Giants next move LEAKED...

SF Giants Digest
2 followers
Nov 16, 2026
Dustin May started two World Series games for Milwaukee this October.
He'd been traded to the Brewers three months earlier
and had opened the season with a 15.95 ERA through two starts.
Now, he's a free agent, and one report says
the Giants are in the market for him.
The Giants lost 97 games,
and only two starters are locked into next year's rotation.
For two months this year, he looked like a different pitcher.
The other four months, he looked like a guy
who got traded two summers in a row.
So, is Dustin May a smart upside swing for the San Francisco Giants,
or one more arm that doesn't change anything?
Here's where all of this started.
Jim Bowden posted that the market for May is blowing up,
with nine teams in play and the Giants being one of them.
The entire list is the Cubs, Nationals, Orioles, Giants,
Reds, Guardians, Marlins, White Sox, and Blue Jays.
Now, it is Jim Bowden, so take that with a grain of salt.
And three days earlier, John Morosi had the Astros, Cubs,
Padres, and White Sox in on May, with no Giants on the list.
MLB trade rumors added that the Miami Marlins
are a team also considering him.
Fox Sports has him 36 on its list of the top 50 free agents
and calls him a rare upside arm in a thin pitching class.
Meanwhile, Milwaukee isn't expected to bring him back,
and a St. Louis reunion isn't expected either.
What isn't a rumor is the price tag.
Spotrac's market value has May at three years and $46.2 million,
which is $15.4 a year.
Ryan Clary doubts that he gets 3 years
with his recent production, and I'd have to agree,
but his stuff is still good.
St. Louis gave him one year $12.5 million last December,
so he's asking for a raise
on a 4.70 ERA.
That only makes sense if the good version
of him is real, so which one is it?
Let's start with the calendar, because his season came in pieces.
He opened the year with an ERA just under 16 through 2 starts,
the worst by a Cardinal since 1995.
March and April were rough,
with a 5-2-8 ERA and hitters hitting 333 against him.
May and June were the complete opposite though,
a 3-8-6 ERA and then a 3-5-7 ERA.
From April 5th to June 11th, he had a 2-8-9 ERA,
over 65 and a third innings.
His FIP in that stretch was a 2-8-6,
the 9th best mark in the major leagues.
Really quickly, if you haven't yet,
make sure to go down below and hit that subscribe button.
About 66% of you guys watching these videos
are not actually subscribed to the channel.
It's completely free, takes just a second of your time,
and would be greatly appreciated by myself
and everybody here at Digest Media.
The reason was home runs.
He gave up .62 per 9 innings this year after 1.59 in 2025.
His strikeout rate went up to 21.9% from 19.5% in 2025.
His walk rate also dropped to 6.6% from 9.8%.
Then July brought 13 walks in 25.1 innings.
And August was worse,
a 6-4-1 ERA with a 4.59 slugging percentage against him.
The split by team tells the same story, he had a 4.38 ERA
with St. Louis, and a 5-6-5 ERA after the trade to the Brewers.
Milwaukee still handed him the ball for Game 2
and Game 4 of the World Series, so somebody there saw the upside.
That second half,
he had a 4.96 ERA against a 4.55 in the first half, so very similar.
His season FIP was 3-6-3 against a 4-7-0 ERA,
so the pitching was better than the results would indicate.
In September and October, he threw 17 innings with a 4-7-6 ERA,
so how the arm looks this
winter is a real question mark.
The results are absolutely mixed, but the stuff is the real argument.
In terms of stuff plus where 100 is league average,
he's still above average in the
majority.
His sinker grades 113, his slider 111,
his curveball 106, and his fastball 103.
Everything is above average except two pitches,
the cutter at 88 and the changeup at 85.
The changeup is the one he almost never throws, 6.1% of the time.
Hitters had a .384 wOBA against it,
and he mostly saves it for left-handed hitters.
In 2025, he threw it just .8% of the time.
Overall, in 2026, his stuff plus ranked at 102, up from 98 in 2025.
Prior to his injuries,
his stuff plus was a 119 in 2020 and a 117 in 2023, so 102 is
nowhere near his peak.
In 2021, with the Dodgers, he was a 133.
That's the type of ceiling and upside that people are betting on.
His pitching plus was 106 this year and 95 in 2025.
The fastball does sit at 96.9 miles an hour, up from 95.4 last season.
He's also rebuilt how he pitches.
His sinker was 33.6% of the time in 2025, and it's down to 20.1.
His slider dropped from 39.3% to 17.7%,
and the four-seam fastball went up to 24.8%.
He's throwing the hardest pitch in his mix more,
and again, that grades out at 103.
The catch with Dustin May is the contact.
He allowed a hard hit rate of 52.3%
in the third percentile of big leaguers.
Nasty stuff and hittable results,
that's why teams call it upside.
Now the part that scares people. May has had Tommy
John surgery twice in 21 and 23.
The second time, the surgeon also repaired a torn flexor tendon.
In July 2024, he tore his esophagus while eating a salad.
From 2021 through 2024, he threw just 101 innings in the big leagues.
Elbow neuritis shut him down for most of September in 2025.
So 145.2 innings in 2026 matters.
It's more than he threw from 2021 through 2024 combined.
That's the argument for him because he's healthy right now,
but it's also the argument against him
and against giving him three years.
May came up with the Dodgers in 2019
and was a Dodger until July of last year.
Since then, it's been Boston, St. Louis,
and Milwaukee, four uniforms in two seasons.
Signing with the Giants would be full circle,
a kid that came up as a Dodger,
returning to the NL West as a rival Giant.
One of the pluses with Dustin May is,
of course, there's no qualifying offer,
so there's no draft pick that will need to be paid when you sign him.
Buster Posey has suggested
that they'll most likely stay away from guys with the QO.
At $12.5 million last year, he was a bet.
At $15 million a year, the bet gets more expensive.
Now, let's look at what the Giants need.
They went 65-97 with a negative 91 run differential.
As of right now, Logan Webb and Landon Roop
are the only two starters most likely locked in for the 2027 rotation.
Wizenhunt, McDonald,
and Tidwell are all out for 2027 after having Tommy John surgery.
Webb led the staff with 160.2 innings and a 4-3-1 ERA.
Rupp threw 155 innings with a 4.01 ERA.
Hauser had a 4.02 ERA, is owed around $11 million in 2027,
and he will most likely take up a rotation spot.
Buster Posey's own words were that the Giants have
to be realistic about where they are right now.
Realistic means a 65-97 team doesn't need a 3-year deal on pure upside,
it needs innings it can trust.
May made 31 starts this year,
and the Giants have a hole in 3 rotation spots.
Put May at $15 million and Bubic at around $12 million,
and that's $27 million for 2 starters.
Devers makes more than that alone.
So what deal makes sense?
In my opinion, nobody should give May 3 years.
I like the contract that St. Louis gave him last year.
One year, with an option, so the Giants keep him only
if the good months are real.
Justin Verlander pitched for the Giants in 2025 on a one-year deal,
and that's the same shape of bet.
He left for Detroit the next year, then retired,
and the Giants didn't owe him anything past 2025.
It's similar to what the Giants tried
to do with Tyler Mowry this past year.
It was a play on pure upside,
and it simply didn't work out for San Francisco.
If May flops on one year, the Giants lose one season.
If he flops on three, they lose the next three.
That's the real case for the swing.
The risk is small, and the ceiling
is a number three starter in your rotation.
I will say, a rotation that needs three starters like the Giants
can't afford to take a swing on upside,
especially when you're not considered to be contending next season.
That's why a guy like Chris Bubich matters just as much.
Bubich had a .255 ERA over 116.1 innings with Kansas City in 25.
He had 116 strikeouts and 39 walks that year.
His WHIP was 1.18, which is the kind of line a team signs.
Last year he had an elbow problem
and only ended up throwing 55 innings between the Royals
and the Dodgers.
The Dodgers used him in 5 relief outings after the trade
and he didn't allow a run.
His fastball averaged 91.9 miles an hour on the season
and 93.7 over his last three outings.
That's a good sign on the health of the arm.
Bubic is a lefty and May's a righty,
so they give the Giants different looks.
MLB Trade Rumors does a pretty good job at predicting contracts,
and they predicted a one-year, $12.5 million deal for Bubic.
Ken Rosenthal and Will Simmons say contenders
and non-contenders alike are calling.
Alex Pavlovich of NBC Sports Bay Area
was at the GM meetings in Las Vegas, and on this
week's episode of Giants Talk,
he hinted that he feels pretty good about his pick for
Bubic to sign with San Francisco.
Bubic is from the Bay Area, Cupertino to be exact,
so there's a hometown pull there
as well.
Hypothetically, if both these deals come to fruition,
Webb, Rupp, Hauser, May, and Bubic
is the Giants rotation.
Now, it still isn't a contender,
but those two plays on upside make it a lot better,
especially considering what it looks like right now.
That rotation 1,000% gives the Giants
a better chance to win every single night
compared to what they were trotting out there
at the end of the 2026 campaign.
It also gives the front office something to build on.
These are two moves that make everything after them possible,
even if they don't make the Giants a contender in 2027 on their own.
I actually really like the idea of bringing
in a guy like Dustin May to the Giants rotation in 2027
because of the upside and how good the stuff has looked,
but I'll be clear here, it has to be at a
fair price. I would not do the three years deal
that Spotrac is predicting. The two good months
he had earlier in the 2026 campaign show
that there's still a very good pitcher in there,
and again, most of his stuff has graded out
as above average through the last two seasons.
Sure, there's been two Tommy Johns,
a 52.3% hard hit rate, but that's exactly why you don't
give him the three years that he wants.
So sure, this deal isn't going to make the Giants contenders
in 2027 or 2028, but if it works out,
you could even talk about extending a guy like Dustin May
who's been in four uniforms over the last two seasons
and probably looking for a home.
So let me know down in the comments
your thoughts on the Giants being in
on an arm like Dustin May according to Jim Bowden.
I want to hear what you guys have
to say down in the comment section below.
If you enjoyed today's video, hit
that like button, hit that subscribe button.
That'd be greatly appreciated by myself
and everybody here at Digest Media.
Thank you so much for watching.
