What is your absolute favorite thing to cook outside on the Blackstone griddle? Leave your suggestions in the comments! Today I am heading outside to fire up my Blackstone griddle to show you how to make the ultimate Midwestern Cheesesteak Sandwich! If you are looking for an easy shaved beef sandwich recipe that cooks up in under 15 minutes, this simple outdoor griddle tutorial is for you. While these aren't traditional Philly cheesesteaks, my Midwestern twist features tender shaved steak, sautéed bell peppers, sweet onions, fresh mushrooms, and perfectly melted Swiss cheese piled high on toasted sub rolls. And yes, you don't need a Blackstone to make this, you can do this on your stove top as well!
Learning how to cook shaved steak on a Blackstone griddle or flat top grill is one of the quickest ways to pull together a delicious weeknight dinner! I walk you through every step of flat top griddle cooking, from staggering your vegetable prep so your onions, green peppers, and mushrooms turn out perfectly tender, to quickly searing shaved beef so it stays juicy and tender. Whether you are using a Blackstone grill, a flat top iron skillet, or a standard indoor stovetop pan, this homemade sandwich recipe can easily be customized to your taste.
Ingredients 12 to 14 oz shaved steak 1 whole green pepper 1 small onion 1/2 container fresh mushrooms 3 tbsp butter Olive oil Garlic salt Black pepper Swiss cheese (or Pepper Jack cheese) Hearty sub buns Garlic aioli or mayonnaise
Tips and Tricks 🥩 Pre-shaved steak from the grocery store (like Aldi) saves massive prep time, or ask your local butcher to shave it fresh for you. 🧈 Stagger your veggies when cooking! Start with onions first since they take the longest, add green peppers next, and finish with mushrooms so nothing gets soggy. 🥖 Toast your sub buns directly on the cooler edge of your flat top griddle for a quick, warm, crunchy texture without needing extra butter. 🔥 Cook your shaved steak over medium-high heat with a quick drizzle of olive oil to get a beautiful sear without overcooking or drying out the beef. 🧀 Melt the cheese directly over the meat and veggie pile on the griddle and close the hood/lid for 60 seconds for maximum melty goodness. 🌶️ Customization idea: Swap Swiss for Pepper Jack cheese if you want a spicy kick, or try your favorite steak seasoning blend instead of basic garlic salt and pepper.
Kitchen Helpers Highlights 🫑 Eleanor stopped by for her special crunchy green pepper slice and chewed every bite like a pro! 🫑 Kira showed off her polite crunching skills with her very own piece of bell pepper! 🧀 Paying the mandatory Cheese Tax before taking the ingredients outside to the Blackstone griddle! 🐾 Kira stepped up to inspect the floor as the official third-best kitchen helper once all the cooking was finished!
Look!
Ingredients!
Ready for it? Look!
Second best kitchen helper ever!
You're in here!
You've also been following me in and out the door while I've been getting the Blackstone ready.
Good job! Good job!
Welcome back to Snow Dogs Cooking, where if I can cook it, so can you!
Today, we're making what we're gonna call Midwestern Cheesesteak Sandwiches.
Because they're not Philly Cheesesteak Sandwiches.
Because they're not the same.
They're a little different.
We put our own little twist on them.
So, we're just gonna call them Midwestern Cheesesteaks.
When I look that up, most of them are made this way.
So, that is what we're gonna make today.
What are you gonna need for this?
You're gonna need some shaved steak.
You can use whatever you want.
I buy this from Aldi because it's already done and I don't have to do all that work.
So, you're gonna need some of that.
You're gonna need some seasonings.
I like to use just garlic, salt and pepper.
You can also use like a steak seasoning or something like that.
You're gonna need some mushrooms, green pepper and onion.
And again, if you don't like onion, leave it out.
If you don't like this, leave it out.
This is nice because you can change it and modify it any way you want.
You're gonna need some cheese.
Today, we're using Swiss cheese because this is what I had to use in the fridge.
Pepper Jack cheese is also really good on this as well.
You're gonna need some nice hearty sub buns.
You're gonna need a little bit of butter.
You're gonna need some olive oil.
And then, whatever sauce of choice.
I'm going with garlic aioli.
You can just use a regular mayonnaise.
You can use salt and pepper mayonnaise.
Whatever or none.
Just cheese.
Whatever you would like.
This is what you're gonna need.
Now today, I'm making this out on my Blackstone.
Not everybody has a Blackstone.
You can make this on a normal pan.
I would advise, if you make it on a normal pan,
that you cook kind of like what I'm gonna do on the Blackstone.
You start with your onions.
Then, your green peppers.
Add those in.
Then, your mushrooms.
Then, your meat.
But, you cook your meat separate.
Then, kind of throw it all together for the last little bit of cooking.
It's just easier for me to do it on the Blackstone because I have it.
But, you could totally do this inside as well.
That being said, we have to prep everything.
So, I have to wash my mushrooms.
Cut up my green pepper.
And, cut up my onion.
First, I'm gonna cut up my onion.
So, basically, I've peeled it.
I've cut it in half.
Now, you can just do little strips.
But, I'm actually gonna do strips.
And then, cut those strips in half.
Which makes the pieces of onion just a little bit smaller.
Onion's all nice and chopped.
On to the green pepper.
Wash your green pepper.
Dry your green pepper.
I just cut the tops off.
Turn the thing.
Pull it out.
And then, smash them and make them flat.
Easier to cut.
I'm gonna do the kind of same thing here.
I'm gonna cut them into strips.
But, I'm also gonna cut them in half.
And, gee!
You actually are waiting in here for something amazing.
You want a bite of green pepper?
Let me cut them up real quick.
Green pepper's all cut up.
You're ready for this crunch.
Ready for it?
Oh, look how good you're being.
Here you go.
You chew for forever.
Good stuff?
Okay, we gotta go give one to Kira.
Even though I'm cooking outside and there's no onion.
Or no onion.
No oven on.
Would you like a green pepper?
Ready for the crunch?
I love that you girls both chew your food and enjoy it.
Now, I'm going to wash.
Yes, wash my mushrooms.
Look, read this you guys.
Wash before use.
How many of you guys don't actually wash your mushrooms before using them?
Cause I know a lot of people don't.
But yes, wash them.
Washed!
And I dry them.
I just put them on a paper towel and then kind of shake them around in here.
So that they're a little drier.
I am going to cut some of these up because that is a big mushroom.
Mushrooms!
So that container I showed you, I used about half of it.
So about half a container of mushrooms.
A small onion.
One whole green pepper.
Oh, and this I believe is like 14 ounces.
Yeah.
So 12 to 14 ounces of your meat.
Okay, so now I have a plate.
I put my buns on them cause I'm going to lightly toast them on the grill.
I set my cheese on the side here so that I know that I have that.
And look!
I have some cheese left.
And look!
You're still here!
Look at that tongue go.
Is this what you would like?
Do I have to pay this cheese tax?
Okay, but you can't have the whole piece.
The cheese tax!
The cheese...
Ah! Ah! Ah! Ah! Ah!
Good job!
Alright!
Go give it to Kira.
Now you're in here!
The cheese tax!
Did you even taste that?
That one you barely chewed.
All my prep work.
So I have a tablespoon of butter with the onions.
A tablespoon of butter with the green peppers.
And a tablespoon of butter with the mushrooms.
We have the meat.
I have some olive oil as well.
Bread, cheese, seasonings.
This will go on after when we come back inside.
We're going to go out to the Blackstone and get cooking.
Alright, so we're out here in the Blackstone.
I got it all nice and ready.
I already oiled it and did all the things.
You can still see some of the oil smoking off.
I have it on a medium heat on both sides.
I'm going to take my tablespoon of butter for my onions.
Set it on there.
Let it melt for a second.
It doesn't even have to be a second.
Kind of get it on there.
Go ahead and put the onions on there.
I'm going to start stirring those around.
Now I'm starting with the onions because the onions do take the longest.
Hey, I'm glad I got that piece out of there.
It was weird looking.
The onions do take the longest.
So I'm going to let these go for probably about two minutes.
Then I'm going to add the green peppers.
I might not add more butter right away.
We'll see.
Hey, so these have been on for just a little bit.
I'm going to go ahead and put these on.
Then decide if I need to add the rest of that butter or not.
Alright, I did go ahead and add the other butter because I felt like it did need it.
I'm going to let this go probably about five minutes before I add the mushrooms.
It's starting to get...
You can tell everything is starting to get a little bit of color on it.
So we're going to go ahead and put that other tablespoon of butter on there.
And dump the mushrooms right on top.
I'm actually going to close the lid for about a minute and then stir everything around again.
So if you're doing this in a pan on your stove, same type of thing.
You want the onions to be just a little bit translucent.
Then you want to cook the green peppers for a little bit.
You're doing this because those take a little bit longer to cook through than the mushrooms.
So onions, then the green peppers, then the mushrooms.
Then I'm going to set all that stuff aside and then I'm going to do the meat.
Then we're going to throw it all back together.
It's a process.
Alright, it's getting there.
Now I'm going to sprinkle it with a little bit...
I don't put a lot of salt on this, but I'll do some pepper.
And then, like I said, I do garlic salt.
But if you've watched me long enough, you know I don't like to put a lot of salt on anything.
So just a little bit because I am going to salt and pepper the meat as well.
The joys of cooking outside, the neighbors cutting their grass.
Totally fine!
Look it! I think this is about done.
I think I'm going to remove this off the heat now.
I'm going to take this off. Don't worry, we're going to put it back on.
See how there's this beautiful glow over here?
I'm going to take our bread.
No butter or nothing.
And I'm going to put it on there for like...
Well, until it's toasty.
Put it right on there.
Toast up that bread a little bit.
And now we're going to prep this side, which I have on a medium-high heat.
I'm going to spray just a little bit of oil.
By spray, I mean drizzle.
I'm just using olive oil.
Take the meat.
Put it right on there.
Now, you don't want to touch this more than necessary.
I'm kind of moving it around just a little bit.
See how fast it's cooking?
It will cook very fast.
I'm going to put salt and pepper on it real quick.
A little bit of garlic salt.
Pepper, pepper, pepper!
Alright, now we have to hope it doesn't stick.
The reason we do this on a medium-high heat is to get that little bit of sear on there.
It only stuck a little bit.
So, I did good!
I did good!
I'm still, you know, not a pro at the Blackstone, but I'm learning.
So, kind of go for like a minute and a half and then flip it.
You can see some of this back here is still a little...
So, we're not quite done with that yet.
I might close the lid for a second.
Let's check these toasty buns.
Okay! Oh, I can feel that they're toasty.
Alright, I'm going to pull those off.
Alright, this meat is just about done.
All of this fun stuff, put it right back on there.
That's also going to get some of that butter flavor in there.
And we're going to stir all this together.
Alright, that's looking pretty good.
Now, I did cut my buns all the way in half.
If you leave them not all the way cut in half, they're a little bit easier to fill,
but these buns didn't want to stay together.
So, we're going to try to pile all this together and then put some cheese on it.
I lied! I'm going to do it the way I've done it before.
I took the cheese, put it on there.
We're going to close this.
I'm actually going to shut the heat off.
We're going to leave that closed for about a minute.
Cheese is all melty.
I'm going to kind of stir it a little bit and then we're going to put it on here.
You can barely tell that there's a bunch of cheese melted in there,
but there is a bunch of cheese melted in there.
This is beautiful.
I'm going to put garlic aioli on mine.
You put regular mayonnaise on yours, right?
I did.
I did the garlic aioli.
I did do the cheese and melt it and then I kind of chopped it in and then put it on the buns.
The meat was really good.
Chewy cheese through all that.
Yeah, I tried it and it wasn't chewy and I was excited because I know a few times.
Did I perfect it finally?
Yeah?
I think I did it right finally.
I've made these a few times and a couple of times they've turned out right
and a couple of times they've turned out not great.
That's a win.
Yeah?
Better than Subway?
Oh, yeah.
The flavor.
Yeah.
And I just did garlic, salt, and pepper.
I didn't do the steak seasoning, which I did in the past and you didn't like.
Oh, right.
I did it the one time.
I didn't like it either.
Right, yeah.
That's for you.
And so easy to make.
I mean, honestly.
If you can find the already shaved steak and actually I think you can ask them at the butcher area
to shave some for you if there isn't any.
All right, we're eating some food.
That was amazing and actually really, really, really easy.
It's one of the easier meals that I tend to make, but again, I didn't have to really do much.
Cut it all up, throw it on there and be done.
If I wouldn't have been filming it, I can probably finish it in less than 10 to 15 minutes.
So, yeah.
And can you tell?
It was hot.
Standing in front of the Blackstone is hot and it's a little bit warm outside, but it was good.
Oh my goodness, look.
Of course, there's nothing on.
I mean, there was nothing on because I was cooking outside.
She's in here checking it out.
She's still the third best kitchen helper ever.
Don't let her fool you.
All right, you guys.
Let us know what you would like to see us make next because I don't know what I'm making next.
So, give me a suggestion.
I have a bunch of dill.
I need to make some stuff.
I do actually have an idea for what I'm going to do with some of it, but...
What do you want to see me make with fresh dill?
All right, you guys.
We hope you enjoyed today's video.
As always, thanks so much for watching.
Thanks for subscribing.
Stay positive, dream big and we will see you again soon.
Goodbye Pawdience!