🔴 FREE LIVE WEBINAR: ANYA × ANYA Are you paying for an expensive label, or better wine? Join me and Anya live as we break down how to source genuine quality without overpaying. 📅 Date: November 19th ⏰ Time: 7:00 PM Milan (CET) / 10:00 AM Los Angeles (PST) 👉 Reserve your free spot here: https://course.thegrandcruaffair.com/preregistration
🎓 Wine Sense Method Course - The full system for reading wine labels, scores, medals and prices like an insider: https://course.thegrandcruaffair.com/ (FREE DEMO AVAILABLE)
📸 Follow me on Instagram: • Grand Cru Affair: / grand_cru_affair • Anya Gariboldi: / anyagariboldi
Costco has VERY expensive names attached to very inexpensive bottles—and honey, I do not care who made it if I can taste the discount.
Today, the labels come off. Five Costco wines, completely blind. I’m judging three things only: Balance, Complexity, and Length. Does it taste expensive, or does it taste like Costco? And then I have to commit: BUY or SKIP before I see the bottle. Either way, somebody’s getting offended.
Professional sommelier Anna Garibaldi performs a blind tasting of five Costco wines to determine if their quality matches their price. By evaluating balance, complexity, and length, she identifies which bottles offer genuine value and which rely solely on prestigious labels to mask poor quality.
Can I say it?
Come on, say it, be honest!
Oh my god.
Costco has very expensive names at such very inexpensive bottles.
And honey, I do not care who made it if I can taste the discount.
Some of this cost less than $15.
Some were made by cult winemakers whose
other bottles sell for over $100.
Hi, my name is Anna Garibaldi.
I'm a professional sommelier, wine judge and diploma WSET graduate.
And today the labels come off five Costco wines completely blind.
I'm judging three things only, balance, complexity, and length.
Does it taste expensive or does it taste like Costco?
And then I have to commit buy or skip before I see the bottle.
Either way, somebody's getting offended.
All right, let's go.
Glass number one, on the nose.
Oh god. You know what's funny?
People for some reason think that sommeliers only remember Grand
Crus. Honey, let me tell you something.
We remember the ---- ones even better. With that
being said, ladies and gentlemen, oh my nose is flushing red.
Passion fruit, canned asparagus,
and that burning sting that tells me the acid is going to be violent.
I haven't even tasted
it yet. To me, this is screaming commercial
New Zealand sauvignon blanc on the palate.
I mean, who needs an espresso when you have the battery acid?
Just pure aggressive sour. I'm sorry.
For me, the acidity is doing all the talking.
The fruit cannot even keep up.
It's literally like biting into an unripe lime. Passion fruit,
asparagus, and that is basically the entire checklist.
The first lamb is done before it even swallows.
So, the first time I tried it,
it was a bit difficult.
First time.
Hmm.
I'll have to get it.
Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc.
Surprise, surprise, what a mystery.
Let's move on.
Glass number two.
Color check.
We have medium ruby with a little garnet rim.
Quick wine tip: red wines lose their pigment with age,
shifting from purple to ruby to that brick garnet age.
So basically it tells me the glass has seen a birthday too.
All right, on the nose.
Oh, hello!
Now this has manners.
I get dark cherries, vanilla, maybe a touch of dill,
and perhaps some coconut actually,
which logically points me towards the use of American oak.
And it also tells me we could be somewhere in Spain,
I guess, on the palate.
Oh yes, that's what a wine is supposed to do,
rich red fruit up front, but then it comes the nice
stuff, leather, sweet cedar, cocoa,
it skips the cheap fruit bomb routine and goes straight to the
proper cellar character.
Tannins are smooth, wood is integrated, acidity keeps it alive,
zero complaints.
It doesn't just stop at fruit, it has spice, it has cedar, leather,
So it's actually got depth and the finish.
It's long and it does not quit easily.
Now, here comes the truth.
Does it taste expensive or does it taste like Costco?
Expensive, easily.
And honey, I know what expensive smells like.
J'adore Costco.
Rioja Reserva.
This is the ultimate cheat code in the wine aisle
and the reason why I will
always be the biggest Rioja advocate.
Rioja Reserva can't just slap Reserva on the label
and call it a personality.
Unlike France, by the way, there are actual aging requirements behind
it. Barrel, time, patience. I mean, for under 15 bucks.
If I were you, I would seriously go for it.
Sorry to interrupt. I thought I was the only Anya
in the wine business. Apparently not.
One name, two sommeliers, different continents.
And one very important question.
Are you paying for another expensive label or better wine?
Join us live on November 19th
and learn how to recognize quality without overpaying.
7 p.m. Milan time and 10 a.m. L.A.
The free registration link is below.
Now back to wine.
Glass number three.
Color check first.
So we have translucent pale ruby.
So Pinot Noir would probably be one of my first guesses?
On the nose. I get red cherry, raspberry, sweet oak, and then...
Can I say it?
Yes, say it. Be honest.
Oh my god. Oh honey, that's hot.
Let's try this one on the palate.
Again, ripe cherry.
I get raspberry and then right through
the middle the fruit just completely collapses
and the alcohol takes over.
For me, no balance here whatsoever. The alcohol is
boiling the entire thing.
Red fruit, vanilla, a lot of vanilla, but honestly a lot of what
feels like complexity is just oak and alcohol making noise.
The fruit is practically gone in
less than two seconds. The only thing that really stays is the heat.
So does this taste expensive?
Oh, it tastes like Costco.
Costco, would I buy it?
Absolutely not.
Skip.
A la poubelle.
Pinot Noir, Carneros, Napa Valley 2021.
14.5% now, to be clear.
14.5% does not make a wine bad.
Some warm climate regions pull it off brilliantly.
But with Pinot Noir, that is a very dangerous game.
It requires extreme care.
If you don't have the acidity and fruit depth to balance that heat,
you're not drinking Pinot, you're drinking pure ethanol.
Carneros sounds expensive, Pinot Noir sounds expensive,
but without the label, honey, I can clearly taste the discount.
All right, glass number four. Color check first.
So we have ruby with some purple rim. To me it
looks very young. All right, on the nose.
Oh wow, that's proper. Dark fruit, cedar, dry tobacco,
pencil shavings. It has that quiet old world restraint.
I'm definitely leaning towards
Bordeaux blend here. I'm not sure if it's a left or right bank.
All right, let's see on the palate first.
Mamma mia, what a letdown.
Non ci siamo proprio.
It's watery green.
The tannins are just completely naked.
So what they do is just dry your entire mouth out
without giving anything in return.
I'm gonna be honest here.
The nose gave me a very interesting Bordeaux,
or whatever it turns out to be.
The palate, well, it gave me that diluted plum and wood.
Basically, and the nose and the palate
had two completely different budgets.
All right, let's check the lens.
It's very short.
The fruit vanishes in three seconds,
That thin woodish astringency.
So does this taste expensive or it tastes like Costco?
I'm sorry, Costco. Would I buy it? Skip. A la poubelle.
Bordeaux Superior Grand Vin de Bordeaux 2023.
70% Cabernet Sauvignon and 30% Merlot.
Left Bank. Old World cut. And this is why I taste blind.
Look at the label. Bordeaux Superior.
The nose sells you the dream. And you think you found the $12 miracle.
And then you taste this.
And the promise was so much bigger than the delivery.
Last one, plus number six, color check first.
So we have deep ruby and warm garnet rim.
Let's try this one on the nose.
We're okay.
I get dark berries, violet, some cracked pepper,
dry herbs, a little smoked meat.
I mean, it's very warm, very savory.
Again, I think we're still somewhere in the old world.
I'm leaning towards Grenache on the palate.
There we go.
Yes, yes and yes. Now we're talking.
It's warm but balanced, probably around 13
and a half percent alcohol.
It doesn't burn because there is plenty of ripe juicy fruit
to carry it. Black cherry, licorice,
wild herbs and more importantly there is no hole in the
meat palate. It actually delivers
from the start to the finish. Let's retaste it.
So I get long, spicy finish, really present.
So my last verdict, does this taste expensive
or does it taste like Costco?
Expensive.
Would I buy it?
Yes.
Definitely not going in the trash.
Gigondas 2021.
14% alcohol, well, I was close enough.
Gigondas, everyone always calls it the little brother
to Châteauneuf-du-Pape.
Is it identical?
Not really.
But does it give you 90% of the vibe
for a third of the price at around 15 bucks?
Outstanding.
Costco, I think we are back on the good terms.
So what did Costco actually prove?
Some of this.
were genuinely impressive.
And some, let's just say the label did all the heavy lifting,
a bargain isn't spent in $12.
It's opening a bottle that drinks like 30.
For this, Costco, I will forgive your parking lot.
I'm Ani Garibaldi.
Cheers.