AutoRicerca è la rivista (ad accesso aperto) del LAB – Laboratorio di Autoricerca di Base, la cui missione è pubblicare testi (in italiano e inglese) sulla ricerca interiore ed esteriore. Ponendosi al di fuori delle abituali categorie editoriali, AutoRicerca offre ai suoi lettori scritti di valore (articoli, dialoghi, manuali, monografie, racconti…) selezionati personalmente dall’Editore. Questo ventiquattresimo numero - tutto in italiano - contiene 3 articoli dedicati alla fisica quantistica e alla relatività, e a una specifica interpretazione di queste teorie, nota come "interpretazione concettualistica".
In this video I want to introduce you to the number 24 of Autoricerca, published in 2022, which is entirely dedicated to the theme of physics.
It contains three articles that address the fundamental and foundational aspects of quantum mechanics and relativity theory.
All three touch in a more or less specific way the so-called conceptual interpretation of quantum theory,
initially proposed by Diederich Arts in 2009 and currently investigated by the Bruxelles group at the CLEA,
that is, the Leo Apostel Center for Transdisciplinary Research,
an inter-faculty center of the Vrije Universiteit Brussels, whose mission is precisely to throw bridges between the various scientific, social and cultural disciplines.
The first article, already published in English in the magazine of the Springer Foundations of Science,
I wrote it keeping in mind one of the goals of the CLEA, that of a wide spread of scientific knowledge.
Therefore, it addresses a genuinely transversal audience of readers, not necessarily with an academic preparation.
Its content was initially presented in an interview that I had the pleasure of holding on May 16, 2019, in Paris,
at the Bertrand headquarters of the European Space Agency, in the context of their Beyond Space Lunchtime Series,
whose purpose was to present to the staff of the agency, of the space agency, ideas that somehow go beyond space as such.
Well, I think I have satisfied them, since the title of my presentation of the article that I later wrote is
a non-spatial reality, and in it I try to emphasize that, based on what I have learned about the behavior of micro-world entities,
we are in some way obliged to accept that they will never be fully represented as entities
belonging to our essential space theater and, more generally, space-time.
In other words, the constitutive elements of our physical reality would be, by nature, non-spatial or non-space-time.
So when does a non-spatial agency exist?
That of non-spatiality is a fundamental ingredient of conceptual interpretation,
since, once it has been established that quantum phenomena such as entanglement, interference effects and indistinguishability,
if carefully examined, tell us that, in fact, there is much more in our physical reality than what can be represented in space-time terms,
then it remains the pressing question of knowing what the true nature of a non-spatial or non-space-time entity may be.
As far as I know, no quantum physics interpretation has ever offered a satisfactory answer to this question,
except for the conceptual interpretation that is extensively presented in the second article contained in this number 24 of Autoricerca,
an article that I had the pleasure of writing in collaboration with Diederik Harz, Sandro Sozzo and Thomas Veloz,
and which was published for the first time in 2018, always on Foundations of Science.
This long work is an extended version of a plenary conference that I had the honor of holding at the Worlds of Entanglement symposium in September 2017 in Brussels,
which included numerous sessions dedicated to various research topics, such as the foundations of quantum physics,
the non-classical probabilistic structures, the entanglement in social sciences, complex systems, quantum artificial intelligence,
the theories of decision in the condition of uncertainty and the study of consciousness, just to name a few.
In my presentation, I explained how it is possible to understand the strange behavior of quantum and relativistic entities
by adopting a speculative hypothesis about their nature, a hypothesis that is at the basis of conceptual interpretation.
In this regard, allow me to quote the French physicist Jean-Marc Lévy-Leblanc, who a few years ago stated the following.
We must today realize, Lévy-Leblanc said, that quantum theory exists and that its concepts, after a century of collective scientific activity,
are deeply rooted in the common sense of physicists.
These concepts no longer need to be close to those of classical physics, but can and should be taken seriously for what they really are.
Such an intrinsically quantum understanding leads us to recognize that the entities of quantum physics are neither waves nor particles, as duality would make us believe.
They are neither waves nor particles even if they exhibit, in very particular circumstances, two types of limited behaviors such as classical waves or classical particles.
It has been proposed to underline this aspect, as Lévy-Leblanc always says, this ontological aspect, by calling them quantons.
Now, the speculative hypothesis at the basis of conceptual interpretation is that these quantons, of which Lévy-Leblanc speaks,
would be nothing more than cognitons, that is to say, not of the objective entities but of the conceptual entities.
However, this is not to be understood in the sense that quantum and relativistic entities would be equivalent to human concepts,
but in the sense that they would share a similar conceptual nature with them.
In the same way that, for example, sea waves and acoustic waves, although being very different physical entities, share no less a similar undulating nature.
All this will be widely explained and motivated in the article in question, which was written thinking of an interdisciplinary audience,
therefore to readers who are not necessarily specialists in the field of physics.
Nevertheless, we address readers with a sufficient general scientific culture,
really motivated to access avant-garde explanations and understandings,
with a particular attention to the very important debate on the possible interpretations and foundations of physical theories.
Regarding the importance of finding an interpretation for quantum formalism,
it is perhaps useful to mention here the words of the philosopher Tim Maudlin, who said this.
There is no doubt that there is a mathematical formalism from which we know how to extract predictions,
that those predictions can be accurate up to 14 decimal places,
but a physical theory is more than a simple mathematical formalism with rules,
it should be able to specify a physical ontology, which means, tell me what exists in the physical world,
there are particles, there are fields, there is space-time, and it should tell me about these things,
and the problem is that quantum theory, as Maudlin always says, is not a theory in this sense, it is only a formalism,
and therefore what people call the interpretation of quantum theory,
which sounds like a silly thing to do, because you could say, well, I have a theory, what would an interpretation be?
Well, an interpretation corresponds in fact to the development of precise physical theories
that make the same predictions, or almost the same predictions, of those derived from this standard mathematical recipe,
that of standard quantum formalism, which, according to Maudlin,
would not be a real theory if an interpretation was not added.
Now, over the years, innumerable interpretations of this quantum formalism have been proposed,
each with its advantages and disadvantages.
Conceptual interpretation is distinguished by the fact that it emerged from the recent success
of the use of quantum mathematical formalism in the modeling of various aspects of human cognition,
such as the conceptual dynamics in the processes of thought and decision-making.
This success led Dietrich Hartz to caress the idea that it could not be a mere coincidence
that the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics was so well equipped
in describing so many aspects of human cognitive domain,
that this was due, in some way, to a deeper correspondence
linked to the true nature of microphysical entities.
Hartz initially worked on the idea of conceptual interpretation in silence,
but as soon as his explanatory power became increasingly evident,
allowing him to deal with all the difficult aspects to understand of quantum mechanics,
such as the principle of indeterminacy of Heisenberg, indistinguishable particles and entanglement,
then, since 2009, he began to publish his intuitions and the first results of this powerful explanatory picture,
whose assumption was that quantum entities were conceptual entities,
that is, entities governed by the level of meaning.
The second article in this volume offers, for the first time,
a systematic, 360-degree presentation of this fascinating interpretation,
which really tests our historical prejudices on physical reality,
those that would like it to be constituted only by spatiotemporal objects.
Coming now to the third and last article,
it is an imaginary dialogue written in four hands with Diederik Hartz.
It is a revisitation and extension of an article, in dialogical form, published in English in 2015.
I am sure that the text will be of great interest to those who, for example,
have been fascinated by the so-called multi-world interpretation of quantum physics,
which contemplates an infinite number of parallel worlds or universes,
which continue to unfold, where all possible outcomes of a quantum measurement
are always and inevitably updated.
In the dialogue, this multi-world vision is opposed to another vision,
a multi-measurement vision, where there is only one world,
and where quantum measurements are able to produce a single outcome at a time.
Unlike the multi-worlds of Everett DeWitt's interpretation,
the single world of multi-measurement interpretation,
more precisely, hidden-measure interpretation,
which, among other things, is perfectly compatible with conceptual interpretation,
well, this single world has a greater depth,
as it contemplates the existence of a vast dimension of pure potentiality,
of a non-spatial-temporal nature,
thanks to which it becomes possible to give a sense and a foundation
also to the processes of a creative nature.
Well, I stop here.
I hope you are not only curious,
and that the three articles presented in this volume
offer you an intellectually stimulating perspective
on the two great scientific revolutions of the last century,
quantum mechanics and relativity.
Each article in turn can be read independently by the other two,
there will be inevitable repetitions,
but, as the Latin proverb says,
that is, in a context of learning,
repeating certain notions and reasoning several times
can facilitate, indeed certainly facilitates, understanding.
One last thing.
For those who do not know self-research,
I remind you that the PDF-format volume
can be downloaded for free with a simple click,
and that it is also possible to download the PDF of the individual articles.
Open access to the electronic version
excludes, however, the possibility of ordering the paper volume
for those who love the scent and music of paper,
and undoubtedly the purchase of the printed volume
is a way to support the mission of the magazine.
Thank you and see you soon.