Les derniers mots avant de passer à L'ÉDUCATION. Les dernières paroles et non les moindres.
Qu'est-ce que LA DÉSÉDUCATION/ LA RÉÉDUCATION ?
Produite, réalisée et écrite par le Québécois Mathieu Côté-Desjardins, cette websérie documentaire de 2010 (sélectionnée aux Prix Gémeaux comme finaliste en 2011) suit le créateur de la série étant nouvel enseignant fraîchement sorti de l'université. Dès les premiers jours de classe, il s'est demandé comment on pouvait offrir si peu de qualité aux jeunes. Puisant dans ses quelques expériences en cinéma et son maigre salaire de nouveau prof (et d'un emprunt bancaire de plusieurs dizaines de milliers de dollars), il décide de s'acheter une caméra vidéo, ce qu'il faut pour faire du montage et se met à filmer divers entretiens divers intervenants du système scolaire (et d'autres nullement liés à ce domaine). « Suis-je fou de penser que le système scolaire n'a aucun sens » ? Exutoire et thérapie sous format documentaire qui fut le premier pan dans sa quête de percer le mystère de la véritable éducation. Ce webisode fait partie de la saison 2, intitulée LA RÉÉDUCATION.
If all the people in the world, including the teachers,
if everyone called a cat a cat,
and named things as they are,
I think we would break the system and start again.
Education, its purpose, is the happiness of the child.
Not only now, but its happiness, if you will, on a long scale.
So, I would say, it's comforting.
And Magagoshi said, but if the child is not happy,
he won't learn.
It's true. I say to my students,
you could have spent 7 years at school,
because they go to university after 13 years of study,
and I tell them, you could have spent 7 years walking,
and you would have been much more advanced than now.
Because, in general, children, when they go to school,
their brain is off, it would be almost half the time, if not more.
How do you want to learn?
It's a new experience, a new journey, a new...
Oh my God, it's coming, it's coming.
They are sponges, whether it's a language, a game, it doesn't matter.
So, we, the educators, we care about them.
In France, we ask ourselves, why do we have such indiscipline?
Why do we have such difficulty? Why don't they learn?
Why do they give it their all?
It's because, as Mr. Renal said, they survive, they protect themselves.
What do you think of the school in general, the traditional school?
What impact do you think it has?
To follow others, to follow the teacher, for example.
But it means that, as we are forced to learn,
it means that, well, it's us who decide to learn.
So, we learn when we want to, it means that when we do something,
we don't do it because we are forced to, but because we want to.
So, the fact that we have the will to do it,
it allows us to progress more in this field
than if we did it because we were forced to and we don't want to.
I am delighted, delighted, sincerely,
that other people are interested in this issue
and want to work on it.
I put my energy elsewhere.
I am not for reform, I am for revolution.
So, I don't intend to spend my time and energy
working with this institution,
which, in my opinion, is basically rotten.
So, for me, the solution is
to take down this institution and replace it with...
There are so many other things we can do.
We don't have the choice that the solutions come in the system right now
because removing all the children from school,
it won't work. Where would they go? What would they do?
We are not used to having them in our society,
in our communities. Parents, they work.
There are many who don't have the choice to work with both parents just to survive.
I'm not even talking about
the parents who are used to having both working
and who want this freedom of work.
There are many who don't have the choice.
But what needs to be done in the system
is to change the way we see human development
and that schools become human, at least.
And that we give freedom to children,
but that we also give, not only freedom,
but responsibility. Freedom and responsibility are together.
You can't have freedom without taking responsibility for your actions, etc.
You have to teach that.
Children are in development. They're not adults.
We always expect them to be little adults.
They should know everything and do everything perfectly.
Don't make mistakes, don't be careful, don't make bad moves.
They're supposed to be perfect already.
So let's take away this human time of development,
of learning. They're supposed to make mistakes
and hurt themselves and hurt others accidentally.
It's the same thing. We learn to be in a relationship.
We're the example.
But in the system, if we could give them the responsibility
to manage schools,
like alternative schools do,
democratic schools,
it would be done in a big school.
But it's because we need to give back the power
to the radical group.
We should stop seeing children as...
My experience
in the business world, etc.,
is very conservative.
Then I find myself
with the radical group in education
and I really see my mission now
to bring the information,
to bring it back
to the radical education side,
to bring it back to popular thought
so that we can bring the solutions
we need to the system.
Is it really the system or is it at the level of the children?
It's at the level of the children, but it's the system
that needs to make changes to bring that to the children.
I hope to inspire the radical education side
because we don't want to throw away
everything that already exists.
We want to look for the creativity,
the human capacities that exist.
It's just that they're in a paradigm
and as soon as we can bring the two sides together,
we can find extraordinary solutions
that bring extraordinary,
interesting, exciting solutions
that include everyone.
We're like two sides.
I think I'm between the two sides.
The radicals don't think I'm radical in my thoughts,
but they also see my business side.
I often look like a businesswoman
when I go to their meetings
and often they look rather hippie, etc.
I love it, I find it exciting,
full of creativity,
but I look very conservative.
I'm writing a book about what I've learned,
my story, my experiences with my son,
but also what I've learned in my research
and what I understand now as a human being,
how we learn, how we teach
and how we educate,
which is not the same.
I want to help people realize
that the way we teach
is not in line with the way
the brain develops.
I also want to take people
through an internal process
to help them realize
where school has negatively or positively affected them
and how important it is in their lives,
without them realizing it,
because the subconscious is extraordinary.
It's hard to explain in two minutes.
You have to go through the process,
you have to come to a conference
and start a discussion.
I don't want people to believe me,
but to start questioning,
to do their own research,
First of all, if he's unhappy,
that's a good reason
to take your child out of the school system
if your child is not happy.
I think there are excellent reasons
to tell a parent not to bring their child to school.
Compassion, number one,
towards our child, because our child lives.
Our children, the children of others,
we think we're all alone,
we don't realize the children of others who are suffering.
You have to be brave,
but we have all the courage.
There is no lack of quality in us,
it's just to bring them out,
but when we manage to regroup,
to improve or expand our knowledge
and our awareness around it,
we become more and more open,
we become brave because we realize
we don't have a choice.
There are children who commit suicide,
there are children who threaten others,
there are children who kill.
We have to have the compassion
that we send our child into this system every day.
Without compassion, that's what we lack.
Sometimes we have to close our hearts
to be able to survive.
We think our children have to do the same,
but no, we need to heal that part
and open our hearts again
to our children and what's going on in their lives.
You have to have self-confidence,
which we also don't have.
We lack a lot of self-confidence,
but courage comes from self-confidence
because we think,
once again, that it's just us
and we don't realize that,
yes, I'm intelligent,
I'm able to have ideas that others don't believe in
and I'm able to talk about them
and I'm able to see that there's a problem
even if people don't agree
and to believe, to listen.
It's super important
because even just going to school at home,
which is already a little bit known,
we're very afraid of that.
We're being attacked by our families,
we're being threatened by the DPJ or something else
by our families.
You really have to have self-confidence
even if they feel isolated
or they don't know that there are other alternatives.
I think the problem is more there.
It doesn't require anything in particular
except the will to do it.
The will.
And when we can meet more and more people,
it helps to give confidence, to give courage.
The monetary question doesn't matter
because there are always middle-aged children
who can be imaginative, creative
with three candles.
It's certainly not a reason
not to go to school at home.
When we talk about parents
who have their children challenged at school,
the first thing I would say
is to listen.
Because we question ourselves
and we listen to the experts.
We know our child, we are certain of our thing,
but we don't have the courage of our convictions.
We don't have the courage to really say
no, you don't know what, there must be another solution.
Or no, it's not true that my child has this problem,
it's really nothing more than at school,
it's really nothing more than with this teacher
because he has to fit in with the class.
If he were learning freely
in an environment
that is very stimulating,
he wouldn't have this problem,
he wouldn't need drugs.
The parent knows that, he sees it,
he has the experience,
he feels the pain of his child.
I think that in Montreal,
like many places, there are kind of two forces
working opposite each other.
So you have the basic establishment,
which remains rigid, behind the times,
and you have educators who know
that they have serious problems,
but they don't know how to solve them.
So what they do is they reach for the only thing they knew,
the system.
Well, we have to have more standards,
and more teaching to the test,
and more days of the year, and more years of the month.
For me, all the other alternatives
that are in the order of
taking distance from the curriculum of the government
or taking distance from the school institution,
I still find them relevant and interesting,
whether it's the Waldorf schools, Montessori,
the people who really practice
the school at home as such.
For me, these are all valid and interesting alternatives
that deserve to be known, for sure.
I feel supportive of all those
who think a little differently.