This Mets Trade Is INSANE...

Mets Digest
1 follower
Nov 15, 2026
The Mets need a starting pitcher,
and the lefty who keeps coming up in trade talks
just finished sixth in the American League Cy Young voting.
Reid Detmers threw 185 innings
for the Angels this season with a 3.36 ERA.
His 211 strikeouts were 7th amongst every starting pitcher
in baseball, a career high.
He's left-handed, he's cheap,
and the Angels control him for two more seasons.
At the August trade deadline,
the Cubs reportedly had a deal for him in place.
It fell apart over a physical, and the position player reportedly
headed to Anaheim in that deal was Jefferson Rojas.
Rojas is a Met now, right after the Detmers deal died,
Chicago sent him to Queens for
Clay Holmes and Tyrone Taylor.
So the question for David Stearns is whether you pay
the price the Cubs were almost going
to pay for a pitcher with really just one great season
as a starting pitcher.
That price has been sky high from the start.
The asking price for Detmers was astronomical
for every team, the Cubs included.
According to Peter Apple,
who also said talks never got close with anyone,
which doesn't match the Cubs report.
The Angels hoped somebody would overpay,
and if nobody did, they were happy to keep him.
They can afford to wait,
because Detmers is one of the best bargains in the sport right now.
He made $2.625 million this season,
after he lost his arbitration hearing in February.
His 2027 salary projects to be about $7.5 million.
And then he has one more arbitration year
before he can hit free agency after 2028.
A 185-inning lefty at that salary
is exactly what every front office wants,
which is why the price is never just one good prospect
in situations like this.
The Cubs' version of the deal was reportedly four players for two,
with pitching prospect Jackson Wiggins heading to Anaheim.
The Cubs reportedly signed off on Detmer's medicals.
Then the Angels turned down Wiggins' medicals,
and the deal died before it was ever made official.
And the Angels aren't in any rush to find a new trade partner.
Their old general manager, Perry Maniason,
just joined the Braves front office.
And as of last week, the Angels still
hadn't interviewed anyone to replace him.
With an ownership change looming too,
nobody is sure who will be running the front office
by the time a Reid Detmers deal gets done this winter.
So even the people pushing for this trade
have to admit what it would potentially cost here
and the looming uncertainty surrounding all of this.
Tim Britton of The Athletic made the case
for the Mets to go get Detmers in July,
and the Rising Apple writer reacting to it
said the problem is an obvious high cost to acquire him.
Mets writers have already started building the packages,
and they all start in the same place.
Rising Apple floated Francisco Alvarez as the centerpiece
because the Angels have reportedly been looking for young catching,
and even then said a one-for-one swap wouldn't be enough.
Heavy's version went even further.
Alvarez, Mark Vientos, Ronnie Mauricio, and Jonah Tong.
All for one pitcher.
Those are mock trades, not offers.
But they show you the shape of it.
A starting pitcher, a top arm like Tong, and even more.
And Rojas is the Mets prospect that the Angels
were reportedly lining up to get.
So expect his name to continue coming up here.
The front office already knows, though,
what happens when you pay that kind of price for a starting pitcher.
Go back to January.
The Mets traded Jet Williams
and Brandon Sprott to Milwaukee for Freddy Peralta.
Williams and Sprott were MLB Pipeline's number three
and number five prospects in the whole
Mets system. Peralta came with only one year of control at $8 million.
It was a Stearns move through and through,
because he's known Peralta since he ran the Brewers.
And it looked like a steal at the time.
It looked like a steal at the time, I should say,
because Peralta was coming off a 2.7 ERA over 33 starts in Milwaukee.
Then he posted a 4.99 ERA in 22 starts as a Met.
By the end of the season,
he was pitching for Tampa Bay with a 3.25 ERA over his last 10 starts.
So the Mets gave up two of their top five prospects.
Didn't even get a full season out of him.
Williams and Sproat are gone for good,
and the pitcher they brought in was in another uniform by September.
Last year's ERA doesn't come with the trade.
And if one year of an all-star like Peralta costs the Mets three,
their number three-ranked prospect
and their number five-ranked prospect,
two cheap years of Detmers will cost perhaps
a good amount more than that.
That's why the point about control matters.
The fewer years a pitcher has left,
the less the other team can ask for.
None of that means the Mets can sit still this winter, however.
Stern said it himself after the season.
Quote, I do think it is necessary for us
to add to our starting rotation, end quote.
The Mets finished with a 4.15 team ERA, 17th out of 30 teams.
Nolan McLean was terrific with a 3.16 over 31 starts.
Christian Scott and Zach Thornton helped in smaller roles,
but neither one got the 25 starts.
Behind them, Shamanaya finished up 4.78,
and Kodai Senga had a 7.34 ERA in his eight starts.
So the need is real.
The question is, which Detmers the Mets would actually
be paying for in a package like this?
Detmers has been a lot of different pitchers in the last five seasons.
He threw a no-hitter as a rookie in 2022
and finished that year with a 3.77 ERA.
In 2023, his ERA climbed to 4.48.
In 2024, it hit 6.7, over 17 starts,
and the Angels pulled him out of the rotation.
He spent all of 2025 as a reliever, with a 3.96 ERA in 61 games.
Then this year, back in the rotation,
he put up a 3.36 ERA, over 32 starts.
That's one great season as a starter,
and it's the exact season that the Angels are
selling here.
Even the Cy Young finish needs some context,
because 6th place came with 9 points, and
Cam Schlittler won it with 210.
From the Angels' side,
his value may never be higher than it is right now, coming off
his best year with two cheap seasons of control left.
And the workload is the part that worries me,
because he went from 63 and two-thirds innings
to 185 in a single year.
Before this season, his career high was 148 and two-thirds innings
back in 2023. That's a massive jump in workload,
and the bill for a jump like that can show up in the next season.
Hitters also caught up to him as games went on.
This season, a .463 OPS against him the first time through the order
jumped to a .661 OPS the third time.
To be fair to Detmers, the strikeouts are real.
His strikeout rate has climbed to 22.6%
of batters in 2022 to 28.5% this year.
So the stuff isn't a fluke.
But the Mets wouldn't be paying
for this season to happen two more times,
and his track record says it doesn't always repeat.
If you think the Mets should stay away
from another Peralta-style trade,
tap the like button and help this video beat this month's best.
Because if the Mets want an arm without paying the farm,
the market already has two of those types of guys.
Start with Michael King.
King opted out of his deal with the Padres,
news that broke on October 29th, and took a $5 million buyout.
King opted out of his deal after he threw 185 innings,
the same as Detmers this season, and with an even lower ERA of 3.21.
And unlike Detmers, he's done it before,
a 2.95 ERA over 173 and two-thirds innings in 2024.
Fox Sports ranks him as the number two free agent on the whole market,
behind only Tarek Skubal.
For the farm system, this is the part that matters.
King already got a qualifying offer from last winter,
so the Padres can't make him another one.
And signing him costs the Mets no draft pick,
no Rojas, no Tong, and no pick.
Just money.
And one thing that Steve Cohen has above anybody else
is those deep, deep pockets.
The risk with King is the length of a prospective deal
because he turns 32 in May and he's going to want years.
But he had a bad final year on the contract costs with Cohen's money
and a bad trade cost the Mets prospects they never get back.
That is to say, if Michael King has a bad final year,
the Mets will be in a tougher position than
a lot of other teams would be.
And then there's a name that Mets fans already know,
and that is Clay Holmes.
They could get Clay Holmes for nothing but money this time.
Three years and $38 million
was the contract they signed him to in December of 2024.
In 2025, his first season as a starter,
Holmes made 31 starts with a 3.53 ERA.
This year, he had a 2.39 ERA through
his first nine starts before he fractured his fibula back in May.
The Mets traded him to the Cubs at the deadline anyway,
and he finished the year at 3.29 over 18 starts.
He declined his player option with Chicago, so he's a free agent now,
and is reportedly more than open to coming back to Queens.
The Cubs would love to bring him back too,
so the Mets can't just sit on him all winter.
If Stearns would rather make a trade,
Nathan Eovaldi is the one to go for.
Texas has one year left on his deal, and he has a full no-trade clause.
His ERA did go from 1.73 in 2025 to 4.20 this year,
the same kind of drop the Mets watched
from Peralta.
So Eovaldi only makes sense if Texas treats it as a money move,
not a prospect grab.
And every one of these options sits next
to the Tarek Skubal meeting the Mets already have
on the calendar. If the Mets do indeed land Skubal,
they will still need one more arm.
If they miss, they need two.
Neither one should cost top prospect Jefferson Rojas.
Which brings me to where I land on this Reid Detmers' trade proposal.
Line up all four arms that are being talked about
with the Mets by 2026 ERA alone,
and the two free agents sit on top.
Detmers is right behind them, and Eovaldi is last.
I say you gotta pass on Detmers, given the price that we're seeing
based on the reports from the Angels.
One great year as a starter, two years of control.
They're going to want Jefferson, Rojas, and more.
They just will.
Freddy Peralta already cost the Mets Jet Williams and Brandon Sprotte,
and he was gone by September.
I think you have to go for Michael King first.
He pitched those same 185 innings.
Put up a 3.21 ERA, and he only costs money.
Holmes will be the fallback.
Eovaldi, only as a salary trade.
But, what would you guys do?
Would you trade the prospects for Reid Detmers right now,
or would you sign Michael King?
Let me know in the comments, guys.
Comment below, let me know, and as always, let's go Mets.
