Wood vs Carbon Arrows

Shatterproof Archery
117 followers
We are for you - Stay Shatterproof!
Archery Questions? We would love to help: [email protected]
https://www.shatterproofarchery.com/
Shatterproof Archery is a small company located in Colorado Springs CO.
We are dedicated to helping more people enjoy more archery.
#shatterproof
#bowmaking
#traditional-archery
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video compares carbon and wood arrows across several performance and practical metrics. While carbon arrows excel in speed, penetration, and cost-effectiveness, wood arrows are praised for their aesthetic appeal, feel, and traditional connection to the sport.
Wood arrows versus carbon arrows, which is better?
My name's Kazdin with Shatterproof Archery.
Today we're gonna test how they feel,
how hard is it to set up, what's the penetration,
durability, speed, noise, and cost.
Let's get to the point.
The first thing you'll notice right out of the box
is that carbon arrows will already have a field point
or just have a field point that you can easily
screw on and screw off.
While wood arrows don't have a field point on it
just a tapered end.
Now it depends on the type of wood arrows you get,
but these ones already have a taper end,
but you'll still need a glue on the field point
versus just screwing on a field point.
For this test today, we're gonna be comparing
the carbon arrows we sell versus the wood arrows we sell.
The carbon arrows are 400 spine,
while the wood arrows are rated differently.
They're rated 45 to 50 pound.
The wood arrows are made out of western larch
and are 11 32nd in size.
Let's get both sets of arrows all set up
and ready to go.
With the carbon arrows, they're basically ready to go,
ready to be shot.
With the wood arrows, we need to glue on the tips
so that they're ready to go.
To glue on these wood arrow tips,
I'm using boning ferulatite.
How to put field tips on wood arrows.
If your arrows aren't already tapered,
you're gonna want them to be tapered.
Then you're gonna melt the glue
and put it on the wood arrow.
Next, you're gonna grab the field point with pliers
and heat it up.
Then you're gonna press it onto the arrow,
push it into a table or something like that,
make sure it's all good, dip it in water,
and then peel off the excess glue.
Now that we've got our arrows set up,
let's get into our first test, which is the field test.
How does it feel to shoot these?
I'm gonna shoot five arrows of each
and just see how it feels.
All right, on the field test,
they're both super fun to shoot.
They both feel really good.
The carbon arrows feel more like a bullet,
like a dart, like really fast,
whereas the wood arrows feel more solid,
like more like a missile.
167.8.
The carbon arrows are about 18 feet per second faster
than the wood arrows.
For our penetration test,
we've got a fresh target right here.
It's barely got any holes in it.
We're gonna shoot five shots with each arrow
and see how deep it goes into the target.
On our target test,
it looks like the carbon arrows
go at about half an inch deeper.
They're 516th carbon arrows,
about half an inch deeper than the 1132nd wood arrows.
Now for the accuracy test,
which is more accurate, carbon or wood arrows?
All right.
The wood arrows are three decibels quieter
than the carbon arrows.
Now for the durability test.
It might have survived.
Oh.
Okay, so we lost an insert.
Lost an insert.
Lost an arrow.
These arrows are invincible.
Oh man.
I should have glued it in.
Carbon rock test.
Oh my.
You got it.
Last chance university for carbon arrow.
Oh.
They just break differently.
Wood versus rock.
That was cool.
Bro, I still killed the deer.
Check this out.
The point broke off,
but look, it still went into the deer.
If you shoot a rock,
you get a little bit more carbon left.
The adjustability test.
This is how difficult it would be to adjust each of these.
First we'll talk about wood.
For wood arrows,
all you gotta do is heat up the field point
and it'll pop right off
if you use the glue that we used.
And then you can cut the arrow shorter.
You can basically use whatever saw to do that.
But then the one tool you do need is a tapering tool.
I guess you could do it by hand,
but there's like pencil sharpener looking tapering tools
to get this arrow ready to put the field point back on.
For carbon arrows,
adjustability is a little bit different.
To get the insert out,
the easiest way to do it that I know of
is to pop out the knock,
drop a drill bit in the back,
and then wham.
Is that not what you do?
Shoot into a piece of plywood.
Just shoot into a piece.
Actually, that'd be an easy way.
You can drop a drill bit in the back
and then whack it out.
And then to cut down a carbon arrow,
you probably need a more specialized saw.
Now for the cost.
For these arrows specifically,
the wood arrows are $129 for six of them,
while the carbon arrows are $59 for six of them.
Now if you're looking just in general at wood versus carbon,
you can get some really cheap wood arrows
that I probably wouldn't recommend.
I don't think they have a finish on them or anything.
But you can get some cheap carbon that I would recommend,
like maybe $36 for a half a dozen on Amazon,
stuff like that.
Now before I talk about who these are for,
let's talk about the final test,
which is which one is cooler.
And it's a pretty clear winner to me
that the wood arrows are way cooler than the carbon.
They just feel, it's like fly fishing.
For people who like, it's like the fly fishing,
or it's like traditional archery versus compound archery.
It's like wood arrows versus carbon arrows.
Depending on the wood arrow, wood arrows are so cool.
They feel more real, more substantial,
like you're connected to a branch
that's connected to the tree that's connected to the earth.
Whereas I don't know where carbon grows.
Yeah, it's easier to adjust wood arrows,
I would say, in length.
But if you're gonna leave them full length,
carbon's a bit easier to work with.
Because for tuning and for hunting,
you're able to quickly adjust field points.
Whereas this, it's still pretty quick,
but actually it is pretty quick still.
If you have heat, glue, water.
Hi-ya, hi-ya!
Oh!
I'm trying to film, bro.
Sorry.
Watch out, you have broken carbon.
