The TRUTH about strand count (D97 2--28 strand test)

Shatterproof Archery
117 followers
We are for you - Stay Shatterproof!
Archery Questions? We would love to help: [email protected]
https://www.shatterproofarchery.com/
Shatterproof Archery is a small company located in Colorado Springs CO.
We are dedicated to helping more people enjoy more archery.
#shatterproof
#bowmaking
#traditionalarchery
AI Generated·May contain errors
How few strands can you use on a bowstring? Nobody wants to just sit here and watch me make 12
strings so enjoy this sick montage of string building while I explain the context for this
video. I recently posted a video questioning Jake Kaminsky's recommendation on strand count.
He was recommending much higher strand counts than I have traditionally used. I asked you guys
Some of you said that the more strands increases energy while decreasing speed. Others said that
the more strands makes you more accurate. Others said that it protects your fingers from the string
and still others said less oscillation upon release makes a more accurate shot with more
strands versus less. So what is the truth? Does more strands really make you more accurate? Make
your bow quieter? Increase energy while decreasing speed? If this is true then changing your bowstring
could immediately make you a better archer. What is the truth? And that is why I'm making
12 strings. A 2 strand, a 4 strand, a 6 strand, an 8 strand, a 10 strand, 12 strand, 14 strand,
16 strand, 18 strand, 21 strand, 24 strand, and a 28 strand string so that we can test the
The string material I'm using for this test is D97. It stretches a little bit more than fast
flight and is my favorite string for hunting because it's a good mix of speed and smoothness.
I usually make my D97 strings at 14 strands. I would like to rule out some opinions. It's very
tempting like the idea that fewer strands is more harsh on the fingers because you have the same
nock size right so you got to pad the serving to make the serving the same size as it would be
with a thicker string so it's going to be the same on the fingers but I'm not going to do that. I'm
not going to rule anything out yet and we're going to run this test and see how it goes. For our test
I'm going to take nine shots with each string. I'm using a Black Hunter Longbow and for each shot
we're going to measure the noise, the speed, the accuracy, and the comfort of the string. Now I
know you don't want to watch hours of testing so enjoy this testing montage while I talk about
why we are testing the way that we're testing. I know some of you are thinking this is a completely
unscientific test and you are completely right. This is what I call a backyard test for backyard
archers. If there's a scientist out there that would like to help me and has a mechanical shooting
machine as well as a professional decibel meter that we could hook up to a directional microphone
and audio analyzer and then we could plug that into a speed microphone array and then we could
put it all in acoustic isolation booth with a high speed camera up to 5,000 feet per second
verified by a Doppler radar. We could also use a draw force curve analyzer and an accelerometer
or vibration sensor and we could use a pressure grip sensor and then we could plug it all into
a data acquisition system. If there's someone out there that has all that stuff I would love
their help. Shoot me a call at 719-232-1434. Unfortunately I don't have all of those tools
so what I'm doing is what I define as excellence which is doing the best I can with what I've been
given. All right let's analyze these results. Now before I show you the charts I'm just gonna say
some results are... I don't understand. Some of these results surprise me a lot.
So let's get into it. Let's first look at the speed the speed chart. So what I expected with
speed was that the fewer strands the faster it would go because there's less mass that the bow
has to push through the air and pull through the air and so it'd go faster which is what we saw to
an extent. It got faster up until 12 strands but then dropped off at 10. Kind of stayed low and
then came back up a ways at four strands which is really interesting on the speed. On the accuracy
what I've heard and kind of expected was that the more strands the more accurate. Obviously 28
strands is a ton of double what we usually do so didn't really expect much on that and that's kind
of what we saw is the more strands the more accurate. 28 was a big drop off and six strands
was a big drop off. It looks like our 16 strand string was the most accurate. That's very subjective
that's just how well I shot in nine shots and they were all pretty similar when you consider
it all the scores averaged out between eight and nine so most of them at eight and a half. So
accuracy kind of what we expected. Comfort that was just my arbitrary how did this feel to shoot
and what was really interesting is the only one that felt like not fun to shoot at all was the 10
strand string which is weird I was really scared to shoot the 8, 6, 4 strand. Oh and not to mention
the 2 strand. The 2 strand broke when we were stretching it on our stretching jig so we didn't
even test the 2 strand string but I was terrified to shoot the 8, 6, and 4 but they actually felt
better than the 10 and the 4 felt just as good as the 12 strand which is really really interesting.
Now before I show you the noise chart this is the one that doesn't make sense to me so
here's the noise chart it's got a double bell curve which what that means is either
one of two things one there's two sweet spots for not a lot of noise and that's at 16 strands
and 4 strands those would be the two sweet spots or if that's not the case
then there is some outside influence on the test that caused the double bell curve.
I don't know but what I'm tempted to do is go and test the 4 strand again and the 10 strand
because the 10 was the highest the most loud which was really interesting because it was also the
uncomfortable to shoot it didn't feel good and the 4 and 16 were the lowest so I'm wondering
if I should go test the 4 strand again and the 10 strand again and see if they were really that
different and how they sounded and also what it makes me want to do is try to build another 2
strand string that doesn't break um it's a bit sketchy really sketchy but in the if you're
looking at the chart the trend is that a 2 strand would be even quieter than a 4 strand
I I don't know why but that's what I'm seeing all right so here's what I'm going to do I'm
going to go retest the 10 strand the 4 strand and I'm going to try and make another 2 strand string
and test that one as well hopefully it doesn't blow up but just to verify this data are there
is 10 really that much worse and 4 actually a smooth shooting string I actually enjoyed
shooting the 4 strand string um is that really the case this is our 2 strand string hopefully
it doesn't blow up on us we're gonna try and put on the bow all right here goes nothing
2 strand 2 strand string 2 strand thank you hopefully it don't blow up am I nervous
that was actually not bad yep it shoots and it's actually kind of smooth
73.5 69.7 73.3 so yeah slightly above average quietest of them all what all right was the 10
strands still the loudest is my question here are the final results of the test this was so
because it was not what I expected don't understand it all but this is what we found
here's all the results on a chart for you to look at first thing you'll notice is that the
2 strand string was the quietest of them all which is insane I don't know if anybody would
have guessed that I don't know if anyone's ever shot a 2 strand string before surely someone has
but the fact that it's quieter than anything else is insane to me the loudest after retest so we
tested the 2 strand 4 strand and 10 strand and we added all that data together with our previous
data the loudest is the 8 strand and then another quiet point or sweet spot comes down to the 14
and then the 16 strand the 16 strand is the quietest the quietest realistic string because
I don't think anyone's going to shoot a 4 or 2 strand so the 16 strand is a sweet spot there
and then anything beyond a 16 strand 18 up had really no added benefit it wasn't really quieter
well it got louder and then it got quieter back at the 28 strand which just ridiculous but the
speed wasn't improved anything like that so anything more than 16 strands not really helpful
one thing to keep in mind though is this is d97 material don't don't get this confused because
different materials have different diameters so this test with a different string material
could be completely different this is only for d97 as far as speed the fastest was the 12 strand
and then 14 and 16 but is very similar and so between those 16 strands seems to be the best
because it's quieter and doesn't lose very much barely any on speed as far as comfortability goes
the 2 strand was so comfortable like what in the world it doesn't make any sense like it was
terrifying at first but it was really comfortable the 16 strand was also very comfortable accuracy
that it's the archer basically I'm pretty sure on all of that so those are the results thank you so
much for watching this video and I've got one last thing before I go if you notice the pun in this
video put it in the comments below if you get the pun that I am thinking of then I will send
you a hoodie for free from shatterproof archery the first person to get the pun there might be
multiple puns but there's one specific one that I'm thinking of thank you again stay shatterproof
and I'll see you on the next video
