تصمیمگیر فعلی در جمهوری اسلامی کیست؟ | گفتوگو با شایان سمیعی

Epoch Times Persian
88 followers
105 Video Views·Apr 21, 2026
آقای شایان سمیعی، کارشناس امنیت ملی، در گفتوگو با شهرزاد قانعی به بررسی این موضوع میپردازد که قدرت تصمیمگیری در جمهوری اسلامی در اختیار چه نهادی است؛ همچنین اختلافهای درونی این ساختار، مذاکرات روز چهارشنبه میان دولت آمریکا و جمهوری اسلامی، و تهدید جدید دونالد ترامپ به انجام حملات را تشریح میکند.
مخاطبین عزیز لطفا نظرات و پیشنهادات خود را برای ما بنویسید
سایت اصلی اپک تایمز فارسی
http://persianepochtimes.com
لطفا ما را در شبکه های اجتماعی دنبال کنید
اینستاگرام:
https://www.instagram.com/epochtimes_persian/
تلگرام :
https://telegram.me/EpochTimesPersian
توئیتر:
https://twitter.com/EpochTimesPer
فیسبوک:
https://www.facebook.com/EpochTimesPersian
Welcome to the program, dear viewers, from the Persian podcast. I am your honest host, and today's guest is Mr. Shayan Siami, National Security Consultant from Washington, D.C. Mr. Siami, welcome.
Greetings from the heart of Iran. I am grateful for your presence, noble ladies and dear people of Iran. Thank you for your hospitality.
Say a little about tomorrow's negotiations. On Thursday, negotiations are scheduled to take place between the Islamic Republic and the American authorities.
How likely is it that this time, meaning for the third time, you will do something that, in light of the ongoing negotiations, would provoke the Islamic Republic, just as you did twice before during this period?
You see, in the first place, we cannot rule out any unexpected moves or surprises from Mr. Trump. He has a strong penchant for such actions, and we've seen him do similar things in the past.
But the issue that matters here is that the presence of the American envoy in Islamabad itself constitutes a significant factor for the U.S. government.
His security detail is also a financial burden; whenever the U.S. president travels somewhere, at least 30 agents must go ahead in advance for security and protection purposes. They must be deployed to the location beforehand.
So the U.S. government is truly investing heavily in these negotiations. Now, the Islamic Republic keeps playing games—We're coming, we're not coming, we're not coming.
Since the Islamic Republic came to power, you've been using the excuse that someone among you must ultimately be the decision-maker. That old story—now we'll go back and consult with leadership—no longer exists.
If the Islamic Republic does not show up at the negotiating table, it will be worse for it. Because at that point, the U.S. will use that very absence to demonstrate to Europeans that, contrary to what you claimed, the issue cannot be resolved through diplomacy.
We are in the middle of the war, and despite having clearly and easily defeated the opposing side and seized all their military capabilities, we are still giving them opportunities—but these are not directly linked to any clear path.
Therefore, we now must carry out that difficult task, which in reality amounts to mobilizing the people of Iran to eliminate the Islamic Republic regime.
But it's certainly not impossible that Trump could disrupt everything in the middle of negotiations, or even trigger new attacks.
So that Mr. Trump himself reserves this right for his own use, as the Islamic Republic has repeatedly lied many times before.
By the way, there is no evidence from the Islamic Republic's own records supporting his claim.
Because even last month, the Islamic Republic told Mr. Ali Akbar Salehi that during the JCPOA negotiations, we informed the Americans that we would put the pipes you want into China for you.
We're taking these back, putting them in a museum; we didn't tell the Americans that we have these exact pipes and that we're replacing them—we've already done it.
When the United States faces individuals like these, it is difficult for it to remain firm in demanding that the statements made by the Islamic Republic be actionable, especially considering the real divisions currently existing within the male leadership of the Islamic Republic.
On one hand, the carpet weaver says we must negotiate, as we possess the military strength of America. On the other hand, Jaleel says he is ready to eat every single grain, even the yellow one, but he will never lend a hand to the enemy's rhetoric.
I'm also considering that if there's an opportunity to perform the act of strangulation or a surprising strangulation, I must not miss it.
How great is the difference among the positions of the Islamic Republic?
These analyses indicate that there are factions originating from the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and Vahidi, and others from Qalibaf and Mr. Aghaie.
But is there really a difference between them, or is this merely a matter of appearance?
I'm bewildered by this serious discrepancy—what's the reason? It's because up until now, there's been a single figure who unified all these elements and even possessed the authority, so to speak, to pull the strings behind the scenes: Ali Khamenei.
But when he's not around and no one has seen him, how does he know for sure whether she's really alive?
This power grab arises from individuals who, despite repeated attempts, have failed to attain high-ranking positions within the Iranian state.
So now, in the nearest opportunity, they're sending him. Qalibaf has attempted three times for the presidency, but failed. Or was it Vahidi who actually established the Qatari Savaq and later handed it over to Soleimani?
So these are people who have been active in the information and security ranks of the Islamic Republic, but each of them wants that position for themselves and seeks power for their own gain.
Qalibaf stated that if he can reach an agreement with the United States, he would even hand over centers such as Esteghlal, Vahidi, Zalghat, Radan, and Ejei to Americans and Israelis, in exchange for a certain number of land points.
On the other hand, Vahidi is constantly reinforcing within himself a sense of agency from Tehran, saying, "I am the decision-maker."
As we saw in the report, Vahidi said, "I am the only one who is in contact with the suspect, and I am expressing his viewpoints to the public."
So he wants to bring himself closer, but in my opinion, the person who is currently the real decision-maker in the Islamic Republic is Hossein Tabaib, due to certain information and intelligence he possesses, and because he is aware of all these developments.
The main decision-maker is currently staying at Camp Vahidi, as Camp Vahidi currently provides him with greater strength than the Islamic Republic system itself.
That is their belief, but in my view, this system has already lost its position, because it no longer possesses the standing and legitimacy it sought among the people—any such interest or attachment among the people has completely vanished.
That's enough. Please explain in greater detail why Mr. Taeib has become the person who currently holds the most power?
This leads us to a situation where, if there were any suspicion regarding Khamenei, they themselves would want to demonstrate it in this manner; thus, in effect, it is Hussein Taeib who, due to his acquired knowledge in intelligence and security, and because of his indifference toward the assassination of the heart—something he has consistently shown—demonstrates that nothing matters to him.
How many people or in what manner must be killed, and why should they be eliminated, just so that their objectives are achieved? But the most crucial point of all is the deployment and dominance of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps.
A system that the Sepah establishes behind the scenes will create a power base that neither Qalibaf nor Iraqchian can emulate on stage.
You see, Trump is actually trying to test the limits and see just how much pressure he can exert on the Islamic Republic.
Trump is actually telling them: if you truly want dialogue, genuine interaction, and a new regime in the literal sense, then you must avoid this destructive behavior.
I can even see from Shurbekhtane that the Islamic Republic government is due to those internal differences that exist.
One, two, three, or four, or all of these elegant ladies—just let them go to show off their power, to demonstrate that Ghalibaf is speaking for himself.
Ghalibaf does not hold the overall leadership position in the system, despite his presence there. Moreover, we know that even within the religious establishment, Ghalibaf is associated with Kazem Ghareebabadi, who is the son-in-law of Muhammad Baqir al-Zahabi.
Human rights have always been a point that the Islamic Republic has avoided. The Islamic Republic knows that by using force against the people of Iran, it has managed to maintain its power.
Now, what has changed is that they can read this human rights violation, and in fact, this is their greatest tool to intimidate and terrorize people, forcing them to stay indoors or abandon support for the government.
Your most important demand is for the United States to lift the sanctions entirely and truly guarantee that there will be no further aggression, in fact, it has already been an entire lifetime of suffering.
This news was disseminated to a river, which might have seemed more like they were trying to push it forward, now that the time has come for America to make a decision. How likely is it that the American government will decide to focus on the destruction of the river, or even completely obliterate it?
One of the actions taken by the United States regarding this issue is the implementation of gateway filtering—why?
Because through this financial manipulation, they managed to severely weaken Safah's economic power and resources to such an extent that Safah was no longer able to afford the expenses required to suppress the price hikes and shortages, which otherwise would have enabled them to confront the agents who terrorize the people in the streets at night.
Now we're having a conversation, but honestly, our power will never reach that of America, so we must think realistically.
This realistic thinking is precisely what subjugates ordinary people, making them surrender to the competition.
So why should we risk our lives for a task that transforms those forces here into forces of internal dissolution?
When they stay with themselves or use their own homes, or take advantage of people to benefit against other repressive forces.
In reality, they are helping people feel less afraid when facing the main rally, so they can go out into the streets and shout for the overthrow of the government.
Thus, we see that this cycle of dismantling or pressuring the Revolutionary Guards begins at the point where we eliminate the Guards' economic power.
I would like to mention another point right here: why does the Islamic Republic consistently refer to the two main principles in all its discussions?
Eliminate all sanctions—initial sanctions and snapback sanctions—by rescinding the Security Council resolution issued by the United Nations, as this issue either requires reinstatement or the removal of the snapback.
And let there be no obstacle for the Islamic Republic, and ensure the continued protection of the proxy forces; if the rulers of the Pahlavi regime in Iran truly cared about the Iranian people, they would say: "Let us move forward in accordance with the dignity and respect of the Iranian people."
Thus, we see that it is the Sepah of that Amoli who must truly be eliminated so that the people can attain freedom.
My brother, the latest news that just came in is that Trump said we must resume military attacks against the criminal Islamic Republic.
Why should there be a goal set for negotiation that suddenly brings such news on a cold day?
He's using two roads, Mr. Trump wants one, and he wants to keep the pressure high.
And tell them, and tell the Islamic Republic government, do not think that I am just another person.
Don't think that we have lost our military power, no.
My military power remains intact, but we are only giving you this final opportunity.
that in fact we sign this surrender letter
But if you don't do this either, we possess this military capability.
Dupon is also a display of power for the negotiation table.
That we remind you: the military regime is ours.
His ability is at our disposal.
You have now brought us to the shores of your own sea, even to Zanod.
So if you want to come, please come for negotiation.
With this perspective, let us proceed that we must
Set maximum and minimum requests.
The Islamic Republic is doing the exact opposite.
So I think this speech is from Mr. Trump
First of all, it's not really a holiday.
In Mr. Trump's own view
They are trying to intensify the pressure of that embargo even further.
And even tell the intermediaries
Don't think that we are showing you any favor here.
No
You must strive in this regard towards the Islamic Republic.
Understand the depth of the tragedy.
And now is when the situation becomes extremely difficult for Pakistan.
Then I'll take it from the time you left, and as much as you have left.
Mr. Shayed, their work is nationally toxic.
I wish you the best.
