Is Apple Butter Pie BETTER Than Pumpkin Pie?

Is Apple Butter Pie BETTER Than Pumpkin Pie?

S
11 Video Views·Mar 29, 2026  #applebutterpie #thanksgivingdessert #bakingwithdogs

Welcome back to Snow Dogs Cooking! If we can cook it, so can you! Today we are trying a viral recipe I found on TikTok for Apple Butter Pie. I read that this pie is supposed to be 10 times better than Pumpkin Pie. If you ask me, apple is the far superior flavor to pumpkin, so I have high hopes for this one!

We are making a creamy, custard-like apple pie using apple butter, and topping it off with a homemade maple cinnamon whipped cream. It's essentially the texture of a pumpkin pie but with the delicious flavor of apple. If you are looking for a phenomenal pie that is actually really easy to make for Thanksgiving or any other holiday, this is the one to try!

Ingredients

Refrigerated or Homemade Pie Crust
2 Cups Apple Butter
1 tsp Vanilla Bean Paste (for filling)
1 Can (14oz) Sweetened Condensed Milk
4 Eggs (Room Temperature)
2 tbsp Flour

For Topping
2 Cups Heavy Whipping Cream
1 tbsp Cinnamon
3 tbsp Maple Syrup
1 tsp Vanilla Bean Paste (for topping)

Tips and Tricks

🥧 Use a glass pie pan if you have one! It helps you see the crust and tends to bake more evenly, though metal works too.

🥚 Crack your eggs into a separate bowl first to avoid getting shells in your main mixture and to whisk the yolks lightly before adding other ingredients.

⏲️ Par-bake your crust! Put the crust in the pan and bake it at 350°F for about 7 to 10 minutes before adding the filling.

🍎 Taste your apple butter before measuring. Some brands are more "cloy" or sweet than others, so pick one you really enjoy since it's the main flavor profile.

🥶 Let the pie cool completely before serving! You want the center to be just slightly jiggly when you take it out of the oven, but it needs to set in the fridge (preferably overnight) for the perfect texture.

🍁 For the whipped topping, whip the heavy cream until you get stiff peaks for the best stability on top of the pie.

Kitchen Helpers

It wouldn't be Snow Dogs Cooking without the pack! Today, Memphis (the best kitchen helper ever) immediately assumed the position—lying belly up in the middle of the kitchen floor, refusing to move, and patiently waiting for a drop. Eleanor popped in to check on the progress (and to see if there were snacks yet), and of course, Greg showed up right on time for the taste test at the end!

We hope you guys enjoyed today's video! Let us know in the comments if you think Apple is superior to Pumpkin!

★FOLLOW US!
http://Instagram.com/SnowDogsCooking
http://Facebook.com/SnowDogsCooking

★Affiliate Links!
https://www.amazon.com/shop/gonetothesnowdogs

★SEND US THINGS
Snow Dogs Cooking
P.O. Box 12
Alpena MI 49707

If you send us taste test boxes, or food boxes, there is a good chance we will put them in a video!

★BUSINESS CONTACT
[email protected]

★About Us:
Cooking with the Snow Dogs ! Our cooking channel is all about cooking but in a fun and easy way! Not everyone wants to make fancy food, and not everyone knows how to cook! In fact, for the longest time, I thought I was a horrible cook! Cooking takes practice and we are going to help you learn how to cook! We will be showing you how to make dinners, how to make appetizers, how to make desserts, how to make breakfast, and how to make food in general! If you are looking for healthy cooking options, well we might not be the right place. We make food we love because we love food! We will always be joined by the dogs of Gone to the Snow Dogs, and the family and friends of Snow Dogs Vlogs as we cook in the kitchen with dogs!

We Love you all! Thanks for watching, Thanks for subscribing, Stay Positive, Dream Big, and we will see you again soon!
http://www.YouTube.com/SnowDogsCooking

#applebutterpie #thanksgivingdessert #bakingwithdogs #snowdogscooking #easyrecipes #fallbaking #pumpkinpiealternative #applepie #dessertrecipe #foodie #husky #huskylife #tiktokrecipe #holidaybaking #maplewhippedcream