Taking on the "Jerry Garcia" Challenge at Island Pig and Fish in Port St. Lucie, Florida! Brave and extremely hungry diners have one hour to take on a BBQ and seafood platter loaded with brisket, burnt ends, fried oysters, mac n' cheese, a fried chicken sandwich, a soft-shell crab sandwich, a double cheeseburger, a Philly cheesesteak sandwich, and a scallop sandwich!! Winners earn their $165 meal for free, a groovy hat, and spot up on Island Pig and Fish's Wall of Fame!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The narrator visits Island Pig and Fish in Fort Pierce, Florida, to attempt the \"Jerry Garcia Platter Challenge.\" The massive feast includes various sandwiches, BBQ meats, and seafood. Despite praising the high quality of the food, the narrator is ultimately disqualified and fails to complete the challenge within the one-hour time limit.
and welcome to today's video.
Today, I'm at Island of Pig and Fish
in Fort Pierce, Florida,
where I'm about to help kick off
the Jerry Garcia Platter Challenge.
In front of me, I have the most insane amount of food.
I am super nervous for this,
but it all looks really delicious.
I am jazzed.
The owner here, Taylor, has been smoking for over 20 years.
He owns a Michelin star restaurant,
so I know this is about to be fantastic.
But in front of me, I have one of their giant,
this is called the Shove,
a Philly cheesesteak sandwich,
which I think is like a traditional Philly,
but it also has brisket in it.
In addition, I have a soft-shell crab sandwich.
I have a bacon-wrapped scallop sandwich.
I have a normal burger, which I'm saying normal,
but this thing looks like an absolute behemoth.
As my sides will call them sides,
I do have a half pound of brisket
and a half pound of burnt ends,
and then also a bunch of their fried oysters.
And then right in the middle of this thing,
I have some of their mac and cheese,
which looks absolutely divine.
But I'm going to have one hour to eat all of this.
If I'm successful, I get the $165 meal for free,
a groovy hat, and my spot on the wall of fame here.
I love the rules behind me as well.
Forks are optional, and everyone loves a good butt rub.
So with that, there is nothing to it but to do it.
Let's take on the Jerry Garcia challenge
and get this challenge started.
I haven't even started eating yet,
and I have food on my shirt just because I was near this.
So that means it's gonna be messy,
and good.
All right, we're gonna do things a little different today,
and I'm gonna start with the mac and cheese.
So without further delay, three, two, one.
It is mac and cheese eating time.
Here we go.
Woo, oh my.
Oh, mama.
Oh, praise.
Oh, I love a good, joyous exchange like this.
It was recommended that I start with the mac and cheese
so that I wouldn't be eating that coagulated,
cold cheese at the end of this challenge.
Oh, this is healthy.
Let me tell y'all,
it was worth not starting with the protein
to enjoy this as it was meant to be nice,
and warm, and melty.
This is definitely not velveted up.
Strategically, this wasn't the best move for stomach space,
but this was mentally an awesome boost
to clear out a lot of space on this platter.
That's it for that one.
We're gonna use this cheese to dip brisket into.
Let's try it raw.
Not raw, but.
Mm, so good.
Now we're gonna dip it in cheese.
Oh, that is good.
Truly have no idea why I said raw.
I guess I just meant plain,
as it was meant to be in its OG state,
but yeah, guarantee this was not raw brisket.
This is some of the thicker sliced bacon I've ever had,
so I know it looks like I'm struggling.
It's just thicker than normal.
Oof, and another misspoken word there.
This is also not bacon.
It is, again, brisket,
so I'm not sure if those carbs went straight to my head.
I was hangry?
I don't know.
All right, that was exquisite.
We're gonna keep up with the theme
and work on this shove Philly sandwich challenge right here.
This Philly sandwich was a behemoth in its own right,
absolutely loaded with da meats and obviously some veggies,
and then the bread that it was on
was also quite hearty as well.
I'm in my happy place.
It was a bit unexpected to be enjoying
a Philly cheesesteak sandwich
during a barbecue-slash-seafood challenge,
but I was all in for it.
It was absolutely delicious.
These were your mom's recipe?
Potato salad, mom's recipe.
The pickles were your recipe.
Okay, the pickles are Taylor's recipe,
and they are fine.
They're kind of sweet.
They're like a sweet, mm, they're good.
I do consider myself to be a bit of a pickle connoisseur,
and these were absolutely top-notch, nice and bright
to break up all of the fattiness
from the Philly cheesesteak sandwich.
Ooh!
I think it's a good idea to move on to the oysters next,
because, I mean, obviously,
seafood deserves to be eaten while it's warm,
so here we go.
Oh, those are yummy.
Okay.
Mm!
Like caught today, right?
No, that's okay.
They're gonna be gone in five seconds.
These are so good.
Mm!
In my intro, I might've forgotten to mention
that there's also a fried chicken sandwich,
which, I don't know how I missed this behemoth up front,
but I don't think I ever said it.
So there it is.
Yeah, this sandwich is Randy's fault.
Yeah, Randy and I basically made our own bed here
as we sort of helped design and finalize
the final touches of this massive barbecue platter.
All right.
Oysters are down, and now it's for this,
probably the most aesthetic burger I've ever had.
This is it for it.
I'm sorry, little guy.
I watched his life process.
I'm sorry, little guy.
Okay, here we go.
Oh.
That's yummy.
Let's just say I got to see a bit behind the scenes,
and we definitely know all of this stuff is nice and fresh,
and this was such a unique sandwich.
I've never had anything like it.
I've enjoyed a soft-shell crab before,
but never in a sandwich.
Okay, next is the sandwich I forgot about,
which is bigger than my face,
so I don't know how I forgot it, but here we go.
Chicken fried sandwich.
Oh.
I don't think there was a single thing
on this platter that I ended up disliking,
and let me tell y'all, this chicken sandwich was top-notch.
I know it's such a basic thing to eat,
especially compared to that soft-shell crab,
but wow, out of this world.
I am soft now.
Ooh.
All right.
That chicken sandwich was a monster.
Let's do some burnt ends.
These look fantastic, by the way.
They're like butter.
That is solid.
These are not low-fat, by the way.
Nope.
As you might've been able to tell,
these were no longer like butter,
but that is my own fault.
I probably should've dove into these
right after all of that mac and cheese.
These are delicious, but rich.
Share these like you're supposed to.
I am being a glutton.
Literally.
Share.
And with those words of wisdom,
I'm gonna leave you guys to enjoy the rest of this video.
Thank you all so much for watching,
and I'll catch you in the next one.
Yay!
This has gotta be a two-pound burger.
Oh, my God.
A one-kilo burger.
Wow.
Diet Coke, yes.
Thank you.
Sorry, full mouth.
No, you're good.
You're refreshing it.
You're doing great.
I'm so proud of you.
Oh, thank you.
Thank you.
Okay.
This thing was voted best burger in Fort Pierce.
I see why.
Once you eat this,
you pass out and lose consciousness,
which I'm about to do.
That is so good.
I just can't.
That is so good.
It is good?
That is good.
Good.
Oh, scallop burger.
Okay, scallops are easy.
Mm-hmm.
Mm.
Mm-hmm.
Thank you.
Yeah, let me get a little baby.
Thank you.
My number one helper.
Is this lighter?
Why are you touching?
Oh, that's lighter.
Oh, okay, yeah.
Okay.
You got it.
I'm tampered with.
Oh, burger.
Don't get me wrong,
the burger is fantastic.
It's just very intimidating.
Oh.
You're a good hype man.
Final bite of the burger.
I'm gonna eat burnt ends.
I'm on the Gandhi diet after this.
We're gonna put this bad boy on a plate.
Thank you, Lord.
Because this plate looks really gross.
Yes.
There we go.
Just a cute little snack.
It's so cute.
Oh, this is tiny.
Oh my God.
These scallops are huge.
That's not normal.
Even though a lot of people think
because I'm small,
that that's normal.
It's just not normal.
I'm sorry.
Oh.
You got six more minutes.
I do, I have six.
Yeah.
Well, unfortunately again,
I had to run away
and I was disqualified.
I only really have two bites of bread left,
which is very sad.
But that was a lot of really good food.
It was just another really high fat rich challenge
and that is really rough on the tum tum.
But that was absolutely delicious.
If you come here,
order normal human portions.
Just enjoy a burger,
enjoy a sandwich,
enjoy some barbecue.
All the food here looks phenomenal.
All the food was phenomenal.
Unfortunately, I will not be honoring
the name of Jerry Garcia today.
So I will not be leaving
with the $165 meal for free,
a groovy hat that has just been looming overhead
or a spot up on the wall of fame
kicking off this challenge.
But hopefully Randy can redeem this challenge
and make the Jerry Garcia challenge
his, well, you know,
his, you know.
Anyways, big thank you to the folks
here at Island Pig and Fish.
All the food was phenomenal.
Big thank you to everyone who cheered me on
right up to the very bitter end.
I now have room for that peanut butter pie.
So with that, I'm going to close this out.
Thank you guys so much for watching
and we'll catch you at the next one,
which hopefully we can finally win.
All right.
Okay, peace out.
Bye.