Produite, réalisée et écrite par le Québécois Mathieu Côté-Desjardins, cette websérie documentaire de 2010 (sélectionnée aux Prix Gémeaux comme finaliste en 2011) suit le créateur de la série étant nouvel enseignant fraîchement sorti de l'université. Dès les premiers jours de classe, il s'est demandé comment on pouvait offrir si peu de qualité aux jeunes. Puisant dans ses quelques expériences en cinéma et son maigre salaire de nouveau prof (et d'un emprunt bancaire de plusieurs dizaines de milliers de dollars), il décide de s'acheter une caméra vidéo, ce qu'il faut pour faire du montage et se met à filmer divers entretiens divers intervenants du système scolaire (et d'autres nullement liés à ce domaine). « Suis-je fou de penser que le système scolaire n'a aucun sens » ? Exutoire et thérapie sous format documentaire qui fut le premier pan dans sa quête de percer le mystère de la véritable éducation. Une saison 2, intitulée, LA RÉÉDUCATION, est aussi disponible sur Gan Jing World dans cette chaîne.
These children who are raised on the principle of pleasure,
do what you want, as you want, even at school,
it doesn't bother me, I put my feet on the table, it doesn't matter,
well, these children don't develop supremacy.
However, supremacy is the moralizing instance,
it is the instance that says, that interiorizes in the child
what must be done and what must not be done,
even in the absence of parents.
If we don't interiorize that, we don't interiorize
what we also call in psychoanalysis the principle of reality,
that is, the reality that resists.
The child must learn that reality resists.
We don't do anything, in any way.
At some point, it stops. Stop.
If the parent can collaborate,
if I know his son, I live with him,
I'm always with my parent,
it's you who know your son,
help me, what do I have to do with him,
what do I have to try, what doesn't he like,
what hurts him, what can bother him,
We want them to manage the discipline,
because parents are not able to discipline their children.
They are obliged, in addition, to deal with problem cases,
behavior problems,
in classes where we are supposed to learn, to study.
But no, we have to integrate those who have behavior problems
instead of helping them themselves,
because we don't want to discriminate.
But don't help them if they are always at the bottom of the class,
don't help them if they are at the bottom of the list all the time,
if they can't get a place,
because the teacher doesn't have time to tackle his problems and help him.
You know, there will have to be rules,
and there will be someone with a pair of balls or a pair of glasses
who will stand up and say,
this is how it will work from now on in public schools.
If you are rigorous, it doesn't concern a lot of people.
There are parents who feel challenged,
because they feel judged in their role as parents.
There are teachers who feel judged
in front of a more rigorous teacher.
Rigorous doesn't mean you have to be more competent than others.
Everyone is competent in their own way.
Rigorous doesn't mean being severe,
hitting children's fingers,
but demanding the maximum of what a child can provide as work.
The school, as a social environment,
has lost a lot of its legitimacy.
The school is a place where society welcomes the young.
They come from their families.
Often, these families are disorganized.
There is a lot of economic distress in Quebec.
It should never be minimized,
especially in big cities.
And so, the school,
whether we like it or not,
that's the problem,
whether we like it or not,
now has a role that we could call supplemental.
That is, it must do what the parents are no longer able to do,
or what they are not able to do,
or what they don't want to do.
For example,
imposing an authority,
setting limits,
respecting norms,
socializing in a strict way,
and so on.
These are things that, often,
the parental cells don't want to do,
or can't do anymore.
Sociologists have observed that
children who go from one home to another
because their parents are separated,
and so on,
are subject to constraints
We are not going to change that.
Society is not going to change
tomorrow morning to please schools.
No, but schools must absorb that.
So, the teacher
becomes a stable pole.
He represents society in the school.
And when he welcomes the young people,
these young people find
in him or her
a form of solidity,
a reference,
a form of authority.
That's the only word, I think,
When you reach the age of 16 or 17,
and all of a sudden,
I don't know,
summer work,
or university,
all of a sudden...
I saw it in a company,
Cascade, not to name it,
where you are a participant,
a teacher comes and says,
look, there was a young man,
summer work, son of a worker,
who was sleeping.
10 or 11 in the morning, he was sleeping.
He was lying on a cardboard,
completely swollen.
He wakes him up and says,
hey, you're not sleeping, you're working.
The other one says,
yes, but it doesn't make sense
because I was at the disco yesterday.
The teacher says,
listen, it doesn't make sense,
you're working, you're taking the door.
Well, the teenager didn't understand.
He didn't understand.
Why didn't it make sense
to go to school at home?
I love you.
He comes to the company,
and it doesn't make sense anymore.
Can you imagine a worker from Pellado
saying to Pellado,
it doesn't make sense to do your file there?
Because there is no superego,
no principle of reality.
They come at 17, 18,
and they face the principle of reality.
I saw it in my classes.
First year students,
18, 19, 20 years old,
I give them the requirements of my course,
and one day a student says to me,
do we have to do all this in your course?
Yes, mademoiselle.
Ah,
so we don't laugh anymore?
Look at your exam.
There is nothing
in the course, nothing.
I answered the question,
yes, but what I'm going to answer now
has nothing to do with it.
It's in the book.
She says to me, because I had to read the book.
She says to me,
I have a bachelor's degree in psychology
at the University of Montreal,
and I have never read a book.
Why do you have to read a book?
The law on public instruction
is very clear about this.
Teachers have an obligation of means,
but not an obligation of results.
They have to do everything
to implement the means
that will promote
the success of their students.
But they are not held
or are not
responsible for
whether their students succeed or not.
Because
this is a trend
that we don't
only see in education.
We transfer
all the responsibility
on individuals.
And
in the world of education,
who is going to pay the costs
or who is in the front line
to receive criticism?
Teachers.
Because we tell them,
it is in your hands
that we entrust
the citizens of tomorrow.
And the law
on public instruction
goes so far
as to transfer
parental responsibility,
parental authority
to the teacher
in class.
It is the teacher who has the responsibility
of the students who are entrusted to him.
It can go far.
It can go to quite intimidating
letters sometimes,
which can be hurtful.
When the first evaluations
or the first results fall
and it does not
meet expectations,
sometimes it is a shock
that is difficult to take.
And instead of trying to understand
why, we will
continue to blame
the practices.
A child who is 3, 4, 5 years old
who goes to kindergarten
and has an older brother or sister
who goes to high school
and sees his parents
complaining at school
and scolding
teachers and instructors,
treating them like nothing,
and defending their child
who did nothing.
What kind of person,
what image,
what esteem, what respect
will he have at school?
When I arrive at school,
it is like my big brother,
my big sister,
the neighbor.
At school, I do what I want
and it is always the teacher who is at fault.
It is an institution that does not work well.
Not me.
It is up to them to scold me.
I try to give them as much as possible
so that they are aware
at home.
But sometimes
it is still not enough.
We ask even more.
I have the impression that
if I accepted it,
there are parents who would come to sit
in class all day to see what is going on.
At some point, we even have
parents who end up posting
in the streets to see
how we monitor.
I hope we will never get to the point
where parents will be able
to follow the progress of the class
on the web.
It has already happened
in some kindergartens.
We don't always realize
what class life is
with 20 students.
We ask for very, very special
interventions for his child,
for things that
look more or less
like school missions.
And then it gets heavy.
I already find that
since the beginning of my career,
we have multiplied
the ways of communicating with parents.
Unconditional love is
a catastrophic mistake.
Unconditional love came
with the moment
when the two parents
had to work when they were sick
to be able to close
the loop of the family's life.
And since they didn't have time
to give to their children...
Do you know how much time
parents spend with their children
in North America?
5 minutes a day.
5 minutes a day,
on average.
26 hours in front of the TV
a week.
So, to redeem
this guilt of not giving
time to the children,
we invented unconditional love.
Whatever happens, I love you.
And then, when we come home
from work, we buy love.
We arrive with candy,
with Nintendo,
with Walkman,
with Discoman.
So, when we have more and more
divorces, with divorces,
the two parents feel more and more
guilty, even more.
So, when the children go to
each parent's house,
each one will overdo
the importance of love.
And that's how the child feels it.
He feels it as indifference
that is bought on the material level,
while it must be lived on the
symbolic and affective level.
Oh no, not again school fees!
School is free,
my eye!
Did you know that the parents
of other generations considered
that education was the most important thing?
They invested everything they could.
You know, my little girl,
the parents have changed.
The important thing is no longer
that education is accessible to everyone,
or that there is quality instruction.
It is that children are
as far away as possible,
out of the house,
busy, to become a laborer
as quickly as possible.