Today, I sat down with Niklas of @Vintagebursche to discuss his experience of what it is like to wear historical menswear. It was an absolute pleasure to have this conversation and it helped me deeper understand what it must be like for men to express themselves through the means of historical clothing.
Last week on the Community tab, I asked you all to submit your questions, and here they are, answered!
Some of the questions we cover include; How long have you been wearing historical clothing/vintage clothing? What periods of historical fashion do you gravitate towards? How did you get started with wearing historical clothes? Do you wear them daily? Which qualities make a garment feel historical? Do people react differently to men & women wearing historical dress? What are three essential things to learn for tailoring? How do you find sources for historical menswear?
We hope that this video will help to answer some of your burning questions and provide a deeper insight into the life of a male historical fashion and vintage fashion wearer.
A massive thank you to Niklas/Vintagebursche for agreeing to this interview in the first place. You are a truly fascinating human being and an incredibly talented tailor. I am especially grateful for your contributions to the historical fashion community!
Thank you so much for watching.
So tonight I sat down with Niklas of Vintage Borsche and talked about his experience of what
it's like wearing historical menswear. I thought it would be really great to pick his brain a
little, talk to him about his perspective and his experience with this form of dress. First of all,
thank you so much for agreeing to this interview. It's great to have you here and to bring some
diversity to the channel as well because obviously since I identify as a woman I can't really provide
any perspective on someone that is identifying as a male. So maybe if you could just start by
introducing yourself and who you are and what you do. Also, thanks for inviting me. My name is
Niklas. I'm better known on the interwebs as the Vintage Borsche. Borsche is a German term
similar to lead, I think. Usually I am an IT analyst, so I studied computer science during my
life. At some point I discovered for myself sewing, historical research and so on. And I
am present on, I don't know, Instagram, YouTube and all those platforms. I actually had to look up
Borsche because I wasn't sure what it meant. You know, obviously it's pretty self-explanatory if you
go on your YouTube channel that that is your name. So how long ago did you start dressing vintage or
historical? I'd say like six or seven years. I've been active on the internet for, I guess,
five years with this Vintage Borsche thing and started a little bit before that at least
dressing sometimes with, you know, vintage style suits and so on. And it's a slow process
and I'm still, you know, trying to replace some items in my wardrobe with things I'm more
comfortable with where I like the style a little bit more. Do you wear historical or vintage clothing
every single day or is it something that you only do sometimes? Like, for instance, can you also wear
historical clothing to work or is it something different that you have to do? I do dress vintage
every day now. However, I turn it a bit down for work. So around the house I like to wear, I don't
know, henley shirts, corduroy trousers, something that doesn't stick out as much as an Edwardian
three-piece suit. To work I like to skip certain things like very high collars, they attract a bit
too much attention. On the other hand, I said I study computer science, I'm an IT analyst, so
there is no dress code at my work so I can basically wear what I want. And of course most
of my colleagues do wear just the shirt and denim jeans, but I prefer the suit and I'm known for it
to be the one with the suit, the three-piece suit and the tie, but that's okay for me. That's great
funny. With historical clothing or vintage clothing it's always like you're ready for any
event because you can kind of play it casual. I mean, you're a little overdressed all the time.
If you have to go somewhere more formal you're already ready to go because nowadays we don't
really have evening wear in the way that they did before. Your new colleagues usually ask me
if I'm invited to a wedding afterwards. Oh, that's funny. So what years do you mainly wear?
What are the kind of eras of historical or vintage clothing? Because I kind of call vintage and
historical separate things, so like I sort of think of before 1920 as being more historical,
but obviously the line is pretty gray. We can't really say for certain what is vintage and what
is historical. So my main inspiration is the 1910s and early 1920s before the trousers get too
wide and so on. I do have some pieces in my wardrobe that are really 100% historical,
like I do have two bespoke suits made for me from patterns from the early 1920s. I do have a frog
coat from 1910s. Most of my suits are just, you know, like a vintage style. Some pieces I altered
so they fit the aesthetic more, but basically modern suits. For me it's more a matter of style
and not so much concerned about being 100% historical, correct? Yeah, and I actually don't
think historical accuracy is even real because it's impossible. Like we just can't know exactly
what people wore. Because you wear historically inspired clothing sometimes. Which elements about
historical clothing do you think make a garment feel archaic or like it is historical? So with
women's wear, a lot of the time it's the high waistline and the very tailored thing or a very
strange sleeve shape. With men's wear, what do you think it is that makes it feel historical?
I'd also say that it's first the high waistline and this is something I get asked a lot because I
wear suits all the time. People come to me for advice wearing modern suits and it feels vintage,
but it's not actually vintage or historical. But the high waistline is, I don't know, a game changer
because they make your legs look longer. It's a lot more comfortable than those low waist trousers
and this is maybe the most important thing for me. Also shorter waistcoats,
emphasizing this high waistline. And the second thing is probably materials because garments are
not that slim for the period I'm aiming for. There's no stretch in the materials. This results
in a more durable garment, I guess. My girlfriend, for example, she wears modern clothes, modern
jeans and they are always really tight fitting and I have to repair them all the time because
materials that are under stress all the time, they get damaged a lot. I'd say that.
What is your perspective on the masculine side of historical costuming or the clothing community? Are
you very involved in this community or is it difficult for you to find advice or guides or
even just patterns for men's wear? Apart from a couple of eras that are popular in reenactment
or living history, there is definitely a lack of sewing content around menswear, I'd say. It seems
men are not that interested in sewing, which I think is a little sad. Men are also underrepresented
on the fashion side. To my mind, there are a lot more vintage style shops and brands for women than
there are for men. That may be an interesting sociological study because I can't really explain
why that is, except probably that fashion and sewing are viewed as more, I don't know, female
areas in society, which I can't agree with, but yeah, that may be the case. Compared to this
whole community around Bernadette, Carolina, also Rachel Maxie or Morgan Donner, I just still feel
that there is nothing comparable on the male side. Nothing. As you said, Zach has a YouTube channel
and from time to time he does upload something, but he's mostly probably occupied with his
tailoring business, which is absolutely understandable. Maybe because a lot of men
are not into sewing, it's a lot more difficult for me to, I don't know, get a hold on to
the community that hasn't established yet. I think it's getting better. More and more men are being
accepted into fashion and it's important that men are involved in fashion. It just is incredibly
important to have all people involved in this aspect because fashion so directly influences
our culture and so we need to hear everyone's voices, people of all identities coming together
to be able to provide an equal opinion on everything, I think at least. I hope it gets
better and I hope I can contribute to that by offering sewing content for menswear. I think
you're doing a great job at it, definitely. I think you definitely provide a gap that exists
in the market and you provide the space for those people who are looking for that information,
which is so important. We think everything's been done on the internet, but it turns out
if you niche down more and more, it hasn't been done. There's one other male I want to mention,
which is Jimmy, the Welsh Viking, who is also a fabulous character who has a great YouTube
channel. I love him, he's really great. Shout out. Yeah, he's in the UK too. What are the reactions
that you typically will get? Because I'm sure you have in your head, at least I know I certainly do,
a few of the great ones and a few of the really negative ones that you've had. And you're in
Germany, so it's going to be different, I guess, for someone in a different country. Yeah, it also
really depends on the city you're living in. I do live in Cologne in Western Germany, which is one
of the four biggest cities in Germany. And in Cologne, there's this carnival where everybody
dresses up like something. So people here are used to seeing someone straying from the norm.
So I think it's really okay here in the countryside, more or less. It's a lot more
difficult. The reactions are mostly positive. But of course, you have your occasional teenager
that thinks you look like a clown. Also, there are some people that connect the suit, no matter
from which era, with certain conservative beliefs and thus look down on you. But again, most reactions
are positive. So ranging from elderly people that are reminded of their youth by my clothes,
to young and artsy people that appreciate just the fanciness of my outfits, if you know what I mean.
It's cool. And again, you develop witty answers to the dumb ones. What's your favorite witty
answer to give? I usually just ignore the really dumb comments. In case someone is really persistent,
I like to say something like, oh, my dear sir or madam, you must mistake me for someone who
cares about your opinion. So one of those kind of answers. My favorite one is if I've sewn what I'm
wearing, I'll just tell them that I spent 300 hours sewing what I'm wearing. Did they sew anything
that they are wearing? And that's pretty great, because that'll get people to shut up pretty
quickly. Because obviously, they're probably not going to say yes. And if they do say yes,
you can make a good friend. What drew you to wearing 1910s or early 1920s clothes?
That's a good question. I researched the last 100 years of classic menswear and just saw that
the silhouettes of the 1910s or the Edwardian period in general meets my taste as well as my
rather slim body. Also, suits from the Edwardian era don't differ that much from today's suits. So
you don't stick out that much when wearing them. And my general interest for the history of classic
menswear drew me to the early 19th century, 19th century, which is what I'm wearing right now. An
outfit of work in progress. I thought this might be a nice opportunity to wear what I already
put together. My whole sewing career started when I started LARPing at the age of 15. And
a significant portion of German LARP leans towards historical accuracy. I also have a
mid-14th century knight's armor and wardrobe that I mostly made myself, as well as a reconstruction
of the Kjolderhund find from the 11th century Norway, including some more creative elements,
because it's meant for Viking LARP. My interest is quite broad, but when it comes to what I wear
on a daily basis, it's more like Edwardian period. What you just told me reminds me of
when people ask you that question, what's some random fact about you that no one expects you to
have? That's the exact answer that I would hope you would give if someone asked that question.
I do have a knight's armor in my basement. When I was 19, I started my computer science study
and joined a German student fraternity, which is something very, very interesting for itself.
The fraternity was founded in 1876. The house I was at first also living in was built in the 1920s,
and there are a lot of pictures of the former members from, for example, the late 19th century
hanging all over the house. This got me into classic menswear because I had to wear a suit
to all the official events, as well as the vintage side of it. So if someone wants to wear more
historical menswear and they can only afford to buy one type of item, what would you recommend?
I immediately thought of a nice historically tailored coat. I think that really depends on
the era you're going for. So if it's something that still counts as classic menswear, at least
1900s, 1890s, for example, I would go for high-waisted trousers because we already talked
about how important the waistline is. However, depending on the style you're going for, there
may be other pieces conveying the aesthetic a bit better than trousers. So I guess a nice coat,
like an inverness coat or cape, maybe is a nice idea. Or a long neck cloth, like I'm sporting
right now. It might be an interesting combination with a modern suit, for example.
You have to figure something out for the era you are aiming for.
What item do you usually wear that has a ton of myths around it, that you have to constantly
break myths about? So immediately for women or for females, it's corsets and stays, because
obviously people think that we're crazy for wearing corsets. And I wear one every day, so I
have to tell people all the time that it's not a big deal, I'm okay. What is the thing with menswear
would you say that is equivalent? Obviously you also can wear corsets. Yeah, if I had more time
before the interview, you know, if I hadn't been in a rush, I would have probably put on my corset,
which I haven't now. But one element is a bit different, which is basically the detachable
collars, which are most of the time very high and stiff. So again, it's a comfort question, maybe.
So people ask me, I can't imagine that these are comfortable, but I would say it's really fine.
Also, this high collar here is just fine. This is also very soft, so it looks uncomfortable,
but it really isn't. Maybe a bit warm, but that's okay. And the detachable collars,
they have a great dynamic, you know, they move a lot in themselves, so you really get used to it.
What aspect of historical dress did you find to be the biggest adjustment? Is there anything that
you really miss about modern or contemporary clothing? Biggest adjustment is that you can't
be too careless with your clothes. We tend to don't care about our stuff because everything
is so cheap and made of polyester. That's maybe the biggest difference, I think, but also a big
money saver. So of course, sometimes I miss being careless, but on the other hand, it saves me so
much money. For example, for my shoes, I do have Goodyear welted shoes that I bought, I don't know,
10 years ago, 12 years ago, which are really, really old now, but still in great shape. And
if I had bought, you know, like the cheap ones from Deichmann, it's like a cheap shoe store here,
in the same period, in those 10 years, I've probably bought five pairs, which is incredibly
expensive, if you think about it in this way. And this is also something cool the modern classic
menswear community figured out decades ago, valuing clothes not by the price on the price tag, but
by the cost per wear. And you get a lot more wears out of well made stuff than out of the, you know,
the cheap, the cheap stuff. I think that also, that's a big myth about historical and vintage
clothing in general, that it's expensive, when you actually do evaluate it at cost per wear,
it's much more affordable. I grew up with not very much money. So I started wearing thrift shop
clothing. Because of that, you can find some really good stuff for really cheap. And it's
made really well, like bespoke stuff, sometimes you can find. So which garments surprised you
with their comfort or their ease of fitting? So for instance, some people will say that breeches
are more comfortable than blue jeans. Do you agree with this? Or what sort of things do you feel like
are more comfortable than their contemporary counterparts? I can't really say that some
garments surprised me. But on the concrete matter, I guess it depends on the blue jeans and the
breeches. Because the tight blue jeans are pretty restricting. And 18th century breeches, I guess,
are too. The breeches have these very baggy bottoms. So you have enough fabric to move.
On the other hand, there are also loose fitting blue jeans, of course, they are quite comfortable.
Just as the types of breeches that became popular in, for example, the 19th century,
those snickerbockers and plus fours, for example, they are very roomy. So
yeah, kind of deals with the circumstance. But is there is there anything that you were like,
wow, this is so much better? Why did I not start wearing this, you know, 20 years ago,
maybe corduroy in general, because it's not that popular anymore. I can't figure out why.
To be honest, are there any historical garments that you're enjoying watching a retrending of
because lately, the fashion world loves to implement little historical elements, especially
Victorian stuff. In this classic menswear community, there's always something vintage
or historical retrending. I'm just sitting back and I'm curious what will be next. For example,
those safari jackets or field jackets. I'm keen to see whether knickerbockers might might retrend
at some point, because I love those. I don't think that detachable collars will ever retrend
because to be honest, they are quite inconvenient, despite the fact that they look pretty nice.
I think the corset has retrended. So I mean, yeah, that's true. It's a different version. But
I already teamed up with with a good friend who's a bespoke tailor in Cologne. We wrote a tailoring
book for menswear from the early 1920s. The detachable collars are maybe one of the easiest
projects in the book because it's, you know, like just some tiny piece with a couple of layers.
Again, classic menswear in general is not that beginner friendly, but maybe if you have sewn
something, start with a detachable collar. Oh, so what what is the book's name? Can you
can you tell us all? The original version is German and I have to admit that the physical
version is, we only have that in German. It's Vintage Herrenmodel Selbstnähen, which is basically
sewing vintage menswear, but we have an ebook in English. One of the questions I got a lot was
what are your recommendations for sewing resources for menswear? That's really, really difficult,
which was the motivation for us to to make the book because there is nothing similar. I really
can recommend the book by Lydia Edwards, How to Read a Suit. Maybe you already know the How to
Read a Dress. This is the best overview you can imagine because you can pick your favorite style
So my friend Cass McGann owns Reconstructing History and she has an incredibly large amount
of historical menswear patterns. A lot of it is also going into early 20th century. I don't mean
to just do a plug of my friend's company, but she genuinely makes great patterns for you and for
anyone watching this video as well. In your opinion, do you think that people react differently to a
man in historical dress than they would a woman? So I guess we should both answer this question
because we each have the other side of the story, so to speak. In my opinion, ladywear in the last
50 years also always seem to be more creative and more diverse than menswear. I don't know if it's
the case. It's just my point of view. It's really more difficult to wear clothes as a man that
society doesn't expect you to wear. And I see that side of it, absolutely. I think that because so
much of menswear today has influences from classical menswear or historical menswear, it kind of makes
you feel like you're on the way to an event or something, and so people end up being forgiving of
that. But when I show up to walking around somewhere with a full-on crinoline and a corset, people are
like, what? They can't figure out what you're doing. I sometimes got asked if I was in the theater or
in an opera. One time a drunk guy in the street started singing opera in my face, which was
interesting. I can imagine on the side of it, of course, this thing in society of men are expected
to be a certain way. I mean, I guess just like women are expected to be a certain way as well,
but with men it's that whole hyper-masculinity, and that would make it, I believe, supremely
difficult for men to wear historical clothing. And then I think on the other side of it, too,
women were often very sexualized when we wear historical clothing. I've received some really
kind of negative comments where people have been sexualizing me for wearing historical clothing,
and it's because corsetry is somehow feminized nowadays. So it's interesting. I feel like it
would be difficult in both ways, for both demographics, but also for different reasons.
You've already said that you do sew some of your own clothing. Tailoring is a very daunting aspect
of historical clothing. What are the three things that you absolutely think you need to learn with
tailoring? I don't really know the correct English term, but when you have a pattern and
the fabric, now you have two symmetrical pieces. You use basting thread to put your marks through
two layers of fabric with one pattern. Using canvas, prick stitching the canvas onto your
fabric, and generally knowing how to three-dimensionally form your fabric. In general,
you use something two-dimensional to make a three-dimensional shape, and it's really
important, I think, to understand how this happens by different seams, by forming the fabric with a
steaming iron, for example. This is, you know, something you need to understand. Is there any
convenient feature about historical menswear that modern menswear just doesn't have and that you
wish it did? Yeah, maybe something you know from the ladies' side. It's pockets, because there are
a lot more pockets in historical menswear, in my opinion, and they're in more convenient places,
because usually, as a man, you just use the pockets in your trousers, which make your trousers look
very bulgy. When you're wearing a waistcoat and a jacket, you have all those pockets in your
jacket, in your waistcoat. They are a lot more forgiving to your silhouette when you use them.
Do you build a gentleman's historical wardrobe from individual pieces that can be mixed and
matched, like a modern person might, or is it more focused upon matching sets? So, for instance, in my
wardrobe, it's very often a matching set, like a walking suit. It has a matching bodice and a
matching skirt. That really depends on your personal style and the era you're going for.
Personally, I prefer three-piece suits, so the sets. I'm the set guy. That was also the reason
why I have those two full bespoke suits, because I wanted three-piece suits with the historical
cups, and this was my only option. Are cod pieces as uncomfortable and annoying as they look?
Because from a female perspective, they look like they're impossible to deal with, like how
corsets are impossible from a male's perspective and everything. I don't own any
15th or 16th century attire, but I know some people from my medieval love that do wear cod
pieces, and as far as I know, they are not uncomfortable or annoying at all. What are your
most and least favorite fabrics to wear? You mentioned corduroy, and also what are some of the
colors that you enjoy wearing? I really, really love tweeds and flannels, because I like the wool and
yarn aesthetic. Thin flowing fabrics, which you find a lot in this Italian tailoring, are not
really my thing. My favorite colors, you might have noticed, are dark green tones,
earthy tones, and sometimes a touch of golden yellow, always combined with, you know, different
shades of gray, including black and white. If you'd like to find any of Niklas's social media
information, it's all linked in the description box down below. Be sure to go and give his YouTube
channel a subscribe. He has incredible videos packed with so much useful information, and they're
always so much fun to watch. Thank you so much for watching, and I'll see you all on Thursday for
another video.