curb this time?
Today we're going to uncover the answers to these
So these mysteries.
Before we start, I have some good news for my friends.
My new member-exclusive show, Black Box, is now live.
It's about the biggest Soviet mole
who infiltrated MI6 in the UK for 30 years.
For those who are already YouTube members,
don't forget to head over to my membership site,
Zenfei.club. That's Zenfei.club.
From now on, all my member-exclusive shows will be released there.
And from now until November 30th,
friends who join as members will get the first month free,
plus a special bonus gift package. What kind of gift?
I'll keep you in suspense for now. Let's look at the spy's origins.
The New York Times reported
U.S. intelligence monitored Huang Lei for a year,
discovering a close relationship with an American.
Per U.S. regulations,
American names in intelligence reports are initially redacted,
a process known as unmasking, to protect citizen privacy.
According to CNN's report, officials requested
to unmask the name after seeing the raw intelligence,
and that's when they discovered
this American was actually Jensen Huang.
This spring, before Trump's visit to China in May,
a classified memorandum was circulated among the
top levels of the Trump administration.
The Liu report stated that the memorandum cited
intelligence claiming Huang Lei was a spy
for the Ministry of State Security of the CCP.
recruited to gather intelligence on Jensen Huang.
And the person spearheading this memorandum
was none other than Secretary of State
and National Security Advisor Rubio.
Later, this memorandum was leaked.
Then, on October 29th,
the Times was the first to expose
that Huang had been identified by U.S. intelligence agencies
as an intelligence asset for the CCP.
On November 6th,
it disclosed the contents of this memorandum.
The Financial Times later exposed their romantic relationship.
On November 8th,
Jensen Huang admitted fault and resigned four days later.
Based on available info,
the earliest Trump administration identification of Huang Lei
as a CCP asset and his link to Jensen Huang was that spring memorandum.
Then, starting at the end of October, report after report came out.
And in just two weeks, Jensen Huang was completely finished.
But just in the last 24 hours, the plot has taken a shocking turn.
CNN reported that CIA officials are still
not certain whether Huang Lei is a spy.
This means the intercepted communications only show
that Huang Lei and Jensen Huang
have a close relationship, but they cannot prove that Huang Lei
consciously passed information he obtained
from Jensen Huang to Beijing.
Next is Attorney General Garland.
He said you are assuming that the Department
of Justice has confirmed he is a spy.
No one has said that and I certainly haven't said that either.
In other words, the Department of Justice is still investigating.
There's no conclusion yet as to whether Huang Lei is a spy.
Then there's Trump.
ESPN commentator Smith asked him, should Jensen Huang resign?
Trump said the key is whether that woman is actually a spy.
I don't know if there's a definitive answer on that point.
If she is a spy, then resignation is appropriate.
If she isn't a spy, then perhaps it's a different story.
The implication is that if Huang Lei isn't a spy,
then maybe there's no need for Jensen Huang to resign.
After all this, it seems even within the Trump administration,
they can't confirm that Huang Lei
is a spy. Then what about that memo from before that said he was a spy?
The Washington Post,
citing a latest revelation from an informed source,
says that the memo Rubio relied on was
based on a CIA report,
but Rubio rephrased the CIA report using his own tougher language.
In other words, according to this source,
it was Rubio who first branded Huang Lei a spy.
The premise, of course, is that this revelation is true and credible.
At the G7 in Paris, reporters pressed Rubio on his role,
but he refused to comment.
The Washington Post reports that bipartisan officials and think tanks
have long tried to undermine Huang Ren-sen's influence
on Trump's China policy.
Huang Ren-sen stepping down is a huge victory for them.
Whether Huang Ren-sen should resign is debated,
prompting many to defend him.
Now Trump's former AI czar
and current PCAST co-chair Sachs has stepped up.
He posted on X that the spy narrative is already collapsing.
He said the only crime that is certain in this whole affair
is that someone leaked that confidential memo.
He's demanding an investigation into the leak,
questioning its source and motive.
Singapore's Home Affairs Ministry also countered the spy narrative,
stating that since February 2025,
they've been investigating Wang Lei's company, Megaspeed,
for false declarations on server purchases,
clarifying Wang Lei is not under investigation for espionage.
The statement also criticized the U.S.,
noting that Singapore's repeated requests for help
have yielded little information. Clearly, they're dissatisfied.
Espionage is a legal charge requiring
solid evidence, while intelligence assessments
are often just pieces of a puzzle. We have no
way of knowing how U.S. intelligence agencies gathered evidence.
While it's technically true
True, he hasn't been confirmed as a spy.
Failing to convict him of espionage doesn't mean Huang Lei is innocent.
Singapore's statement noted
that while police lacked sufficient evidence to convict Huang Lei,
he lied during questioning, gave false information,
and deliberately downplayed his role in Megaspeed.
His company also bought billions in NVIDIA chips,
but their current whereabouts remain a mystery.
We previously detailed
the Shanghai state-owned asset background of her and her husband,
Kang Wei. Though Shanghai police detained
Kang Wei before the Spring Festival,
he has since been released.
Bloomberg reports Huang Lei has safely returned to Beijing.
He lied to police, is backed by CCP's state capital,
And handled chips with unknown destinations, likely sent to the CCP.
He also used a honey trap on Jensen Huang
to lobby the U.S. to relax chip controls.
There is no doubt that Huang Lei is carrying out the will of the CCP.
So, this raises another question.
Why has the spy narrative started to loosen at this time?
One possibility is that the evidence wasn't solid enough to begin with.
Intelligence that was perhaps not yet fully verified
was, through layers of media retelling,
directly simplified into the claim that Huang Lei is a CCP spy.
The current statements from the CIA and the Department of Justice
are simply pulling the whole investigation back
to the starting point of suspicion.
The Trump camp may be split between two competing factions,
anti-China hawks like Rubio,
Treasury Secretary Besant, and congressional allies.
Back in May, activist Loomer
rolled to the White House and Defense Department
questioning Jensen Huang's ties to Tsinghua University
and alleging he was involved in a major scandal.
Later, short sellers exposed the link
between Huang Lei and Jensen Huang,
while Silicon Valley's tech faction,
like Sachs and Musk, opposed them.
The Washington Post reports that Jensen Huang's
stepping down is a win for Hawks.
Tech insiders, however, see it as a shame.
They're now investigating the media leak.
Alternatively, the White House may be de-escalating.
Trump was briefed on this last year, but didn't warn Jensen Huang.
As the spy narrative grows, public pressure will mount.
If the White House knew, why did they do nothing?
This hurts the administration,
especially with a Democrat-controlled Congress taking office in
January. The Wang case will be their first major target,
putting the Trump administration under
immediate pressure. That's why the attorney general said
that no one has called him a spy.
Schrunk saying he doesn't know if there's a conclusion yet might
also be an active attempt
to cool down the situation.
So friends, why do you think this spy narrative is starting to soften
And at this moment.
If you think it's because
the evidence wasn't solid enough to begin with, type 1.
If you think it's because there are two factions
in the Trump camp battling it out, type 2.
If you think it's more likely that the White House
is actively toning things down, type 3.
Leave a comment and let me know your take, friends.
Once this spy narrative started to soften,
calls of support for Jensen Huang began to rise.
A website called Stand With Jensen Huang has launched an open letter to
the NVIDIA Board of Directors titled 33 Years Deserves an Explanation.
The letter makes three demands.
Reinstate Jensen Huang before an independent investigation
clarifies the facts,
disclose the scope and timeline of this investigation, and release
the board's evidence. A line in the letter resonated with many.
33 years of leadership
doesn't exempt him from accountability,
but Jensen Huang deserves due process, not a trial by media.
By now, the petition has topped 100,000 signatures,
including 5,000 from NVIDIA staff, and Elon Musk is leading the effort.
He posted on X that he signed the petition to reinstate Jensen Huang.
His post has over 7 million views.
Other Silicon Valley leaders,
including the CEOs of Epic Games and Coursera, have also signed.
Inside NVIDIA, things have blown up.
A Wired report reveals an internal suggestion box post calling
for board accountability has drawn over 1,600 comments.
Employees even emailed the company demanding
the truth about Jensen Huang's departure, declaring,
I stand with Jensen Huang. If the U.S. fails the man
who forged its future, the world doesn't deserve him.
Reports suggest hundreds of employees signed
a letter threatening to leave for Musk's companies
if the board doesn't reinstate Jensen Huang.
They claim Musk guaranteed them spots,
but since only one Hong Kong outlet has reported this,
we should take it with a grain of salt.
Amidst this outcry, many long-time employees
and partners have also shared stories of their
time working with Jensen Huang.
Jensen Huang has a well-known habit. He requires all employees
across the company to write a five things email every week,
clearly stating the five
most important things they are working
on and what they have observed in the market.
According to the book NVIDIA Way,
he reads about a hundred of these emails
every day. He often replies to emails in just a few minutes
and also requires employees to
respond to emails within 24 hours at most.
NVIDIA's former secretary said that Jensen Huang
doesn't procrastinate on anything and nothing ever gets stuck with him.
People outside the
company have also deeply experienced this.
The founder of the AI startup Playground AI
said that his company had been plagued
for several weeks by a bug in an NVIDIA driver.
In the end, he tried sending an email to Jensen Huang,
and the bug was fixed within 12 hours.
He marveled that despite NVIDIA's 30-year history,
Jensen Huang still acts like a scrappy entrepreneur.
When two engineers called late at night to nervously resign,
Jensen didn't try to stop them.
Instead, he helped name their new company, encouraging them
while warning that entrepreneurship is harder than they imagined.
Now, two NVIDIA investors, Brad Gerstner of Altimeter and Gavin Baker,
have written to NVIDIA's board of directors,
urging them to take their time in finding a new CEO
and to keep the door open for the possibility of Jensen Huang's return.
However, the attitude of NVIDIA's board
of directors has effectively put an end to any such hopes.
Jensen Huang will not be working
with NVIDIA in any capacity in the future.
The board stated that they are working
with an executive search firm to find a new CEO,
leaving absolutely no room for negotiation.
Why did NVIDIA's board of directors make such
a clean break from Jensen Huang this time?
As we discussed in our last episode, including this instance,
it's the first time NVIDIA has appointed a chairman of the board,
which signifies that the entire board has reclaimed power
from the founder's hands.
Of course, there's the reason of the scandal,
and the board may also have judged
that Jensen Huang's troubles are far from over.
Most recently, another point has come to light,
which is that Jensen Huang deceived
the board regarding the Huang Lei matter.
Last October, he sent two messages to NVIDIA's senior management,
stating that his interactions
with Huang Lei were merely normal business dealings between clients.
That is why NVIDIA's chief legal officer later called
the U.S. Department of Commerce
to inquire about Huang Lei being detained in Singapore.
For those who aren't familiar with this matter,
you are welcome to watch our previous episode
where we covered it in detail.
There's another reason that also came to light in the past 24 hours,
which is that within NVIDIA,
there were already two factions wrestling for power.
The Wall Street Journal reported that this August,
during a meeting with senior financial
executives, Jensen Huang interrupted
the presentation by the CFO, Chris.
The same Chris who is now succeeding him as NVIDIA's CEO.
He said he was like a deer in the headlights,
just stunned and at a loss for what to do.
He also said that he was just the CFO
for a company experiencing explosive growth and
couldn't help him set strategy.
Why was there such a big disagreement between them?
I specifically looked into it
and it mainly comes down to Nvidia's strategy.
Let me use an analogy to make it easier for everyone to understand.
Real estate developers, in order to sell these properties,
would act as guarantors for the
homebuyers, allowing them to get loans from the bank.
In the end, the houses were sold and the books looked great.
But what happens if the homebuyer can't pay back the loan?
The entire risk then falls on the developer who provided the guarantee.
NVIDIA is like that developer, and the houses represent the chips.
The homebuyers are companies like OpenAI
and those involved in AI computing power.
NVIDIA acts as a guarantor for these companies,
investing money in them so that they can afford
to buy NVIDIA's chips.
And the largest of these is a financial guarantee
of up to $250 billion for OpenAI's data center
in Ohio.
Why would Jensen Huang do this?
The Wall Street Journal reports
that major cloud providers are seeking alternative chips
as NVIDIA has already secured massive wafer and memory supplies.
This is critical because AI chip supply chains,
specifically TSMC's packaging and SK Hynix
memory, are currently facing extreme shortages.
So, in order to lock in this supplier capacity
and prevent competitors from snatching it up,
NVIDIA needs to sign long-term and large-volume procurement agreements
with upstream suppliers in advance.
In other words, NVIDIA has actually already ordered
a massive amount of stock.
If their downstream customers don't buy it,
this inventory will pile up and won't sell.
So they simply provide financing to their customers,
enabling them to buy their products.
So what Chris is worried about is whether
these customers can actually afford to pay.
Therefore, regarding the OpenAI deal,
he spent a few weeks renegotiating,
and in the end, he managed to cut that guarantee commitment
in half from the initial $250 billion.
Not only that, but he also began reviewing some
of the company's internal credit guarantee
arrangements. And the person
who handled these guarantees was none other than Jensen Huang's
son-in-law, who is now an NVIDIA vice president.
Capisce? So you see, Jensen Huang plays the role
of the one stepping on the gas pedal within NVIDIA,
while Chris plays the role of the one
stepping on the brakes.
Now that the one who was stepping on the brakes is in charge,
There is a potential chain reaction risk here.
If the new CEO, Chris, tries to pull back those financing guarantees,
then the companies that relied on Nvidia
for blood transfusions will have to go borrow money on their
own because Nvidia isn't providing financing anymore.
And if they can't borrow money,
they'll likely have to cut back on their purchases
or even stop buying chips altogether.
Once they stop buying,
it will backfire on Nvidia and Nvidia's revenue will drop.
This reminds people of Intel in 2018.
In June, Intel CEO Brian Krzanich suddenly resigned due
to a past employee relationship
that violated company policy.
His successor was the company's CFO,
Bob Swan, who first served as interim CEO and
was made permanent six months later.
Krasanich himself was an engineer by trade,
having worked his way up step-by-step within
Intel's chip factories.
Bob Swan, on the other hand, was a pure finance guy.
After he took office,
Intel's focus shifted to controlling costs,
buying back stock, and making the financial
reports look good.
However, persistent technology delays culminated in 2020,
when Intel announced another setback,
causing its stock to plummet 16% in one day.
That same year, Apple ditched Intel for its own custom chips.
Meanwhile, Intel fell behind TSMC in manufacturing,
while AMD steadily chipped away at its market share.
In 2021, Intel had no choice but to replace Bob Swan
and bring back Pat Gelsinger,
who had an engineering background, but it was already too late.
One year after Krzanich stepped down,
Intel's stock price was already trailing
the broader market by 17 percentage points.
Of course, today's Nvidia and the Intel of back
then are not exactly the same.
When Intel changed leadership back then,
They were actually already lagging behind technologically,
but today's NVIDIA chips are still the best in the world.
Krez is also serving as NVM's CEO.
The board of directors is currently looking for a permanent successor,
both inside and outside the company.
But one thing is the same.
Those who are good at crunching numbers may
not necessarily be able to manage the technical roadmap.
Whether NVIDIA will repeat Intel's tragedy depends
on who its next CEO is.
Another point worth noting
is that Jensen Huang's departure will impact Taiwan's supply chain
in the short term. We've seen this before.
His expansionary approach involves placing
massive orders, signing long-term contracts,
and pushing suppliers to scale up production.
Taiwan's supply chain fears NVIDIA's new
CEO may lack Jensen Huang's aggression,
leading them to reconsider production expansion.
Still, I believe the long-term impact on Taiwan
will be minimal.
When Jensen Huang resigned, NVIDIA stock plummeted,
but competitor AMD surged 7%, and Broadcom rose 5%.
Money didn't leave AI, it just shifted from NVIDIA to rivals.
And regardless of whether it's Nvidia, AMD,
or chips designed in-house by Google or Broadcom,
they all ultimately have to be manufactured by TSMC.
As for the servers, they are still
assembled by Taiwanese firms.
Orders might be redistributed among these clients, but
they won't leave Taiwan.
However, for the CCP, this pain will be very significant.
Reuters reported that over $3 billion worth
of Chinese AI computing projects
that rely on restricted NVIDIA chips now face an uncertain future.
As we've mentioned in our previous episodes,
Jensen Huang has been actively lobbying in Washington
to ease the restrictions on chip exports to the CCP.
With him out and a risk-averse CFO taking over,
plus bipartisan pressure in Congress
to tighten chip defenses, those barriers are bound to keep rising.
And in fact, NVIDIA's market share in China is already shrinking.
Bernstein estimates that in 2024, it was around two-thirds,
but by 2026, it will drop to about
8%.
So it's foreseeable that the door for NVIDIA
to provide special chips to the CCP
is basically going to be welded shut.
At this point, as the Jensen Huang scandal has developed,
it seems that both those who support him
and those who oppose him have already taken their sides.
Where will Jensen Huang go from here?
Is it still possible for him to return to NVIDIA?
Leave a comment with your thoughts. On the downside,
NVIDIA's stance is clear and the board is already seeking headhunters.
Jensen Huang holds only 3.6% of shares
and NVIDIA lacks special founder voting rights.
A simple board majority can remove the CEO, limiting his influence.
However, he's supported by strong voices from employees,
Google, and shareholders.
If the spy claim really doesn't hold water,
then Trump's remark might be a different story.
It could potentially become an opening.
Currently, traders on the prediction market PolyMarket
are betting that there's a 31% chance
of Jensen Huang returning to Nvidia by the end of 2027.
So friends, do you think Jensen Huang
will return to Nvidia? If you think he will, type will for me.
If you think he won't,
type won't. And please share your reasons
with all of us in the comments section.
Next, there are a few key dates worth keeping an eye on.
In three days, on November 17th,
NVIDIA will release its first earnings report without Jensen Huang,
the first time in 33 years.
Chris will be leading the presentation as CEO for the first time,
and whether he announces a scaling back
of guarantees is the biggest thing to watch.
Also, how Chris performs will be a signal
that the outside world is paying close attention to.
From the 18th to the 19th, there's the Trump-Xi meeting in Shenzhen.
How will Trump play this chip card against Xi Jinping?
Also before Thanksgiving,
Jensen Huang will testify behind closed doors in Congress.
What will inevitably be asked is his relationship with Huang Lei
and the role he played
in the entire mega speed resale of American chips.
This is something that is very worthy of our attention.
And regarding the leak incident that Trump's former AI czar,
Sachs, wanted to investigate, the incident where this memo was leaked,
will that investigation continue?
All these deserve our attention.
Subscribe to TrueView and watch this drama unfold with us.
This drama will likely stay hot until early next year,
when the Democratic Congress launches
its first major case against the Trump administration.
Subscribe to TrueView to follow along,
and please consider joining my membership site
at zenfei.club. The club? The first month is free.
Fans should join because all my future exclusive content will be there.
As for YouTube memberships, if you are already a YouTube member,
please be sure to move over
there.
Also, with the holidays approaching,
for those of you looking to pick out great gifts for
yourselves, friends, and family,
be sure to join my membership because you can enjoy even
bigger discounts than non-members.
All right, that's all for today. Thank you all for watching.
What do you think about Jensen Huang's next move?
Leave a comment and share with us.
All right, that's all for today. Thanks for watching, everyone.
Before you go, please like this video if you enjoyed it.
New viewers, subscribe to Zhen Guan Dian and share with friends.
Every interaction
helps the YouTube algorithm so more people can see my work.
I'm Zhen Fei. Thanks for watching.
Have a great weekend
and join us again tomorrow right here on ZenGuanDian.
See you then.
