When the Keel Fails: A Hard Lesson in Epoxy, Purpleheart, and Boatbuilding Mistakes
Getting a call from a customer saying the keel is falling off the boat you built for them? That’s every boatbuilder’s nightmare. In this episode of Nomad Boatbuilding, Mark Reuten dives deep into a rare and frustrating failure on a wooden boat he built just last year. After months in the water, the keel began to separate—and things only got worse from there.
Join Mark in the workshop as he investigates this epoxy bond failure, shares honest reflections on what went wrong, and begins the careful process of taking the keel off without damaging the boat. Along the way, he shares practical boat repair strategies, discusses the challenges of working with Purpleheart, and talks adhesives—from West System 105/205 to G/flex and polyurethane options.
Whether you're a wooden boatbuilding professional, epoxy enthusiast, or DIY repairer, this video offers a valuable learning experience about adhesive selection, wood movement, and the importance of mechanical fasteners in keel construction.
📌 Chapters: 0:00 – The dreaded phone call 1:58 – Initial inspection of the keel 4:10 – Why the joint failed 6:23 – Removing the keel carefully 8:05 - Removing glued in plugs and screws 12:52 - Using the brace and bit for removing screws 14:08 – Using heat and hand tools 21:00 – Reflections on epoxy and wood compatibility 26:16 – What I’ll do differently next time
Getting a call from your customer that
the keel on the boat you just built for
them is falling off is not the call you
want to get. I've not looked at this
since I was first shown that there was a
bit of an issue. That was a few months
ago. It is way worse than I remember.
So, this thing is fully let go. Howdy
folks. I'm Mark from Nomad Boat
Building. Welcome to the workshop. Now,
I've been building boats for somewhere
in the neighborhood of 30 years now. And
in all that time, I haven't had any
boats come back to me wherein something
went wrong that we can identify in a
short amount of time. This is a boat I
built last year. It's been uh living in
the water ever since I built it and it's
come through that really well. But
there's one thing that has gone a little
bit ary. I don't know what has caused
the problem yet, but today we are going
to sort it out.
This is my customer Bruce. About 6
months after launching this boat, he
gave me a call and he said that there
was a little bit of a problem with the
keel and he asked me to come have a look
at it. So, I took a trip out to the
island where he lives. And sure enough,
there was a small gap along the side of
the keels, maybe about 6 in long. I
couldn't quite tell what was going on
cuz it looked like there was something
black kind of squeezing out. And I
couldn't remember how I'd put the keel
on. Judging by what I saw squeezing out,
I thought perhaps I'd used a flexible
polyurethane,
which sometimes doesn't like to see
constant submersion. So, I thought
perhaps some of it was washing away a
little bit. I told him I'd have to make
a return trip to address the problem.
About a month or so later, I arranged to
come back. I brought along some tools
and materials with me with thought that
I could do a little bit of a cocking job
to fix it up. Well, when I got there,
the gap had gotten much worse. It had
stretched down about half the length of
the boat and was a bit deeper for sure.
So I said to him, I want to fix this
properly. And so we held the boat out.
We brought it back to the shop and I
left it on the trailer for a few weeks
to dry out and until I could find the
time to address the problem.
I've not looked at this since I was
first shown that there was a bit of an
issue. That was a few months ago and I
hadn't looked at it since we pulled it
out of the water and towed it home. I
just was going to let it all dry out and
then take a look at it. It is way worse
now than it was when I saw it before.
So, this thing is
fully let go. This popped while it was
just sitting on the trailer for the last
couple weeks. Now, that was a scarf
joint I did with epoxy, but this this is
what I'm more concerned about. Looking
at it now, I think I put this on. Is
that
Yeah, I think I epoxied that on. So, but
that epoxyy's hanging on to the bottom.
So, we'll pull this off and we'll have a
look at it. I
This is purple heart. I think I probably
should have used a different epoxy.
I couldn't Yeah.
Yeah, that is my first real epoxy
failure. But we'll take a look at what
failed, whether it was the face of the
wood grain. I don't think it was. I
think I think this is a bond failure.
And but if but I'm pretty sure it's my
fault, not the epoxy's fault. I probably
I don't remember. I honestly don't
remember what I might have done or what
I didn't do. Maybe I should have Maybe I
should use Glex on here instead of
regular 105 205.
Okay. So, we need to think about how to
get this off. I don't if this let go.
I'm I'm nervous about all the rest of
this.
Oh, okay. Over here on this side.
This is letting go.
Let's get a putty knife.
See, I can see it's starting to let go
there.
Man, that's annoying. This I put in with
just regular traditional bedding
compound and mechanical fasteners. And I
did that specifically because SKGS are
are prone to damage and I thought better
to have something that is easily
repaired.
I did not in a million years expect this
to let go. So, the reason I did not
mechanically fasten this is because my
my rationale is that with KES they're
getting araided all the time as you're
dragging them up and down docks and
such.
And by not mechanically fastening it, I
my reasoning is you could just as it
gets really beat up, you can just take a
power planer and buzz down the bottom to
freshen up the exposed portion.
And uh and then keep on going until
you've decided there's not enough keel
there. In which case, you can just glue
a new piece on top
and save yourself from having to dig
around for fastenings.
So you either fasten from the outside in
which case you've only got the thickness
of the bottom which may not be all that
adequate or you fasten from the inside
which case you got the points coming out
which then obstruct that planing plus
you have either plugging the inside or
you're seeing the fasteners. So
we'll start taking this apart. Now I did
fiberglass the bottom of this boat.
So I want to be careful that I'm not
like tearing fiberglass off while I do
this. I guess we'll just start by
pulling out fastenings along the stem.
And it looks like I'll be pulling out
the keel or the the SKG. So, I'll have
to get under the boat and pull those
fastenings out.
So, good practice when you're pulling
out fastenings is to just give them a
light little tap first.
That's to sort of shock the bond.
And then I like to use a brace and bit
for extracting them initially because
um I don't want to risk stripping a
fastener head out with a power tool
necessarily.
So I can be a little more gentle with
this.
Once I got the bond broken, then I can
back them off a little bit. I'll use a
drill to pull them out the rest of the
way.
Now, what what strikes me about this
problem is that I really do pride myself
on trying to make sure I put things
together properly in the first place.
Like, I don't
I genuinely try to avoid cutting any
corners.
I know I've got some mechanical
fasteners in here, so I'm going to have
to scrape back my paint and try and find
those.
And I guess we'll take care of whatever
mechanical fastenings I can take off at
the back here.
I don't know exactly where I went on
this other than perhaps I didn't araid
this well enough for the mechanical bond
to hold or perhaps I should have used
acetone. It's purple heart. Like I don't
consider it an oily wood because it
doesn't doesn't feel oily. But maybe I
should do a little research and check
into that. Um, purple heart is being
used throughout the wooden boat industry
and I've never heard of any issues with
it up until now. Okay, here's the trick
for dealing with a glued in plug. Take a
slotted screwdriver and you start right
in the middle.
You want to find one, break out a little
tiny piece
and you start working your way back
towards the edge.
If you're lucky,
it'll all just break cleanly away from
the edge so that you can fish out the
plug without damaging the surrounding
wood.
It's one reason it's kind of a good idea
to put it plugs in with something other
than epoxy to be perfectly honest, which
I failed to do in this case.
I'm going to clear out the
fastening hole.
Why that's not wanting to wiggle loose.
I think I'm going to put soldering iron
onto that.
Yeah, that wouldn't be a terrible idea.
That did it. All the difference in the
world.
So, at a bare minimum, I would say I
should have used a longer scarf. The
fact that this joint let go as well
tells me it wasn't the scarf length that
is the issue here. So much as there's an
incompatibility
between the the adhesive and the species
of wood. And I should have taken
different measures. So, let's see if we
can pry that scarf open.
I don't know if I'm going to try and
reuse this bit of wood or use something
different.
Yeah, there we go. That's loose. Now,
what will happen if I try and
I really don't want to damage the
fiberglass
in this joint. So, I'm not sure how I
want to try and take this apart.
I think I want to just try working a
knife underneath here.
Might even try making it a I should warm
this up. Maybe I'll put the heat blanket
on here for a while and just warm that
up and see what happens. That's what I'm
going to do.
So, heat blankets can be really useful
in the shop. You might have to look
underneath your grandmother to find one.
I use them a lot in instrument making.
I've even like straightened out necks
with them and stuff like that. So, just
plug this in
and we'll just leave it for I don't
know, probably give it a couple hours or
something like that and just see what
happens.
I got other things to do so I don't have
to be anything but patient. Put this up
on high
and we'll come back to that.
[Music]
[Music]
Being careful to try and not break out
any grain around the fast that might be
hanging up.
[Music]
Another good reason to do stuff the slow
way.
[Music]
Love braces because you can get a ton of
control.
You can really feel how the screws
hanging on or whether or not you're at
risk of breaking it.
Okay, this little strategy seems to be
working. So, what I'm doing is I'm
I'm adding heat to the joint. Just using
this drywallers knife.
Getting it up off the surface of the
bottom because I don't want to
heat the fiberglass that's on the
bottom. Just dropping an iron on here.
So, it's carrying that heat down into
the joint
and adding some wedges to help apply a
little pressure.
See? And slowly but surely, it's
starting to let go.
Oh, there we go. Man, that is letting go
awfully easily.
The fact that it's letting go easily is
a good thing because it's saving me a
lot of effort. I was really not wanting
to have to try and cut this off.
Okay, just stop there for the moment.
So,
that's interesting the way that's
moving.
coming up hard there.
So, maybe we'll just try adding more
heat right to that spot.
I'm also heating up this knight while
I'm at it to come at it from the other
side.
And the heat blanket up forward seems to
be doing a pretty good job, too. So,
it's feeling nice and warm up in here.
And I'm just just a little hand
pressure.
Try getting in there with the pry bar a
little bit.
I should add some wedges to this, too.
If you're liking these videos, you can
support me by giving me a thumbs up,
throwing me a couple of bucks through
super thanks, subscribing to the
channel, turning on notifications, and
of course, you can join me over on
Patreon. Find links in the corner or
down in the description.
[Music]
[Music]
I got to say I'm genuinely surprised how
well this is working.
I should be alarmed at how well this is
working actually.
Okay, I turned off the heat for a while.
I think I got to put it back on because
it feels like that was actually helping
some. It's sort of slowed down a bit
here.
Turned it off while I went for lunch.
Basically,
really wish I had a smaller iron. I need
to get small detail iron for this kind
of stuff. Well, I have never needed to
do this kind of stuff until now. So,
suppose there's that.
Let's see how the bow's looking. That's
had the heat on it for the whole time.
So, getting a heat blanket for the shop
is really handy. What I've been using
this for a lot is warming up my epoxy
when I want to especially when I want to
do a wet out
when I want to like saturate some
fiberglass cloth.
If I need to put another wedge on this
side, that wouldn't probably wouldn't be
a terrible idea.
So every time I scarf something, I end
up with at least a a 1 to 12 wedge.
Whole box of these things lying around.
It's funny. This is up. This is where
the whole thing started letting go is
right here for some reason.
Put the blanket back on right at the bow
here. Might
have to get the hot knife going
underneath there. It's a little more
resistant for some reason.
So, we definitely got a bond failure.
That is food for thought.
I'll know a bit. I can tell a bit better
once we get this apart. It's a bit hard
to see what's going on right now, but I
was my biggest worry was that the bond
the fiberglass
bond to the plywood was letting go and
that would have been ugly. So, I'm glad
if anything's going to happen that this
is what's happened.
But I do find it so very curious that it
has let go the way it has.
So, the question is, what do I repair it
with?
I'm inclined to put the Keelsson back
down using a flexible polyurethane
adhesive instead
cuz it's very rare for that stuff to let
go of surfaces.
And reglue the joint
with Glex
and mechanically fastened the joint
itself. These are also epoxied on, but
they're fine. I'm pretty sure I
mechanically fastened those at the at
the ends for sure.
I think what I might just do is contact
West System
and ask them about Purple Heart in
particular, about whether or not they've
done any testing on Purple Heart.
All right. Well, we'll get this off.
Guaranteed we'll get it off.
steady as she goes.
I feel if I take my time, I should be
able to tease this off. And if I rush
it, I risk tearing something apart, and
I don't want to do that.
If pulling fresh ideas out of your
kester every day is your idea of fun,
boat repair might be the business for
you.
You can hear the crackle.
So close.
Don't get impatient.
Don't get impatient. Now,
now's the time for extra patience.
Every time I've regretted doing
something,
it's usually because I was impatient
about something.
Didn't want to take the extra step.
Didn't want to give it the extra time.
Didn't want to give it the extra day.
And it always takes you twice as long to
fix whatever thing it was that you were
impatient about.
Yay.
I could feel myself biting into the
fiberglass here. I was really nervous
about that.
So, we lost a little meat, but we can
fix all that up.
Look at that. It's like it didn't hang
on at all.
That's crazy. And down here where it's
black, this is where the water was
working its way underneath.
Man,
zero adhesion.
That's so crazy.
one thing. You know what's hanging on?
Oh, hilarious.
The polyurethane.
I put the stem on with Sycoflex
polyurethane
and that's hanging on fine
onto onto end grain. Although I mean it
peeled off a little bit, but point is is
that was hanging on pretty darn good.
Well, this is a first for me. This is
pretty much as close as you get to 100%
bond failure,
which is
really
surprising.
So, what am I going to do about it is
the question. Well, I have a couple of
thoughts.
Um, first of all, I think I'm just going
to set this out to dry cuz it has been
in the water for months. For the most
part, it feels quite surprisingly dry. I
mean, this this had full contact.
However, it just let go under coercion.
Right back here,
this is the area that let go on its own.
And, you know, everywhere you see black,
that's where water was getting in. So, I
think I want to just make sure this is
well as dried as possible. My first
thought was that this was like it was
wood movement. But yeah, I mean there's
some cupping for sure.
Like it's it's crowned a little bit. So
definitely some wood movement.
Um
so when we put it back together, we'll
definitely use some mechanical fastening
to help reinforce
this joint.
You know, the irony is I used mechanical
fastenings to attach it, but then I
pulled them out.
If I just left them in, probably would
might have been fine. But then again, I
mean, the way it's let go just tells me
that it's not fine. Even if I
even if id left it the way it is, I'm
glad we we're dealing with it. The one
thing I'm not going to do is try and
reapply it in the exact same way to do
the same thing over and over again and
expect different results. That would
just be stupid.
Well, I'm really happy I managed to get
this key off without wrecking anything.
The primary culprit, I think, was the
purple heart because it's a highly
resonous wood and therefore very
difficult to bond and because it was
flats on which under constant submersion
caused it to cup. So, as a result, I
think the cupping force is what caused
the bond to start to break. And then you
combine it with an epoxy resin that
wasn't optimized for hanging onto a
resinous wood and then no mechanical
fasteners all combined to cause this to
fail. Had this piece of wood been
vertical grain, that is with the grain
running perpendicular to its broadest
face, and had I used mechanical
fasteners, I think this probably would
have held. And had this application not
been under constant submersion, maybe
just occasionally submerged, I think it
probably would have held as well. Now,
I've been using West System epoxies for
about 30 years. I have total faith in
it. But you have to choose the right
product for the right situation. And
this is where I failed. You can't
blindly expect epoxy to work in every
situation without considering the
context. Now, when gluing this keel on,
I did contemplate whether or not I was
making the right choice. But I concluded
there was enough surface area on this
piece of wood that I didn't think it
would be much of a problem and I didn't
expect the wood to move as much as it
did. So that was just dumb on my part. I
used West Systems 105205
resin hardener when I probably should
have used West Systems GLEX as the
primary adhesive for this joint. Now,
why didn't I do that? Well, I didn't
have all that much Glex on hand.
Certainly not enough to do the whole
joint. And I've used the 105 205 in
virtually every situation for my entire
career and found it to work just fine.
However, wood movement can be a very
powerful force and in this case it
simply overcame the bond. Regardless,
now we need to fix this and we're going
to have to carefully consider how we're
going to address this fix so that this
problem doesn't happen again. But we're
going to save that for the next episode
and I hope you join me for that. I want
to thank you all for watching and we'll
see you next time.