The longsword duel from THE KING is on point.

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
21 Video Views·Mar 15, 2025
The King (2019) has one of the best sword fights seen on screen recently. But what makes it so good? We break down the swordplay, choreography and filmmaking of this duel and what makes it work so well (and not so well).
I think this duel from 2019's The King is one of the best sword fights I've seen on screen recently.
So I'm going to break down the sword play and the filmmaking and what I think works and what I think
doesn't quite work as well. In terms of context, what you need to know is that Timothy here is
playing Henry, Prince of Wales, otherwise known as Hal. His brother Thomas has been sent to squash
the rebellion of Harry the Hotspur, but Hal turns up and demands this.
This is based on Shakespeare so narratively this really works. It makes Hal, who will ultimately
become Henry V, a fascinating character. He is arrogant and we will see that reflected in his
fighting, but he's also concerned about the lives of these subjects. In terms of the duel,
they're wielding longswords. They're also known as hand and a half swords. And here's a cool detail
I picked up from the book The Medieval Longsword by Guy Windsor. From around 1380 to 1410, knights
were beginning to wear visors, but they did not yet have catches and locks to hold them down.
And both the play and the film are set around 1403. So the goal was to actually try to open up
their visor and hit them in the face. And this is kind of part of the strategies that we see in play
in this fight. At the start of the fight, in the first phrase, Hal and Hotspur are in wide measure,
so it's entirely accurate for them to be in what Fiore would call a short guard. Fiore de Liberi
was the author of the 14th century manuscript The Flowers of Battle, which is one of the oldest
surviving fencing manuals. If you do HEMA like myself, you're more likely to see the long guard.
To start off with, it's useful to form the guard poster longer, because what we do is closer to
armoured fencing. But Fiore actually says that the short guard is more appropriate for those
in armour than without. You can also make that thrust from poster breve, this short position
resting the pommel just below where my belt would be. My tip is maybe a little bit higher.
And you can see that in action in this shot. I really love this counter-camera move. It makes
the two fighters encircling each other feel really dynamic, and that adds to the tension
of two people otherwise doing nothing. Fiore says that the short guard should lead into a
thrust with a passing step, which is what Hal does. It's just not a very committed attack.
He's forcing Hotspur back in the hopes of creating an opening, which is what happens. But that's
because Hotspur drops his guard, which doesn't actually make a lot of sense. A trained swordsman
should be able to retreat and hold their guard. But the backwards movement does create a sense
of motivation for the guard to be dropped. So we go with it, and that lowered guard creates an
opening, a very clear opening at Hotspur's head. That does bring me to a general criticism about
the portrayal of longswords in popular culture. Most movies and books and comics portray longswords
as heavy, cumbersome things, but trust me they're actually very fast. The offhand near the pommel
gives you very precise point control, which means they're both a great cutting and thrusting weapon.
But we tend to see cuts more in theatrical swordplay because cuts are big emotions. That
means they read much better to the audience. We can understand what the fight is about, and they
read much better to the performers in the scene, making the timings easier. The other thing to note
is that choreographed fights are about looking cool. They're not actually about trying to hurt
the opponent or even touch them. When you choreograph these things, you want to create a
feeling of intensity and danger, and what I call visual plausibility. Which brings us back to this
moment. There's no tactical reason for Hal to go to this one-handed cut here, but it does add
emotion, it does look cool, and it sets up Hotspur's deflection. In a quote-unquote real fight,
Hotspur would have been voiding the attack altogether. It's going to miss, and Hal has
created a huge opening on his head. Just look at how he's leaning forward. But they've smartly
shot this in profile, so at speed, you don't actually get a real sense of how wide that
incoming attack is. And so Hotspur's choice to deflect is plausible. Hotspur's deflection is
also a really big one, which visually justifies why he doesn't just bop Hal on the head as he
charges past. From a story point of view, this opening attack from Hal does highlight Hal's
arrogance. It's messy, and it's reckless. Hotspur seems more controlled. Just look at this moment,
Hal beats away Hotspur's sword, and that comes across as really quite aggressive. And what's
cool about it is that beating swords is historically accurate, and it's something that
can be done pretty safely by performers. And all of that leads to this great bit of choreography.
When I watched this movie for the first time, it was this phrase of the fight that made me
go, oh hell yeah, they know what they're doing. Hotspur thrusts at Hal's face. Hal over-parries.
Totally understandable. And that allows Hotspur to cut around the opening on the other side.
This is very tactical play. This forces Hal into half-swording. He parries the incoming blow by
reinforcing the sword's structure with his off-hand. This is historically accurate, really cool, and is
quite common in armoured combat, especially armoured combat that is moving into close play.
And we are in grapples. Hal grabs Hotspur's sword hand at the wrist, and Hotspur does the same.
They're in deadlock. This happens to me in longsword sparring quite often. But our sparring
is friendly, so we can't do this. Just a quick note in the filmmaking here, I think this is a
wonderful moment of the choreography, the camera position, and the edit all working together.
We can see the momentum of the headbutt being transferred because of the cut that is very
precise. The headbutt probably wouldn't actually do that much through the armour, but it's visually
plausible, and it's sold really well with the filmmaking. It feels brutal. The cut point here
also makes it safer for the performers to do. You don't need to hit them as hard. And Hotspur
uses that headbutt to break distance, and making Hal's structure weak. Hotspur can and should go
for a killing blow, but they've had to slow Hotspur's reaction here because this is a
choreographed fight. So we want to set up this moment, give enough time for Hal to void the
blade by ducking. Again, this is accurate and very cool. I've even managed to pull it off in
a tournament once. And now that creates an opportunity for Hal to lift up and throw his
opponent. Grappling is a big part of HEMA and a lot of the historical texts. In fact, you can still
see these kinds of throws in modern tournaments. The double leg takedown wasn't typically done in
armour. It's more of an unarmoured move. The problem is that in armour, your centre of mass
is much higher. So the counter to it is much easier. In fact, there are lots of elements of
the choreography here that have the feel to me of an MMA cage fight. Because I think to a modern
audience, that reads as a real fight. Now, it makes sense that Hal is getting Hotspur onto
the ground. They're both wearing armour. Cutting weapons aren't that useful. You actually want
blunt force trauma. Get them on their backs in heavy armour and then beat them up. Or stab them.
Hotspur grabbing the longsword with both hands to make it a strong strike while aiming for the
gap in the armour. So good. And what I really love about the filmmaking throughout this entire fight
is that it's not fancy. It's mostly wide shots and medium shots. So we can see what is going on.
And it makes it believable that it's these two men wailing on each other and not close-ups of
performers. And they break distance. So we've gone from close play back to wide measure. We do see
some of the same ideas repeated because, well, characters and people have signature moves. There's
things we feel comfortable doing, especially under pressure. Hotspur starting in half swords makes
sense. It's just more common in armoured combat to start in a half sword. Because if you want
to force the blade through a crack in the armour or under an unlocked visor, then this grip will
make that easier. And we have a few more clashes in the classic hit-the-sword-not-your-opponent
choreography beloved of everything, especially Star Wars. It's the busy work of fight choreography.
The fight does progress into a nice bit of kind of duelling half-swording,
and we get this great strike with the crossguard. Blunt force trauma. Nice.
Now, I don't quite buy this disarm, because if Hotspur is hitting the weak of the sword,
the top of the sword, then it should be falling behind Hal. Instead, I think Hal is actually
kind of throwing the sword away, which doesn't make sense, but it is visually plausible in the
movement because of the action. For story reasons, they don't actually want the sword behind Hal.
They need it in front of him. They want Hal to be retreating and reaching for the backup weapon
of choice for armoured longsword combatants, the Rondell dagger. Rondell daggers are awesome
because they're really useful for stabbing between the gaps in armour. Gross, but so good.
Many thanks to Giddy Warhope from the School of Historical Fencing for his
technical and historical insights. The King is great. You should watch it. It's got a great
script, some great filmmaking, and some great visually plausible fight choreography.
Hi, this is Stu Willis, and we are Shot Zero. We make videos, posts, and essays about shot design
and swordplay sometimes. If you like what you saw, please check us out
on shot-zero.com to find all the ways you can follow us, and thanks for watching.
