Scars, Repairs, and Markings - 17th Century Walloon-Hilt Sword Review

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 27, 2026
After reviewing several unusual and unique examples like the Amsterdam City Guard and Dutch East India Company swords, it's finally time to look at the stereotypical Walloon-Hilted sword!
AI Generated·May contain errors
So over the course of time we've seen quite a few Wolloon Hilted Swords on this channel,
and that's four to be precise. We've done comparison videos, we've seen them individually
described and shown in detail, and we've also speculated a little on some of the
more weird ones. Ironically enough though, none of the deep dives I've done on specific
examples of Wolloon Hilted Swords are actually of the stereotypical Wolloon Hilted Sword.
We've seen the Amsterdam City Guard Sword, we've seen the Dutch East India Company Sword,
we've seen the mini version of a Wolloon Hilted Sword, some have cross hilts which are unusual,
some don't have the guard that's complete in the typical sense, some have a monoblock kind of hilt
without the applied shells. I just realized I've kept delaying showing the actual one Wolloon
Hilted Sword I have, which is the stereotypical one. So here we go, today we're kind of filling
that gap when we're looking at the Wolloon Hilted Sword. So what are we talking about,
or what am I talking about at least, when we talk about Wolloon Hilted Sword? And I say that
because Wolloon Hilted Sword isn't really a pure typology, there's even debate on whether they
should be called Wolloon Hilted Sword at all. So what do I intend when we talk about it is a
sword that is exactly like this. This one has all of the qualities and characteristics I would
consider typical of a Wolloon Hilted Sword and lacks none of them. It has some defects to it,
it's not a perfect sword, but it has everything. So let's start by looking at what they have. Well,
let's start with the blade. The blade for me is a straight, double-edged, rather broad blade.
You could imagine it something similar, I would say it's similar in many ways to me to what I
would imagine on a Schiavona. So a sword that has a lot of authority, a sword that is not meant for
nimble fencing or being a virtuoso of the art, but is meant for really kind of cleaving through
a bunch of enemies or stabbing them too perhaps, but in a very battle-like way more than a fancy
approach. Furthermore, when I think of a stereotypical Wolloon Hilted blade, I also think of something
with a rather short fuller towards the forte of the sword, usually with a lenticular section
and often marked with Solingen marks and Passau wolves, but the marks can come in all kinds of
shapes and sizes and varieties. When I think of a Wolloon Hilt on the other side, for me the
stereotype is defined by a guard that is made out of two kidney-shaped or shell-shaped plates,
which are often embedded onto a frame of the guard, and they are then connected through a knucklebow
to a pommel. To add protection to this guard, another characteristic that I think is defining
of the Wolloon Hilt are the side bars that protect the outside of the hand here, and then a shorter
one here you'll see that protects the inside of the hand. These bars are often connected by extra
cross bars that kind of lead them to connect to the central knucklebow. In many cases, you'll also
find a thumb ring. These are definitely, for me, defining characteristics. Another defining
characteristic is the rounded pommel. The pommel can be more spherical, more ovoidal. That's not
an issue, but it's always rounded. For me, this is the Wolloon Hilted sword. That's just to say
anything different moves away from the standard. So, for instance, you will find Wolloon Hilted
swords that don't have the screws, but they have kind of a slot in which the guard sits. You'll
have Wolloon Hilted swords that are without the thumb ring. You'll find Wolloon Hilted swords that
have more or less bars. You'll find some versions in which the shells here are integral to the guard.
You'll find some versions that have different kinds of piercings. You'll find versions that
aren't pierced at all. You'll also find curved blades. You'll find longer ones, shorter ones,
stouter ones, and more narrow ones. In terms of pommels, you'll even see differences. You'll often
see swords of this kind with a lion or bear head. That's typical, for example, of Swiss swords.
And none of these characteristics make these other swords non-Wolloon Hilted swords. For me,
they all fall squarely in the definition. But this, for me, is the stereotypical version of it,
from which deviations will pop up to my interest or to my eye when I see them. So don't get mad
at me if you have the feeling that I'm discounting some version of a Wolloon Hilted sword that's
important for you. As non-Wolloon Hilted, that is not the case. It's just not necessarily matching
my standard. And on the issue of standards, I also want to mention one thing. None of this is
written in stone, and none of this is absolute. For me, it's important to have a standard version
of this kind of sword, because there are so many different typologies, that having a standard helps
me notice the deviations. For you, the standard may not be necessary, or it may be different.
That's fine. As long as there's no expectation of our ideas being true for everyone, then I think
we can usually kind of move forward in it. Now that we've described our benchmark Wolloon Hilt
qualities, I think it's time to look at this one close up. If you're interested in the measurements
of this specific sword, you'll find it all in the video where I compare the four different Wolloon
swords I own. So let's start taking a look at this one close up, because we haven't yet. You'll see
here it has these two asymmetrical, again I mentioned, like kidney shape or shell in some case.
Sometimes you'll have decorations on them, sometimes they won't be pierced. But in the vast
majority of cases, they're pierced. And they're often pierced in this very kind of crude way, I
not too far away from each other. It's not like some fancy openwork like you would see on some
rapiers, for example. And this is due to the fact that these swords tend to be military swords.
They're meant for like heavy use, and they're not rich in unique features that you may find instead
on swords that are more meant as fashion statements or status symbols. In fact, probably a proper name
for this sword would actually be a field sword or a campaign sword. These are the names that you
often find in other languages. For instance, in German, it would be Feldwegen, to refer to this
kind of sword. Looking at the bars, we see a rather stout and strong construction. There's
some decoration, as you can see here. One typical theme, decorative theme on these kinds of swords
is this kind of enlargement at the center of a bar, where it seems like the two halves of the
bar are almost two separate pieces that unite at the center here. So this is especially common,
as far as I know, on earlier versions of this kind of sword. So imagine we're talking about
the 17th century, so an earlier part of the 17th century rather than more towards the 18th century,
but of course, with many things sword-related, you can't hold these kinds of distinctions to
this specific year. It's just a general trend. We'll also notice the thumb ring here. You'll
see that it's quite comfortable, but also that it's generally comfortable for the unarmored
thumb. If I already had a very thick glove, it would fit, but my thumb rests comfortably here
without a glove, let's say. So it could probably fit a light glove, but I'm not sure how much more.
You'll see that the bar configuration, you probably already saw it in the intro section,
we have the outside protective bar here, we have the knuckle guard, and we have this inside
protective bar. You'll also notice that the inside one is shorter, kind of connects directly to the
knuckle bar here, whereas the outer bar here connects into the pommel, and then has this
separate section that blends into here the knuckle guard. This is a very typical style of guard for
a wooden hilted sword, of course. And since we're talking about connection to the pommel, you'll
notice that you have two connecting points. One is the knuckle guard that comes here at the center
of the pommel, and one is the outside hand guard. In this case, you'll notice that the sword is not
in the best shape at the moment. One screw is completely missing, and in fact, I'm not sure
it comes through on video, but it seems like the inside is stripped off. So I wonder if someone
tried to pull this out and just kind of stripped the thread out. And you'll see that here the screw
isn't a screw anymore, it's kind of a rivet almost. It's a nail head or screw head that's
been flattened over, so this can't really move away anymore. In any case, even though you have
screws holding the hilt assembly together, all of these swords are beamed. So it's not that the screws
make for easy disassembly or anything, I just think they're made for quick assembly when being
produced. It was easier to screw parts in place rather than to have to weld them in place
or kind of connect them with wedges or stuff like that. You'll notice that the pin on this sword
seems to be rather shiny. So to me, this kind of differential aging between the pommel and the
pin points to it perhaps being a composite. I would not be surprised at all. However, you'll
also notice that the sword itself in many sections has undergone... well, let's say the
the aging is not overall uniform, and we'll see that especially on the blade as well. So it's hard
to kind of draw absolute conclusions from this. It could be a composite, it could be that it was
reworked and remanaged from original pieces of the one sword, it could be that it's just original but
it's been cleaned out in this section here around the pin, and as you can see in other areas as
well. However, if I were to venture a guess, I would definitely say that I think someone reworked
it at some point, because you'll see that this pommel, for example, doesn't sit perfectly straight
on the grip. So you'll see that the edges here, this one is really flush with the grip here,
whereas on this side it kind of pops out. Of course, it could be that the tang was bent at some point,
but to me this feels like a sloppy reassembly. That's, of course, not to say that any of the parts
is inconsistent with the rest. It could be a sloppy reassembly of original parts. What we do
see for sure, though, is that the grip has been reworked. This kind of coarse wire binding is
usually typical of rewired grips. It's not what you would... even on munitions grade, so to speak,
swords of the time, the wire binding would be a little more refined, in my experience. You also
see there's a lack of Turks head knots, and you instead have these ferrules. This is also rather
unusual. You would normally see, or at least in all of the versions I've seen, you normally have
Turks head knot as a closing device to kind of seal the grip section here. Also, you'll see that
these ferrules here are made out of what looks like brass, which is, I think, unusual, because the rest
of the blade is iron and steel, so this is the only brass component. However, unusual and composite as
it may be, this sword still has some interesting things to tell us. For example, there's an
inscription on the pommel here, so it seems to be an L, and inside the L there seems to be an O, for example,
or a zero. I don't know what these mean, of course. These could be the initials of the owner, they could
be some kind of inventory mark or regimental mark, like some almost anteliterum regimental marking,
I'm not sure, so who knows? Maybe in the future, this little writing here will be able to tell us
something more about the sword. You'll also see that there's a lot of weird coloring to it.
It seems like there's some yellowish sheen, sometimes it's shiny, sometimes it's more dull, and that's
because at some point in time, this specific sword was varnished. This was a common practice
among collectors some time ago. It's definitely fallen out of fashion. I don't know of any modern
collector that would slather their sword and varnish like this. It does often help to preserve the
sword really well, but it also creates a rather ugly visual effect, and there's also the risk, of course,
that if there's rust or humidity under the varnish, it keeps eating into the metal under that
protective coating, so it's definitely not a method I would recommend, but it's something you do see a
lot in older collections once they go for sale. You'll also see, speaking of treatment of the metal,
perhaps by well-meaning but not well-practicing people, you'll see that the guard here seems to
have been polished in a bit of a rough way, so I'm not going to go as far as to say that there was
power tools applied here, but we're as close as we can get, I think, without having grind marks.
What's interesting, though, is that it's been done in a bit of a lazy way, I think, so
while a lot of the aging has been removed, you still see it in a lot of sections.
It almost feels to me like someone just wiped and cleaned really roughly and then got tired before
addressing the small detail areas, and that's a good thing, of course, because this sword, while
wonky and not perfect, has still been able to preserve part of its historical character, I would
say. Speaking of which, I think one interesting thing to look at is the underside here of the guard,
where you actually see kind of the hammer marks, and I hope they come through on video, but it's really
rough and uneven as a surface. It's definitely something you wouldn't see in modern manufacturing,
where a plate would be perfectly smooth, but this is definitely not the case here,
and it actually feels like these bumps and things are due to the
punching, because if I feel almost at every punch hole, there's like a dip, and this actually also
tells me that the punching direction of the plate was from the inside out, at least on this sword,
because here you feel the bends on the underside, you feel like the dips in the metal,
whereas on the outside it's been smoothed out, so obviously you would have paid a little more
attention to the outer section of the guard rather than the inside. In any case, it's smooth, so
there's no like burrs or edges that would hurt during use. We'll also see it has this quill in
that unfortunately is a little bit crooked. It's seen better days, but it's still there, so that's
a good sign. Sometimes swords lack their quill and if it's been hit. One other interesting thing
I think we can look at when we're looking at the plate, here's how thin it actually is. You'll see
that here it's inserted into a groove in this frame, but then here on this point, you can
actually see it in its full width, which is not much, so these would have not held a full-on
thrust. In fact, in many cases, you see these swords are damaged, you have the guards that have
been pierced or like broken through, and in many cases the guard itself just is missing because
they would have fallen off or come off at some point in time. So this is, as far as the guard,
the things I wanted to show you in which I think are most interesting on this specific sword.
Moving on to the blade, if you remember the Amsterdam City Guard sword I have, the blade is
surprisingly similar in terms of width, in terms of length of the fuller, in terms of size of the
fuller, in terms of lenticular section. It's just a little bit shorter, so I think it may be this
much shorter than the Amsterdam City Guard one. However, whereas the City Guard one has a full
complete tip, this one is rounded, so it's definitely possible that the blade was a little
bit longer and was shortened. But I would be very surprised if these blades weren't from,
if not the same manufacturer, at least from the same kind of order or consignment. They're so,
so similar that, yeah, that I wouldn't be surprised if they came from the same forge.
Speaking of which, markings. This one has some markings, but they are a little bit unusual.
One, because you can't read them, or at least the majority can't be read. But now we'll see
something else too. So first of all, what you can see is in the fuller here we have some X's.
This is fairly typical of, you'll see there's an X here that's very visible, and there's what's
left of an X, I think, here. So we can assume, yeah, there's an X also here on this side,
and unfortunately nothing readable. Oh, actually yes, it's right there, another X. So we have these
four X's, and normally in between these kind of symbols you would have Sahagum or Insulingen or
some other kind of mark of that kind. Here we don't have that, but we do have, look at this,
and tell me if it reminds you of something. To me, this, especially if we look at it in
reminds me of a very badly drawn Passau wolf, perhaps. You can almost see the body here, the eye,
some attempt to the legs, I think it's more visible here, it would be running in this
direction. This is my impression. So I wonder if this blade is displaying a badly forged Passau
wolf mark. We know that the Passau wolf was often reproduced in Insulingen, but it usually
didn't look as bad as this. So I don't know what happened here. Of course, it's also possible that
I'm just seeing things, and that these are remains of something, some other symbol, but it just looks
so much to me like a crude Passau wolf, and it's too similar on the both sides. You have these two
longer lines that kind of converge here. It's too similar to the wolf to me, and too consistent on
both sides to be just like scratches or damage in the blade. So I don't know. I'm curious to hear
your opinion on what this may be. However, apart from the X's, which are definitely a mark, and the
weird Passau wolf, which I don't know what it is, there are no other marks, there are no stamps,
there's no maker's mark, there's nothing to enable us to identify this blade in any better way.
But, and this brings me back to the issue of someone trying to clean it in a very rough way,
but I think perhaps stopping just before causing irreparable damage, you also see these weird lines.
These I've seen on power tool cleaned or aggressively cleaned blades. You'll normally
see these weird lines here. I don't know if it's a Dremel, if it's something manual that was done
at some point, but it's usually visible on some damaged blades. Luckily, here we have a very
minor amount of this damage. It's mostly these two lines you see here. I think there's something on
the other side as well, but overall it's not horrible. So the blade has been cleaned, for sure,
because you can see there's bleeding and everything, but the blade itself at some point has
had most of the corrosion removed here. The blade, other than that, so other than those markings,
the blade is surprisingly intact. There are a few notches, but very minor on the edge,
on both edges, but especially on the bottom edges, on the cutting edge.
Both are sharp, by the way, or were sharp, and the blade though is in surprisingly good shape.
So here it is in all of its quirks and imperfections. I hope you enjoyed it.
What's interesting to me is that the Walloon Hilted swords I have that are actually complete
and non-tampered with are the examples of non-typical ones. This one instead, which is
the most tampered with, the most damaged in a sense, is actually representative of what the
stereotypical Walloon Hilted sword is. So I find that really interesting. Nevertheless, this is a
beautiful sword. It handles really nicely, and for all of its imperfections, I still think it's a
lovely piece of history. So I hope you enjoyed it, and I'll see you soon in another sword video. Bye!
