An explosive open letter attributed to General Zhang Youxia is shaking China’s political and military elite. Did Zhang write it—and does authorship even matter? This program breaks down four realistic scenarios behind the letter and explains why, real or not, it has become one of the most dangerous documents inside the PLA power struggle.
A few hours ago, I did a live stream where I read you an open letter allegedly written by
Zhang Youxia last December, at a moment when he believed he was in real danger and could be
arrested at any time. In the letter, Zhang Youxia lays out in striking detail his fundamental
disagreements with Xi Jinping over personnel decisions, how the military should be run,
and most critically, over war, especially Taiwan and China's alignment with Russia.
He traces the history of their rift, describes what really happened at the third plenum in 2024,
and explains the power structure that emerged afterward, including promises Xi Jinping
made to step down in 2027. General Zhang makes one point very clear. He had the capability to stage
a military coup, but chose not to do so. And if he is arrested, he says he will not resist.
And drawing on his own experience fighting in the Sino-Vietnamese War,
he strongly condemns reckless wars launched by political leaders. He also criticizes
Deng Xiaoping, arguing that Deng, like Xi, remote rewrote the constitution to concentrate authorities
with devastating consequences. So the letter describes how collective leadership has been
hollowed out and replaced by one-man rule, turning the PLA into a personal loyalty force.
So he is especially alarmed by what he sees as Xi Jinping's obsession with
personally commanding what he calls a grand historic war to unify Taiwan.
But here's the million-dollar question. Is the letter real? Did General Zhang actually write it?
I think there are four realistic possibilities. First,
Zhang did write the letter himself in full. By that time, he and Xi Jinping had been locked
in a power struggle for at least a year, and Zhang's situation was deteriorating,
and he may have written the letter in advance to prepare for the worst.
The problem with this scenario is that the letter feels almost too perfect. It seems to be able to
anticipate every major question people would later ask after his arrest. Did he plan a coup?
Did he leak military information to the Americans, or sensitive information such as nuclear weapons
information? The letter answers all of them in advance, and that level of foresight makes
some people doubt whether it was really written before he was taken. Also, the language of the
general, it sounds like an essay written by an intellectual. That leads to the second possibility,
which is that the general did write the core of the letter, but not all of it. After his arrest,
his friend, as the letter allegedly was recorded by, his friend or a close associate may have
expanded it, adding key sections to address the latest rumors and public speculation. This person
or these people would have based those additions on a deep understanding of the general's views,
his relationship with Xi Jinping, and the internal situation. So that's the second possibility.
And the third is that the letter was written entirely after his arrest by close associates
or trusted allies. Their goal would have been to make the general's voice heard. While he himself
may not have written the text, these people knew him well, understood his thinking, and were
intimately familiar with the conflict between Zhang Youxia and Xi Jinping. So in this case, the content
could still be largely accurate, even if the author or the authorship is indirect.
The fourth possibility is that the letter was written by a sympathetic insider who's not
personally close to Zhang, to the general, but someone who understands the CCP system and wanted
to help him. So let's summarize. Option one is Zhang wrote it exactly as it appears. Option two
is Zhang wrote it, and it was later expanded. Option three is that it was written on his behalf
by close associates to support him. And option four was that it was written by
somebody else, someone who's sympathetic. So in the last three cases, the author would still be
a CCP insider, someone who understands party logic, military culture, and internal history.
And the language, the way it's written, it obviously shows that it's not written by
someone who's an outsider. It was someone in the system, because it's not something a random
outsider could have produced. So of these four, I think option two and three are the most likely.
The two together could account for more than 50% possibility. Option one and four are possible,
but I think less likely. So some people may argue, well, if the general himself didn't write
the letter, we should simply ignore it. I disagree. Even if the chance that General Zhang
personally authored the letter, every word, or wrote every word, is very low, the letter was
almost certainly written by someone who has firsthand knowledge of what actually went on
inside the Forbidden City, the walls of Zhongnanhai, someone who's fairly knowledgeable
about Xi Jinping's relations with Zhang Youxia, and the dynamics of their relationship.
So that makes the substance of the letter highly valuable. So regardless of who physically wrote
it, I believe this document is important and deserves serious attention from anyone trying
to understand what's really happening inside China's political and military system.
Some people even believe that the appearance of the letter at this moment is crucial,
as it solidifies support for the generals at this moment. They see it, they say,
forget about who wrote it. It is a weapon that the anti-Xi faction just launched to fight back.
And if you look at it from that perspective, the letter did serve that purpose.