Swords of 1066 with @scholagladiatoria

Ancient Edge
3 followers
1 Video View·Dec 4, 2025
Hello everyone, my name is Zach and welcome to my channel. I am here with Matt.
Hi guys.
Who you may recognize from a little channel that's just recently hit, was it 500,000?
Yeah, yeah, that was fun.
Yeah, so congratulations on that.
Thank you.
Yeah, I've come over to Matt's because I've got some questions.
Okay.
And I've been researching 11th century arms and armor.
Battle of Hastings.
Yeah, I have a pretty good grasp, I think, of the armor of the 11th century.
But I wanted to come to you to ask what exactly is going on with the swords in the 11th century?
Because, you know, you look online, most of the stuff that comes up,
shops trying to sell you, you know, William the Conqueror's sword and things like that.
It's hard to know what's right and what's not.
Yeah, so it's an interesting period, the 11th century.
So to put it into context, so we're coming out of what would commonly be described as
the Viking era, I guess.
And when most people think of the Viking era, they think of swords that look like that,
don't they?
With quite projecting pommels, with quite short cross guards.
The blades, we'll talk about the blades in a minute,
this would be an oak shot type 10.
But if we just focus on the hilt for a second, so fundamentally a short guard, and very often
the guard doesn't really project any further than the pommel, although the pommel projects
quite far in this period.
Now, when we get into the 10th century, there is a tendency to get slightly longer guards.
This isn't universal, there are also still short guards around, but there is a tendency
in some places in the 10th century, so the 900s, for guards to get a little bit longer,
and for pommels to start to diversify in forms.
If you look at the outline of that kind of pommel there, so this is an English style,
probably Anglo-Saxon style sword, that type of pommel starts to turn into what's sometimes
described as a tea cozy shape, okay?
So if you imagine a teapot with a tea cozy on the top of it.
And this actually, if you look at the overall outline of it, is not far away from being
what we call a Brazil nut pommel.
And we find later swords with Brazil nut pommels, and actually the outline of this pommel shape
ergonomically is actually quite similar, okay?
And it tilts away from the hand.
Now that's a really interesting thing because with earlier Viking era swords, they tend
to be straighter across the bottom here.
If we go all the way back into the migration era, then a lot of the, well, a lot of the
Viking era swords, but a lot of the earlier migration era swords are literally just a
straight bar across there.
Now it's not to say, again, it's not to say the straight bar type have disappeared yet,
they haven't.
It's just that we're starting to get pommels which curve away from the hand, and guards
which sometimes curve away from the hand, like that Anglo-Saxon design, but also are
starting to get longer.
So we end up around about 1000 AD with swords that start to have much longer cross guards
on them, and a few new types of pommel.
This is a little bit later, this kind of more classic Brazil nut pommel.
They are around in the 11th century, but what we tend to get is one that's a little bit
more, what I describe it as a blob.
So it's not a wheel pommel yet, I think a lot of people think it's a wheel.
If we look at the Bay of Tapestry, for example, you wouldn't really call that a wheel pommel,
and it's not as Brazil nut-like as this yet, it's a little bit more nondescript and blob
shaped.
But the really, really big development is this length of cross guard, and the question
is, why?
Why these long cross guards?
Yeah, so the handles on all of those I'm looking at are all very short as well.
Yeah, although there is a general tendency for them to get a bit longer, so this one
here is actually precisely modeled on one in the Museum of Ireland in Dublin, and this
is a sort of 800, so 9th century style hilt.
And very often Viking era hilts are under about 9.5 centimeters, so just the handle,
so we're just talking about between the guard and the pommel.
They're usually under, not always, some are bigger, but most of them are under 9.5 centimeters,
and they can be as small as like 7.5 centimeters, really, really cramped and small, but that's
partly because of the way you hold them.
There is a general tendency as we get into the 11th century and the new types of pommel
and cross guard for the grip to get a little bit longer, but not much, it is still quite
short.
So the change in the Brazil nut, I was wondering if that's because the handle is smaller,
and so that...
No, the handles, if anything, get slightly longer.
So that, okay, so that's blown my idea out of the water.
So what's going on then?
What's driving this change?
So look, if we pick up a standard textbook on this subject, most people would marry this
development of this type of sword with a long guard, with a pommel, which it's easier
to, or as some people would say, it's easier to extend out like this.
They would link it in with cavalry and horses.
However, I completely refute that for several reasons, but here's just two reasons I'll
give you straight off the bat.
One is these long cross guards actually start to appear in Scandinavia quite early on, and
they weren't famous for using cavalry.
Firstly.
Secondly, if we go to France or Francia, they'd been using cavalry for hundreds of years.
You know, Charlemagne had huge amounts of cavalry.
It wasn't like cavalry was a new invention, and they'd been using Frankish style swords
like that.
So it doesn't make sense to me.
No, that completely doesn't figure with me that cavalry requires longer cross guard or
more shaped pommel.
So, you know, where I've landed up with this, and I've covered this in a few videos on my
channel, is I think it's actually, it's probably connected to lots of things, but I think it's
partially connected to shields.
Okay.
And one thing that definitely does happen at this time is the move from the center gripped
boss grip shield.
Yeah.
Pardon my cold.
To the strapped shields as seen on the bare tapestry.
Yeah.
Now, why do I say that?
I'm certainly not the first person or certainly won't be the last person to say that.
If you have a strapped shield and you're striking with a sword, your hand is more likely to
go beyond the range of the shield than what your shield is protecting.
So your hand is more exposed and more vulnerable with a boss grip shield, which are fantastic
on foot.
They're not so good on horseback, of course, because you can't move the hand around much
because you're holding reins in the left hand.
It projects far further out.
So when you strike with a sword, your hand is behind the shield.
So I personally think that as people start to switch from boss grip shields to strap
shields, that is when a cross guard starts to become more practical.
And there's a possible ancient world parallel to this.
If we look at the Greeks, so in most of the ancient world, there are no hand guards on
swords.
A sword is just for stabbing and hitting.
You don't really think that much about protecting your hand.
But in most of the ancient world, most people have boss grip shields.
Yeah.
The Greeks, however, have essentially a strap shield because they've got one bit around
the forearm here and they're holding that hand at the front edge of the shield, which
means when they strike with their Xiphos, the hands more likely to project beyond the
edge of the shield.
And lo and behold, they have swords with cross guards on them.
Okay.
So that's, you know, I don't know if I'm correct, but that's what I think.
That certainly makes sense.
Yeah.
So on the Bay of Tapestry, we see most of the people there do have the kite shields,
whether they're Saxon or Norman.
But we do see some Saxons with Frankish style conical boss grip shields.
And there's an interesting thing as well.
You know, we don't have all of the Bay of Tapestry.
And towards the end of the tapestry, there's a scene when the Saxons start to basically
rout and get mopped up by the Norman forces.
And as we get to the end of it, we see more and more of these, I think because they're
trying to show a mass of Saxons.
So categorically, and you never, ever see these in the hands of Normans.
No.
The Normans always have the kite shield.
And of course, bear in mind that Edward the Confessor was, for all intents and purposes,
a Norman.
So there had already been an injection of Norman culture into England by this point.
So clearly kite shields have become popular.
And we know that kite shields were used in Scandinavia as well.
So kite shields had started to come in, but clearly a lot of Saxons still were using their
own boss grip shields as well, I think.
And archaeologically, we've got remains of the bosses.
So does this suggest that while the Norman knights would most likely be wielding a sword
similar to this, we might see swords like those being used by the Saxons?
Yeah, so the problem with using bear tapestry as a source, and it is a fantastic source,
and we don't have many sources from the 11th century, so we have to use bear tapestry.
Some people are really critical of it, but it's like, well...
What else do we use?
Exactly, we've only got like 20 sources, so clearly we're going to use bear tapestry.
But one of the problems with it is the artists making it, probably English women, as far
as we know, they clearly decide what an armour, what a helmet, what a sword, what an axe,
what a horse is going to look like, and a bit like Lego elements, and then they just
reproduce that over and over and over again.
So pretty much all of the swords in the tapestry look the same.
They've got a more or less long cross guard, and they've got a blob-type pommel, and they're
all one-handed arming swords, as all swords are at this time.
However, I feel pretty certain saying that a lot of the English who would have fought
at Stamford Bridge or Hastings absolutely would have been using traditional Anglo-Saxon
swords that they happen to have.
It might have been their grandfather's sword or their father's sword.
It could have been their great-great-great-great-grandfather's sword.
We don't know.
I mean, we've got things like the Coppergate helmet, which is clearly from the 700s, but
it's buried probably in the 800s, so some of these things would have stayed around in
use, and swords weren't that prevalent in 11th century England, so if a sword was still
usable, you'd use it.
So absolutely, I think there would have been 9th, 10th century swords still in use, and
probably in a place like England, which was...
I wouldn't quite call it a backwater.
It was one of the principal kingdoms of Europe, but...
We've always been quite conservative.
Yeah, and also, until the Norman conquest, it was looking to Scandinavia.
Harold Godwinson's mother was Danish, and you'd had Cnut and his family ruling over
England, so you still got houseguards with big two-handed Danish axes.
So we were more like a Scandinavian kingdom at that point, and in Scandinavia, going all
the way through the 11th century, we've still got these sorts of Viking-era-looking swords
still being used.
Okay.
Well, so, for me, I'm looking at something Norman, so it's likely I'm going to need to
be looking for something like this then.
Yeah.
And...
Yeah, with the Brazil nuts, because we know the Brazil nuts were in use in the 11th century.
In my opinion, they tend to be a bit more late 11th century.
At Hastings, I think you're more likely to see more of a blob-type pommel.
Okay.
To be honest, they're quite boring-looking swords, actually.
They're kind of the first arming sword, as we'd call it from a later medieval point of
view.
It's a generic straight crossguard and a blob for a pommel.
And from this one, different to the Viking-style one...
You'll prefer how that one handles, incidentally.
The one that you've got is quite a beast.
This one is much more nimble.
Okay, so we have differences in the blade weight.
So just for the viewer who obviously hasn't just felt what I've just felt, a lot of the
weight in this sword is down at the tip to make it cut better.
This particular one is a beast.
This one's actually made by Paul Binns.
That one's actually a windlass.
But it just so happens that Paul Binns had made this really big blade and I asked him
to mount it up on a Norman-era hilt.
This would be good from horseback for just a massive great cleaving blows, but I absolutely
wouldn't want to use this on foot with a shield one-on-one in a duel-type situation.
I'd definitely choose the lighter, quicker one.
Yeah, so this one, the tip of the blade is a lot faster and a lot more maneuverable.
Yeah, and there's another thing which also I said about blades.
So in the migration era, so after the Romans bugger off basically, in most of Germanic
Europe, we've got what we would call the type 10, oak-shot type 10 blade, which is almost
parallel-edged, very broad, quite spatulate-tipped, okay?
This in the, yeah, 10th, maybe late 9th, 10th century, we start to get blades.
This isn't a great example, but you see it's starting to get a bit of taper on it.
And in fact, there are more tapered examples than this.
So already in the late Viking era, well before the Normans turn up, you've got blades which
have a taper down the blade, which obviously changes the weight mass distribution of them.
And by the 11th century, most swords are tapered.
They are broader here than there, and they're even thinner down here.
So they're starting to get more pointy, which might be an adaptation to the fact that more
people have got mail, because we know definitely in the 11th century, as we can see in the
Bayeux Tapestry, most soldiers have corvettes of mail.
Whereas if you go back to King Alfred the Great's time, probably most didn't have mail.
So there was a lot more armor around.
So the point starts to become more and more important.
And having a longer blade, particularly if you're on horseback, seems to have become
more important.
So generally the average length of the blades in the 11th century becomes greater.
And if you have a longer blade to keep it wieldable, you want to make it tapered so
that it won't be too unwieldy.
Because if you, if you, this is, and this is the-
Yeah.
So this, the reason this is such a beast to handle is because it is a long blade, but
it is also very broad at the tip.
Whereas this one is much more tapered and therefore much more wieldable as a result.
So yeah, this is, this is a bit later still.
This is, this is more sort of late 12th, 13th century, but it's the same principle as the
Norman era swords.
Okay.
Very cool.
So yeah.
Thank you very much, Matt.
My pleasure.
Quick rundown.
Thank you guys for watching.
Thank you to my patrons over on Patreon.
You've got one as well, don't you, Matt?
I do.
Yeah, yeah.
I love my patrons.
They're very important.
Check the links in the description, guys.
And hopefully we'll see you again soon.
Bye-bye.
