In this video, I blind taste taste white Premier Cru wines from across Burgundy and ask a slightly dangerous question: does the Côte d’Or really deserve all the glory?
Hi everybody! This is Agnes from No Sediment and today we are going to taste
white Premier Cru wines from across the Burgundy and ask slightly dangerous question
does Côte d'Ivoire really deserve all the glory? The idea for this video came to me while I was
traveling through Burgundy and peeking into almost every wine shop I passed. For one, I had a
While studying the offer, you see wines at all sorts of price points. You see different names,
villages, vineyards and climat on the labels, enough to confuse even the most seasoned Burgundy
lovers. What I thought could be confusing for a consumer is that I could see Premier Cru wines
priced anywhere between 30 euros and 500 euros. Of course, we already understand that not all
Some have consistently been rated higher than others. Some, legend has it, were meant to be
formalized as Grand Cru and were only refused that status because of whatever political,
financial or ownership reasons. Burgundy lovers take great pride in their knowledge of these
complexities, especially those who have dived so deeply into Burgundy and feel so comfortable there
that the only reason they poke their nose out of it is if they smell a glass of champagne.
So why are we going to talk about Premier Cru today? Burgundy is unique. Broadly speaking,
Burgundy's quality hierarchy can be divided into four major categories. At the base,
we have regional wines, Bourgogne Blanc, Bourgogne Rouge, Bourgogne Pastute, Grain, among others.
A step above that, we have village-level wines. These take the name of the village or commune
where the grapes are grown. Think of Merceau, Volnay or Puy-Fusay for that matter. Next up,
we have Premier Cru wines. On the label, you will see the village name followed by Premier Cru
and in certain cases, you might even see the name of a specific Premier Cru site or climat.
At the very top, the pinnacle of Burgundy, creme de la creme, the jewel, the treasure and the crown
sit the Grand Cru wines. There are 33 Grand Cru vineyards in Burgundy and each has its own unique
AOC. Take together with the rest of Burgundy's appellations and it is no wonder that Burgundy
is responsible for 23% of all France's AOC wines and seems to take great pride in it. So Grand Cru
in a way remains a completely different story. First of all, with almost no exceptions, these
are very limited and very expensive wines. Except for Chablis, there are no Grand Cru vineyards
outside Côte d'Iorre. The Côte d'Iorre is the heart of Burgundy and the holy grail for Burgundy
lovers. Further south, we have Côte Chalonnaise which is often praised as the land of discoveries
and even further south, we have Mâconnet with probably the most famous appellation there at
Funny enough, I think that village Burgundy can offer a great deal of fun and excitement
but also quite a lot of disappointment. And to make things worse, it is village-level Burgundy
that has shown a very significant price increase over the last 10 to 15 years. Prices have doubled
and in some cases have risen by as much as 300 or even 500 percent. If I am being honest, we have
seen a significant price increase across all Burgundy wines. But having said that, when I look
at Burgundy shelves and see that the price gap between village and Premier Cru has narrowed,
I cannot help but wonder if the safer choice now lies with the Premier Cru label. And now we can
find Premier Cru wines in all major Burgundy sub-regions Chablis, Côte d'Iorre, Côte Chalonnaise and Mâconnet.
There are even discussions underway about elevating some vineyards in Beaujolais
to Premier Cru status as well. And that means, or at least I tend to think so, that there are
still spots to look for good value wines in Burgundy. And I do think that you can find less
disappointment in the Premier Cru category. Initially, it might seem like a silly experiment
to compare Côte d'Iorre Premier Cru wines to those of Côte Chalonnaise and Mâconnet because we clearly
know which ones are more affordable and which carry greater prestige. But despite what we are
often told through promotional activities, vineyard classification and official recognition are not
nearly as romantic as they might seem. There is always politics, money and power involved. For
example, Jasper Morris, Master of Wine, has written that one reason so much of Chalonnaise was classified
as Premier Cru is that vineyards classed as Premier Cru would not be requisitioned by the
occupying German forces. These vineyards were codified in 1942 and apparently it was done in
quite a rush. So, it might be the case that some Premier Cru vineyards in the Chalonnaise are not
up to the standards we might expect from them today. Certain things could also be said about
some vineyards in Côte d'Iorre. Meanwhile, the Mâconnet Premier Cru vineyards are only enforced
from the 2020 vintage onwards and although they are based on historical data, prestige and
consistency in outperforming other sites, we still cannot entirely exclude the factor of politics and
power play here as well. So, I thought it would be interesting to taste these wines in blind and
whether what we are talking about really is quality gap or maybe instead we are simply discussing a
And let us also ask with this tasting, can we really expect a similar level of quality from
all Premier Cru vineyards across Burgundy? Or does Côte d'Iorre remain the sacred grail?
Let's start with wine number one. I do love the color here. It is relatively deep lemon and you
know that this wine will pack some tension and some intensity and concentration. Not that you
can tell all of that from the color. It can be very misleading as well. But at this level,
yes, you feel this really ripe fruit profile here. All the yellow fruits you can imagine.
Think of pear, apple, peaches, even hint of melon maybe. You can also feel some note of vanilla
and toasted nuts and sweet spices. So, it seems that this wine has seen at some stage of its
vinification oak. Those stone fruits that I feel on the nose here, they're maybe slightly bruised
in a way. But let's taste it. Overall, I think that this wine is quite generous and open and
really inviting. It has some tension when it comes to acidity, when it comes to focus and precision
of the fruit. But all together, I think it acts like this nice, gentle and kind hug. And it is
very approachable right now at this very moment. And then there's this generosity of fruit and
openness of fruit on the palate. It's all really ripe. It seems that this wine is coming from a
warmer vintage, a relatively sunny, sunshine-driven site. I will give this wine 90 points. Let's move
to wine number two. So, with wine number two, we see slightly paler color. And on the nose,
on the nose, I would say this is quite aromatic, perfumed wine style. There is tension and
nerveness to it. If we had all these ripe yellow fruits, these orchard fruit-driven profile in wine
one, here it is more citrus fruit, lime, lemon. Lemon is quite ripe here. And there's another
element that I feel a lot, and that is floral characters. We have these citrus fruit florals
and maybe some acacia blossom as well, like that fresh spring morning meadow.
Slight green elements as well, but not green in a way that it is unripe, but more like maybe
lime peel or, you know, some sage. Let's taste the wine. Well, wine one had that jolly, generous
appeal to it. Wine two is more focused. It has higher acidity and it has slimmer body. It seems
more steely and linear in a way. While I'm talking with you, what I really enjoy here is that long,
long-lasting aftertaste because that lemon, that lime peel, that floral character is so persistent
that through all these seconds, me conversing with you, I still feel the wine on my palate.
I think this is quite magnificent bottle. I will give this wine 92 points. Let's move to
wine number three. Wine number three, we also feel those bright, ripe yellow fruits as we did
in wine number one. So here we have those peaches and apricots. They're a bit crunchier. They are
not as ripe as in wine one. And what I also feel here in wine three is that creamy, buttery
element that adds a bit of extra layer, if you will. But what I also enjoy that it is not
overpowering the fruit. The fruit still plays the main role. It is the leading actor here in the
wine three. It is evolving now because now it starts to smell of chamomile, fresh chamomile
blossom. I really like this wine. Wow. It seems layered and complex and it keeps developing in
the glass. Let's taste the wine. So wine number three, it is almost like mix between one and two
because you have that generosity of fruit. It is quite open and it is there, you know, to please
you. But as you pay attention on that fruit, the acidity slowly creeps in and it just lifts it all
up and, you know, adds extra dimension to the wine. It elongates the wine and all of a sudden
to that ripeness of fruit, we get that wave of freshness, that wave of focus and precision.
And it is really beautiful. And what is also quite interesting with wine number three,
as opposed to wine number two, is that we also have really long aftertaste. But here,
the aftertaste was this one dimensional element. You know, I had that citrus fruit character.
Here, the aftertaste at first, I had that fruit ripeness, that stone fruit character.
Then I had some of the floral elements and now it almost feels there's something herbal to it.
So this is really complex and interesting wine. I will give this one 93 points. And let's move to
wine number four. Okay, so wine number four. On the nose, we have similar elements of those ripe
stone fruits. I'm talking peaches and yellow apple, but that really ripe in character. But
there's also some spiciness to it. Like you almost have that, you know, peach compote or peach jam
that is mixed together with rosemary or thyme to add a bit of oomph, to add a bit of, you know,
depth, flavor, depth to the fruit. And I have very similar experience in this glass.
And then when you talk about it, and you think like you have
catched the aromas of these wines, and you have already defined them,
you know, it starts to evolve and it starts to evade. Let's taste it because now I feel like
it just closed. Wow, I think this wine also packs a lot of flavor and complexity and concentration
on the palate. The aftertaste is really intense here. But I think this wine in a way,
it shows a lot of power and structure and body. But there's also some fragile elements to it,
you know, there is this really concentrated and nice, firm acidity that elevates it that
makes that ripe fruit profile quite refreshing and not at all dull. I do enjoy this wine,
that spiciness, that ripeness of the fruit without losing, you know, that elegant fragility
some of the best wines can offer. I will give this wine 91.5 points. Shall we reveal the wines?
We will start probably with the lowest scored wine. All of these wines were fantastic. All
these wines were great. And I would be incredibly happy to enjoy all of them on their own. But also
there are differences in quality and in style and the way I perceive it. So we will start with
wine number one, which I gave 90 points if I'm not mistaken. Alright, so this is 2022 vintage.
It is Montagny Premier Cru and it is a blend from several Premier Cru vines. This is interesting.
It was really generous and an open and rich and ripe fruit driven. Jasper Morris says that more
than half of Montagny vineyards are actually Premier Cru. So according to him, some of the
Premier Cru wines could be of higher rate and some maybe not so much. This is blend from relatively
young vines and this wine was I think the cheapest of the bunch and it received 90 points. This was
really beautiful wine. Maybe the richness and opulence was a bit too much for my personal
taste. But let's move to wine number four, which I gave 91.5 points. This is one of my recent
discoveries. Eric Forrest Puyfuset Premier Cru Lecre 2024. It would be very difficult
for me to identify the vintage because 2024 was a really challenging vintage and you could not
see it in this wine. It was really clean and beautiful and you had that nice focused acidity.
For the longest time I have been a great supporter and fan of producers who harvest their grapes
relatively late. I like the generosity of flavors. I like the ripeness of the fruit in the wines.
I like when wines offer something more flavor-wise than just acidity. And I think this wine
represented it beautifully. And when I visited this estate, the winemaker explained it and it
made a lot of sense. Of course, when you harvest grapes later, there is this risk of increased
residual sugar, which will translate in higher alcohol level. But other elements in grapes
concentrate too. And including acidity. So sometimes waiting more, allowing grapes to
fully mature on wine, you can actually get better acidity on the palate as well. And this wine,
it has only 13%. It is a relatively cool and challenging vintage, as I said. But for me,
this is a great discovery. I really enjoyed this producer. Let's move to wine number two, which
received 92 points. And I would have been quite surprised if it wouldn't be Chablis. Because
this specific Chablis Premier Cru Le Vaillon, it was the slimmest, the freshest, the nerviest of
all the wines. And I think I did describe the style more citrus-driven. It was also more perfumed,
in a way, on the nose. This was beautiful. With Vaillon, we are not on the slopes where the famous
Grand Cru vineyards are. With Vaillon vineyard, we are actually on the other side of the river.
And I think it can offer great value. In a way, both of these wines are actually
very similarly priced. So you can see that they also offer quite good value when it comes to
Burgundy. Because when we talk about value, we always have to remember that we are talking about
value in Burgundy. It is completely different than when we talk about value in other winemaking
regions. Let's move to wine number three, which I know where it is coming from by now. I gave this
wine 93 points. And I thought it was quite magnificent. And it was evolving and developing.
So we are in Cote d'Ivoire. We are with Jean-Louis Chavis Pouligny-Monacher Premier Cru Le Folletier.
It is one of the largest Premier Cru vineyards, if I'm not mistaken. It is also often regarded as
one of the finest Premier Cru vineyards in Pouligny area. And I think in this specific case,
this wine really shined. I was impressed by it. And when I was tasting the wine in blind,
there was a question mark. Could this be the Cote d'Ivoire wine? Because the way it evolved in the
glass, because the way it was so complex and layered and was not one-dimensional, you know,
there was a lot of things to talk about when we smelled, when we tasted the wine. And I am
absolutely sure if I would take this bottle back home and enjoy it over the course of dinner,
it would reveal a lot of new elements and things in the glass and the conversation would continue.
Well, we can see now that Cote d'Ivoire indeed was the top scored wine. However, we have to be
this bottle is twice the price of this bottle and twice the price of this bottle and thrice,
three times more the price of this bottle. However, the scoring was not that much greater.
Of course, this is a beautiful bottle and it was a great experience. Let me know in the comment
section below, where do you look for good value in Burgundy? If you at all look for value in
Burgundy and also should I make similar experiment tackling red wines of Burgundy,
that would be also quite interesting. And meanwhile, make sure to watch this video next.