Quando il reale viene definito in modo operazionale, la libera scelta, inerentemente dinamica, svolge un ruolo centrale nella sua costruzione. Quello che di solito viene chiamato "universo blocco" emerge allora in modo personale per ogni osservatore-partecipatore, osservando che parte del futuro è già contenuto nel presente, senza però che questo significhi che il cambiamento sarebbe impossibile.
In the theory of special relativity, there is a certain difficulty in conciliating the reality of one's own personal experience,
the one we live in the present, in the so-called here and now,
with the reality described by the quadridimensional continuum spacetime.
Now I'll explain.
What really exists?
The physical entities that move along the personal lines of the universe,
or only the lines of the universe as such?
This simple question is the expression of a dichotomy between two apparently unconcilable points of view,
that of presentism, according to which physical entities exist only and uniquely in the present moment,
and that of eternalism, according to which physical entities exist not only in the present,
but at the same time also in the past and in the future.
Now, this question of what really exists, that is, of what is really real,
is also at the heart of the research on the foundations of quantum mechanics,
a research that has developed above all since the 1970s,
on the trail of the famous article by Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen of 1935,
where researchers of the caliber of Von Neumann, Mackey, Jauch, Piron, Foulier-Randall, Ludwig,
and finally Harz, just to name the most famous,
have come to build a quantum, asiomatic, operational and realistic formalism
that has allowed to obtain a very general representation of the physical systems
and, as special cases, the descriptions of quantum physics and classical physics.
Now, analogously to what Einstein did with the measurement of distances using rigid rules
and durations using clocks,
also in this general, operational and realistic formalism,
what exists is deducted from an analysis of measurement processes
and from the possibility of making certain or only irreducibly probabilistic predictions
about their outcomes, giving to the dimension of potentiality its rightful place in reality.
An obvious observation.
From a metaphysical point of view, what exists does not need to be defined
operationally through measurement processes,
being what exists necessarily independent of any experimental measurement.
But a reality defined operationally is necessarily part of reality
in a broader metaphysical sense,
since experiments always have the last word.
Very well, but let's focus for a moment on how,
in classical pre-relativistic physics, what exists is described.
The present reality is considered as everything that can be seen, touched,
heard and, more generally, experienced in a given temporal moment.
The term can is very important,
since reality is not reduced to the mere content of our current experience,
in the present, but includes all our possible experiences,
those we could have had in the present
if only we had made other decisions in our past.
There is not only what I am experiencing in this moment,
but also everything I could have experienced in this moment
if I had made a different choice.
And this shows the fundamental importance of free choice
in the construction of reality from an operational point of view.
And, of course, in such a construction we can push beyond the limited scope of our senses,
thanks to the much wider scope of our knowledge of the world,
in particular that of science.
Having said that, in order that the multiple personal realities of the different participants
can coherently integrate into the construction of a single global present reality,
it is necessary to be able to have an absolute and invariable time,
able to advance, imperturbable, always equal to itself,
identical for each participant.
But relativity, special relativity in particular,
teaches us that this is not possible,
that the present is something strictly personal,
that there is no global present, valid for everyone.
And it tells us that time itself becomes something strictly personal,
that there is not a single time, but a multiplicity of different times.
Therefore, in our operational construction of reality,
we have nothing to do with a single global reality,
but with multiple personal present realities.
And when we carefully analyze these multiple constructions,
we discover something very interesting.
Now I'll explain.
When the wristwatch of a participant indicates, for example,
the 5 o'clock in the afternoon of a given day,
then it is the 5 o'clock in the afternoon of that day
in the entire universe of that participant.
In other words, in relativity, similarly to Newtonian physics,
a participant can extend their present moment,
in this case the 5 o'clock in the afternoon,
to everything that does not move with respect to their body.
For example, the clock on the wall of their office,
which also indicates the 5 o'clock in the afternoon.
But let's assume that a day before,
the participant has chosen to make a space trip back and forth,
so that when he returns to his office that same day,
with his wristwatch that indicates the 5 o'clock in the afternoon,
the clock on the wall, on the other hand, indicates a different time,
an hour in the future, compared to that of his wristwatch.
Let's say 6 o'clock in the afternoon.
Let it be clear, this time difference between his wristwatch
and the clock on the wall is something that can be calculated
with great precision, thanks to the relativistic formulas,
and depends on the speed and duration of his trip.
Well, but if we consider an operational construction of reality
that is based on the possible experiences of the participant,
we must at this point conclude that his present personal reality
contains both states of his wall clock,
both the one that indicates 5 o'clock and the one that indicates 6 o'clock,
which is in the future, compared to the first.
And since the participant can make trips of arbitrary speed and duration,
it is in fact the entire universe line of his wall clock,
which is part of his personal reality at 5 o'clock in the afternoon,
and of course this applies to all physical entities that are not his body.
I open a brief parenthesis.
Even if the wall clock that indicates 5 o'clock
and the same clock that indicates 6 o'clock
are both part of the present of the participant
and are both in his office,
this does not mean that they are close.
In fact, they are very distant from each other,
because to experience the wall clock that indicates 6 o'clock,
when his wrist clock indicates 5 o'clock,
the participant must make a trip back and forth
of a certain duration at ultra-relativistic speeds.
So let's not be fooled by appearances.
The future is in the present as a possibility,
but it is not always within reach.
Ok, we can at this point observe that the set of all the lines of the universe
of the physical entities that are not the body of the participant,
which are part of his present reality,
well, they form a so-called block universe.
A block universe that is strictly personal to the participant.
A block universe that does not contain his body,
because the participant cannot travel with his body
and at the same time leave his body, for example, in his office.
They are only the external entities to the participant,
that is, external to his body,
which are available to participate in his experiences in the present
in different temporal versions,
that is, in different versions of age,
within the limits, of course, of their lifespan.
Only the external entities to the participant
are part of a genuinely quadridimensional construction.
Now, the existence of this personal block universe
does not imply that change would be something impossible.
The reality of a participant remains dynamic
and should not be confused with that of his quadridimensional block universe,
just as the reader of a book should not be confused
with the content of the book that he can go through,
according to the reading paths that can change at any time.
I open another parenthesis.
If the reading of the watch from the participant's wall
is equipped with a quantum measurement,
then the possible travels back and forth of the participant
can be interpreted as procedures
for preparing the state of the measured system.
And the fact that in relativity time and reality are strictly personal,
this too, in some way,
is something typical of quantum mechanics
and is usually indicated with the term of contextuality,
even if here we certainly have to deal
with a type of spatial-temporal contextuality specific to relativity.
Now, my recent collaboration with Diederick Arts
on the interpretation of relativity
starts precisely from this approach
aimed at rigorously identifying what exists in the operational sense,
according to the theory of restricted relativity.
Obviously, part of this analysis
has already been carried out by many others in the past
and we can find it in textbooks
when we talk about quantities such as proper time
and proper length,
which are, precisely, strictly personal quantities
related to a specific observer-participant.
On the other hand, in the treatises on relativity
there are still numerous residues of Newtonian thought,
especially when it comes to interpreting
what formalism reveals to us,
if taken seriously.
Let's consider the example of proper velocity,
which has also been given a specific name,
celerity,
whose magnitude ranges from zero to infinity.
Rarely is this used for interpretative purposes.
Now, proper velocity is the spatial component of a quadrivelocity
and the magnitude of the quadrivelocity of a physical body,
of any physical body,
in any reference system,
is always equal to c.
This is a result that can be found in any textbook,
even if it is usually considered
as a simple mathematical property
without a particular physical meaning.
But if we consider that the transformations of Lorentz
can be derived even without using
the second postulate of Einstein,
it is certainly possible to give to the structural parameter c
a much more general interpretation,
as absolute velocity of all the material entities
whose motions occur in the entire quadridimensional spacetime,
of the motions therefore characterized by a component,
also temporal, which, among other things,
is always not nothing.
We must here understand the temporal dimension
as the equivalent of a spatial dimension,
measuring time exactly like space,
that is, in units of length,
for example, in seconds.
And it is interesting to observe that the temporal component
of the spacetime movement in the space of Minkowski
is able to explain also the origin of the mysterious energy
contained in the mass of a body,
quantified by the famous formula of Einstein
E equals mc squared.
In fact, when an entity is spatially at rest
compared to a reference data,
it always continues to move along the fourth dimension,
the temporal dimension,
and it does so at its own speed c,
therefore with a quantity of motion
equal to m times c,
with m its mass at rest.
Consequently, the latter, the mass at rest,
can be interpreted as temporal kinetic energy,
that is, as energy associated with motion in time.
But I see that I have already gone too far.
So, in summary,
spacetime can be seen as a genuinely spatial,
quadridimensional structure
that emerges in a different way for each participant
from a non-spatial substrate,
that is, from a non-spatiotemporal substrate.
The classical entities, in the sense of non-quantum,
reside in this quadridimensional space
in a completely stable way,
while the quantum ones,
let's say they only frequent it in an ephemeral way,
being non-local entities,
that is, of essentially non-spatial nature.
Now, let's be clear,
with this video I just wanted to stimulate your curiosity.
For those who want to learn more,
I refer you to my recent article with Diederik Hartz,
of which I will put the link in the description.
Thank you for listening.