Lecture 02 Module 02

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Oct 22, 2023
So, the another aspect that I was alluding to which is often used in designing constant
voltage supplies is the following.
Let me motivate the principle behind it and we will come back to the actual implementation
of it at a later stage in this course, but a thought process is as follows.
So, what is the main reason behind burning excessive power while we were trying to
drive a resistive load? The main reason was as follows, the load was connected here.
So, the main reason was as this resistance was changing, it was changing the effective
resistance of this box. As that RL was changing, this was changing the effective resistance
looking down. The parallel combination of R and RL was changing the effective resistance
with respect to the resistance that was attached on top of it.
So, as RL was changing, the division ratio, the resistive division ratio was also changing.
Correct? So, that is why, that is why it was being difficult to maintain a constant voltage
at across, it was getting difficult to maintain a constant voltage across this terminal.
So, what did reducing R do? Reducing R sufficiently ensure that this division ratio
becomes largely insensitive to RL. If the division ratio is largely insensitive to RL,
it is not a problem, then I can always maintain approximately constant V naught.
So, therein lies the problem and therein also lies a potential solution.
What is the potential solution? The potential solution is, what if instead of using a fixed R,
what if I say, I will do this, I know that this RL is variable.
So, let me call this one R1 and let me call this R2 for the time being.
What if I also make, what if I also make R1 to be variable? How we will make R1 to be a
variable is a story for another day, but what if we make R1 to be also a variable resistance?
If we can make R1 to be variable resistance, then it is probably possible to ensure that
this division ratio of R2 parallel RL and R1 become unity or rather become half for all values
of RL. In principle, this is possible, but how, if you have to do that, what do you need to do?
Because note that this RL can change. If RL changes, I will have to ensure that the change,
the information of the change of RL gets captured and then transferred to R1.
So, in principle, we need a block, we need a block that can observe a change
and feed that information into R1. So, what is this block supposed to do?
This block is supposed to observe change in RL and adjust R1 accordingly.
Right? So, in other words, I need to feed back the information from the output that is from RL
to R1. So, that is why negative feedback becomes our feedback networks become
a very important aspect of analog circuit design in the context of controlling things, right?
So, as we had, as I had mentioned in the introductory video, this lecture,
this course will be as much about designing an amplifier as it will be about designing an
amplifier from the perspective of negative feedback, right? So, this is one of the
motivations of why negative feedback is important, that is, in order to control
an output voltage effectively or efficiently, we need to observe the change in output
and feedback that information somewhere in the network to make an adjustment, right?
So, because in principle, this is what we would like to do. Hence, in principle,
negative feedback is something that we will be focusing on for a major part of this course,
okay? Okay. So, we will come to a more formal way of introducing negative feedback,
few lectures down the line, but let me, let me concentrate on one more extremely important
aspect that we will be covering in this course or we will be using in this course.
It is extremely simple idea, we all know about it, but I would like to reintroduce it
from the perspective of resistances and keeping and identifying which block can drive which load
or which block cannot drive which load or you know, another way of saying the same thing is
under what condition a particular block that you are designing will be able to drive a certain
load or might not be able to drive certain load, right? We have already seen that example,
we have already seen the example from the perspective of a resistive divider,
but let us try to see another example. Even though this is a very simple concept,
right? We will be using it time and again throughout this course,
so it makes sense to go over it one last time, okay? So, let me try to, let me try to
convince you about this importance with a thought experiment.
So, let us assume that I went to the, I went to the, I went to a electrical store,
I bought a battery, okay? So, let us say I went to an electrical store and I asked for a battery.
So, I got a box, I got a box, I do not know what is inside the box, I have been told that this is a,
this is a battery and this comes with two terminals, okay? I am fairly certain that
this is an LTI network inside, right? Let us say this is an LTI network inside,
right? Okay? So, what I do? I come home and I put a voltmeter between these two terminals,
let me say, let me mark these terminals as A and B, right? I put a voltmeter between these terminals
and I observe, right? I observe VAB under this condition is equal to 1 volt, right?
Then can I conclude from this observation that this is indeed a voltage source?
I obviously cannot, right? Because what is the property of a voltage source?
A property of a voltage source is that, so what is a voltage source? So, voltage source,
the major property of voltage source is the voltage across its terminals is insensitive
to any load attached between its terminals, correct? This we all agree, right?
So, how does the statement that I just made, any different from the observation that we have made?
The observation that we have made is for an open circuited load,
right? We have not really tested out whether the voltage source is, whether this stuff that I have
bought from the market is actually a good voltage source or not, because I have not put any
resistances across its terminals, okay? So, then what I did was, I said I could not find
any resistance lying around. So, what I did, I went ahead and shorted the terminals A and B,
right? So, what I did, I experiment 2, right? So, this is experiment 1, I did this.
So, let us say I do an experiment 2. In experiment 2, I go ahead and do this,
again same network, I know this is an LTI network, what I did, I went, I go ahead and
short these two terminals and I observe this current and I call this Iab or let me just
simply call it Isc, it is a short circuit current, we call it Isc, I observe that this is equal to
10 milliamps. Now, from this observation, can I conclude that this is a current source that
supplies a current of 10 milliamps? Again, obviously, I cannot conclude this from once
experiment because what is the definition of a current source, what we understand by current
source? The current through the terminals is independent of the load attached.
If it has to be a current source, then the current through the terminals has to be independent of the
load attached to it. Now, mind you, I have not attached any load, I have just simply
shorted the output. So, from these two experiments, can I conclude that the stuff
that I have bought from the market is it a good voltage source or is it a good current source?
Actually, I cannot conclude either because I have some missing information and what is the
information that is missing? Now, we all know that if this were a good voltage source,
if this were an ideal voltage source, then what would have happened if I had
shorted the terminals A and B? If I had shorted the terminals A and B,
I should have seen an infinite current. An ideal voltage source does not have
any internal resistance. So, let us assume this stuff inside my LTI box
is an ideal voltage source. If this were an ideal voltage source and I did the experiment 2
by shorting these two terminals, this is A and B, what would this current have been?
This Isc would have been infinity. However, what do I see? I see a limited current,
the current is limited to 10 milliamps. So, what can I conclude? I can conclude
that this is not an ideal voltage source and the fact that there is probably a resistance associated
with the voltage source. So, there is a resistance R s associated with the voltage source.
Since I have resistance R s associated with the voltage source, the short circuit current is
instead of Isc, the short circuit current is 10 milliamps.
So, now what is 10 milliamps? This I have a battery, what is 10 milliamps? 10 milliamps
Isc is V bat by R s which is 10 milliamps. What is V bat? From where do I know V bat?
This was experiment 2, this is experiment 2. What was experiment 1 telling us? Experiment 1
was telling us that if this contraption was open circuited and I was measuring this voltage V ab,
I was getting V ab to be equal to 1 volt. And what is V ab in terms of V bat?
Because the current that I am drawing is 0 because of open circuit, my V bat V ab
is equal to V bat which is equal to 1 volt. Which means what? Which means my V bat is 1 volt
and my R s is 1 volt by 10 milliamp which is 100 ohm. So, essentially the stuff that I have
bought from the market is this, is 1 volt 100 ohm and this comes inside my box.
I had gone to the market to get an ideal 1 volt, but when I came back, I came back with
this contraption. So, now is this a good voltage source or is this a good current source?
How can I, how can I, what can I infer from this? I will argue that I cannot infer anything from
this information. Why? Because whether this is a good voltage source or a good current source
depends upon what resistance am I planning to drive. Let me elaborate.
So, if I connect a resistance R L, if I connect a resistance R L, what is the voltage V ab? V ab
is 1 volt times R L by R L plus 100 ohms. Let me replace, express this in terms of
the internal resistance of the, of the battery. So, under what condition this V ab will not change
regardless of the values of R L? What is the definition of a voltage source?
Let me take you back to the definition of a voltage source. The definition of a voltage
source is, is that thing that is insensitive to any load that is attached between its terminals.
Now, there is a load R L attached at the terminal. However, my V ab should not change
if this band is supposed to be a voltage source. So, for voltage source, for the box to behave
like a voltage source, what should I, what should get satisfied? We should ensure that,
that those ranges of R L for which R L is much, much greater than R S,
for these ranges of R L, my contraption inside the box will behave like a voltage source.
So, if you satisfy this, if you, if you use this box to drive those values of load,
rather if you use this box to drive load resistances, which are much greater than
R S, which in this case is 100 ohms, then this will behave like a voltage source,
right? Your output, output voltage is, will remain insensitive to the change in, change in R L.
Now, can this block, can this box behave like a current source? So, what should I, what should I,
what should I try to see? I should try to see what is the current, right? What should,
what is the current through this, through this load, right? So, what is the current I R L?
My current is 1 volt divided by R L plus R S, right? And what is the definition of a current
source? The definition of a current source is that contraption whose output current
is insensitive to the change in any load resistances, right? So, under what condition
this output current is independent of R L? This will be independent of R L under the condition
that, so if R L is much, much less than R S, right? Then I R L is 1 volt by R S, which is
10 milliamps for all values of R L, which is much less than 100 ohm.
And hence, under these, these ranges of R L, right? Under these ranges of R L,
this box will behave like a, like a current source, right? Note that the same box,
the same box I went to the market and asked for a voltage source, but the same box is, can behave
like a voltage source or like a current source depending upon the range of load that you are
trying to derive, right? So, in other words, if I mark the range of R L, right? So, if I say
R L is much less than 100 ohm, this behaves like a current source, right? R L much greater than
100 ohm, my box behaves like a, this box behaves like a voltage source.
But if it is in, around the range of, if R L is of the order of 100 ohm, then,
then this is neither a voltage source nor a, nor a current source, right? In that range,
both the current through R L and the voltage across R L are dependent on the load resistances.
So, now, if you are somebody who is in charge of designing the box, that will be the, that will be
our job in a different context, we will, in a different context, that is something that we
will be doing throughout the course, we will be in charge of designing the parameters inside the box.
What is the first question that you should ask? The first question that you should ask is that,
okay, fine, you have asked me to design some, some block, maybe some amplifier,
or maybe some regulator, but what is the load that I am planning to drive?
Because it is dependent on the performance of my block will be dependent on what am I trying to
drive? And what is this dependent on? It is dependent on the Thevenin resistance that I
am seeing at the output of the block, right? If I, if I, if I know what is the Thevenin output
resistance of the block that I have designed, or the block that I am planning to design,
then I can make a quick and dirty approximation to figure out whether this block will behave like a
voltage source, or will behave like a current source for the ranges of load resistance that
have been provided to us, or it might not behave either like a voltage source or a current source.
So, this also becomes important when you are debugging a circuit, right? When you are debugging
a circuit and you see that your output voltage is changing when it is not supposed to change,
or it is your current is changing when it is not supposed to change, what is the first thing that
you should go and check? One of the first things that you should go and check, you should go and
check whether the Thevenin equivalent resistance at the output of your block is either very high
or very low depending upon, with respect to the load resistance that it is driving, and it depends
on what you are trying to make, right? So, what is the conclusion of whatever we have been
focusing on for the last two lectures? Essentially, these last two lectures were
a motivation behind all the things that we will cover in this course, right?
So, what was the first motivation? The first motivation is we need a block for amplifying
power. Second is we need to understand feedback design power efficient solutions.
And what is the third thing? We need to be, we need to pay attention to the output resistance
of a block that is driving certain loads, right? So, these are the three bedrocks, right? These
are the three bedrocks of this course, or rather you can say that these are the three targets
that we need, we plan to be, we plan to get comfortable with as the course progresses.
The final one, this one is super important, right? We will be using it day in and day out,
right? So, because we need to pay attention to an output resistance of a block or for that matter,
some equivalent resistance of a block or for that matter, Thevenin output or Thevenin resistance
of a block, we need to, we need to brush up our basic circuit theory problems on figuring
out resistances of a block. So, what I will do is I will post an assignment in the first week,
which will be a refresher of figuring out output resistances or rather resistances
of different types of linear time invariant circuits, right?
You can, you can go through them and this first lecture will, this first assignment will be a,
will be a refresher or a revision of, of the concepts that we already know,
right? From our previous experiences of dealing with basic circuit theory,
right? And we can then take it forward from there.
