Join Shane, the tech-savvy millennial, and Fred, the seasoned boomer, in a thought-provoking discussion about the film "American Fiction." In this engaging conversation, the two dive deep into the movie's themes, touching on topics that span across generations.
🤔 Is Black Culture Today a Gimmick? Shane and Fred bring their unique perspectives to the forefront as they explore the portrayal of black culture in "American Fiction." They delve into the question of whether contemporary representations are authentic expressions or mere gimmicks, unraveling the complexities of cultural representation in modern cinema.
💔 Navigating the Struggles of Alzheimer's Care The conversation takes a poignant turn as they share personal experiences and reflections on the film's portrayal of the challenges involved in caring for a family member with Alzheimer's. Shane and Fred offer heartfelt insights into the emotional rollercoaster of dealing with this devastating illness, highlighting the universality of the human experience across generational lines.
🎼 The Emotional Power of Film Scores Shifting gears, our duo explores the impact of the film's score on audience emotions. They analyze how the carefully crafted musical composition enhances the storytelling, eliciting specific feelings and connecting viewers on a deeper level. Shane and Fred unpack the artistry behind film scoring and its role in creating a truly immersive cinematic experience.
🎥 Subscribe and Join the Conversation! Don't miss out on this captivating discussion that goes beyond the screen. Subscribe now to be part of the dialogue, and share your thoughts on "American Fiction" and the broader issues it raises with Shane and Fred. Let's build a community that values diverse perspectives and meaningful conversations. 🍿✨
this time on the real generation gap
they have really normal family issues
and they go through a small story arc
there's character development but it's
not ridiculous if that makes sense it's
real it's real to me there was nothing
racial about him yeah every family of
every race has this
[Music]
mhm hello welcome to the real generation
gap my name is Shane schm I'm Fred satii
and I'm special guest BJ Kang and today
we are reviewing American
fiction before we dive into this review
please give us a thumbs up hit that
subscription button and leave us a
comment on what movies you think we
should review next let's get into it so
when I first saw this movie poster I
looked at it and I thought you know I
would never watch this to me it looks
like something like Tyler Perry would
make and I think that those movies are
always very corny representations of
black culture which ironically is
hilarious because that's what this movie
is completely about and I did not know
that at all and that kind of you know
sprung up the question has Black Culture
become a gimmick what do you guys think
well I kept thinking this is an
antiblack black movie where it's like
not so much that they're trying to spin
a narrative that it's like against black
people but just the narrative is about
it's against the narratives about black
people that are popular in Hollywood
today it's like this family are all very
educated very successful people they're
all doctors yeah they're all doctors and
that's not the sort of family you sort
of black family you see a lot in like
American Cinema or the ones that at
least are the most popular I've seen a
lot of like black Le movies like very
prominent Black cast movies which is
like you know uh boys in the hood 12
years of slave Friday uh which are all
also great movies yes they are but it
seems that it's always yeah they're the
slave or they're the the ghetto dude in
the hood and that's the the stories we
always have and whenever it is those
stories I feel like it's always
automatically Contender for the awards
like oh he was so great in the slave
Oscar bait yeah yeah and it's just like
because it's a Slave movie or or because
it's about a a black person going
through whatever the the black
stereotype is it's always it's become a
gimmick to in in my opinion and that's
kind of what I thought about this movie
like oh it looks like a gimmick and yeah
so it's I think it's awesome that that's
what this movie is about love it what
what it is very uh black yes that's it
I'm happy you said it and not me Fred
what' you think well the thing I liked
most about it was it has almost an all
black cast in fact the white people that
are in the movie are these pathetic
wimps they're these weird pandering like
anything black is so cool you know and
we got to get rid of those kind of
people and I also don't like a movie
that has a token black person like
you'll see a mov movie in a white
Community with a white family only the
daughter has a black boyfriend or the or
the wife has an ex-husband who was a
black eyy you know what I mean they put
that in there it's like oh my God but
this was a movie Perfectly written
perfectly cast perfectly acted perfectly
directed I was really really happy to
see this movie I didn't want to see it
either necessarily and our friend Rudy
he he was the one who said look man you
got to go see this movie and I'm like if
I have to and I came out of there like
shocked yeah I really I'm a big fan of
this story and when I when I watch
movies I like to think of the character
development where does the main
character start where does he end and I
like this movie because I think it's
really real in the sense that not
there's not always this Grand character
development the main character kind of
starts as an [ __ ] but in the end he's
still kind of a dick and uh I think
that's like real it wasn't like like
some Grand like he becomes a better
person or he frees his family from
poverty or something crazy like that it
was just like this upper class family
they have really normal family issues
and they go through a small story arc
there's character development but it's
not ridiculous if that makes sense it's
real it's real to me and I like that a
lot I like the fact that you use the
word real cuz this is a word that's
thrown around a lot in the entire movie
they use words like raw authentic real
or like we need to tell true experiences
and stories when the whole time he's
being his real self he's a black man
being his real self and for some reason
that's not real Blackness and it's just
like he's going through this like whole
conflict of like what the hell does that
even mean editors they want a black book
they had one I'm black and it's my book
look at what they expect us to write yo
Shir where you be going in a hurry like
that what do what do you think Fred like
well thanks for asking because this is a
comment on society today in in a hall
everything that they said was real and
raw and natural and all that stuff that
was all the stuff that was not real the
real guy was a dignified gentleman he
was an intellectual an academic and so
were his families they couldn't make any
money being in that and even so was his
competitor too she was an intellectual
as well yeah she was a you know some
University Professor who wrote this crap
and it was commercial crap and I I I
love that you know I I love it that they
brought out that especially once again
the the white people when they're like
oh this is so raw this is so real this
is so edgy it was like this is all
fiction black people are not like that I
think that often times the media uses
race to divide us so we don't focus on
the things that unite us right those
secret societies those secret societies
are just class division or you know
economic division but instead they want
to keep us divided by things like race
and there there's even other things in
this like uh being gay is a big it's
kind of a big proponent in uh the the
movie The brother is gay and he didn't
want to come out to his family and then
his mom uh says really messed up stuff
to him and he had a good character Arc I
liked I liked his character Arc the most
actually and Rudy was even talking about
it with me and uh basically his
character Arc is the whole time he just
wants he wants to just be accepted for
who he is and uh yeah no drama he's not
being stle gay he's not putting on a big
fairy show or something he just happens
to be a homosexual I still live in
Tucson what's wrong with Tucson there's
one gay bar and it's full of college
kids one of them asked me if I was Tyler
Perry I mean Tyler Perry lives in
Atlanta right [ __ ] you so Sterling Brown
is the name of the actor and he he's not
gay so it it he he did a fantastic job I
I really every actor in this thing yeah
was so great yeah when I was basically
he he wants to be accepted by his family
and his mom like calls him a I knew you
weren't a queer she said something like
that that's what she said um and then
they they said the dad she was the one
that had the Alzheimer yeah and they
said the dad never accepted him but in
the end spoiler alert the maid was like
don't go anywhere your family and then
that's when he felt finally felt
accepted and like good and that's all he
ever wanted to hear from his family
members um but yeah like that was a big
part of the story but it wasn't like
blatant your face like overthe toop
homosexuality it was just that's who he
is I agree like the acting was
phenomenal because the way that they
approach the characters the way that
they portray the characters the writing
and the acting together is is written
with so much class so much subtlety it's
like yes the brother is gay and that's a
pretty prominent thing that goes on in
uh like Black Culture but it's done with
so much tact and not with like a lot of
fanfare and not making such a big deal
out of it that's pandering or sort of
putting it on ped St that it comes off
really realistic and believable and it's
kind of an interesting
Duos the
writing doesn't have any ebonics in it
the ebonics are
affected right so the guy who made the
movie everything is clean and classy and
all that kind of stuff and yet it's a
movie about if you want to be successful
in Black
especially with these white people yeah
you have to be this denigrated degraded
person yeah yeah and that opened up some
really cool scenes I thought it was
really cool when he was writing but then
the scene was being played out in front
of him yeah I thought that was a really
cool way to to show that to illustrate
that he was inventing the characters and
and he every now and then they checked
back with him like what do I do yeah I
thought that was a really cool way to
illustrate you know the one character
says oh man why did you write that why
would you have to write that about me
it's like cuz that's what sells yeah and
and there there was an issue in the
movie that was very near and dear to my
heart and that is affording to care for
a parent on the decline yeah okay here's
a a dignified gentleman he's a college
professor and his mother is beginning to
get
dementia and he he can no longer care
for her and it's difficult for the
family his sister dies his brother is
got got issues got got a divorce problem
and he's got to make money he's got to
make money to put her in the nursing
home he's too wealthy to get public
assistance and he's too poor to just
afford it so he has to do some uh cheap
thing to drag in a whole bunch of cheap
money really quick take care of her and
so he decides to suck up his dignity and
write a crap trash novel MH and of
course the thing explodes in the charts
and he's making a fortune now but just
like in dream scenario right in dream
scenario the guy wanted to be
acknowledged for his
work and he didn't want to be the pop
culture guy and this guy's the same way
he's like I've written good books no one
will buy them I wrote a crap book that
everybody is
buying yeah and I think but the
beginning of the point you were making
that uh Alzheimer's it's it's super
real and right now I have an aunt on one
side of my family and an uncle on my
other side of my family and they don't
even recognize me anymore um and it's
just really difficult to deal with as a
a nephew who I see them once or twice a
year uh I can't imagine dealing with it
as a parent and I know that it's
becoming more common uh a more common
illness in our society so I think that
touching on that was really real and uh
and raw and raw it was and like that
that's what I really loved about this
family struggle that they're going
through they're a black family but the
struggle that they're going through is
not common to what you see in other
movies like if you've ever seen the
movie fences which is also a very good
movie the one with Denzel Washington the
family struggles are going through is
that there's an affair they're poor um
and things like that they struggle with
like racism and that's fine that's a
real struggle that some families deal
with the problem becomes when you look
at an authentic story and you see a
formula and then you think that you can
just copy that formula to make money
that's great writing yeah yeah yeah
every everything about this movie was
Top Shelf mhm there there was it was
lacking for nothing I I came out with
not one criticism all the family
problems that this family had there was
nothing racial about them yeah every
family of every race has this MH so
there's real relatable there's
relationships between the siblings you
know they don't all get along right
which is super real I know all about
that um I thought that was you know
really cool um that they just you know
they didn't necessarily hate each other
they didn't necessarily they weren't the
best of friends people but they were
trying yeah they were trying yeah and
there's some resolution to that at the
end too but kind of which is nice and I
I especially love the ending because
it's it's sort of unsatisfying it it
sort of is not sort of it doesn't have a
clean wrapup but that's kind of like how
life really is sometimes there's
sometimes certain scenarios do not are
not neatly wrapped up or not satisfying
and that's a point that he's uh that
monk tries to make earlier in the movie
where he says uh you shouldn't be
writing you shouldn't be creating art
simply to satisfy the people because
then you're not making art and I thought
the ending perfectly Illustrated that my
favorite part of the Fantastic magic of
this movie was that there were three
endings and that's that's a real
exploration of the story then right so
all these things happen 90% of the story
was there and how's it going to end well
it could end this way or it could end
this way and then it's black screen yeah
you decide yeah you know and that's
really cool when something like that
happens I thought that was a fun way to
end it and you're right the third ending
really was the cliche that made every
other cliche in the movie wrap up in a
nice tight little package there you want
it that way you want it that way we give
you that one M are you familiar with
Jeffrey Wright's work Fred is this the
first thing you've seen you know saw him
in Asteroid City yeah right but but not
overwhelmingly I I know who he is I
recognize him and everything like that
but I'm certainly haven't seen all of
his stuff and a big fan but apparently
he's working a really lot and he should
be because he's a fine actor do you
think this movie will be like noted in
Awards and do you think it'll get the
credibility that it deserves or do you
think it'll fall into not not fall into
the the you know what the movie's about
being a I sure would like it to be the
success it deserves to be yeah and one
of the things I loved about it too and I
say this in so many of our things look
at Leslie aams look how beautiful she
still is I love it when that's the case
right she was a young girl singer
actress right okay I have no idea who
she is she looks like she's from
something I've seen on Disney Channel I
can't remember oh wow right she was she
was a big star she had hit records okay
right and look at her now I mean
obviously she's age but look at those
cheekbones I mean
she's watch out ladies Fred goes for the
cheekbones I'm tell and and of course
she played her she played her part
spectacularly well having dementia and
just her her tiny hand motions and the
way she's a little disoriented yeah it
was like I was like oh wow that is my
aunt like yeah I I also thought it was a
really interesting the type of music
they decided to choose which was it was
a jazz it was real Jazzy and um when it
comes to like uh black movies like black
panther for example there there was a
real hip-hop trap beat and a lot of
other African movies they rely on using
uh African American music to when it
comes to like race or even being a
culture it's it's a spectrum of
experience and you shouldn't really be
tethered down I hate that word spectrum
you should really Spectrum these days
you shouldn't really be tethered down to
like a set checklist or set attributes
to you know just be who you and stuff
like that yeah it wasn't a cheap written
movie cheap acted movie and it wasn't a
cheap soundtracked movie they put
dignified soundtrack with a dignified
movie seems perfect to me and there's
nothing better when a soundtrack Blends
so well that you're not aware of it
that's when it's really cool see
sometimes I like to be aware of it like
sometimes it hits sometimes it it gets
you it gets you going like um in um the
iron claw oh yeah I thought that was so
cool when that came in or like I'm
thinking uh Jango and chained when uh I
think it's Tupac comes on right that
when the first time he picks up a gun
Tupac comes on I I thought that hit but
you notice it but it worked no you're
right yeah you're right there dramatic
music is always phenomenal yeah but I
also agree with you too sometimes that
you shouldn't pay attention to it
because it's supposed to be uh evoking
some kind of emotion inside of you I I
have two issues with the movie for one
thing the movie is great and it should
be regarded as a great movie it should
not be regarded as a great black movie
I'm I'm insulted by that I'm insulted
for them you're insulted as a white
what's that I said you're insulted by
that that is so great so I'm insulted
for them because they don't have what it
takes to be insulted for themselves um I
agree with you to in the sense that
that's what this movie is about he just
wants to be noted as a great writer but
I do think we do we I do think we need
to acknowledge when it's our differences
you know like there are black movies
there are Bollywood movies um there are
latino movies and this is a black movie
and I think it needs to be acknowledged
as a great black movie but it can also
be acknowledged as a great American
movie I hate to see it pigeon hole that
way what do you think I think that
probably ties why into like it's called
American fiction because that we have
that fixation on like this is this is
black this is Latino this is white and
it's like and the whole point is that he
just wants to write a good fiction book
but all of a sudden it's becoming an
identity a a a book where it's tied to
his identity which I think that's why
it's called American fiction because
only in America do we hyperfixate on
identity so much like that the really
Masterpiece he writes this ridiculous
trash thing totally in Ebonics every
every bad black cliche there can be is
in there to the N degree and he gives it
like a dignified title I don't remember
the original title that he gives it my
pathology oh okay spelled wrong yeah
spelled wrong everybody all the white
people accept that they go this is the
this is the greatest raw thing you're
you're a genius of literature we sold
your book no we believe Mr Lee has
written a bestseller there a joke the
most lucrative joke you've ever told and
he decides to push it to the absolute
limit he goes you know what he wants it
to fail he wants he's he's like pissed
that he's getting success right he right
he needs it to be a success but he hates
it he's very conflicted he's very
conflicted and that conflict affects his
relationship with the beautiful neighbor
that he's that he's trying to have a
romantic relationship so so in the in
the effort to sink the ship finally with
the last torpedo he goes I'm changing
the name of the book I want to call it
[ __ ] and everybody's they're momentarily
shocked they're like well maybe we if we
spell it with a pH and we and everything
but it doesn't take him more than a
minute to they say well let let's think
about it he goes no we're doing this or
I'm out because he's being real gangster
he's acting he his Persona as the writer
is that he's like an escape convict yeah
to to add Mojo to the to the story now
is stag a pseudonym yeah Mr Lee can't
use his real name is this based on your
actual
life yeah you think some [ __ ] ass
college boy can come up with that [ __ ]
no no no I don't and he says no it's
this or this is it or I'm out and then
they look at each other go like it's
genius what what why didn't we realize
it right away of course that's so Raw
it's in your face it's in your face and
so they decide to go with it and of
course for him it's like oh my God no
matter how bad I make it they're going
to love it yeah yeah I I think he is a
really interesting I think the scene
between him and the competitor though
when they start conflicting over his
book is is really interesting because it
starts to show that yes he has a point
that we're pandering with a lot of trash
but uh we have to remember where that
trash sometimes comes from is like the a
lot of this trash was a is a Formula
based off of real stories that that uh
that did happen like people did go
through those struggles and there's a
part where he says that like there's a
part where she says like he points out
like you wrote that book but you didn't
experience any of it and she goes do you
think I only write books from like my
experience and and then there's another
part where his mom says a genius is so
lonely because they can't connect with
the rest of us and it's like his
intellectualism as as smart as he is and
as good points as he has he's
disconnected from everyone and to some
part maybe even a little bit from his
community because you know he's not
really acknowledging that yes we're
making a formula off of a lot of these
uh these stereotypical stories but they
do happen and maybe there's space for
for both you know so overall Fred is it
a 10 what are you giving it I I have to
give it a 10 it's Flawless Fred hands
out the
tens you know something Shane I love
movies and when a movie is great it's
100% great 100% I I'm in love with it
yeah you know if it's not great when you
just hand out the 10 everything's a 10
well I only pick great movies you know I
didn't give a 10 the junk movies right
we saw that weird uh romantic comedy
thing that was you know like a two so no
I'm I'm not generous but I I am a lover
BJ what about you man I admit I give it
a 10 too I really love this movie I
thought it was expertly crafted in my
opinion although definitely will be
unappreciated yeah um as a black movie I
get no I'm just kidding I'm just
kidding um no I give it you know you
know what I'm going to give it 10 why
not perfect score should perfect and
this is the and it's nice that we had a
third cuz we don't have unity all the
time it was everybody thought this I'm
really pral of everybody involved with
this whole thing I think it's a
masterpiece I think yeah I think it's
even more so a 10 because of what I
thought it was it's the exact opposite
it's a commentary on that which made it
awesome right a really happy surprise go
ahead and give us the outro cool thanks
again for watching the real generation
gap this has been a review of American
fiction I'm Shane schm Fred satii and BJ
King we'll see you guys in the next one
all right guys thanks for watching
please hit that like button hit that
subscribe button leave us a comment what
you think about this movie is Black
Culture a gimmick is this the best black
movie of the year is it just the best
American movie of the Year let us know
what you think we'll see you guys at the
next
one