In this engaging podcast conversation, BJ Kang and Fred Sottile delve into the historical and fictional portrayal of Stalin's death in the film 'The Death of Stalin.'
While exploring the comedic yet grim portrayal of Soviet Russia's power struggles and the ruthless tactics employed by its leaders, Fred brought up the current power struggle in Xi's communist regime in China and Washington D.C.'s political circles.
From analyzing characters to critiquing the film's portrayal of the era, they offer differing perspectives on its significance and entertainment value. Join them as they navigate through the complexities of history and humor, and share your thoughts on its portrayal of history in the comments below.
they were all just vying for power it
was almost like they were kind of hardly
people a bit they were very much people
but they were very much obsessed with
trying to fill the power void that is
just strictly a survival at any cost and
when you come back to it we're all
Savages really there's been no
[Music]
Evolution hi welcome to the real
generation gap I'm BJ King and this is
Fred Sai and today we're reviewing the
of Stalin a historical fictionalization
of the death of the USSR leader and the
chaos to fill the power void that
follows you know I watched this movie
and politics in a polit bureau it's a
real clown show isn't it yeah one of the
reasons why I suggested this movie was
because I was really impressed with the
way that they were able to uh portray
the sort of power grab and a pretty
traumatic one at that but derive like
some pretty natural and pretty hilarious
moments from it you know I got to wonder
what's going to happen when Soros dies
imagine the power vacuum there I know he
has a son but you know the sons of these
guys are always inept right yeah and you
just know that when he goes there's
already a vast amount of politicians
lawyers accountants that are going to
all want some chunk of that right yeah
it'll be interesting to see that that
chaos that clown show just a thought
yeah and that's what makes this film
funny to me in my opinion it's like it
it's hard when you think of the USSR as
funny as there's any comedy that comes
from it like let's be honest that
starvation more than what like like tens
hundreds of million people dead from
starving freezing no medical care yeah
right circumstances of pure hopelessness
Mass imprisonment Mass persecution yeah
and so who did get to work on it Michael
Palin right after Life of Brian and nail
Jesus to the cross it must have been
really living hell but you did recommend
this movie because it is funny and I did
laugh at times but
after we did the review on the road to
wellville I I thought the movie was
funny however the road to wellville is
based on like true historical events and
there's true people that lived that and
I felt that the comedy was a little
unbalanced in the road to wellville and
so it was my idea suggest this one where
I thought that the comedy was naturally
derived uh but you know definitely takes
front center but uh doesn't overshadow
the seriousness of what's going on
during this time I mean this is the USSR
for crying out loud so you like balance
comedy when it comes to genocidal polit
bureaus I don't know man I don't know
yeah did you find the film was like
insensitive in any way
or these young people it's always I was
offended you know no there was no racism
MH you know these guys they're they're
trying to search for their position now
in in in a regime that doesn't exist yet
yeah so you going to be the boss am I
going to be the boss am I going to work
for him is he going to work for me we
got to kill a couple of these people
somebody got to you know what happens
what do we do with stop 's psychotic
daughter and his alcoholic son we got to
deal deal with them somehow and they
were funny characters yeah they were
they were I mean I did laugh but holy
smokes to be honest you're right it's
death of Stalin there's not like
anything I would say that's like gut
busting you know laughing funny but it's
a sort of dry situational humor that
comes from the absurdity of like a hyper
bureaucratic government like that with
all the paranoia and power plays going
on it's it's it's ridiculous you know
yeah they even had that scene where the
train was on time right it was like who
how come the train is here it's supposed
to come here now it's on time you know
the one thing that they did right they
made the trains run on time yeah so yeah
it was a funny movie a funny movie based
on a horrifically serious you know you
wouldn't think that this would be made
but you know you got to find funny stuff
in these and Michael Palin he was a king
of satire I mean the uh Monty Python was
hilarious and then he he made other
movies that were like that I I liken
this very much to Life of Brian you know
Life of Brian was uh in a horrible time
the Romans were oppressing the Israelis
in their homeand yeah crucifying people
and here was a guy who just nothing made
sense to him everybody was wacky the
Romans were wacky the Jews were wacky
every his circumstances were wacky the
fact that he ended up being nailed at
across at the end was you know he took
it in stride so yeah Michael Palin's the
he must in his own life he must have a
very sarcastic view of politics and
history yeah and you and I both know
that history is written by The Victors
well that's the cliche but it's written
by people who really don't know
everything that happened yeah they just
write down what they think I mean I I
I've made many many attempts to read um
the gulag
archipelago and it's it's a huge piece
it's in in my opinion impossible to read
it's regarded as a literary Masterpiece
but that was a guy who he lived through
this horrible event and he he really
made a historic account of it you know
so things like this this had a lot of
accurate historical things all the
people cruff really was there and that
kind of thing but um I love Jeffrey
tambor's character was it mov Malikov
Mal malov malinov yeah he he was trying
to do the right thing by everybody Bui
was trying to survive the thing and
remain in power he recognized the power
pacum yeah you know and in real life
cruff did become the premere right mhm
so a lot of things were good I loved the
scenes in the Kremlin I don't know if
that was actually the Kremlin but just
some of those floors and ceilings and
you know the buildings themselves were
pretty spectacular those parts were were
pretty amazing the set pieces and the
costume design I really love that the
subtle distinction between the Red Army
and the nkvd there's a very subtle
distinction of the blue accents on the
uniforms versus the red Army's red
accents yeah so everybody was in the
armbands back then weren they that was a
real thing Nazis had them you know yeah
but there was there was a real lot of
care put into like reinforcing the
environment that they were in which is
this is the USSR but we're in the PA
Bureau building you know and they're in
the grand Halls of you know Moscow and
there's a lot of uh you know
bureaucratic nonsense going on in those
uh those behind those walls it was
really chaotic and when you have an
individual who's in power look what
happened in Cuba with Fidel right when
he died same thing power vacuum They
Don't Really in any of those structures
there's never really a a chain of a
chain of transition mhm it's always when
that guy dies it just becomes a big
Power grab yeah it's just a period of
Madness and that period of Madness was
portrayed real well in the movie in a
funny funny way yeah but you got to know
in real life these guys all wanted to
kill each other sure that that's what I
really liked about this fil was like it
was a really good balance and uh Simon
Russell Beal who plays uh Bara um he was
probably the most ruthless out of all of
these characters and was probably the
most ruthless out of all of the Central
Committee that was going on in the USSR
at the time I mean he the acts that you
see him do in the movie are actually
they were worse in real life obviously
worse in real life yeah but but he was a
ruthless guy he he did he didn't care he
didn't care what happened to anybody as
long as he retained power and he was
unable to do it yeah so he was
outmaneuvered and right outmaneuvered by
the funny guy by the court tester yeah
that's why I thought Bashi was a perfect
actor to put in kev's shoes for this
movie Kev historically was he in order
to survive in Stalin's Inner Circle he
was the funny guy he knew that the best
way to survive and to not you know be
ousted from his inner circle or to have
Stalin be paranoid against someone was
to be the one guy who made him laugh the
most and that scene where you where
kushev goes back and has a has his wife
write down what jokes that Stalin liked
and which ones he didn't that's a real
thing that happened and if you want a
versatile actor to play a man who has
two different faces trying to survive in
this uh paranoid crazy man's uh
committee you get bashy you get Steve
Bushi to do it he really did do a great
job he did it was funny because he had
that bald head wig thing on and it
looked so goofy he looked like one of
The Cone Heads you know it's amazing the
Hollywood can do that yeah but but they
they do so I thought it was a good
recommendation I I enjoyed watching it
even though it was a little silly for me
and I'm I'm silly you know I'll watch a
silly movie or something but just
because it was it such a dark place and
such a dark time and such a dark history
and everything there you know everything
to do with Soviet Russia was just so
unfair I mean they just genocidal
destroyed the population and other
populations you know I mean they didn't
care if they starve the whole country or
anything so you know it's it's like
making jokes about the Holocaust it's
just like always in bad taste you know
yeah and I'm not going to tell any
Holocaust jokes as much as I'm you know
compelled to but I'm so focused on the
horror of world events even now yeah you
know one one of the things um that came
to mind and came up in conversation was
China has this going on right now yeah g
he's a singular dictator for him to
remain in power he has to suppress all
opposition whether it's from the tiniest
people to to other oligarchs Chinese
oligarchs industrialists anything like
that he has got to remain iron fisted in
power and he's doing a good job of it
yeah but it's 2024 now we still have the
same format we have the same Paradigm
it's you want to come to power you want
to hold power you have an oligarchy that
brings you to that Apex and then after
that it's just strictly a survival at
any cost yeah and it's barbaric I mean
when you come back to it we're all
Savages you know it's just a till of the
hunt in 2024 yeah it's really there's
been no Evolution when this uh all this
violence started in Israel recently and
then just before that when it started in
the Ukraine I couldn't believe that in
this day of age day and age that we're
going to have an armed conflict really
really an armed and the world is going
to watch this you would have thought
that the UN would have shut this down
immediately yeah they would have some
vast amount of like a people that all
agreed a giant consensus of world
leaders would have gone to Russia and
said Vladimir you have to stop killing
people zinsky you have to stop running a
corrupt government where you're a banker
for the American president and you're
doing all this between the
genocidal chemistry Labs you know the
medical stuff that's going on and all
the money laundering and everything you
would think that there would be an adult
in the room at last but it's not this
movie all of these guys were wacky kids
they were kids that grew up and got big
and fat but they were still having a
schoolyard battle now you mentioned this
so I'm going to bring it up this is a
great thing that you said that made me
laugh is when is too many medals too
many how many medals is too many look at
these guys could you imagine a grown
adult dressing like that it's worse than
the Pope I here's a fun fact that
character right there who I believe is
is zukov who is the field Marshal he had
more medals in real life they actually
they actually had to tone back on the
amount of medals that they put on him in
this movie because that would have been
too that would have been too cartoonish
but he had more medals in real life than
he actually does in this movie how many
possible battles or campaigns could you
be involved in that you need to be
decorated to that degree you see it even
in our own government you see these guys
come before Congress they got this great
big fruit salad bar right you know all
these things all these things and it's
interesting to me that even though
you've got all those things what did you
improve why are we a better world
because you did that one that one that
one that one I think that one's for the
Royal auto club he got that when he
bought an MGB you know what I mean but
it's just just ludicrous you know the
stuff on the shoulders you know the
epilates and everything look look at the
coat this guy's we and how much money
was that to be fair this was the General
this was the uh the deputy uh uh
Marshall who who who beat Hitler he he
was the leader he was one of the leaders
of the Red Army during World War II so
well that's good that's good that's
that's a whole another can of worms
right our allies the Russians yeah you
know to to defeat Hitler wow we could
talk about that that's the whole rest of
the you know till the sun goes down and
we're out in the parking lot but look at
that with the scar on his face yeah he
looks like a genuine badass he really
was um he kind of looks like Putin I
mean look at that you know the actor was
J Jason Isaacs he's a very popular
British actor and I thought for
specifically zukov I thought he did a a
great job at capturing sort of the not
so much the historical figure of who he
was but like the legendary figure of who
he was I mean there's a scene where
Steve Bim cuts into his discussion that
he's having with other partygoers and he
goes and zukov then put the banner on
Hitler's bunker and then punched out a
bear the legendary you know the
legendary stories about zukov was like
that and it paid cred to history too in
order to you know basically stage a coup
like what they did in the movie they
needed zov's help because he was a
beloved hero in the Soviet Union yeah
yeah I guess if you're Larger than Life
you have you have the correct place
you're correct to be there and and dress
the part you know every girl's crazy
about a sharp-dressed man right so so I
I enjoyed the movie I'm glad you
recommended it I might have not watched
it otherwise and that's this whole real
generation gap thing right is to turn
you onto stuff and for you to turn me
onto stuff yeah tell me about the ones
you liked uh I like I said Simon Russell
Beal who played Baria the U the one all
the way there on the right yeah just a
Monster yeah so a homicidal lunatic I
thought he did a terrific job because
Baria was was ruthless and brutal and
cold and a monster in real life and he
did such a good job of playing someone
so slimy so cruel but also such a
manipulator and such a schemer you know
who I'll give credit to Jeffrey Tambour
yeah yeah Jeffrey tamb
he played the part of the guy who was
supposed to take over and he had the
best interest of the world at heart he
had the Russian people's interest at
heart and even though we had all these
good qualities nobody liked them or took
them seriously because they all wanted
to fight their way to the top and he was
like I'm the second in command according
to our constitution I'm the one that
takes over and now I have to correct
everything and make everything right
according to the policies that were set
in place and everybody else was like the
hell with the policies we're going to
we're just going fight that this is a
cage match you know so I like Jeffrey
Tambour anyway he definitely played U he
was a puppet like in that movie
completely right even though he was the
one who was right in the whole group
yeah he was the one that really didn't
have any power and and didn't struggle
for power you know so I liked him him
and his part there's Jeffrey Tambour on
the left you
know that's a perfect picture him look
how look how disappointed sad dejected
you know and he's facing he's facing
these guys who would just want to murder
him yeah I'll definitely agree that uh
the death of Stalin is I would say is
when it comes to its humor it's a bit
more maybe a little reserved I described
it as dry and situational not Innovative
I'll give you that much for sure but I
thought it did a really good job of
deriving humor from I was impressed with
how much it derived humor from what was
such a grim and oppressive regime I
thought you know trying to find
something funny out of that at all would
be impossible well what you find funny
they had a scene where they had people
on their knees and they were shooting in
the back of the head execution style and
then happened that distracted them and
they just left all the guys stand on
them on their knees and they just went
off and then the guy who was next to be
shot was
like where is everybody you know
eventually they just walked away I can
see something like that happening in
real life you know it's like when the
police pull a guy over and then all of a
sudden they get like the homicidal
lunatic is you know right down and they
just like just drive better and they get
back on their car and drive while you're
standing there like where's my ticket
situational humor right there yeah yeah
one of the scenes that I really like
that stood out to me that really
captured the sort of uh the the the
nonsense the comedy from the the the
political games was when when Stalin's
truck is taking off from his uh his
Manor and Baria gets out first to lower
his hat down right so that so he looks
more respectful than the other members
and so they all quickly follow and then
he immediately is the first one to run
back to his car so he's the first one to
sort of follow the thing and it was just
that was hilarious to me cuz they they
all just start scrambling back to their
cars and and uh Steve buan character
goes I was like what are we last now cuz
he ends uping and he was the first one
at the front and that was like teenagers
of hot rods yeah you know what I mean it
show like it was a juvenile Animal House
moment was like we got to get in line
everybody oh my God you know and they
all almost crashed into each other like
they all conversed at once and that it
was like a seen out of mad mad mad mad
world or something God how could that
happen with adults in a situation like
that I mean they were all just vying for
power and you
know it was almost like they were kind
of hardly people a bit they were very
much people but they were very much
obsessed with trying to fill the power
void not not only were they vying to
have power but they were also trying to
make sure that they weren't killed by
somebody else who was vying for power
what an awful situation that's why I
thought it was really interesting where
you said like it felt like there was no
real villains in this movie when Barry
was clearly I think to me right he was
the villain he was the biggest threat
but you know what I didn't take him
seriously from the beginning I knew he
wouldn't end up doing well you know yeah
because you usually somebody that's real
intense like that is rejected by the
group yeah and and they really rejected
him well didn't they yes they did yeah
so what did you think of the uh the
trial scene that they had at the very
end where they take him out to like a
sort of yeah that was that to me was
historically accurate yeah you know it's
like we have charges we found you guilty
we're going to execute you now we're
gonna you know it's like do I get to say
anything
no that was definitely one of the most
dramatic parts of the movie right there
and that was that was one of the movies
where it was just the most somber a lot
of the comedy uh there there was no
comedy in that scene to me because it
was like very straight to the point this
is what the USSR was like it was a
political Rat Race and there it was ugly
and it was messy and it got bloody got
bloody when when I think of all those
people in the goog when I think of all
the people wrenched out of their homes
out of the arms of their loved ones
people that just disappeared without an
explanation there's been plenty of
movies about it yeah you know and like I
said I tried to read sultanates and and
it just was so heavy and lengthy and and
it's just hard to you know I I I found
it very easy to fall asleep during
reading it I I saw another movie where
some people way out in Siberia escaped
and they they they literally walked all
the way to India over over the over the
Himalayas and that to escape that and
all all that they went through and doing
that and I I it's very hard for me I
wouldn't want to hurt somebody a little
bit like I I wouldn't want to step on
your toe yeah and the fact that there
are these just these not only killers
are one thing but torturers are another
to take train loads of people and take
them way out into Siberia and just dump
them off no food and no medical care and
you know what what just freezing to
death and oh my God the the brutality
and barbarity of that it's it's hard for
me to accept as a human being yeah I I
can hardly believe that it still goes on
but it does there are ethnic groups all
around the world that are that are
suppressed and murdered and genocid
wiped out and I was born during the
Korean conflict and then I had the
Vietnam War to look at and then all
these things the Middle East Desert
Storm and all I I can't believe that it
goes on time after time after time it's
just one of these when do we learn and
we don't learn yeah we're still all just
a bunch of juvenile jackasses you know
and look look what's in Washington DC
right now where were they raised what
what kind of what's what what in society
continues to produce that over and over
these damaged people rising to the top
of power and just making life miserable
for everybody else yeah so the movie was
a funny movie and I watch it as a funny
movie I laugh during the movie in a
situation like that no one is safe yeah
no one the the guy at the very top may
be assassinated and everybody below him
may be so you're almost better off just
being like you just run a print shop
somewhere you know I mean in America
right now the entire population nobody
feels safe yeah everybody's afraid to
say the wrong word or go to the wrong
thing or even look at the wrong person
the wrong way or any kind of a faux paw
would get you in some horrible trouble
we're not supposed to live like that
we're supposed to be happy friendly
people with a good sense of humor very
helpful that's that's the better nature
of man so it's good to it's good to see
a situation like this a movie like this
yeah and you realize I I like to vilify
China and say this is going on in China
but it's going on right here too it's
going on right here yeah look look at
people who are just swiped the the most
smallest thing like you're swiped off of
Facebook they censored you off you can't
go on Facebook anymore are you kidding
are you kidding really they're they're
they're micromanaging us to that level
today in my email I got a thing from
Google Maps where they showed me
everywhere I went for the past entire
month you made three trips here two
trips over here you went to this place
you went it shows this visit right here
you know how many times I went here in
the last 30 days what is up with that
what's up with that H how they send me
the
report I mean if you don't think they're
recording every word we say in every
keystroke of our computer they are
that's what they did in the movie like
when uh kushev and and uh Molotov were
talking in in in his bathroom they
flushed the toilet because they were
worried that they were going to be
bugged and everyone was on a list
everyone was terrified of being on one
of Barry's lists cuz it's like for the
smallest little thing you could get
thrown into one of the nkvd uh holding
cells and get tortured and then not come
out or Worse right yeah yeah right right
you come out dead yeah
so I don't know for me I really enjoyed
the film because I thought that it drew
a lot of really great natural comedy
from the bureaucratic Rat Race going on
in the Central Committee but it also you
know did not shy away from showing the
seriousness the sort of uh the suffering
that goes on from those rat races but it
seems like maybe uh from what I've been
hearing from you thought maybe it wasn't
his balance as good that maybe it sort
of glossed over the that suffering that
really you know went on during that time
I think it's just a difference of
perspective MH you know and and I think
that the environment that you watch the
movie in has something to do with it so
maybe I had an attitude at the time you
know and maybe you did right you know
you're looking for a certain thing maybe
or whatever it may be maybe I maybe I
had just seen something pretty Grim
before that so the movie was a little
more Grim yeah you know maybe if I had
three or four people with me and I was
all happy and we were partying a little
bit and stuff maybe that the movie would
have been funnier so I understand what
you're looking for and there was some
amount of balance of that I think it's a
matter of perspective I think each
individual is going to judge that for
themselves you think this movie is gonna
it'll look different like based on who's
watching it definitely I think that uh
the the many horrible things I've seen
in life uh made me focus on that I I
really not happy with
entire genocidal regimes I'm very very
unhappy with the incursion of Communism
into the United States now I know it
doesn't end well so this should be a
warning to people and and I it's hard
for me to to break away from that
because I I watch politics I'm kind of a
political junkie yeah and I see horrible
things happening every day here you know
witch hunts and stuff like that and I'm
not happy about it it shouldn't be I
really enjoy the movie and I suggested
it cuz personally I think it's a really
for for I think a comedy that is
historical and also balances like some
serious topics I think this is a
must-watch do you think that this is a
must-watch um no I don't think it's a
must-watch but I I would like to see
people you know what this is one of
those situations where I want to see the
comment section I would love it for the
people who do watch this to go in a
comment section and because you're you
felt it was so well balanced and
everything I'd like to know if people
were really happy with it or if they
were outraged by it or they thought it
was genius or they thought it was stupid
I'd like to see that I might have
watched this movie spontaneously you
know I I fall asleep in front of the TV
every night you know takes me like three
four nights to get through a movie I
suggested this movie because I thought
it was a really good balance it derived
great natural humor from a real
historical event well also not glazing
over the seriousness of what went on in
during this time and for me I think
that's a mustat and I was going to ask
like do you not think this is a
must-watch I didn't think it was a
must-watch but I appreciate app your
perspective yeah it's okay for you too
you know I think this was a good
suggestion I think for me uh I think for
other people as well I I think this is a
must-watch I think when it comes to you
know like I had the problem with the
road to wellville and our last one and
where I felt that you know it's real
historical event there are serious
things going on in this film and I felt
like there was a lot of things that the
audience was robbed from because there
wasn't enough of a focus on that and in
this one I felt like it was a really
balanced focus and I felt like if you
want to have a good you know comedy
historical one with serious topics this
this is what you should watch I
certainly concede I I certainly concede
yeah yeah for me I agree that it wasn't
it it wasn't amazing it wasn't like the
greatest film of all time but I think
it's definitely a necessary one to watch
I think when it comes to seeing how
humor can be driven out uh you know
driven out of a natural historical event
as well as balancing you know the
seriousness with it and some active
performances are are really good really
capturing the characters of these uh
these historical figures I think it's a
mustsee watch and it's got its flaws
here and there but I think for me it's
an8 out of 10 okay that's that's a good
rating I I appreciate that you liked it
that much and I will go with a six okay
great you know
so thank you for watching the real
generation gap make sure to hit that
like button and subscribe and leave a
comment down below did you think the
death of Stalin was a balanced comedy it
where it you know both the seriousness
and The Comedy of it was well done or do
you think that it completely missed the
mark let us know in the comments coms
down below thank you