Hi, I'm Mike with House on the Mend and in this video we're going to be reviewing
the Garden Joy 21 volt reciprocating saw. We're going to cut wood, metal, PVC,
and I'm even going to show you how it mixes paint. So let's get started.
Now I'm not sponsored by Garden Joy. They simply reached out to me
and offered to send me this product for my independent review.
So let's open up the box and see what comes inside.
All right, I've got everything laid out that comes in this really nice plastic case. It's got
two pretty decently built clasps on it. The only thing I will say is the hinge on the bottom of the
case is just a long strip of thin plastic. It's not an actual hinge, so eventually that will wear
out depending on the amount of opening and closing that happens. But nonetheless, you do
get a case that everything fits into and I think that's a great value. The unit itself feels really
good in the hand. Everywhere you see black other than the trigger, the safety, and the sticker,
but everywhere else is a rubberized grip. Really nice. This feels like good quality finished
plastic. I don't feel any sharp edges anywhere. Unlike the battery that we'll get into in a
minute, this area here for releasing the battery is really jagged and sharp and the whole entire
case for the battery feels much cheaper than the unit itself. So right in the area where your thumb
and forefinger go ambidextrously is the safety. You can lock it so the trigger can't be actuated
or unlock it so it can, and those two are clearly marked. Push in on this side for unlocked,
vice versa over here for the lock, and they actually show you that, so that's pretty cool.
The quick release, as you see here, is a twist to unlock, then push in the blade, release,
and you have a blade locked into place. The guard up here is a thick stamped metal.
Very secure. As I turn the tool over, I see just two blades that the battery will slide into.
That is just strictly the positive and negative. That means that there is no information being
shared between the battery and the tool as far as overheating or anything like that,
even though as I look at the battery, I do see three spots where this battery could communicate
with perhaps a different tool, but not on this one. This saw comes with two metal blades and
four wood blades, which I think is a great value. Also included is a pair of safety glasses and
a pair of gloves that have the palms and fingers dipped in butyl rubber, very common for gardening.
These are a medium size as far as I can tell, because I can get my hands in them, but my
knuckles come way back here, and they are a little bit tight. I wear a large glove, so these are
obviously a medium. The safety glasses are better than some that I've seen, although they are pretty
flexible and cheap. You can see it peeling away here. I'm not sure why they keep including these
in some of these tools that I'm covering. I think the money would be better spent in
upgrading the materials for the battery. Speaking of the battery, you get one in the package and it
is a three amp hour battery. Nice mid-range size battery, right? So a lot better than a one and a
half or two that I've seen in some of the products I review, but less than say a four to a six or
more that you can get with some tools. This battery does not come with a charger that has a cradle
that you slide the battery into. Instead there is a radio jack that plugs into the top of the battery
and then this plugs into the wall. I would imagine if it's like similar tools I've reviewed, you're
going to have a green light and a red light to denote if it's charging or fully charged. One
thing you will not see anywhere on this unit is a battery life indicator, and that is because
according to the instructions, the battery indicator is supposed to be right here on what
would be the left side of the tool. It's pointing to these three dashes right here, very similar to
the Milwaukee M12 tools. However, when I plug in the battery and I start the unit, I don't see any
lights coming out of here, even in the dark. This is a very well-lit area here. Nowhere on this tool
do I see what is supposed to be the battery indicator, so this seems to be a falsehood.
Installing the battery couldn't be simpler. There's a couple guides and a couple rails on the
tools and the battery that just click it into place. To remove the battery, you simply push down
on this release button here, and off it comes. While we're here, let's go ahead and listen to
what it sounds like. Pretty quiet. There's no discernible whine to it, so that's all good.
To give you a sense of scale, below you see the very traditional reciprocating saw that I have
owned for, jeez, 15 years. It is excellent. You can see how different the ergonomics are, so
with this one, it is very front-heavy. If you wanted to try to cut with one hand, it is not
intended for that. You really need to get both hands on the unit, whereas with this new style
of reciprocating saw that I see very prevalently nowadays, it is easily operated with one hand,
and if you want to use two hands, it's got this spot right here to wrap your hand around to give
you a little bit more support. Another thing we should take a look at is the size difference
and the weight difference. The manual says that the tool is three and a half pounds,
so let's check that. The tool by itself is about two pounds six ounces. If we add the battery,
then, yeah, three pounds eight ounces. That's about three and a half pounds, just a tiny bit
over as compared to this beast who is well over six and a half pounds tool only. Next, let's set
up to charge the battery, see how long it takes to charge, and whether or not it creates any
alarming amount of heat while charging. Right on top of the charger, you can see this green LED
light. When I plug it into the battery, it changes to red, indicating that the battery is charging,
and let's get an overall temperature. It is starting out at 73 degrees Fahrenheit.
After only 36 minutes, the green light on the charger indicates that we are fully charged,
and the temperature didn't rise at all. In fact, it dropped two degrees, so
pretty impressive. It must have come with quite a bit of charge on it. Well, since it's called a
garden joy, I thought it only fitting that we start out here in the garden. I've got the wood
bit and a fresh battery, and we're going to cut some branches on this tree that's still dormant
but alive. Then, we're going to head to the Bullhead City house. We're going to cut some
palm trees to see how it does on the more fibrous fronds, and then we'll end up by cutting some
dried lumber. So, here we go. Certainly not struggling to cut through this wood. It's got
plenty of power. Not as effective as a mini electric chainsaw, but reciprocating saws are
just so much more versatile, right? All right, so it's struggling with this branch here that's only
inch, inch and a quarter thick. Well, that was not impressive at all, and I can smell
like a chemical motor burn kind of smell. No smoke coming out of it. I'll get a close-up of this.
All the paint is already scraping away of this included blade, so not really doing too well
in the garden. These two branches here are in clear conflict, so I think I'll cut this one.
Now, when it comes to trimming palm trees, the one-handed cutting capability of a saw this size
really comes into play as a benefit. Easy. Well, I'd planned on doing more outdoor testing,
but the wind is so bad today that you'll probably hear it knocking on the garage door here.
Nonetheless, we've got a vise set up here, and I got a bunch of scrap material that we're going
to practice cutting. I wasn't too impressed with how this tool did on those live branches we were
cutting, but I have some closet rod here that I used to paint some cabinets on, so it's just scrap.
Let's try cutting a few pieces of this, see how it does, and then I also want to test it against
my existing rigid saw and see which one does better. All right, here we go. So clearly,
it did a much better job on this kiln-dried wood than it did on the original branches we were
cutting, so let's do a timer and see with the same blade how this saw performs against a
traditional reciprocating saw. All right, same blade. Wow, that seemed like a lot faster.
So clearly, the rigid saw is a lot faster. In fact, almost three times as fast at making a cut
as this Garden Joy was. Now, I think that's the combination of the speed and then also
possibly the amount of travel that you're getting in the stroke. I'll measure that
a little later, but let's do a little bit more testing. These saws are routinely used for
demolition work, and when you're demoing a house or a wall or something like that,
you're inevitably going to come in contact with a sill plate or, in this case, pressure-treated
lumber that would be on the ground in contact with concrete. Let's make some cuts here and
see how it does. So once again, it struggled getting through this wood. Let's see how the
same blade does in my rigid reciprocating saw. Wow, so much faster. Well, just as I suspected,
the travel on the Garden Joy is just over half an inch, 0.57 inches, whereas with the rigid,
it is just over an inch, so almost twice as much travel. So I've theorized a couple times that I
thought the rigid might be faster, but to be fair, it looks like the Garden Joy is capable of
3,000 strokes per minute, and the rigid is rated for 2,500. Well, clearly the rigid
reciprocating saw is going to outperform the Garden Joy because it's faster and has a longer
stroke. So let's, for the rest of the video, just concentrate on what this reciprocating saw can do.
I have a little jig that I've made here that helps me cut miter cuts on metal, be it if I'm
making window screen frames, or in this case, we have some three-quarter by three-quarter square
aluminum tubing. So let's see how the supplied metal blade handles it. Good, no problem there.
All right, schedule 40 PVC pipe is a regular thing to cut with a reciprocating saw. Let's
see how this metal blade does on PVC. Oh yeah. And finally, working with galvanized pipe,
if you're running conduit or anything like that, you will often use a reciprocating saw. Got it.
And no review of a reciprocating saw would be complete without me showcasing the Mixquik.
Not a sponsor, just a product I love and makes it so much easier to mix cans of paint
or spray on texture when repairing walls. It goes right into any reciprocating saw, has a strap
that will hold the can of paint in place. Greatest invention ever. You never have to mix a can of
paint by hand. If you've got the Mixquik, I'll leave a link for it in the description.
Well, I think we've done enough testing that I can give you my list of pros and cons.
First, the pros. The rubberized grip, the ergonomics, and the overall build quality are
all really good. This does not feel cheap in the hand. All the edges are sanded down. It is a nice
feeling, easy to use tool, one or two handed. Next, the noise level was not bad at all. It's
mostly the material that you cut that makes a lot of the noise. Regardless, I wear hearing
protection all the time, but the tool itself did not have any kind of whine or anything to my ears.
The battery life was really good. Every bit of the cutting you saw me do was on one charge of
one single battery. Speaking of the battery, the battery platform is something I always stress
when recommending a tool to people is, are there other tools that you can use with the same
battery? And in Garden Joy's case, there is a drill, a mini electric chainsaw, and a half-inch
impact driver currently available for this same battery. So at least if you buy this tool, you
know you can get a few other tools and use the same battery for all of them. Lastly, the included
case and cutting blades, both wood and metal, I thought was a great value. Now the cons. First
and foremost, the lack of a battery life indicator anywhere on the tool is always a con in my book,
and I especially don't like the fact that these hash marks here that the manual states are the
battery life indicator don't do anything. That feels like false advertising to me. I find it
hard in my business to take a tool with me and use it on a daily basis if I don't know how much
battery life is on it. And I have actually gravitated away from any tool in my arsenal
that doesn't have a battery life indicator. And then the travel of the blade being only like a
half-inch caused every single cut to take three times longer. And for that reason, I would caution
people that need to do a lot of cutting on this particular tool. If you can find something with a
longer stroke, you're going to be happier with that tool. Now if you found this video helpful,
will you please give it a thumbs up? It really helps the algorithms to start suggesting it to
more viewers like you. Also please consider subscribing. I'm working really hard to put
out good quality content. There's a lot more videos and tool reviews to come, and it's free.
All you have to do is just log in and click on the follow button or subscribe button, and it
really helps the channel. Now I'm going to leave a link to the Garden Joy reciprocating saw and the
quick mix. Full disclosure, those will be Amazon affiliate links. So if you click on them and end
up making a purchase, it won't cost you a thing, but I do get a small reward at the end of the
month. It helps to justify all the time it takes to set up and record these reviews. Speaking of
this review, I want to thank Garden Joy for sending me this tool. It takes a lot of courage
to send an independent reviewer a tool and not have any input whatsoever on what the reviewer is
going to say, and I respect them for doing that even though I had a couple pretty harsh criticisms.
So until next time, thank you for watching.