Does free will exist? Neil deGrasse Tyson and Chuck Nice sit down with astrophysicist Charles Liu sit down to discuss the existence of free will and whether physics allows for choice in our lives.
We explore cause and effect: how does uncertainty and chaos in the universe factor into free will? How important is the illusion of free will to society? What does a society that acknowledges a lack of free will look like?
00:00 - Introduction: Free Will 00:24 - Cause, Effect, & Chaos 4:51 - What Would You Do If Everything Was Predetermined? 6:40 - Free Win in Society 12:08 - Understanding the True Nature of Free Will
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Two speakers debate the existence of free will, contrasting deterministic physics and biological imperatives with the psychological perception of choice. They examine whether human actions are preloaded responses to stimuli or independent decisions, ultimately discussing how a lack of free will should foster societal compassion and restorative justice.
Charles, I want to compare notes on free will.
Oh, one of my favorite things about it.
Here's my take.
It is true that at some level of resolution that we can observe,
causality is absolutely true.
Given these initial conditions, this is what will happen afterwards.
That's the physicist in you speaking.
So if you take it to its logical conclusion,
then there is no free will because everything is predetermined by things
that everything has an antecedent, whether you know it or not,
something is causing it to happen.
Something precipitated the thing that caused the thing that made
that was going to happen.
But there is also stochastic
uncertainty in the universe. It's built in.
There's randomness. There's unpredictability. Yeah.
And so you have to ask, I think, if you're a physicist,
what level of chaos actually affects you
to the extent that you could actually make an instantaneous decision
based on other stuff that's not necessarily in your past experiences
or what you have just seen in your current environment?
But wouldn't all those past experiences and your current environment,
despite the fact that if you're introducing an element of chaos
so that you've never experienced this ever before,
your experiences that you have had
would then inform your decision
about the thing that you've never experienced.
You're informed is the word.
Oh, is it rather than or dedicate? Right. Right.
Oh, require. Oh, right. That's the thing.
Yeah. Let's say you're in a room with a whole bunch of audience members.
You tell a joke. Right. It falls flat.
In that moment, you have many things you could do to turn it into a laugh point.
True. Right. You hear silence.
And you'd be like, oh, that was good.
And then one laughs or, you know, so you make some.
Is this Mike on the old one?
You know, what do you do?
Do you have the freedom to choose one of several choices
that you had designed from your past that you prepared
to deal with that eventuality or is the choice made for you?
But if he was less experienced, he might not dig out of that hole.
Yes. Effectively or efficiently.
Exactly. But if you've been in 100 cases where you had a joke bomb.
Right. You have data on how to pull out of it.
Exactly. So statistically, you have a chance again.
And it happens instantaneously.
You don't even realize that it's happening. It's in the moment.
But yeah, right. Did you have free will to not see that?
Right. So now that would be interesting
because here you are in a place where your instinct,
your training and your desire, 10,000 hours, whatever it is,
will, as a reflex, cause you to say this, this and this.
And the people go, wow, that was great.
Look how he turned it around.
Charles, can I say in that comment that he preloaded his neurosynapses
so that in that moment they all tripped, right?
They tripped, meaning triggered to go to the solution to that problem.
Right. Same is true.
But then I wouldn't have free will at that point.
It would just be a response.
What I would have is a response to a situation.
Not necessarily. I wasn't really choosing that.
It shows it for you. It shows that you have five choices
and then your system chooses one of the five.
Or in that moment, in that moment. Right.
And so in that moment, you are not exercising free will.
Did you set it up, though, with free will in the past
so that you could react this way deterministically?
You actually were in control of the circumstance. Right.
Here's another physical example of that.
A football player is trying to sack a quarterback.
The quarterback jukes left.
The person trying to sack the QB doesn't have enough time
to think about whether to move left or right or up or down.
It has to react based on years of training and practice and experience.
So in that moment, that action is not free.
But in the setting up of that moment, if it was free enough,
does that constitute free will?
From a physics perspective, it might not.
Then again, from a psychological point of view
or from a biological point of view, it might.
But what good are you if you're not landing on one side or the other?
Yeah, I don't need you to say it could be this or that.
And I'm right both ways.
Whichever the actual answer is, I was right. Yeah.
Well, he's saying I don't really have the free will to make that.
I'm going to be right or wrong.
Let's just ask an opinion.
In my opinion, I would like to have free will exist in this universe,
even though philosophically it can be argued that it does not exist.
Are you happy with a world where you perceive free will, even if it isn't?
Maybe. This has to do with the movie Arrival, right?
Starring Amy Adams.
Yeah. If you know how your future is going to turn out,
would you like to live your life anyway?
Right. And the answer is, yes, I would.
But I still would like to think that the future is not yet.
No, no, but I know what is different.
I'm not saying it's predetermined and you know it.
I'm saying, would you still be happy with life
if someone if some alien said, look, dude,
your your life is predetermined as nothing you can do about it.
Keep on believing you have free will.
And then they go back to their planet.
You're a puppet on a string puppet on a string.
That's a free will.
I'm afraid we are free will puppet on a string.
What I would say in that case is that I would hope that the knowledge
that I have, that puppet on the string circumstance
allows me to circumvent it.
I can find a way if, you know, it's fate, right?
You've seen so many Greek mythology stories
where you try to avoid the fate of whatever the gods have.
The act of avoiding it is what makes it happen.
Like Oedipus, for example, would be the most famous example.
Sorry. So.
So the bottom line is, yes, I would still be satisfied
with trying to do something different because even the illusion
of trying to do something different is in itself a form of physics wise, though.
It's not. That's the challenge. Yeah. Right. Yeah.
So. So, Neil, if you had to right now decide
that free will does exist or doesn't exist, what would you prefer?
I am my thinking over the recent years because I didn't used to think
about this at all.
I think in recent years is leaning towards the absence of free will
for practically everything we think and do in our lives.
And I base that on the fact that over time,
things that we have done as people in our species.
At one time was you are totally to blame for that
or something you did or something you we've learned.
No, this person is more susceptible than you are to addiction.
Right. There's a biochemistry there.
This person cannot just be made the life of the party
because they're on the autism spectrum.
They don't control that in the way you might think they should.
Just because you're the life of the party as you add up all of these things.
Let's go back to epilepsy, where before that was even a word.
You were occupied by the devil.
Did you do something bad or what?
You knew it was not.
Everyone knew you were not in control of it.
But today no one is saying,
did you have the free will to not have an epileptic seizure? Of course not.
Do you have the free will to not be depressed?
The person who's ready to jump off the bridge in that instant,
do they have the free will to not jump off the bridge?
I don't think so.
And the more I add up and explore the human condition,
I'm forced to conclude
that the direction we are headed
is that we are all products of an absence of free will.
And as a result, society needs more compassion
for people who do not otherwise fit in.
See, I have the exact opposite position in my own mind.
I feel that it is because of the absence of free will
that you see in most behavior, that it is that one percent
of free will activity that moves us in the right direction,
bends us toward compassion, takes the arc of history or justice.
But then going back to what Neil just said,
there are people who actually suffer from personality disorders,
that suffer from brain disorders, where they can't do what you just said.
They can't express compassion.
They can't move towards a day when no one even
thought to analyze it that way, as a brain disorder.
You were just an a-hole. Yeah, exactly. That was it.
If they can't, you can.
You can show that person compassion or understanding.
And therefore, free will as an entity exists.
You're drawing a line that I have seen
be in constant motion over the decades and over the centuries.
That line that you're saying, they don't have free will, but I do?
Uh-huh. I don't know that I can.
See, I have free will over some things and not over others.
Someone can see me and say, ah, that person needs help in this way
and has the free will to help me.
I see somebody else who needs this help and free will.
Together, it is a network.
It's not that any individual... So you have to draw the line
for every individual and even perhaps for society.
Does the criminal who's born in poverty
have free will to not be a criminal if most of the people in prison
came in below the poverty line?
So there's some sociological force operating there
where we are less susceptible to that force.
I think that's a great question, analogy.
Let's say this.
Say those folks who have been branded criminals by our society
are incarcerated. Yes.
We can then...
We're fortunate enough not to face those same circumstances.
Who are not incarcerated can look at these incarcerated people.
And instead of saying we must keep them away from society,
welcome them back.
So that's called restorative justice.
Yeah. And that's a free will example of the exercise of free will.
Of society. Of society.
Toward individuals who may not have had the options,
had the life experience to recover from a bombed joke.
I saw an old movie where there's a guy who was a junkie.
Yeah. Right. And he needed help.
But they said, no, the cops came and arrested him because he was a junkie.
Today, you wouldn't do that. Right.
You would say the person needs help.
They need. Right. Right.
Even if that person had robbed somebody, that person needs treatment.
And the people who cannot shake
whatever it is that afflicts them tells me
that free will cannot be as free as we think it is.
Do you remember the the the shooter in the University of Texas at Austin?
I remember that. OK.
There's a movie they made out of it called The Tower.
Yeah. Where he left a note saying, I just want to kill people.
Something must be wrong with my brain.
Please, when I die, look at look into this.
They looked and there was a tumor putting pressure on a part of the fact.
That's how we learn anything about how the brain works.
And you have situations like this person had the free will to write the free note.
He had the free will to write the note.
But so he did not have the will to resist shooting.
But that's the the line that you were talking about is a partial one.
Why isn't that line always in motion as we learn more and more
about how the mind works? It is.
OK, so then maybe it's it's it's a convenient line of convenience today.
But tomorrow we're going to find out, oh, my gosh, that person
has no real free control.
It's over their behavior, over their personality.
It's over their tendencies, over their treatment of others.
It's not a line of.
It is, in your words, a perimeter of ignorance.
When Newton said we couldn't explain certain things, right, God must have done.
Of course, that's a god of the gaps.
Of course, that delineates what we don't know.
The line you describe, I hope, is in fact that perimeter of ignorance
which we slowly are moving toward and moving so that we do understand
what the true nature of freedom is.
So this is where people will push back.
Most people are concerned not about
the actions, but the consequences.
So what they're thinking about is the punitive response
to someone who does something wrong and is a punitive response,
a deterrent for somebody doing something wrong
or doing something wrong in the future, especially if they don't have the free will.
Right. So so there's the other side of this entire analysis
is how does society interact with people
who are being brought into the circle day by day?
We're learning what we have control over and what we don't.
Biophysiologically, intellectually, emotionally.
Yes. Why do people need anxiety meds?
Do they have the freedom to not?
They have children.
That is why that is why I'm telling you, I'm taking them every day.
And I got three reasons that I take them every day.
Some kids need them because they have parents.
I'm just saying.
Yeah, it's very nice.
OK, so, Charles, if we're going to exit this conversation.
Yeah. If we find a point of agreement, it's that this perimeter of ignorance
we recognize inside the perimeter.
There are forces operating against free will.
Yes. Our physiology, our neuro chemistry and physics.
That surely that perimeter may grow,
but it's possible that there's a limit to how far it will grow.
Yes. Beyond which we have to admit the existence of free will.
Yes. OK, I'll give you that.
Very nice.
All right.
It doesn't have to be absolute in one direction or another.
It's a bit more fluid.
OK, I'm OK with that.
There is uncertainty in the universe.
I embrace. I'll tell you this much.
I've been married for 20 plus years.
I do not have free will
on that. No.
Chuck and Charles, thanks for helping us with this explainer.
Awesome.
But the perspectives, let's call it, but emergent perspectives on free will.
Neil deGrasse Tyson for StarTalk, yet another explainer in the universe.
Keep looking up.