Does Consciousness Cause the Cosmos? | Donald Hoffman

Human & Consciousness
3 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 11, 2024
Some claim consciousness, our inner awareness, is part of a 'cosmic consciousness'. Not only is consciousness the deepest reality, but also it brought into existence the totality of reality. This would mean that mind, the mental, is fundamental and primary, while the entire physical universe is derivative and secondary.
Don, you make the extraordinary claim that consciousness is fundamental, and if I give
you that, how do you then make the next leap to say that consciousness is causative of
the physical world, such that things that we think are so fundamental, like not just
mass energy, but space and time, are derivative, the contents of consciousness?
That's right.
So, the idea is that part of the structure of consciousness are the conscious experiences
of the conscious entities, the conscious agents.
And what we call the physical world is simply the contents of the experiences of conscious
agents.
So, and different, going biological, different organisms, different species, will have different
structures to their nature of awareness, to the kinds of conscious experiences they
have.
In that sense, they'll be living in fundamentally different universes.
Well, that's just because their perception, though, of the reality, if the reality is
an independent reality, different organisms will have different perceptions of what that
reality is.
That's nothing surprising.
That's right.
My assumption is that the fundamental reality is just consciousness.
So that when we have different, for example, spaces and times, maybe one organism has ten
dimensions of color perception, another one has four, we have three, those are just going
to be features of their space.
Maybe some organisms see in four dimensions, who knows, or two dimensions.
So the deeper structures of their quote-unquote physical worlds could be quite different from
ours.
Well, that could be just their interpretation or how they see the same physical world that's
out there as an independent entity.
That's right.
If your assumption is that the real physical world is a 3D of space and one dimension of
time, then that would have to be the interpretation that you would give to the different perceptions.
But I'm suggesting that consciousness is fundamental.
And so that any perception of space and time is nothing but the contents of consciousness.
Now the burden is on me, of course, to make that mathematically precise.
You have a lot of burdens.
That's right.
And I'm cashing out some of the burdens.
So I can have a model of consciousness that's precise and a dynamics that does allow me
to derive certain aspects of quantum mechanics completely.
The wave equation of the free particle and things like that.
But there's more to do.
I would think that's the understatement of the year.
Now what you have done in giving some experimental justification to your extraordinary claim
that consciousness is fundamental, you have some interesting data in terms of the evolutionary
fitness driving perceptions of reality to extinction.
These are interesting ideas that you've come up with.
But at the very maximum, that would seem to give you consciousness as a fundamental factor,
but it would not, by the same fact, ipso facto as we say, it would not wipe out the reality
of the rest of the world, but it would allow you just to bring consciousness down to the
same level of existential fundamentalism, but not to wipe out the other side.
The physical side.
Yeah, you are taking the additional step.
You're creating a new miracle by not only making consciousness fundamental, but wiping
out all the physical world at the same time with no justification.
Right.
So I take consciousness as fundamental, and I say that the physical world is not fundamental.
And I'm saying that your data, what you're basing it on scientifically, you can say whatever
you want.
Sure.
We're a free country, you can say whatever you want.
But in terms of what your data has shown, I mean, I can see how consciousness might
be, in your interpretation, fundamental.
But that does not give you the right to say that everything else doesn't exist.
It just gives you more fundamental things.
I absolutely agree with you.
So I could choose to be a dualist, for example.
I could say I've got this mathematical theory of consciousness, and it's quite rigorous
and it's fundamental.
And I also accept that there is a real objective physical world.
Space and time at the Planck scale is fundamental as well.
I could go there.
And you don't have to be a dualist to do that.
You could just say that instead of four fundamental forces in the universe, there are five, or
I don't know, maybe six.
Maybe you need two for consciousness.
In other words, you could have just consciousness being another fundamental element in the universe,
not necessarily dualistic.
I mean, if we have four fundamental principles in the physical world, electromagnetism, gravity,
strong and weak force of the nucleus, I mean, we're not a fourfold, that's not a dualistic
or a triplistic or a fourpolistic approach to life.
Oh, absolutely.
That's a physical world.
And maybe consciousness is just another one there.
And there are people like Nick Herbert, the quantum physicist Nick Herbert, who's proposed
exactly that, that fundamental particles also have a, you know, a unit like of charge,
but also of consciousness.
Yeah, that's sort of a proto-consciousness kind of a psychist kind of view.
And I wouldn't want to discourage anybody from trying to pursue that.
So as scientists, we all have to sort of, and I agree, at this point, there's nothing
that tells me what I have to do.
So now it's a matter of taste.
And the issue is, I like a monistic theory.
I like the idea that consciousness is fundamental.
And if I can only start with one definition of a conscious agent, and I can give you all
of quantum field theory from that, that's pretty, from a scientific point of view, that
has the kind of elegance that we're looking for.
One hypothesis, and then everything flows from that.
And I haven't done that yet.
I've got some of it, but not all of it.
But to be fair, in terms of your own data, you have, you have brought consciousness down
to a fundamental level.
But you have done nothing to invalidate the existential reality of the physical world.
Other than your desire to be monistic, as you define monism.
Well, I would say that it's, it's consistent.
You don't agree with that?
No, I would say that it's consistent with what we know about, for example, results in
quantum mechanics.
That it's a consistent interpretation of quantum mechanics, apart from my theory.
That the physical world and its properties don't exist apart from their perceptions.
So you can actually, so I mean, the justification I'm talking about here is not a proof.
But it is a justification that says there is this very, very strong body of evidence
from quantum mechanics that very bright, very bright practitioners within the field of quantum
mechanics, not all, but many bright ones have interpreted as saying that the physical world
only exists, its properties, space, time, position, momentum, only exist in the act
of observation.
So it's the physicists themselves, not all of them, by no means, the decoherence physicists
take a different point of view.
But the quantum Bayesian physicists, for example, are quite happy to say that it's basically
the act of observation that creates all the physical properties.
That probabilities only exist and the wave function itself is only in the mind of the
observer.
It's not an objective property of the universe.
So you take that and you combine it with your independent data that brings consciousness
to a fundamental level to at least begin to justify your monistic view that consciousness
is the totality of the reality and that the physical world is the contents of consciousness.
That's absolutely right.
I would lean heavily, for example, on the quantum Bayesian approach to quantum mechanics
to suggest that we don't need to take physics as fundamental.
And then the mathematics of consciousness to suggest that maybe we can take consciousness
as fundamental.
