In this second part of our keel repair series, I’m fixing a mistake I made on a small wooden boat I built about a year ago. The keel—originally glued on with West System 105/205 epoxy—started to fail under constant submersion, and now it’s time to do it right. In this video, I share the full repair process, lessons learned from the failure, and demonstrate how to use G/flex epoxy, West System 105/205, and mechanical fasteners to reinstall the keel—this time with confidence. Whether you're working with Purpleheart, sepili mahogany, or any oily hardwood, this episode is packed with real-world epoxy bonding tips and hard-earned wisdom.
📌 What you’ll learn: * Why the original epoxy bond failed * The difference between G/flex and 105/205 systems * Why oily woods like Purpleheart need special treatment * How to prepare wood surfaces for optimal epoxy adhesion * Scarf joint improvements, clamping pressure advice, and fastener strategies * Mixing epoxy by weight vs. volume—and why it matters * Pro cleaning/prep techniques (including what rags not to use!)
▶️ If you missed Part 1 where I removed the keel without damaging the hull, watch it here: https://youtu.be/YO1L_EdIe3k
🛠️ This episode is sponsored by West System Epoxies. Huge thanks to their tech team for their help and for making rock-solid adhesives that boatbuilders can count on. West System Epoxy Info – https://www.westsystem.com/
👍 Like, subscribe, and hit the bell if you're learning from these builds. Your support keeps this channel afloat.
Hi, I'm Mark Rutin. Welcome back to Nomad Boat Building. This is the second part
of a two-part series in which I've got to repair my own work. About a year or so ago,
I built this small wooden boat, but I failed to choose the right products and application
method when installing the keel on it. And under constant submersion, the epoxy bond holding that
keel on began to break. And now I've got to fix it. Now, you can go watch the first video right
here where I investigated the problem and figured out a way to get this epoxy glued
keel off the boat without wrecking anything. Yay. Today, we're going to try and figure out a
good repair strategy for putting this keel back on so that this problem doesn't happen again.
So, in last week's video about repairing the boat that I built, a lot of you commented about using
Sycoflex or 3M 5200 uh to install the keel. And actually, I usually do that. I usually do
exactly that. I honestly don't exactly remember why I chose to do something different this time.
And my big mistake was just not using mechanical fasteners as well. West System epoxy is a really
versatile product and I feel like it's important to try and demonstrate that and I also want
to demonstrate that I still have faith in the West System products despite the fact that this
particular application of them didn't work out in the first place. So now that we have this off,
we can see a few things. First of all, I've got zero bond throughout most of this keson.
I mean, it was on there, but it came off of there. Like, this epoxy has not stuck to the
bottom of this at all, except for in a couple tiny spots right near the bow and right at
the very stern. That tells me a couple things. Either A, I didn't prep the surfaces properly,
or B, I chose the wrong product. And I think it might be a combination of the two. Now, I did
sand these down, but perhaps I didn't sand down coarse enough. But more importantly, I used West
Systems 105205 resin hardener combination, which is perfectly fine for most applications. However,
Purple Heart is considered to be an oily wood. So, for that reason, I probably should have used
Glex for this whole application. Before Glex came along, we were still gluing these difficult woods
with the 105205 resins and using good surface preparation as the tool to make that work. So, I
assumed it would. And clearly that wasn't the case in this particular situation. This purple heart
just has too much resin in it. And I also think part of the problem was that this stock looks
like it's essentially flats on. And when I lay a ruler across it, I can see it has in fact crowned
this way on this portion of it. And over on this portion, it's got a cup to it. The fact that they
moved is the thing that probably allowed this bond to start breaking in the first place. So,
I had a talk with the folks at West System. I gave them a call and talked to their tech department.
They confirmed that this Glex glued scarf should have been fine. The ratio should have been okay,
especially considering the whole thing was glued to a substrate. That was one reason I made the
scarf joint as short as I did because I figured the whole thing's reinforced by a large stiff
backing member. So, I thought that would be okay. Number two, perhaps I didn't araid this quite
coarsely enough. They recommend that you araid it with 60 grit sandpaper going in line with the
grain of the wood. And the tech department were looking at the photos I sent them and
they they feel like this looked glue starved. I was careful not to try and squeeze the daylights
out of this when I was gluing it up. That's I'm I'm careful about trying to do that. That's one
thing with epoxy is you don't want to clamp things ridiculously tight. You want to leave
some room for that epoxy in there. In my opinion, I left enough and as evidenced by the fact that I
can see a reasonably strong film of it here. However, clearly it didn't work. I do have a
video about gluing up this very joint. It's called make wood any length with a basic scarf joint. So,
you can go watch this video and see where I might have screwed up. The tech department noted in that
video that I mixed my epoxy by weight one, in fact, I should have mixed it 1.2 to one. That
means I had a hardener heavy joint. And hardeners, I've learned, are actually water soluble. So that
might have been part of the problem as well. So where do I go from here? Now, I really like Purple
Heart because it is tough tough stuff. Can take grounding really well. So here's what I'm going
to do. Uh rather than start from scratch because that's a whole bunch of extra work and I've got
the key the SKG that would have to get fitted. Most of this was fine. These portions down here
are small. They're narrow. They're not going to move all that much. Not so much that they would
break any bond. So, we'll put the back half on here with Glex. We're going to do a long scarf,
a 12-in long scarf instead of 6 in long. So, we'll double the length of the scarf. The scarf joint is
going to land within this range here where the original wood is still looking clean. And all
this portion that's been exposed to seawater, that's going to get chopped away. And then the
front portion, I think what I'm going to do is use a different material for the bulk of the
keelsen. and cap it with some purple heart. So, I'll use say I think probably sepilia mahogany
for the main portion. We'll glue that down with the 105 205, which is very adequate for that.
Making sure that we uh prep those surfaces really well. And then we'll add just a/4in cap of the
purple heart on top to be the grounding shoe. And we'll put that on with Glex. The whole thing will
get mechanically fastened down as well, just for good measure. So, I think that's a great
compromise that will fix this boat fairly quickly and efficiently and uses products from the sponsor
of this video, West System Epoxies. One could make the argument I'm doing the same thing twice,
but I'm not. So, I'm reducing the volume of wood that the Purple Heart has, so it has less ability
to move relative to the strength of the bond. I'm changing the adhesive I'm using that is hanging
on to the purple heart itself and being much more fussy. Making sure I do good prep work.
I'm replacing half of that mass of material with another species that I know bonds really,
really well with West System adhesive. First, we'll pop this outside into the sunshine where
it has the best chance of drying up more before I start gluing it on. And in the meantime, we've
got some prep work to do on the hull itself. So, I think the armadillo is the best tool for this job.
was just about perfect. So, I'm just going to start by giving this thing a good lick down.
There's a healthy layer of epoxy still stuck to the bottom that was underneath the keel. I want
to keep that there because obviously it hung on really well, but I do want to get rid of all the
staining from that seawater that got in there. So, I'm just going to focus on giving this a
good thorough sanding with a coarse grit. Get rid of all the staining from that seawater and give
us a good solid foundation to build upon. We'll give it a little lick for the long bar here too,
just to make sure we got a nice fair surface to build on as well. And now on to the keelsson
itself. I'm going to use a coarse sanding belt on here and really focus on trying to clean up
the whole portion of the keels that we're going to reuse. The bit that got exposed to sea water,
that's going away. So, we don't have to worry about that. Just the back half. Now,
purple heart when it's oxidized is purple, but when it's freshly cut, it's kind of this very
boring kind of brown color. So, what I wanted to do there was get all the purple off. Try and get
it as neutral as I can get it because that means I've got fresh un oxidized wood there and it's
going to be the cleanest possible surface. Okay, let's get the scarf cut. Move on to the next bit.
I think what I'm going to do is give myself like an inch here and then we'll go 12 in.
We'll square across. And then here we want just a half inch.
We connect the dots. Still debating how I want to cut this. I think because of the height,
I'll cut this on the band saw. And this we want a square across. Because my eyes aren't getting any
younger, I sometimes will use tape to delineate that line just to make it easier to see. Okay,
this all goes away. This stays. I should cut this hunch first. Flip it over. Yeah,
let's set up the table saw to do that. [Music]
So, this is providing a right angle for me to cut against
just to make it easier to handle this on the saw.
[Music]
Now, that came out a little squint. Unfortunately, it's cuz this wooden sitting quite dead flat
against the bandsaw fence. I guess I got plenty of length here. Just shorten this up a hair. We
make our piece that fits it a little bit steeper. Take that right across. [Music]
This is really ready to go right on the boat. No need
to worry about fussing around making the other half of this right away.
[Applause]
Think we'll pop this on there. Maybe we'll just touch off where the screws
go and then I'll flag the drill bit and do a pilot drill. So, we'll screw that down
first. I always just use small smaller diameter steel screws for doing my temporary fastenings.
Okay, that's pretty good. I'm going get it clamped down from the ceiling.
There's the right drill bit.
That comes off.
Comes out.
Stress off them.
[Music]
Okay. Number eight screw 764 core diameter.
Flag it. [Music]
So I have essentially a quarter of an inch. I don't usually flag off these guys.
Okay, that is ready to get installed. So, I think I want to just move right ahead with doing that
before this gets any spends any time getting staying exposed to oxygen. I have no idea if
oxidization will affect the bond on this. I'd like to not find out the hard way. Working clean is so
Well, I think it's important. I know that every time I don't work clean, I regret it. Every
time something goes wrong that makes me regret not taking a moment to really tidy up nicely.
Not screwing around this time. Using the acetone.
I'm going to do it twice for good measure.
I asked the tech guys whether or not the age of my Glex would be
a problem. It's not that old. It's a few years old, but he said he'd tried
stuff up to 8 or 10 years old. It was fine. So, how much am I going to need?
So, six 12 grams of each something like that. Okay. So zero note the cut weight
2.5
tear. So GLEX is the 650. There's a 655 as well. And if we're mixing by volume,
it's a 1:1 mix. Hardener. Resin. Now I'm going to mix by weight, which has a different ratio of 1.2
two parts resin to one part hardener. Get out your calculator. 13.1 * 1.2 is equal to 15.72 tear.
I'd always wondered why when I was using my Glex before and mixing by weight and
going 50/50 that I was always ending up with like a little bit more resin than hardener,
not realizing that by weight I should be going heavier on the um on the resin.
Want to save yourself a ton of time, you make a little mixing wand like that. So,
we'll start on the keel itself. So, it's got some time to soak in. So, thinning your epoxies down
for the purposes of penetration weakens them. So, you really don't want to do that. If you really
want to thin them down, you should be using a heat gun. And I would really seriously consider
applying a heat gun to this to get this to penetrate better. Except my heat gun died.
I'm struggling to find a replacement heating element for it. I'd buy a whole new heat gun
if I hadn't spent 300 bucks on the one that I have, which in my mind is not the kind of
thing you don't repair. Butter this like I'm putting honey on toast. Do not want to skimp
on this one. This to be the repair that doesn't need to be repaired yet again. That's for sure.
Okay, now I just want to quickly skim out
the bottom here.
So, get the tooth spreader and just work it a little bit.
So, here's something to know. When you use spreaders like this, if you go across the
joint like I'm doing, makes it easier for air to escape and improve your contact. So,
if you get air bubbles trapped inside this thick gooey layer, it can hold up the whole thing.
Real Okay.
[Music]
I'm just giving all these fasteners a little tease by hand. Make sure
they're tightened as far down as they can go without being overtightened.
Give it a little tap to help move things along.
So, when you do glue plugs, it's kind of it's kind of helpful if you don't glue like the very bottom
of it where you putting where your screw fastening might need to be revealed without crap in it.
Now, we always want to align the grain with the uh thing you're plugging because if you don't,
wood movement might cause the plug to move in opposite directions and cause
it to want to pop out. and trying to eyeball the orientation of the
grain on the plug is almost the hardest thing of the whole job.
So, another nice thing about Glex is it kicks off a little fairly fast. Well, fast in that you've
got, you know, in about 3 hours or something, it's substantially cured. Okay, now I can mop it down.
I forgot plugs back here. Luckily, we still have a bit of goop to clean up.
Okay, we don't bother trying to clean up around the plugs. We just leave those and
saw them off later or sand them off later. Here's another thing I learned from the guys
at tech support at West System. They asked me what rags I was using to clean off the
uh the the surface of my wood before scarfing. And they they recommend not using fabric rags because
sometimes there's detergents and fabric softeners and stuff like that that the solvent will break
down and and can contaminate the surface of the part that you're trying to wet out. Okay,
I think that will do it. So, I'll get going on making my replacement section for the keel here.
[Music]
[Music]
Just okay.
[Music]
Good.
[Music]
Come on.
So close. So very close. Yeah. I just need a little slight shave and we're home. [Music]
We're running a little high, but I think I'm going to leave it alone cuz once it's installed,
I could just slick this off with the belt sander, I think, and fair it down.
Just lay out where our fasteners are going to go. Extra one in this scarf
just for good measure, I think, wouldn't be a dumb idea. Okay. How far from the edge?
Okay. Now, we're going to do a dry fit and drill holes.
I sometimes complain about the low ceiling in this shop, but honestly,
if I had a higher ceiling, I think it would [ __ ] me. Okay, looks good.
[Applause]
[Music]
Okay. Now, for installing this, I'm going to be doing something a little bit out of the ordinary.
So, we're going to be using Glex on the purple heart as we did before, but then we're going
to use uh 105 205 resin on the rest of the joint. And one thing you can do with Glex,
which is interesting, is you can use it in combination with the other adhesives.
you you need to mix the Glex on its own and the other adhesive on its own with the appropriate
amount of hardeners. But you can mix them together or we could use them side by side,
which is what I'm planning to do. Now, one of the reasons for doing this is because
the GLEX is considerably more expensive than the other epoxy is one reason. So,
there's a an economy component to this. The other one is that kind of demonstrates this
this particular technique. 12 g. There we go. Zero that one. 12 times 1.2. It's 14.4.
[Music]
Okay, now let's go and get some acetone onto the boat, onto the parts.
[Music]
Give it another swipe for good measure.
And I'm going to hit the mahogany, too, just because why not? Why not?
I have had an issue with gluing sepili just once or twice. I don't know what the problem
was. Probably just glue starved maybe. But let's just play it safe. So hit both sides of this.
Okay, good. Now we'll mix up some 105205 to wet this out with. West Systems 105 resin is the
foundational product for their basic product line. Then you combine that with your choice
of hardener for the application. The 205 hardener, which I'm using,
is the fast hardener. 206 is their slow hardener. 207 is their special coatings
hardener intended for wetting out fiberglass cloth and situations where you're going to
clear coat over top. You can also use that for just clear coating on its own. And then
there's 209, which is an extra slow hardener intended for hot climates. Flip this over.
I am usually way cleaner than this. Oh my god, what a disaster. What a disaster. Okay, so what
I think I'm going to do is do um I want to do one more a neat coat on the hull as well. By neat, I
mean unthickened. Then I want to do uh a slightly a slightly thickened coat between these components
just to make up for stuff I can't see, but it's just going to be a little tiny bit of filler.
Okay, so onto the hull.
So, if there's one thing this experience has taught me is I
should really sit down and reread all the West System product literature
because what I thought I knew, I didn't know.
Okay. So,
first piece
Yeah, that's pretty good. I I don't know. I just got this feeling like
I want a little bit more underneath this scarf.
Just a little bit more.
[Music]
And now the purple heart.
First screw up here.
[Music]
Give everything the once over with a screwdriver.
I would use the brace for this, but I don't actually
want that much torque because of the minimal holding I have on the screws.
Don't want to risk popping one out. Okay, now we'll plug these holes.
Got so much epoxy squeezing out of this hole back here. I can use that as my pot.
And the funny thing is, if there's a pile of epoxy in a fastening hole,
you cannot get the plug into it to save your life. You got to mop it out. Where's my Q-tips?
and mop out the hole that's giving me trouble. Use it in the rest.
[Music]
Okay.
Clean up. So, these little tooththed spreaders are great with system 809 notched spreader. I use
them a lot. Um, but they do kind of start jamming up on you even when you clean them well. And so,
what I'll sometimes do is just take a little triangular file and recut the teeth just like
you're sharpening a saw. Um, do that a few times before I toss them and replace them.
So, cleaning up you can do with a number of different solvents. Um,
acetone, lacquer, thinner. I don't like either of those cuz they're so smelly.
So, I, as you can see, I've only used the acetone for doing the um for wiping down the wood. I just
I really don't like this stuff. U what I mostly use is denatured alcohol or methyl hydrate.
You can use vinegar as well. If you really don't want to use the solvents, you can use vinegar. I
just find it doesn't cut through the goo quite as nicely is the one thing about vinegar.
Well, there is a lot of squeeze out.
Certainly did not skimp on the epoxy, that's for sure.
So if I end up with like a a larger amount of epoxy like this that is a waste,
I will put it outside often in a bucket of water, like suspend it in water just
because the the exothermic reaction on this could easily make this thing start smoking
and essentially self-combust. So certainly don't want that happening in the workshop.
I really am perplexed that I managed to screw this up. so badly. I have to say I think it's a
combination of things. I think it's a combination of choosing the wrong product for the overall
lamination. Although I did choose the right one for this maybe a little bit. It's the mixing of
the epoxy on this cuz I ended I did a one one instead of a 1.2 to one by weight. So
that made it hardener heavy. So that could have been a problem. And then having material that
is essentially flats on but with a lot of power to it to uh break the bond. That obviously was
problematic cuz this did change shape. It it cupped or it crowned this way. So it created
a cup on the bottom in one portion and in the forward portion it did the opposite because of
the the grain orientation. So the edges lifted up on the forward p portion which is where that
bond started to break. So I don't think there was any one specific thing that I screwed up.
I think we there's a a bunch of little factors that all came together to cause this failure,
you know. And probably the biggest one is I should have used a few mechanical fasteners
regardless. Not that I don't trust the adhesive products. I do. But uh you know they have their
limits. So what we've done is we've prepped our surfaces by properly sanding with a coarse grit.
Wiped everything down with acetone. The sepili layer underneath has been glued down with 105
205 resin and hardener with a little little bit of colloidal silica thrown in for good measure to uh
make sure that any small voids are are dealt with. The purple heart has been wetted out with Glex and
then it's been bonded to the sepili 105205 on the sepili Glex on the purple heart and a little bit
of colloidal silica thrown in for good measure. Again, I've kept that colloidal silica component
quite low just to make sure that it was there was minimum compromise to strength while giving
myself just a little bit of gap filling ability just in case. And then we've put some mechanical
fasteners in and we've left those in permanently. [Music] She's launched. She's floating now. I've
not had a chance to row this at all since I built this boat. Say she rows quite nicely. I want to
thank West System for sponsoring this video and I want to thank all of you for watching and I
hope you join me again next month with another West System video. Ciao for now, folks. [Music]