ANOTHER PERFECT 10/10 SWORD?! - real Witcher 3 SWORD review

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
2 Video Views·Apr 18, 2026
This NEW battle ready WITCHER silver sword from SWORDIER is actually perfect!
The Witcher Sword.
Yes, a real, sharp, battle-ready Witcher Sword replica from Swordia.
And this thing is actually incredible.
The weight balance is amazing.
The fit and finish shocked us.
For a video game replica sword, this is easily as real and functional
as any historical replica that you can buy on the market.
And we cannot wait to really put it to the test.
We are going to test its durability, how well it cuts in this review.
But from initial inspection, oh boy, this sword is brilliant.
Greetings, I am Tyrant.
And I'm Shad.
And today we're taking a look at another, I would say,
pop culture replica, battle-ready replica from Swordia.
Yes, I was going to say, like, is it right to just call these a replica?
But battle-ready replica, that kind of, you know, describes what it is.
But...
Because they're real swords in every single capacity, except they look...
Like, the inspiration and the design has obviously come from
pop cultural games or whatever the subject matter is.
But we should mention, like, having...
When I say battle-ready, I'm talking about...
It's not just sharp, made out of strong steel.
Its refinement and balance is specifically designed to be a functional sword.
Yes, it's a real sword.
And I have not seen replicas like this ever before really Swordia started doing it.
Like, as functional as this.
I think there are a couple.
Except if they were custom-made.
I saw some custom-made ones.
This is sharp.
Yeah, it's sharp.
Mine wasn't.
Sucks to be you!
So this one here is obviously the Witch's Silver Sword.
Now, it's not exact one-to-one.
I thought the other one was the silver one.
No, this is the silver one.
I get it mixed up.
There's a little bit of context here because obviously in the game...
Now, I'm not the biggest...
So much caveats here.
In the Witcher games, you can, like, change...
Upgrade the sword and do different...
This is, like, the base common, you know...
So this is, like, I would consider to be their simplistic interpretation of the Witcher sword.
Obviously, you have that very, very unique...
Distinctive.
Crossguard, which I love.
Super into.
So...
Hang on, pause, pause.
Because I had...
I suspected Tyrant liked this one more than me because...
It's on Titan's Bane.
I actually am not a fan of this style of crossguard.
It sweeps up too much for me.
It's a little bit aggressive, but that's why I put it on Titan's Bane.
And I don't necessarily have it on my regular sword.
I'm not going to let that affect my score rating because that's personal preference.
Well, not only...
It's functional.
Like, it is functional.
There's nothing about it except personal preference.
But I'm still not a fan of it.
Whatever.
I like the other Witcher sword.
Sure, okay.
That's fine.
That one's really nice in terms of aesthetic design.
This one here comes in at around about $410.
All right, so that is a bit more expensive than their other battle-ready replicas.
Yes and no.
Because they do have a couple of replicas.
Like, they have the Bullhorn Orcrist, which is like $600.
So they do have some more expensive ones.
But this is kind of one of the more pricier ones.
Which I think is justified because...
Obviously, we'll be throwing up the b-roll.
The wrap and the finishing and kind of like the overall quality of this one
is higher than the Glamdring, the Anduril.
Honestly, this is probably the best quality battle-ready replica
SWATI has made so far that we have received and reviewed.
And we've looked at Glamdring, Anduril, Lord of the Rings ones.
Was there any other Non-Lord of the Rings ones that we've looked at?
I don't think so.
Okay, well, this is the first Non-Lord of the Rings one.
But dang, dang.
Like, when Torreth is mentioning how tight and precise this wrap is,
it's flawless.
It is flawless.
And that's hard to pull off with this central metal riser right here.
But it is solid, it is connected, it is strong.
And then, like, the pattern design on the pommel,
that's inserted and sometimes that's hard to pull off.
I think that's just cast.
Yeah, like...
The reason why we bring this up is because, obviously,
there was nothing wrong with any of them except for maybe the Anduril.
A couple issues with that.
But in terms of the fit and finish of a lot of the other replicas,
they have not been bad at all.
It's just this one is a lot more refined.
Like, there were some areas...
I know we haven't really taken a look at the Dark Sister yet,
but the Dark Sister has, like,
a bunch of sharp burrs that are annoying as hell.
Stuff like that, where it's, like, little finishing issues.
That's why I was getting confused.
Because we have received House of the Dragon,
but we haven't reviewed it yet.
This one, they finished it perfectly fine.
It doesn't have the plastic handle.
It has, you know, a leather stitched handle.
The riser is good.
Transitions to the pommel.
With a texture, actually, put into the leather.
And then the blade itself.
Like, they've done really well.
And not only that, then we come to the weight.
This is, like, I could easily use this one hand.
Big long sword like this.
And then when you get it in two, it's like,
what the heck is going on?
Because, like, we have had several swords very recently
that when we've just picked it up,
the weight balance has just been perfect.
And that has usually been one of the hardest things
that swords have, you know, tried to execute properly
throughout the history of sword, you know,
you know, selling market manufacturing.
Well, I would even directly compare it
to one of their other long swords.
Like, look at the pommel, man.
That's good.
It's because it has, it has a nice-
What is going on?
It has somewhat of a distal taper.
It's not a huge one.
Somewhat of a distal taper and a beautiful profile taper.
Like, half sorting with this is just gorgeous.
Oh my gosh.
Like, it's slender.
It's fine.
So, this one here, I think is like a,
and the funny thing is, I'm not even the biggest Witcher fan,
but this sword is just like a legit, really good replica sword.
Honestly, like-
Battle-ready replicas.
If you, if you didn't even care about the Witcher
and you wanted a top-tier,
maneuverable, functional, well-executed, built sword,
this is amongst the top that you could pick from,
separate from it being a pop culture replica,
which is wild to me.
Yeah.
Let's cut with it.
I can't wait.
Because they are nice and sharp.
And in case you're wondering,
yes, we do have an affiliate link to this sword
and all other swordier swords in the description below.
Let's get to cut.
I can't wait.
So, we're actually reviewing multiple swords today
and I've just moved from one of the other ones,
which was a brilliant sword.
But going from that weight to this,
this, damn.
It's so good.
This one, this just steps it up again.
Like, I can use, like, look at this.
Ready? First cut.
I didn't put a lot of weight over.
I'll be, uh, like,
you shouldn't be able to do it that easy with this one.
But, oh, interesting.
Okay. There was a bit of filleting on that.
So let me, um, let me just go.
You know, I mean, it is good.
The weight is better,
but it's not cutting better than the last one.
Yeah, I think it's the profile that they put on it.
So with this type of blade geometry,
they are, I mean, it's more of a thrust-centric blade
than a slash-centric blade, right?
This is something that I would half sword with
to get through armor.
Gorgeous tip on it.
It has that nice diamond cross section.
But that also means that in cut,
it's not necessarily going to be the best slicer.
Yeah.
But, I mean, it's cutting, it's cutting very well.
Not the best, but very, very well.
There's no hope for this one.
I'll try it.
Hardest cut.
Reverse edge.
Horizontal.
Just straight.
So like on angle, that's fine.
But flat horizontal.
Didn't even dig in.
I mean, if you didn't do it with the other sword,
you're not gonna be able to do it.
I know, this one.
But in terms of reverse edge angular.
Yeah.
I love seeing the medieval aesthetic and weapons
adapted into fantasy, especially video games.
And there is a more recent video game
with some surprisingly decent looking weapons and armor.
And that is Crimson Desert.
Just dive into it myself and play.
But how good are some of these kind of medieval elements
that they are adding into?
Well, Tyranth and I take a look at that
in this week's exclusive video.
Looking for and reacting to some of the more accurate
medieval things that appear,
whether it be castles, swords, weapons, armor,
shields.
And also looking at some of the fantasy things that appear.
It's a lot of fun.
And you get access to this exclusive video
for just $1 a month.
Like really, that's only $12 in a year.
And you might think it's not much,
but that is what is saving us.
So please do help out if you can.
$1 through Patreon, Subscribestar or channel memberships
saves this channel, helps us keep going.
And thank you to everyone who is supporting us.
So now let's get back to the main video.
I twisted on that one.
That was me.
I go down and come in.
There we go.
Out of 10 for cutting?
Seven.
Okay, I'll make it more interesting.
Out of 10 for handling?
10.
Yeah.
Yeah, it's interesting.
10 out of 10 handling, 7 out of 10 cutting.
But I think it's important, like I mentioned before,
what this blade, what I would use this blade for.
Don't get me wrong, cutting with it is great and all,
but getting in with armor for this is...
See, this side is a little bit blunt now
because Shad's been cutting with it.
So I'm going to go over to this side.
Excuses.
Oh, there's just no way.
You can tell by how it sounds.
Yeah.
It sounds like hitting a pillow.
Yeah, we haven't done it with any of your swords.
I reckon we're going to be able to do it with the Tachi.
That's why I think it's going to be interesting.
That sword has a ring, a really nice ring.
Yeah, it's good.
It's not bad at all.
I mean, it's one of the top tier swords we've actually reviewed
and it's a pop culture replica.
Yeah.
What is going on?
Testing the flex on the Witcher blade.
See, it's a lot more flexible.
But again, not in a bad way.
This isn't like the Anduril.
The Anduril was ridiculous.
This is well within tolerance.
It's just a little bit more flexy than some of our other swords.
Yeah.
All right, against the wood.
How was it?
Similar.
Similar, really?
It wasn't as bad though.
This is starting to be a bit of a feature with swordier swords.
A lot of swordier swords aren't the nicest with vibration.
Yeah, and I think it is a direct trade-off
when you have such a nice refined handle.
It's kind of what you get.
Their handles are usually a bit thinner because they're 3D printed.
Which I like.
I like that too.
I like that a lot.
But the trade-off is that, hang on, there's one cut.
Yeah, yeah.
I mean, it's not worse, but it wasn't nice.
But again, the handle on this one, super refined.
Yeah.
So that's a trade-off that I'm definitely willing to take.
This is tricky, right?
I'm becoming less, I'm becoming more reluctant to,
I guess, downgrade sword ratings based on the vibration in this test.
Well, this test here is the most brutal kind of test you can do for this.
Yeah.
This isn't like a tree.
Cutting a tree isn't much nicer.
This is terrible.
This is dried out wood.
And the main test this is, is to test durability of the tang, the hilt.
We're not seeing any loosening.
The fact that it was uncomfortable,
I mean, you're rarely ever going to hit that type of abuse in normal sword use.
Usually the most comfortable swords on this sort of test
have been like the big, thick, wide arming swords.
And I think it's because the blades take a lot of that.
With these more refined gelatins, that's kind of what you get.
You're right.
Shorter blades handle vibration a lot better.
And maybe it's just because the length of vibration needs to travel is different
and just very different dynamics overall.
And I think some of the blades that do have more refined geometries
that have done well in this test have been ones that have bent at the tang.
Interesting.
So these aren't bending.
No, they're solid as hell.
Hang on, hang on.
No, don't do that to that crossguard.
That's a cool crossguard.
How can you tell though?
I know, right?
Actually, is that?
I think a little bit, yeah.
Yeah, look, let's make it even.
See, there we go.
Why are you reluctant about this one and not the other one?
Because it's a cool crossguard.
You know what I want to do?
Oh, disgusting.
All right, let's do it.
Let's smash it.
Steel time.
Witcher blade.
Oh.
That did not feel as bad.
Yeah.
Either of those.
Like, and it bent less.
And it did bloody barely any edge deformation.
Wow.
That is, that's some of the best we've got from Sordia.
That's rather impressive.
That is, they've upped their game.
Okay, interesting.
That is, that is top tier durability.
It is.
That is, that is up there with the very best.
Okay, this sword really impressed me.
Yeah.
Like, I like it better after having reviewed it than from going into it.
And I already had a pretty positive opinion of it.
Well, see, the thing is, right?
I'm not like the biggest fan of the Witcher games and stuff.
So the sword is not necessarily my favorite.
But it's just a damn good sword.
Just in general.
Separating it from the Witcher, this is one of the nicest handling swords we have reviewed.
Yeah, it feels good in the hand.
The edge and geometry, like for cutting, isn't the best in the world.
But it's a trade-off for the thrusting ability and its balance.
So that's not a flaw in design.
We're not going to mark it down for that.
It was still really, really good at cutting.
And look at this, look at this profile taper and point.
And it was damn tough.
Yeah.
Some of the best durability we've seen.
Which, my gosh, Tyrone, this puts this sword in the realm of a 10 out of 10 sword.
Yeah, I mean, like, I have, there's no edge damage.
Like, look at that.
Like, that's still kind of sharp.
Yeah, like, there's basically no damage from that.
That is, that is remarkable.
And it's a video game replica.
Like, it was a little uncomfortable in the vibration.
But I don't think that's a flaw of the design.
Are you done with it?
Have you straightened it again?
Yes.
You're bending it really.
And I'm like...
Well, because it's spring steel.
It's springy.
But look.
It's usable again.
Mostly fine.
Apart from the cross guard.
I still don't like a cross guard, but I can't mark it down because it's smooth.
It's well executed.
I think this is 10 out of 10.
Yes.
It is our second 10 out of 10 sword, man.
Swordia, what are you doing?
And I think it speaks volumes that, like we said a couple of times,
I'm not necessarily the biggest fan of, like, you know, the frame.
It's not like I'm like a super fanboy where I'm like, no, no.
It's a witcher, so it has to be 10.
I was like, no, I just think it's a really well executed sword.
Yeah, pretend I never saw The Witcher, didn't know where it was from,
and I was sent as a sword for review.
I'd be like, that's an interesting cross guard, but damn, it's a good sword.
Edge held up perfectly fine.
The warp I just quickly fixed because it actually wasn't that bad to begin with.
Hardened cross guards.
I want them.
They're something that I'm starting to get.
Look at the peen block.
It's really nice.
That is a gorgeous peen block.
The fit and finish hasn't started rattling.
The tapering of the handle and everything is just so good.
It's flawless.
I think this is a really solid just sword.
10 out of 10 for a video game pop culture replica battle ready sword.
I can't believe that.
I mean, it shows that swordier.
Actually, they're trying to improve their quality,
even with everything that they're making.
So we've reviewed a lot of their Lord of the Rings swords.
They recalled all of them to retest and recall them.
I mean, they pulled them from the website so that they could work on the new ones.
People weren't buying the old versions and now they've put up the new versions.
Now I want the new versions because if they're pulling something like this out of the hat.
Yeah.
Damn!
Well, yeah, if this is your jam, go for it.
It's good.
I mean, it's a touch more expensive than some of their other ones.
It is, it is.
Like 410.
But for a 10 out of 10 sword like this.
They upped the quality.
They really did.
Guys, if you want to see the only other 10 out of 10 sword we've ever reviewed,
link right there.
The fact that we got another 10 out of 10 so recently
is just making me thrilled for what we can get nowadays.
One thing that I want to bring up is when we got these, we got sent a couple, right?
The quality between them all is also almost identical to every single one.
Because some swords we have gotten like a bit of variance in it.
So much so Shad's like, I want this one.
And I go, I want this one.
This one is like.
Between the two.
They're all the same.
Like you can't tell the difference.
Yeah.
So I like that as well.
So guys, big recommendation.
We have an affiliate link for this sword if you're interested in it.
Which, uh, you know, sword.
Is it a silver sword?
I can't remember.
But it's really awesome, this sword.
And if you want to check out our other 10 out of 10 review.
Right there.
Appreciate you guys.
Have a good one.
Cheers.
