Why Elites in the Roman Empire Literally Had to Fight Their Own Battles

The Roman Legacy - The Strength of Rome Endures.
17 followers
So the political leaders were often also the leaders on the battlefield.
They were.
Wow.
They were.
That's what, that's literally what they were there to do.
Wow.
So that's as if James Carville would actually would also then have a military,
he would have to be a politician or Federman, you know, the laid back warriors.
But anybody or the casual dress down Friday warriors,
you know, which I think they would love it.
Great.
They would love it.
But those people also, if I love the fact that if they made rules for people,
they also would have to get out on the battlefield.
And at some way, they have to put their money where they have to put their blood,
where their mouth is.
A hundred percent.
And it actually goes deeper than that.
So, yeah, if, if you're right, if you're running for console and you want to be console,
the thing that you want for yourself and expect for yourself is to be the leader of the Legion
and then go out and defeat something or someone on behalf of Rome and then come back and have a
triumph.
And the triumph is you getting to parade through Rome and show off the spoils of your conflict.
And sometimes there were actual wars to fight.
And sometimes there's, there's this very funny thing.
It's called triumph hunting, which is when a console becomes,
comes into power and he's like, there's nobody to fight.
And so he'll just pick some random tribe and attack them and be like,
oh, I defeated such and such a people.
So he can have his triumph.
Which we still do today in different ways.
Yeah, but create enemies.
Yeah, we, we do invent enemies and then go fight them, don't we?
But, but there is, but there is a thing like in, in early Roman society,
really through almost to the end of the Republic,
there was a property qualification to serve in the legions
because you had to have enough money.
You had to have enough land to participate in the legions.
Their assumption, their, their sort of cultural assumption
was that the people who constitute this society that we are in are fundamentally like
the landowners.
And if, so if you own a plot of land, then you're a part of the society.
You're the people who go and fight for this society and defend this society.
If you are, you know, if you're in poverty, if you don't have land,
you don't qualify for service in the legion because in their mind,
you're not actually really, truly a part of this thing
that we are trying to defend.
Right, so how can you put that you're, you're all into it
if you don't have something, you don't have a vested interest almost.
Yeah, and, and then the leaders and then, and then yeah,
the higher you go, the more you are out there.
Now, granted, like they're in the command tent, you know,
they're, you're not like on a horse, like literally leading the charge,
but you were expected to be out there and an active military leader
and everybody who had a stake in that society,
that meant that you also had to be there.
The richest people in society went off to war.
The poorest people stayed behind and we have kind of a flip that.
Yeah, God, that's fascinating.
I can't even imagine, but it sounds like, you know,
you always hear like, oh, I wish all of these, you know,
if these politicians had to have their children go off to war,
they would feel totally different about the things
that they send children off to war to do.
Yeah, they're called chicken hawks.
Yeah, wow.
I didn't know that that was the term it is.
Yeah, yeah.
Chicken hawks?
Yeah, we've had chicken hawks all throughout history.
The people who will bang the drums of war
and then send other people off to die.
Chicken hawk has, go back up to the top, sorry,
has multiple meanings and bird names.
It refers to three hawk species,
coopers, sharp-shinned, and red-tailed.
In gay slang, it's used to describe an older man
who prefers younger males, okay?
And politically, it can describe someone who supports war
but avoids military service, like draft dodgers kind of.
Yeah.
Similar to that.
Yeah, and we've had a whole run of them as presidents.
You know, Clinton got out of it, Bush got out of it,
Trump got out of it.
Oh, yeah.
You know, Obama, I don't think, had the opportunity to.
But yeah, we certainly have not followed that same steed
where the people who are writing the rules
are the same one who have to go out there
and make sure it's not,
make sure it's their own blood that's providing the ink.
Yep.
What did the kings and the royalty live like?
Were they living, was it just like a,
what was it like over there?
Could you just knock on the drawbridge?
How did you even get over there?
Well, for one thing about the Romans
is they did not have kings anymore.
And this is an important part of their political ideology.
Once they kick the kings out in the legendary date of 509 BC,
there aren't kings anymore.
Okay, and why did they kick the kings out?
For a variety of reasons,
most especially, like it was immediately caused
by the aristocrats,
those from the senatorial class,
not liking the last king of Rome.
And it's actually a story that he raped
the daughter of a prominent senator.
And so that's what precipitated
the overthrow of the last Tarquin king.
And that was in the Roman,
that's how the Roman Republic started?
Yeah, yeah, because like if you go back,
like Romulus allegedly founds Rome 753
and then they're kings of Rome for like 250 years.
Okay.
And then around 500, that's when the Republic gets going.
And what started the Republic in?
Take me through that story.
Like the legendary story is that there's a last king
who was the local senatorial elite in Rome
did not like him very much.
What was his name?
Tarquin.
Okay.
And the Tarquin family comes from,
yeah, Tarquin is supervise,
but they were an Etrurian family.
And Etruria is North of Rome, not Roman.
So it was a foreign monarchy.
So they were provincials?
The Romans were being ruled,
yeah, the Romans were being ruled by a king
who came from someplace else.
That's all it is.
It's a foreign monarch.
Got it.
Which is something that is common throughout history.
And so they don't like the foreign monarch.
And this is all trying to like sort of capture
how the Romans get out from under the cultural hegemony
of Etruria at the time,
because the Etruscans were quite a bit better at things
earlier than the Romans were.
And then the Romans come along and supplant them.
But to your question of,
which is really like the high aristocracy,
the senatorial class,
and then ultimately the emperors,
like how are they living?
Well-
Oh, wait, did we finish the story of what happened?
Oh, you told us about the story,
but what happened with the-
Oh yeah, according to the story,
Tarquin rapes the daughter of a prominent setter in Rome.
And that guy goes and he rallies all of his brothers
and his allies and his friends,
and they overthrow the king and they kick him out.
And then they say, we're not doing kings anymore.
Wow.
We are going to do a like job rotation system
and set up proto-democratic assemblies.
And then that's how they ran themselves for like 500 years.
And is that how democracy began?
Well, democracy, I mean, it's one of the places like,
yeah, I mean, democracy is coming from like Greece, right?
They're taking cultural cues
from what's happening over in Greece,
because like just as,
and there is debate about when the Roman Republic
was actually founded,
because you do get sort of Solon coming over to Athens
and being like the great lawgiver of Athens
and sort of the like, I'm going to get this date wrong,
but it's like around 470
is when he's the lawgiver of Athens.
And this is when you start getting sort of like
what we think of as democratic government.
And it's entirely possible that later Roman historians
and backdated, like they retconned their own history
so that they would come along like 30 years before that,
because everybody knew about what was going on in Athens.
And they were like, actually, we got there 30 years earlier,
which is just them, you know,
doing a little light revision of their own history
in order to make sure that they were always the super bus.
It's like an Instagram filter.
Exactly.
Yeah, a little Jakarta.
Yeah, but you know, if you're a senator.
So now we have the Republic going on.
This is where the Republic of Rome,
this is the second of kind of three of the,
this is the second of kind of the three main parts of Rome.
Then we get into the Roman Empire.
Exactly.
Okay.
Yeah.
So now we no longer have kings.
No longer have kings.
Kings bad.
You cannot be a king.
In fact, if anybody tries to be a king,
if anybody tries to become a king,
any Roman citizen can kill that person.
Oh yeah.
Kill the kings.
Oh yeah.
No kings.
Sacramento kings.
No kings.
There is a reason why the emperors are not kings,
because kings are verboten, right?
You are not ever going to be a king.
And every Roman senator ultimately thought
that they were superior to any king.
And there were kings throughout the Mediterranean world
who would be like clients of the Roman Empire.
And any Roman senator considered themselves socially,
morally, politically above a mere king.
So you have the Republic now,
and the counselors of the Republic, the rich guys,
how were they living at the time?
The people who were sort of the aristocrats,
which is synonymous with the senatorial class,
they are the major landowners of Rome.
And so they do not have occupations.
They are living off of the rents of their land.
They're living off of the produce of the peasants
who are living on their land,
and then ultimately the slaves who are living on their land.
That's where their income is coming from.
That's where their wealth is coming from.
They themselves don't have to do anything.
They don't have to have a profession.
They don't have to have a job.
And in their minds, this is what made them
the perfect people to lead the Republic
because they were the only people who had the leisure time
to be literate, to read things about history,
to learn things about how to actually do statecraft,
to have the time to engage in all of those pursuits.
And that made them uniquely able.
And then if you say like,
well, hey, maybe we should educate everyone then,
and then we can have all of these.
And they're like, no, no, no, no, no, no.
You don't wanna go that far
because really they just wanted to be in charge.
But there is sort of a self-justifying
ideological project there,
which is like, we're the ones who have the time to do this,
and so we will be the ones who do it.
And so they would have country villas.
They would usually have like a place in the city.
A lot of them clustered on the Palatine Hill.
To this very day,
jockeying for a house in the best neighborhood,
this is a tale as old as time.
This is what was going on on the Palatine Hill.
You wanted to be in a good house, in a bigger house.
Amongst the other people
who were thinking and making decisions.
