My Honest Opinion on Tactical Swords

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
2 Video Views·Dec 11, 2025
When history is too boring and you'd rather have a sword fit for the carbon-fiber infused tastes of a couch commando mallninja... I guess this is what happens. Plain black blades with minimalist hilts and plastic handle scales.
How's it going? The lighting's a little too dramatic, isn't it? Today I want to go on a
little rant about tactical swords. Quite a concept, isn't it? As soon as you see the term
tactical, you know immediately it's a marketing gimmick. I highly, highly doubt that there's a
single soldier on the entire planet who has or carries a tactical sword. And owning one or
several is a different story for, you know, collecting purposes and whatnot. But carrying
a tactical sword in the field on duty? I'm gonna press X to doubt that. Obviously it is really
just a marketing gimmick and not supposed to be anything else. Nobody is expected to charge into
a gunfight with a sword. But even as a collector's piece, it is kind of curious, isn't it? When it
comes to reproductions of historical swords, there's something more to it than just the collecting.
You know, that in and of itself is viable. Of course, people collect all kinds of things, right?
You know, from the old-fashioned stamps that grandpa would collect to action figures and perfume
bottles. There's so many things that serve no practical purpose. You just collect them because
you like them. Whatever, you know, that's always the case. But when it comes to reproductions of
historical swords, there's also the aspect of connecting with history in some way. You know,
recreating parts of physical history, if you will, right? There's something interesting about that.
And of course, there is also the angle of using them for historical martial arts. But a tactical
sword is specifically designed to give the impression of something that could conceivably be
used in the modern military, postmodern military, or in the near future or something like that.
It's quite often, you know, like a hypothetical zombie apocalypse scenario and stuff like that.
Now, of course, I'm needlessly overthinking this, just to acknowledge that. This is just something
cool for people to spend their money on that they don't need, along with all the other things they
don't need that they're supposed to spend money on, right? But even within that framework, a tactical
sword is kind of funny. The thing is, history has already laid all the groundwork. The heavy lifting
has been done. We know what properly designed swords are like in terms of ergonomics, in terms
of things like hand protection and blade shape, to optimize cutting performance, blah, blah, blah,
the right balance, this and that, the other, everything that goes into making a sword,
designing it and making it. So many ways to optimize swords, to choose the right thickness
and the right taper and make the balance just so that it's a really good compromise between
striking power and speed and agility and all of that. You have so many ways to make the handle
particularly efficient and comfortable, like you can bevel it in all kinds of ways. There are plenty
of different takes on grip wraps that are both practical and aesthetically appealing, but then
along comes the tactical sword that is basically just a flat bar of steel with a rough secondary
bevel and blocky plastic handle scales slapped onto it. I mean, don't get me wrong, there are some
tactical swords that are well made. Back in the day, around 2010 or so, I used to have a Zombie
Slayer by Valiant Armory. That had a much better blade geometry, directly inspired by historical
blades, and the handle scales were okay. Taking a look at the pictures from then to refresh my
memory, would I even really call that okay now? Well, let's call it underwhelming. I did like that,
but if you compare it directly to a historical longsword, it's inferior in every way. Really,
the only positive thing you can say is because it doesn't have a proper guard, it's slightly easier
to carry, although the scabbard is designed to be worn on the back like an edgelord anyway,
in which case it doesn't even really matter. And I've handled some really bad examples too. I mean,
not truly terrible, not total garbage, but compared to historical designs, really underwhelming.
And just everything that those kinds of swords do, those fail to do, you know, in terms of, again,
practicality and ergonomics and handling and everything. Really, edges in particular,
they tend to have really terrible edges, to the point where even if you wanted to market them as
useful for bushcraft or whatever, no, no, they don't cut for ----, quite frankly. Of course,
it depends on the price range. The more you pay, generally, the more you get. Generally,
there are some exceptions of overpriced junk, but if you look at something like zombie tools,
for example, these are really well made. They're nigh indestructible, unless you do
crazy things like shoot them. Yes, yes, yes. I know people still referring to that
ancient event, but fair enough. It was pretty funny. But the thing is, even though I like
zombie tools and have reviewed them positively, I did so with a particular framework in mind.
You know, this idea of, okay, this is something that's supposed to be cool, that's designed to be
it's zombie apocalypse themed, right? And within that, like, taking into account what they were
trying to achieve. Yeah, this is exactly right. Okay. But if I look at that stuff from through
the lens of historical weapons, you know, something that you would actually want to use,
the rating wouldn't be so high. Like, the handle scales are totally overkill. You don't need full
metal handle scales for this. You know, wood is just fine, or to stick with a theme like G10,
or something like that, the way tactical swords usually do. And it's also way thicker than it
needs to be. I mean, again, to be borderline indestructible, that's great and all. But,
you know, as a fighting tool, even against zombies, it's not really a good idea to slap
that much extra weight on it, because it will be exhausting. If you have to just,
if you have an entire lineup of the undead, you have to dispatch like 50 of them in a row.
Yeah, you're going to be a little exhausted, and you may not get enough food and water,
and all of that. So, that's not really a good thing. You want things to be optimized,
to be as efficient as possible, to require as little energy as possible to get the job done.
I've talked about this more than enough and demonstrated its effectiveness. I'm not going
to start that old spiel again. So, there are well-made themed swords like that, whether it
be tactical or zombie-themed or whatever. And in that case, sure, I get it, for collecting
purposes and just to have fun with it, just to, you know, cut water bottles or tatami mats or
whatever, you know, things we engage in that the normies would look at like,
what the hell? And I have a suspicion that the way normies look at gun nuts,
outside of America at least, that's probably the way gun nuts look at
people with tactical swords, right? There are weirder and even more pointless things to spend
your money on. But, you know, as long as someone somewhere enjoys it, that's a good enough reason,
right? It's just the poorly made ones, really the only thing they have going for them,
other than the novelty, is the price. They tend to be fairly cheap.
But they don't even look good to put on the wall, because they are designed to be minimalist.
And don't get me started on minimalism, especially when it comes to interior design.
I despise minimalism. I mean, just look at old, beautiful Victorian... Anyway,
so in short, I've owned tactical swords. I get the idea, but I also don't get it,
you know? Like, I also don't see the point, even within the framework of being a sword
nerd and collecting these things for basically no reason other than they're cool. Even within that
context, I don't quite get it. How do you feel about tactical swords? Let me know what you think.
In the meantime, if you haven't yet, feel free to do a tactical subscribe maneuver
and hit the tactical like button. Yeah, I'll stop now. Thanks for watching. Take care.
