Consciousness Is Not Produced by the Brain | Rupert Spira

Consciousness Unveiled
3 followers
1 Video View·Dec 9, 2024
In Consciousness Is Not Produced by the Brain, Rupert Spira challenges the materialist view of consciousness and explores its true nature. In this deep discussion, Spira explains why consciousness exists independently of the brain and how it is the fundamental reality behind all experience.
Drawing from non-duality and philosophy, he delves into the unity of consciousness, the illusion of separation, and the limitations of the mind in understanding itself. This thought-provoking conversation invites you to question conventional beliefs and explore a deeper awareness beyond physical existence.
Go back to the matter model. That is the model that matter was here first and that consciousness
was generated from matter. In this model, matter is independent and one. Yes?
Yes.
So you have no problem with the idea that there is something, the original substance,
that whatever was here first must be independent.
Yes.
And that it must be one. So you have no problem with the idea that there is something
that is independent and one.
Yes.
Why do you feel that something is matter rather than consciousness?
Maybe it's just a matter of the majority of people are supporters of that.
Okay, but remember that the majority of people once used to think that the sun went around the
majority of people once used to think that the earth was flat. So truth is not a democracy.
So you can obviously see that just because the majority believe it
tells us absolutely nothing about whether it's true or not.
So dig deeper, find a better reason for believing that consciousness
is independent, sorry, that matter is independent and one rather than consciousness.
I don't know if this is exactly a deeper reason, but I can tell from my personal experience that
brain damage in many cases leads to impairment of consciousness,
as least as I can see it from outside.
It leads to the impairment of the content of consciousness.
Is it possible to see the difference from outside?
But let's take a mild form of brain damage. You have a glass of wine.
Okay.
And this very mildly damages or alters the configuration of your brain. Your experience
changes. But does the consciousness that knows your experience change?
No, it doesn't.
Take a more serious
alteration of the state of your brain or state of your mind. Some kind of illness,
mental illness, mental condition, we start losing our memory, we become muddled.
Can we say that whatever it is that knows our muddled mind is essentially changed?
No, there must be some consciousness still there to be conscious of the changes.
In your experience, does the consciousness that knows your experience ever change?
No.
Let's just take two thoughts. Take the thought 2 plus 2 equals 4.
That thought is known by consciousness. It appears in consciousness, it is known by
consciousness. Now take the thought 2 plus 2 equals 5. That thought appears in consciousness
and is known by consciousness. The fact that one thought is true and the other is untrue
makes absolutely no difference to the consciousness in which they both appear.
Do the same thing, I won't spell it out, do the same thing with
an unpleasant sensation and a pleasant sensation.
An unkind feeling and a loving feeling. A just act and an unjust act.
Does the consciousness in which each of these thoughts, feelings, sensations and activities
appear change according to the content? No, it doesn't. It's our experience that
consciousness is always the same. When I say it is our experience, consciousness is the one
experience. So it is consciousness' experience that consciousness is always in the same condition.
You can verify that from your experience. You, consciousness, can verify that from your
experience. Yes, but wouldn't it feel the same if this consciousness was produced by something else?
Wouldn't it be just the same feeling that it's always the same consciousness?
Consciousness was produced by something else.
It would start in time. The moment it was produced it would start.
Have you, consciousness, ever had the experience of yourself beginning?
I can remember a beginning.
When you say I can't remember a beginning, you imply that there is a beginning to consciousness,
but you can't remember it. But why do you imply that? Because of your conditioning.
Because that's what everybody says. And the reason why everybody says it is because nobody
takes the time and the trouble to actually look at their experience of consciousness.
Has anybody here ever had the experience of consciousness beginning?
Or of consciousness ending, for that matter?
Well, it's almost an impossible experience because
if consciousness ended there would be somebody there to be conscious of that.
So, as you rightly say, nobody has ever had or could ever have the experience of consciousness
either beginning or ending. And yet our world culture is founded on the single belief that
consciousness begins when the body is born and it ends when the body dies. But that belief is
completely unverifiable. And yet our culture is founded on it.
Simply a belief that doesn't stand the scrutiny of reason or experience.
So I just have to trust my experience more.
Well, there are two possibilities. Experience or belief.
Which do you think is the most trustworthy?
I take the experience.
Because if we trust our beliefs, the only reason, as you said earlier, that we trust our beliefs
is because everybody else believes the same thing.
So everybody believes that consciousness is a by-product of the body, that it shares the
limits and destiny of the body. Why? Because everybody else believes it. That's why everybody
used to believe the earth was flat, or the sun went round the earth, just because it was the
paradigm. And the superficial look at the earth seemed to validate that belief. But a deeper look
at the situation, a few people began to realize, no, it can't be. It's not. The earth can't be
flat. We look at it more closely. And then they began to gather evidence. And a few more people
began to understand it. And eventually there was a paradigm shift. In this case,
mystics from all traditions for centuries have been saying that consciousness, spirit,
is the ultimate reality. It's not even a new idea.
You see, the consciousness-only model
doesn't imply that we have to completely get rid of
our knowledge of matter or physics. It just puts the laws of physics in a larger context.
From Jane's point of view, you remember, Mary dreams that she's Jane. So from Jane's point of
view, the streets of London seem to be made out of this stuff called matter. And the laws of physics
are descriptions of the way this stuff called matter behaves.
Those laws of physics, they don't have to be changed.
They're just given a new interpretation. They're seen in a larger context. The laws of physics,
the laws of the way this stuff called matter in Jane's world works, they're still true
under the consciousness-only model. Gravity still works in the consciousness-only model,
just as it worked when the earth was flat, or when we thought the earth was the center of the
changing paradise. But it was put in a new context. It was given a new interpretation.
In fact, under the consciousness-only model, the laws of physics are
upgraded from descriptions of the way matter behaves to descriptions of the way mind unfolds
in consciousness. Because from the consciousness-only model, the universe is an activity of mind.
It's not an object made out of matter.
Do you think it's a coincidence that physicists still haven't found this stuff called matter?
Could it be that the reason they haven't found this stuff yet is that it's not
there in the way that it is normally conceived?
Whereas we have found this stuff called consciousness.
You could say, well, how are we going to choose between these two models?
Very easy. If we stick to our experience. Consciousness is experienced. Each of us
knows that they are aware. Consciousness is experienced. It is experiencing itself.
Nobody's ever found this stuff called matter. All we ever find is the content of our own minds.
So matter is a kind of abstraction.
Matter is the name our culture gives to the stuff that is supposed to exist outside consciousness.
But we've never found that stuff.
