Medieval Sword Review & Cutting: Windlass Oakeshott Type XIV

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
22 Video Views·Mar 9, 2025
The Windlass Oakeshott Type XIV medieval arming sword: reviewed and tested for cutting ability (with the factory edge).
Hey folks, Matt Eaton here, Scholar Gladiatoria, and so here we have the Windlass Oakshot Type 14
sword, which I'm going to be reviewing in this video. I'll try and keep things as concise as
possible. So first of all, a lot of you watching this video will be familiar with Windlass.
Windlass have been around, I'd say, a long time, literally since the Second World War,
and they were, during the Second World War, making cookeries for the British Army and Indian Army,
and they essentially, in modern times, have branched into sword making. They make military
regulation swords, and they make swords for lots of other people, and they make swords under their
own name as well. Windlass are known for making reasonable quality but affordable swords, so the
comparing like with like, the price point that they're coming in at, is really quite reasonable
for what you're getting for that price. But not only talking about for the price, how is it as a
sword? Well, I'm going to dispense with the scabbard pretty much straight away, and I'll talk a little
bit about the scabbard towards the end of this video. Now let's really have a look at the sword
itself, which is obviously the main bit that people are paying for and are interested in.
Now, over the years, this Type 14 has been around for many, many years actually, and has received
generally favourable reviews. It's generally regarded as really good value for money, and I
wouldn't disagree with that at all. In fact, I wouldn't disagree with basically the average of
what you'll find online for reviews of this sword. It's really good value for money, and it's a nice
sword. It handles nicely, and it does everything that you'd expect from a Type 14. Now just very,
very briefly, what is Type 14? What am I referring to here? Well, for anyone who doesn't know,
Ewart Oakeshott was someone who made a typology for medieval straight double-edged swords, and
the Type 14 is one of those types. This type of sword was particularly around in the 13th and 14th
centuries, so this type of sword in use in medieval Europe would have usually been intended to be
coupled with either a shield, a heater shield for the most part, or in the civilian world, or if it
So a lot of people use Type 14s when they're practicing something like I-33 or 133 sword and
buckler technique, and frankly, actually an outline, if we ignore the details of the Type 14 for a
minute, an outline, it's not dissimilar from swords you find in the 15th century as well.
Although the particular details of this fuller and the Type 14 where it sits in the typology
had more or less been replaced by other types in the 15th century, so it's more of a kind of 13th,
14th century, particularly 14th century sword, and this was used by all different types of
soldier, everyone from knights who would obviously have more expensive and in some cases decorated
more fancy versions, all the way down to, you know, typical kind of spearmen and archers and
crossbowmen and people like this. So this is a type of sword that anybody who's interested in
the 14th century, for example the Hundred Years' War, absolutely this could sit within particularly
the earlier 14th century. They were still around in the later 14th century but they were gradually
being replaced by Type 15s and Type 18s and things like this, Type 17s, but particularly in the first
half of the 14th century, so the early part of the Hundred Years' War, and for example the Scottish
Wars of Independence with William Wallace and Robert the Bruce, that kind of period, so we're
talking around 1300 to 1350 particular, particularly being the hot spot for this Type 14, and really
anyone interested in that period, as I say, this is a very good general purpose arming sword. Now it is
relatively short, but it's not super super short. Let's have a little look at its statistics for a
So they're very accurate and this is exactly 1165 grams. So that is not heavy and it's not
particularly light either. It's probably fairly representative of quite a lot of these Type 14s
that were around in the 14th century, but equally there are lots that are lighter than this. So I
would say that this is possibly slightly on the heavier end of the spectrum and there is one reason
for that that I will come back to in a minute, but that's not to say that this is an overweight
sword or a heavy sword. It is of historical parameters. It is just at the slightly heavier
end of the spectrum. That being said, let's just have a little look at its length for a second. So
the blade, you can see it's not a particularly long sword, but the blade is 66 centimetres or 26
inches, that is. Okay, so that is, some people might refer to that as a short sword, but it's
not really a short sword in a medieval arming sword context. That's pretty much a, again, a
shorter end of the spectrum for arming swords at that time, but it is a short-ish sword, but it's
certainly of the length that could quite plausibly be used by a knight as an arming sword or it could
be used with a buckler by an archer or whoever. But I wouldn't quite call it a short sword, but it is
going in that direction. So it is a little bit on the heavy side for its size. That being said, it
doesn't feel heavy in the hand. I mean, you can move the thing around really pretty damn quickly
and that's because the weight distribution on it is very nice. Now, a lot of people focus on
point of balance, and as I mention in many of my videos, actually point of balance, or centre of
gravity, is only slightly indicative of how a sword will handle, because you can have equal
weights at two ends of a barbell and it will balance in the middle. However, when you try to
move that thing, it will have a lot of rotational inertia because the weight is distributed at the
ends of the object and not in the middle. That is the opposite in the case of these types of tapering
blades that we see in the medieval period, because in this case, let's put the tape down for a second,
in this case, a lot of the mass is concentrated around here. So actually, it is concentrated
around the direction that you are going to be rotating and turning the sword. So it actually
has quite a small rotational inertia in that it still hits with quite a lot of authority,
but you can move the thing around quickly because there's a lot of mass in the centre of this and
not a lot of mass at the end up here. It's also aided, of course, by this very nicely formed
disc pommel, which aids with the balance, of course, and it's got a nicely formed and quite sturdy
steel guard, as you can see. Now, let's have a little talk about how this particular example
is made. So first things first, my golden rules, if you look on the Mat Eastern website, you can find
what my golden rules of sword replication are. It complies well with a lot of those, okay.
So looking up the flat of the blade, this is hand forged incidentally, the blade is 1065 carbon steel,
heat treated to roughly 50 Rockwell hardness, so it's a fairly hard blade. I have cut with this
already and we're going to have a little bit of look at cutting later in this video, and it seems
to be a fairly hard blade. I haven't hit other steel with it, but it seems to have good flex, good
heat treatment. The blade is, you can see that it's been forged, it has some rippling if we look along
the flats of the blades. If we look along the edges, the edges are not bendy, they are not twisted or
warped, they are perfectly in line on both edges, no issues at all. The fuller is well ground and it
does run all the way into the hilt, as most medieval swords should do. It doesn't stop before we get to
the hilt, so it runs all the way in, so it's of the correct historical form. It finishes quite nicely,
it doesn't have any kind of abrupt or irregular grinding. In terms of the bevels between the flat
and the fuller, I would say that they're a little bit rounded. This is often the case with
hand forged blades that are then heavily ground and polished afterwards. It removes the degree
of definition, so there is not a very sharp definition between the fuller and the flats.
However, that is the case with lots of antique and original blades as well. It's just that if you look
at higher end swords, and again we're going to talk about price point here, if you look at more
expensive swords, usually you will find that will be one of the things that will mark out to your
eyes a more expensive blade, will be that there will be a more defined line between the fuller and
the flat of the blade in general. However, as I say, a lot of originals are actually like this,
so that's not to say that modern high-end replicas are always representative of the
original medieval swords, because they're often not. They're often more defined and more clinical
in a way than the original medieval swords. So just something to be aware of anyway. Now let's
talk about the actual edge bevels. So one thing about windlass swords is most of their models,
most of their models of sword are essentially made as blunt swords, but they're not like
reenactment blunt swords, they are just not made to be sharp from the outset. So this does have a
secondary bevel. So when you order most windlass swords, they will have a second, if you order them
sharp, which is I think what most people buy windlass swords for these days is sharps for
cutting, test cutting, or solo training, you will find that they have a secondary bevel on them.
Now, one point of criticism that I would raise to these, and this connects to the mass or weight
issue, is that I believe that the primary market in the modern world for these swords is cutting,
is people who want a sharp sword for cutting. And so I believe that this blade could be better
by being made sharp from the outset with a single bevel. So that is, if I just put down the sword
for a second, that is the edges come from the center of the blade here, if you imagine you've
got the fullers, up directly to the edge. And this is how most, not all, but this is how most medieval
European sword edges are formed. They are either a direct bevel to the edge, so just one single
bevel, like a chisel, or they are hollow ground, so they actually bow inwards and then come to a finer
edge. And what we don't usually see with medieval swords is them coming to almost an edge
and then having a secondary bevel in the final bit. What I would say is, for the price point that
these are at, that's still not a major problem and they will still cut well. You've got to remember
that a lot of swords in history and in different cultures, for example Indian swords, do have
secondary bevels, so a secondary bevel can still cut well. It's not that this will necessarily be
a worse cutter for having a secondary bevel, it's just that medieval European swords don't usually
have that second bevel. They do occasionally, but they don't usually. One way you can improve this,
incidentally, if you get one of these swords, and they are very good value for money so I wouldn't
in any way discourage you from getting one, in fact this is a very good option if you want
to type 14, is when you've got it, order it sharp and you can actually reduce the effects of the
secondary bevel by apple seeding the edge with some further sharpening of yourself. So instead
of having one angle then a second angle for the main bevel of the blade and then the final edge,
you can actually round off that shoulder, as it were, and turn it into an apple seed edge and this
would equally be historically accurate for these kinds of swords. And it is a very strong edge, a
very reinforced edge, it's stronger than the direct bevel, it's stronger than the hollow grinding.
That will also reduce a little bit of mass, although it's such a small amount of mass I'm
not sure that you would notice a difference. So the two reasons why I think that these should be
made with the single bevel is number one it's historically correct for this type of sword,
number two it means that you're reducing some mass, it means that the blades
would be a little bit lighter, and I think that this could be an even better sword if it was made
slightly lighter. Right, I'm not going to linger any longer on the edge point, I think I've probably
made myself clear. So in terms of fit and finish, so we've talked mostly about the blade, the polish
is nice, it is a high mirror polish but it has the looks of a hand mirror polish, it's not so high
that it looks like a kind of factory-made stainless steel or anything like that, it's probably what
was authentic to a lot of period swords. It's better than a satin polish and I criticize some
high-end makers for having a satin finish when I think they should have better than a satin finish,
so this is better than a satin finish and it's nicely done. So I like the blade, I'm going to
talk a little bit about distal taper in a second but I'll just carry on talking about the rest of
the construction. Everything is tight and solid, if I bang the sword, if I wiggle the sword, everything
is tight, there's no movement in the pommel, no movement in the guard. I can, you don't really get
a ring when you do this and that seems to be because of the way that the grip is mounted,
I don't know why but you don't really get a ring in the blade. It is peened at the end so
completely historically accurate and the tang is a one-piece construction, there's no welding in
there, there's no rods, in this one there's no thread or anything like that, it is a one piece
with the blade, comes through and is peened or riveted at the end of the pommel, historically
accurate. The grip is wood obviously with leather over the top, it is stitched up the back,
historically accurate, it's not the most high-end way of making a grip, usually you'd put cord and
then you'd have leather wrap over the top, this is just leather over wood but that is also done
historically, that's not unhistorical, that is historically accurate and it is of course a,
it saves some cost on the end product as well. Obviously if you've got one of these and you
wanted to work on it and bling it essentially you could upgrade the grip wrap if you wanted to,
you could replace the whole grip if you wanted to, but the basic components are good. One little thing
to note, it's a strange thing I've noticed with all of the windlasses I've looked at, is if we
just zoom in here for a second you can see the aperture for the blade, it does sit very nicely
into the guard but they use a parallel edged kind of grind or machine to take out a groove
in the centre of the guard here, so it's not exactly shaped to the base of a blade. Now
that actually saves cost because it's easier to cut out a channel, it's not really historically
accurate in that usually the slot, not always I have to say, there are examples in the Museum
of London where this isn't the case, but usually the slot would be the same shape as the cross
section of the blade, in other words it would be like a flattened diamond shape and it would so
the guard would sit closer to the edges. In this case it doesn't, it doesn't really bother me
and I can see why they've done it because in machining terms it's easier to do that.
The main thing is that the blade does sit into the guard and some more affordable manufacturers
the blade won't actually go into the guard like that, so you know full kudos to windlass for
actually doing that so it seats in there. Right okay I said I'd talk a little bit about distal
taper, so one of the things that is lacking on vast numbers of a very large proportion of
shall we say affordable or you know economy priced swords, functional swords, is a lack of distal
taper and I have to say in the case of this particular sword there isn't much much distal
taper but in reference to some styles of blade there wasn't historically always very much distal
taper and as it happens one of those types of blade that we don't see an awful lot of distal
taper on are these medieval blades which taper a lot in the profile in the silhouette so if they're
very broad at the base here and get narrower and narrower often if we look at the originals they
don't have much distal taper in this direction and that of course is because it's to do with
weight distribution and stiffness and it's to do with the amount of metal here versus the amount
of metal here and quite simply if your blade is very broad you don't need it to be very thick and
not only do you not need it to be very thick for stiffness because you're getting the stiffness
from the width additionally you don't want it to be very thick because that would make it too heavy
so actually it's about having the right amount of metal here here and here and it doesn't really
matter whether you taper it this way whether you taper it that way or you taper it in both
directions which is often the case so in terms of this sword it's actually got it flexes in a
nice way it's quite stiff at the base of the blade because it's broad i'm having to be slightly
careful because this is a relatively sharp blade you can see it flexes mostly in the second half
of the blade but it's stiff it is a stiff blade so i can push it into my wooden post here and
flex it and it doesn't flex i mean it flexes it's got good flex good temper but it's difficult to
it is a stiff blade so very good for thrusting it's got a lot of authority in the cut as well
a slight bit on the heavy side and i would prefer the edges to be a single bevel instead of having
a secondary bevel in an ideal word in other words i think windlass should make these as sharps from
the outset but the hilt very nice nice construction it's simple but it looks right i might possibly if
want to nitpick i might have tapered the cross guard off at the ends a bit it looks a little bit
bar like it looks a little bit thick at the ends and i personally if you look at again if you look
at higher end swords if these were tapered down a bit it would reduce the mass slightly again
it would reduce the mass and i think it would give a slightly more refined look
so to summarize i'm quite impressed in fact by this type 14 it's nice it's very nice i'll be
keeping this it's a lovely little sword and it is fun to cut with i'm going to go out and cut some
more so you guys can see i highly recommend it for the price i think it's i think it's really good
value and it's also a very nice potential project sword if you want to do a little bit of modification
this is actually a really good basis for it it's a good affordable basis for it you can put a better
edge on here you can do you can apple seed that edge or reduce a bit of mass make it sharper make
it a better cutter you could possibly taper these quillons you could maybe put some detailing on the
end of the quillons you could change the grip if you wanted to you could put ribs or bands on it
or you could do a cord wrap or whatever you like and it has the look of the originals it looks
right if you put this next to an original type 14 in a museum cabinet it would look like a respectable
replica of one so i would say a good solid effort from windlass here and i like this type 14 a lot
now before i go and do some cutting with this i did say there's my buckler i did say that i would
talk about the scabbard briefly so first of all brilliant that it has a scabbard i love the fact
that you're getting an affordable sword which frankly would be worth the money without a
scabbard but you're getting a scabbard with it and i do think that high-end manufacturers that don't
give scabbards i think it's scandalous because it doesn't cost that much money to make a simple
scabbard and especially if you're selling sharp swords if you're storing sharp swords around in
the house i think that any sharp sword should have a scabbard to protect the edges not all my sharp
swords do because getting scabbards separately made is expensive business so i keep them in boxes
but i think it's brilliant that they supply a scabbard now the leather is nice it's stiff it's
not wood lined so it's not historically accurate really it's not inaccurate but most medieval
scabbards were wood lined with leather over the top but it is stiff leather it looks the part
i don't like these okay so these big locket plates i think they don't look historically accurate and
they don't need to be there so most medieval scabbards don't have this type of mount at the
top this is a later period thing they do have a chape at the bottom and i have no issues with
the chape at all the chape's nicely formed and it's tight my opinion is the locket is doesn't
fit great it's a little bit too big it just looks like a big piece of bent steel and i think it
cheapens the look of the scabbard so i actually think that windlass should get rid of these and
just keep the leather at the top just have leather with a chape okay so there we go i hope that's
useful feedback i'm going to go outside now and i hope you enjoy seeing me put this through its
chopping various things
So, hopefully that's demonstrated that this little sword is pretty reliable, it's not
picked up any edge deformations or curls or anything like that.
You wouldn't expect that obviously from, certainly from bottles, but hopefully not from wood
either.
But no loss of edge or anything like that here, no marks on the edge or nicks, no bends
or twists or anything untoward like that, nothing's come loose in the hilt, it's all
nice and solid still.
So, it cuts with quite a lot of authority.
Where this sword falls down is it's not terribly sharp, you'll notice that this is a sharp
edge that I'm happy to run my fingers up and down.
So it's not really sharp, it's not really what I would call sharp.
I do understand that some manufacturers say, oh well this is historical sharp, well it's
not really, it might be historical sharp to how some antiques have survived but it's
not how they would have been originally.
So this needs to be sharper but as always, I always want to review and demonstrate swords
as they come to me, not after I've done things to them.
And I will definitely make this sharper, I will also when I get time apple seed the edge.
Once more I would conclude that the main thing to say about this sword is really that it
would benefit from being made as a sharp from the outset and have a single bevel and
have a sharper edge.
That being said, this is a tremendous sword for the value, for the money.
And if I had, obviously I sent this as a sample to review and test, but I will definitely
be keeping this because it's just a really nice sword and it's nicely representative
of the type, it looks historical.
It's got some of the key things that other manufacturers, certainly of more affordable
swords get wrong.
This one's got right, it's nice and solid, I can trust it.
It's all a solid good construction and it's fun, it's fun to cut with.
So there we go, check the link below if you want to maybe look to adding one of these
to your collection.
It's a nice little thing, it's not a lot of money for what you get.
It's a good sword, good fun to cut with.
I would only say once again, those couple of constructional comments I would say to
Windlass about improving this even more.
But principally if people want this as a cutting sword, bear in mind it's not going to come
to you tremendously sharp, at least mine didn't.
It's sharp enough to cut bottles as you saw, but it's not as sharp as you'll probably want
it and it could have a better edge geometry if they manufactured them in a slightly different
way.
Even if they just came to a very fine edge that didn't quite have the final sharpen and
then that was just added on customer's request.
Anyway, thank you very much for watching, check out the link below.
Give us a like and a subscribe and I'll be back with more reviews of other swords, including
more Windlass swords, really soon.
So make sure you subscribe and I'll see you back here on Scholar Gladiatoria channel really
soon.
Cheers folks!
Thanks for watching, we've got extra videos on Patreon.
Please give our Facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't already.
Cheers folks!
